Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ValuesDissonance / AnimeAndManga

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* According to ''Anime/PersiaTheMagicFairy'', "[[AfricaIsACountry Africans]]" wear barely any clothing, are all close to animals and live as cavemen. Other character state that the main reason Persia is such a WildChild is because she was raised in an "[[AfricaIsACountry African]] culture" instead of her parent's traditional Japanese culture.

to:

* According to ''Anime/PersiaTheMagicFairy'', "[[AfricaIsACountry Africans]]" wear barely any clothing, are all close to animals and live as cavemen. Other character state that the main reason Persia is such a WildChild is because she was raised in an "[[AfricaIsACountry African]] culture" instead of her parent's traditional Japanese culture. The portrayal of [[https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/evelyn_ep_1.png black characters]] is even worse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


*** Many aspectas of the series didn't age well, including the depiction of Africans (which went into DarjkestAfrica territory and {{blackface}}) and Arabs (whom were given very stereotypical appearances and characterized as extremely greedy).

to:

*** Many aspectas of the series didn't age well, including the depiction of Africans (which went into DarjkestAfrica DarkestAfrica territory and {{blackface}}) and Arabs (whom were given very stereotypical appearances and characterized as extremely greedy).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Many aspectas of the series didn't age well, including the depiction of Africans (which went into DarjkestAfrica territory and {{blackface}}) and Arabs (whom were given very stereotypical appearances and characterized as extremely greedy).

to:

** *** Many aspectas of the series didn't age well, including the depiction of Africans (which went into DarjkestAfrica territory and {{blackface}}) and Arabs (whom were given very stereotypical appearances and characterized as extremely greedy).

Added: 964

Removed: 718

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Manga/KimbaTheWhiteLion'':
** Many aspectas of the series didn't age well, including the depiction of Africans (which went into DarjkestAfrica territory and {{blackface}}) and Arabs (whom were given very stereotypical appearances and characterized as extremely greedy).
*** ''Leo the Lion'' (or ''Susume! Leo''), the follow-up series , features an episode where Leo/Kimba attempts to teach his son Rukio independence by dragging him out into the middle of nowhere and making him fight his way back home on his own. Though Rukio is obviously terrified for most of the journey, it's revealed at the end that he was never in any real danger because Leo was secretly following him every step of the way. This is intended as a heartwarming story about a well-meaning dad using ToughLove to teach his son an important lesson. To contemporary audiences, especially Western ones, it just looks like a physically and emotionally abusive nut leaving his child for dead.



* ''Leo the Lion'' (or ''Susume! Leo''), the follow-up series to ''Manga/KimbaTheWhiteLion'', features an episode where Leo/Kimba attempts to teach his son Rukio independence by dragging him out into the middle of nowhere and making him fight his way back home on his own. Though Rukio is obviously terrified for most of the journey, it's revealed at the end that he was never in any real danger because Leo was secretly following him every step of the way. This is intended as a heartwarming story about a well-meaning dad using ToughLove to teach his son an important lesson. To contemporary audiences, especially Western ones, it just looks like a physically and emotionally abusive nut leaving his child for dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking from Azumanga's YMMV page.


** Sakaki's low self-esteem and her wish to be shorter and cuter like [[TokenMiniMoe Chiyo]] would seem downright ludicrous to western viewers. This is because Japanese beauty standards for women put more emphasis on being petite--a trait Sakaki doesn't have, being a tall and ([[SubvertedTrope seemingly]]) AloofDarkHairedGirl.

to:

** Sakaki's low self-esteem and her wish to be shorter and cuter like [[TokenMiniMoe Chiyo]] would seem downright ludicrous to western viewers. This is because Japanese beauty standards for women put more emphasis on being petite--a trait Sakaki doesn't have, being a tall and ([[SubvertedTrope seemingly]]) AloofDarkHairedGirl. Japanese culture also places more value on conformity than individuality, so Sakaki's insecurity stems from feeling isolated from her peers. Even then, her height and bust--while larger than average for sure--are much less extreme in the west than in Japan, where she's taller than most fully-grown men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Downplayed with the the storyline in regards to Nagisa and his [[AbusiveParents abusive mother]]. While Hiromii is explicitly portrayed as an AxCrazy ControlFreak until her HeelRealization and her treatment of her son is definitely PlayedForHorror, the fact that Koro-Sensei [[BystanderSyndrome does little about it when witnessing it]], as well as how [[EasilyForgiven she was let off the hook for it so easily]] ''really'' doesn't sit well with Western readers. In the West, Hiromi's parenting style is criminal by law and she would be doing serious jail time for abusing and ''drugging'' her own son. Korosensei, Nagisa's teacher and a witness to Hiromi's abuse, also would likely have called the police/child services to save Nagisa from future abuse; this sticks out more and more as time goes on, as more places in the Western world make teacher mandatory reporters, meaning a teacher like Korosensei not reporting witnessed abuse would have him facing criminal negligence charges.

to:

** Downplayed with the the storyline in regards to Nagisa and his [[AbusiveParents abusive mother]]. While Hiromii Hiromi is explicitly portrayed as an AxCrazy ControlFreak until her HeelRealization and her treatment of her son is definitely PlayedForHorror, the fact that Koro-Sensei [[BystanderSyndrome does little about it when witnessing it]], as well as how [[EasilyForgiven she was let off the hook for it so easily]] ''really'' doesn't sit well with Western readers. In the West, Hiromi's parenting style is criminal by law and she would be doing serious jail time for abusing and ''drugging'' her own son. Korosensei, Nagisa's teacher and a witness to Hiromi's abuse, also would likely have called the police/child services to save Nagisa from future abuse; this sticks out more and more as time goes on, as more places in the Western world make teacher mandatory reporters, meaning a teacher like Korosensei not reporting witnessed abuse would have him facing criminal negligence charges.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Downplayed with the she storyline in regards to Nagisa and his [[AbusiveParents abusive mother.]] While Hiromii is explicitly portrayed as an AxCrazy ControlFreak until her HeelRealization and her treatment of her son is definitely PlayedForHorror, the fact that Koro-Sensei [[BystanderSyndrome does little about it when witnessing it]], as well as how [[EasilyForgiven she was let off the hook for it so easily]] ''really'' doesn't sit well with Western readers. In the West, Hiromi's parenting style is criminal by law and she would be doing serious jail time for abusing and ''drugging'' her own son. Korosensei, Nagisa's teacher and a witness to Hiromi's abuse, also would likely have called the police/child services to save Nagisa from future abuse; this sticks out more and more as time goes on, as more places in the Western world make teacher mandatory reporters, meaning a teacher like Korosensei not reporting witnessed abuse would have him facing criminal negligence charges.

to:

** Downplayed with the she the storyline in regards to Nagisa and his [[AbusiveParents abusive mother.]] mother]]. While Hiromii is explicitly portrayed as an AxCrazy ControlFreak until her HeelRealization and her treatment of her son is definitely PlayedForHorror, the fact that Koro-Sensei [[BystanderSyndrome does little about it when witnessing it]], as well as how [[EasilyForgiven she was let off the hook for it so easily]] ''really'' doesn't sit well with Western readers. In the West, Hiromi's parenting style is criminal by law and she would be doing serious jail time for abusing and ''drugging'' her own son. Korosensei, Nagisa's teacher and a witness to Hiromi's abuse, also would likely have called the police/child services to save Nagisa from future abuse; this sticks out more and more as time goes on, as more places in the Western world make teacher mandatory reporters, meaning a teacher like Korosensei not reporting witnessed abuse would have him facing criminal negligence charges.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The Japanese Tough Love part is completely irrelevant since Hiromi's abuse is not portrayed as justified in any way. She was just Easily Forgiven for it, but it was very clearly Played For Horror.


** The storyline in regards to Nagisa and his [[AbusiveParents abusive mother.]] Japanese society often approves of parents being harsh/controlling towards their children, as youth are often taught to have the utmost respect for their elders since their ToughLove parenting is for their benefit. In the West, Hiromi's parenting style is criminal by law and she would be doing serious jail time for abusing and ''drugging'' her own son. Korosensei, Nagisa's teacher and a witness to Hiromi's abuse, also would likely have called the police/child services to save Nagisa from future abuse; this sticks out more and more as time goes on, as more places in the Western world make teacher mandatory reporters, meaning a teacher like Korosensei not reporting witnessed abuse would have him facing criminal negligence charges.

to:

** The Downplayed with the she storyline in regards to Nagisa and his [[AbusiveParents abusive mother.]] Japanese society often approves While Hiromii is explicitly portrayed as an AxCrazy ControlFreak until her HeelRealization and her treatment of parents being harsh/controlling towards their children, as youth are often taught to have her son is definitely PlayedForHorror, the utmost respect fact that Koro-Sensei [[BystanderSyndrome does little about it when witnessing it]], as well as how [[EasilyForgiven she was let off the hook for their elders since their ToughLove parenting is for their benefit.it so easily]] ''really'' doesn't sit well with Western readers. In the West, Hiromi's parenting style is criminal by law and she would be doing serious jail time for abusing and ''drugging'' her own son. Korosensei, Nagisa's teacher and a witness to Hiromi's abuse, also would likely have called the police/child services to save Nagisa from future abuse; this sticks out more and more as time goes on, as more places in the Western world make teacher mandatory reporters, meaning a teacher like Korosensei not reporting witnessed abuse would have him facing criminal negligence charges.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Anime/PapillonRose'': The ''R'' concept's villains are all trans women, with the text not being much kinder to trans lesbian Papillon Adonis (her civilian name is Futanari, a controversial term for fantasy-intersex women), and noting that antagonist Shiorintie was reborn with her ideal body like it's a problem. Suffice to say that this is all considered a lot less funny nowadays.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Anime/DreamHunterRem'': Being such a gleeful product of TheEighties, the series entertains a long list of points that would not fly today: the empowered protagonist wears campy {{Stripperiffic}} attire, at one point advises a girl to find a boyfriend not to feel lonely (and ''kisses'' her completely out of the blue), later finds a perverted PE teacher that is completely PlayedForLaughs, and has two grown men in love with her despite being implied to be a high-schooler or so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*According to ''Anime/PersiaTheMagicFairy'', "[[AfricaIsACountry Africans]]" wear barely any clothing, are all close to animals and live as cavemen. Other character state that the main reason Persia is such a WildChild is because she was raised in an "[[AfricaIsACountry African]] culture" instead of her parent's traditional Japanese culture.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One possible reason why [[StalkerWithACrush Quiche]] is the [[FanPreferredCouple fan-preferred pairing]] for Ichigo in the West is that his EstablishingCharacterMoment, stealing Ichigo's SacredFirstKiss, is far less shocking to Westerners than it is to the Japanese.

to:

** One possible reason why [[StalkerWithACrush Quiche]] is the [[FanPreferredCouple fan-preferred pairing]] for Ichigo in the West is that his EstablishingCharacterMoment, stealing Ichigo's SacredFirstKiss, is far less shocking to Westerners than it is to the Japanese. This is arguably not so much the case in a post-Me Too era, where people now tend to be more sensitive to consent and the pitfalls of romanticizing predatory behaviour.

Added: 846

Changed: 846

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Some of the anime's more "sensual" scenes were deleted in the Arabic release. A young girl showing her body in the manner Rei does when singing would be considered heavily shameful in Middle Eastern societies.* In ''Manga/IkkiTousen'', when a character is revealed to really be the incarnation of Wang Yun rather than who he had previously claimed to be, it's treated as a huge shock and evidence that he's completely evil. Wang Yun was a ''hero'' in the original ''Literature/RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms'', but it seems the Japanese don't think too highly of him. That was before, well, [[spoiler:Zuo Ci (the one who was Wang Yun) actually betrayed and manipulated his friends...]] This was one of the more heavy plot rewrites in the anime, which was made after Wang Yun's identity was known to the reader, but before he revealed it to the characters. In the manga, while he's still manipulating everyone behind their backs, he's got good intentions, and is treated as a hero. Even in the anime, he's mostly just setting the villains up to kill each other.

to:

** Some of the anime's more "sensual" scenes were deleted in the Arabic release. A young girl showing her body in the manner Rei does when singing would be considered heavily shameful in Middle Eastern societies.societies.
* In ''Manga/IkkiTousen'', when a character is revealed to really be the incarnation of Wang Yun rather than who he had previously claimed to be, it's treated as a huge shock and evidence that he's completely evil. Wang Yun was a ''hero'' in the original ''Literature/RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms'', but it seems the Japanese don't think too highly of him. That was before, well, [[spoiler:Zuo Ci (the one who was Wang Yun) actually betrayed and manipulated his friends...]] This was one of the more heavy plot rewrites in the anime, which was made after Wang Yun's identity was known to the reader, but before he revealed it to the characters. In the manga, while he's still manipulating everyone behind their backs, he's got good intentions, and is treated as a hero. Even in the anime, he's mostly just setting the villains up to kill each other.

Top