Andy gets his old A Capella group together and puts them in a show for the company.
Dwight finds an anxiety pill in the office and looks for the person, unaware that the one who is helping him, Nellie, is the one that takes the pill.
Jim makes a huge investment without telling Pam.
Tropes
- The Cameo: Stephen Colbert as Broccoli Rob.
- I Have This Friend: Dwight wants anxiety pills for his cousin Mose. "He's just having a tough time, being wifeless and a high-pressure job and his crazy cousin Mose. Other cousin Mose."
- Multitasked Conversation: Angela complains about the acapella group singing "Monster Mash" (claiming that it glorifies the occult), Jim argues that since it's Halloween they have to sing "Monster Mash", Pam remarks that things you "have to" do include feeding your kids and putting them through school, and the argument quickly becomes about Jim investing most of their savings into the business without telling her. By the end of it, Kevin concludes that Pam really hates "Monster Mash".
- Noodle Incident: Pete looks at the costumes and says he didn't know everyone wears costumes on Halloween. Creed, wearing a bloody shirt, says "me neither". Followed by this talking head.Creed: "It's Halloween. That is...really good timing."
- That's What She Said: Makes its first appearance on the show since Michael's departure, whispered by Creed after Clark says "There’s just no way you guys are making this magic with just your mouths!"
- Wham Line: At the end of the episode, Andy reveals his family has lost all their money.Andy: My family is broke.
