Mutilations on the latest body suggest the killer might be linked to the Old West. Sara confronts her past at the hospital. Connor and Byrnes work against the team. Kreizler is forced to rethink how he treats those in his household.
Tropes:
- Bilingual Bonus: Kreizler's "Es tut mir leid" ("I'm sorry") to the body of the last victim is not translated in the subtitles.
- Historical Domain Character: J.P. Morgan makes a brief appearance.
- Instant Sedation: Connor has someone sedate John with a rag with chloroform.