While Christmas shopping, Beast Boy is kidnapped by Santa Claus and forced to help him make amends with the Holiday Mafia run by Baby New Year.
Tropes:
- Dirty Coward: One of the members of the Mafia that Santa Claus and Beast Boy have to strongarm to prove Santa's loyalty is the Groundhog's Day groundhog, who's terrified of shadows in general instead of just his own and is tortured into submission by Santa just making shadow puppets on the wall.
- Out-Gambitted: Just when it's revealed that Santa tricked the Mafia into believing his change of heart in order to take control of their operation, it turns out Beast Boy was actually working with the FBI the entire time and has collected enough evidence to have the entire group arrested.
- Out of Focus: Beast Boy is the only member of the Titans to appear in this episode.
