Recap / Nailed It!

Season 1

1. First Date to Life Mate (Guest Judge: Sylvia Weinstock)
2. Fantasyland (Guest Judge: Zac Young)
3. Head Under Water (Guest Judge: Valerie Gordon)
4. Weird Science (Guest Judge: Dave Arnold)
5. Big In Japan (Guest Judge: Yolanda Gampp)
6. In Your Face! (Guest Judge: Jay Chandrasekhar)

Season 2

1. High Society (Guest Judge: Jon Gabrus)
2. Fictious and Delicious (Guest Judge: Ron Ben-Israel)
3. Tailgate, Failgate (Guest Judge: Johnny Hecker)
4. Holi-daze (Guest Judge: Waylynn Lucas)
5. Zoo You Bake? (Guest Judge: Art Smith)
6. Out of This World (Guest Judge: Joshua John Russell)
7. Bonus:3,2,1...Ya Done!! (Guest Judge: Antoni Porowski; Crossover with Queer Eye (2018))

Holiday Season 1

1. Jingle Fails (Guest Judge: Lauren Lapkus)
2. Winter Blunderland (Guest Judge: Justin Willman)
3. You Mitzvah Spot! (Guest Judge: Sylvia Weinstock)
4. It’s a Family A-Fail (Guest Judge: Gemma Stafford)
5. Toying Around (Guest Judge: Ron Funches)
6. 3…2…1, Ya Done! (Guest Judge: Jason Mantzoukas)
7. Just Dot It Yourself! (Guest Judges: Jim Noonan and Kate Berlant)

Season 3

1. The Marvel Episode (Guest Judge: Felicia Day)
2. Cake-O-Phobia (Guest Judge: Natalie Sideserf)
3. Masterpiece or Disasterpiece? (Guest Judge: Betsy Sodaro)
4. Prehistoric Bakes (Guest Judge: Rosanna Pansino)
5. Oui Can’t Bake! (Guest Judge: Hubert Keller)
6. Ready to Wear, Ready to Eat (Guest Judge: Charles Phoenix)

Holiday Season 2

1. We’re Scrooged (Guest Judge: Jason Mantzoukas)
2. A Classic Christmas (Guest Judge: Maya Rudolph)
3. Shalo-many Fails (Guest Judge: Ron Ben-Israel)
4. It’s a Wonderfail Life (Guest Judge: Bridget Everett)
5. One Fail, Two Fail, I Fail, You Fail! (Guest Judge: Jillian Bell)
6. New Year, New Fails (Guest Judge: David Burtka)

Season 4

1. Let’s Get Lit (Guest Judge: Matt Walsh)
2. The One With The 90’s Theme (Guest Judge: Fortune Feimster)
3. Indiana Fails and the Temple of Slop (Guest Judge: Gemma Stafford)
4. Chariots of Failure (Guest Judge: Gabby Douglas)
5. Jungle Bungle (Guest Judge: Rachel Fong)
6. Howdy, Failure! (Guest Judge: Adam Scott)
7. The Big Bake Theory (Guest Judge: Valerie Gordon)
8. I Do…Hope I Don’t Fail (Guest Judge: Christina Tosi)