Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / SilentSpring

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->-- The book's closing statement

to:

-->-- The '''Rachel Carson''', the book's closing statement
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Motif}}: From the first chapter on, Carson consistently likens the effects and nature of chemicals to those of radiation--a danger which already loomed large in the public consciousness in the 50s and 60s.

to:

* {{Motif}}: PhlebotinumAnalogy: From the first chapter on, Carson consistently likens the effects and nature of chemicals to those of radiation--a radiation, a danger which already loomed large in the public consciousness in the 50s and 60s.

Added: 185

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PollutedWasteland: In addition to spraying, Carson touches on industrial pollution, describing several areas (rivers in particular) rendered lifeless or dangerous by careless dumping.



* SterilityPlague: Many of the chemicals discussed interfere with reproduction in animals such as birds; sterility is the main cause of the die-offs such as that of the robins.

to:

* SterilityPlague: Many of the chemicals discussed interfere with reproduction in animals such as birds; sterility is the main cause of the die-offs such as like that of the robins.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InescapableHorror: Many of the chapters describe how chemicals from spraying become embedded in every level of the environment, making exposure to them inevitable.


Added DiffLines:

* SterilityPlague: Many of the chemicals discussed interfere with reproduction in animals such as birds; sterility is the main cause of the die-offs such as that of the robins.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The book begins with a short parable called "A Fable for Tomorrow" about an idyllic American town whose plants, animals, and residents suddenly begin to sicken and die, with no discernible cause--revealed to be the consequence of powdered herbicides being dispersed by aircraft. The story is a warning: Carson states at the end of the chapter that, while no such extreme example had occurred yet, every individual element had in one place or another.

to:

The book begins with a [[AnAesop short parable parable]] called "A Fable for Tomorrow" about an idyllic American town whose plants, animals, and residents suddenly begin to sicken and die, with no discernible cause--revealed to be the consequence of powdered herbicides being dispersed by aircraft. The story is a warning: Carson states at the end of the chapter that, while no such extreme example had occurred yet, every individual element had in one place or another.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The rest of the book describes these events, detailing the proven effects of commonly used chemicals on every level of the environment--from estuaries and rivers to to forests to humans--and compiling numerous cases from around the country where ecosystems had already been seriously damaged. Highlights include the extinction of Dutch elms; the massive die-off of robins in the Midwest when chemicals got into the worms that the robins ate; the tendency for pesticides to kill off natural predators to the pests they target, exacerbating the problem; the use of flower-killing herbicides to clear the view on roads when all that was needed was to cut down trees and scrub; the ease of coming into contact with (and dying of) dangerous chemicals ''by accident''; and the unknown effects of a multitude of compounds mingling and creating new, even more dangerous poisons.

to:

The rest of the book describes these events, detailing the proven effects of commonly used chemicals on every level of the environment--from estuaries and rivers to to forests to humans--and compiling numerous cases from around the country where ecosystems had already been seriously damaged. Highlights include the extinction of Dutch elms; the massive die-off of robins in the Midwest when chemicals got into the worms that the robins ate; the tendency for pesticides to kill off natural predators to the pests they target, exacerbating the problem; the use of flower-killing herbicides to clear the view on roads when all that was needed was to cut down trees and scrub; the ease of coming into contact with (and dying of) dangerous chemicals ''by accident''; and the unknown effects of a multitude of compounds mingling and creating new, even more dangerous poisons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Silent Spring'' is a 1963 environmental science book by biologist [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rachel_Carson Rachel Carson]]. It raises concerns about the rise and widespread use of chemical pesticides and would become a foundational text of the American environmentalist movement, leading among other things to the US banning the dangerous chemical DDT.

The book begins with a short parable called "A Fable for Tomorrow" about an idyllic American town whose plants, animals, and livestock suddenly begin to sicken and die, with no discernible cause--revealed to be the consequence of powdered herbicides being dispersed by aircraft. The story is a warning: Carson states at the end of the chapter that, while no such extreme example had occurred yet, every individual element had in one place or another.

to:

''Silent Spring'' is a 1963 environmental science book by biologist [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rachel_Carson Rachel Carson]]. It raises concerns about the rise and widespread use of chemical pesticides and would become a foundational text of the American environmentalist movement, leading among other things to the US banning the dangerous chemical DDT.

The book begins with a short parable called "A Fable for Tomorrow" about an idyllic American town whose plants, animals, and livestock residents suddenly begin to sicken and die, with no discernible cause--revealed to be the consequence of powdered herbicides being dispersed by aircraft. The story is a warning: Carson states at the end of the chapter that, while no such extreme example had occurred yet, every individual element had in one place or another.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DangerousPhlebotinumInteraction: The book repeatedly stresses that no one can predict the consequences of newly invented chemicals mixing in the environment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChemistryCanDoAnything: Deconstructed. Carson credits this popular belief with the public's trust in chemical companies' claims that their products could achieve some sort of new Eden. In reality, the chemicals being used could not be honed to poison only their targets and often were not even particularly effective at eliminating them.

Added: 236

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The book begins with a short parable called "A Fable for Tomorrow" about an idyllic town whose plants, animals, and livestock suddenly begin to sicken and die, with no discernible cause--revealed to be the consequence of powdered herbicides being dispersed by aircraft. The story is a warning: Carson states at the end of the chapter that, while no such extreme example had occurred yet, every individual element had in one place or another.

to:

The book begins with a short parable called "A Fable for Tomorrow" about an idyllic American town whose plants, animals, and livestock suddenly begin to sicken and die, with no discernible cause--revealed to be the consequence of powdered herbicides being dispersed by aircraft. The story is a warning: Carson states at the end of the chapter that, while no such extreme example had occurred yet, every individual element had in one place or another.


Added DiffLines:

* TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture: The parable in the first chapter, appropriately titled "A Fable for ''Tomorrow''", is supposed to take place in the very near future to the book's publication.
* AlliterativeTitle: '''S'''ilent '''S'''pring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Animal Wrongs Group and Strawman Political relate to people's reactions to the book and are not present in the book itself. ~ Author Tract is when an author hijacks a fictional narrative to expound some thesis; this is literally a science book.


A book by Rachel Carson written in 1963. It helped launch the environmental movement as we know it.

The first chapter is a short story parable about a little town that was losing everything good it had -- its wildlife, its birds and birdsong, its beauty, its scenery, the health of its people -- and had no idea why. It ends with the notice of little white crystals of a herbicide that had just been dropped from a plane over the town...

The most memorable parts of this book are about the horrors of modern chemicals -- well, modern for 1963, but some of them are still on the market, and many of them have long half-lives. She describes what they do to nature, what they do to people, and how they are in the end not as effective at what they're ''supposed'' to do as the methods used before the chemicals were invented. Other environmental issues also come up -- invasive species, for instance.

Highlights include the die-off of robins in the American Midwest, as chronicled in a study on migration and population that started right when the change happened, because chemicals got into the worms that the robins ate; birds and DDT; the tendency for pesticides to kill off the natural predators to the pests more effectively than the pests, which ultimately results in more pests; the extinction of Dutch elms; using herbicides that kill flowers to clear the view for roads when all that would be needed is to cut down trees and scrub; the ease of using, and dying of, dangerous chemicals ''by accident''; and new chemicals spontaneously forming where chemicals have leaked into the water supply.

The final chapter is about how to fix things -- though, given the tone of the previous chapters, it's more on how to keep them from getting even worse.

In short, this book is the 1960s literary version of ''Film/AnInconvenientTruth''.

The banning of DDT and its relatives is probably related to this book.

to:

A book by Rachel Carson written in 1963. It helped launch [[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/silent_spring.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:The cover of
the original edition.]]

->''"The 'control of nature' is a phrase conceived in arrogance, born of the Neanderthal age of biology and philosphy, when it was supposed that nature exists for the convenience of man. The concepts and practices of applied entomology for the most part date from that Stone Age of science. It is our alarming misfortune that so primitive a science has armed itself with the most modern and terrible weapons, and that in turning them against the insects it has also turned them against the earth."''
-->-- The book's closing statement

''Silent Spring'' is a 1963
environmental movement as we know it.

The first chapter is a short story parable about a little town that was losing everything good it had -- its wildlife, its birds and birdsong, its beauty, its scenery, the health of its people -- and had no idea why. It ends with the notice of little white crystals of a herbicide that had just been dropped from a plane over the town...

The most memorable parts of this
science book are by biologist [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rachel_Carson Rachel Carson]]. It raises concerns about the horrors rise and widespread use of modern chemical pesticides and would become a foundational text of the American environmentalist movement, leading among other things to the US banning the dangerous chemical DDT.

The book begins with a short parable called "A Fable for Tomorrow" about an idyllic town whose plants, animals, and livestock suddenly begin to sicken and die, with no discernible cause--revealed to be the consequence of powdered herbicides being dispersed by aircraft. The story is a warning: Carson states at the end of the chapter that, while no such extreme example had occurred yet, every individual element had in one place or another.

The rest of the book describes these events, detailing the proven effects of commonly used
chemicals -- well, modern for 1963, but some on every level of them are still on the market, environment--from estuaries and many of them have long half-lives. She describes what they do rivers to nature, what they do to people, and how they are in forests to humans--and compiling numerous cases from around the end not as effective at what they're ''supposed'' to do as the methods used before the chemicals were invented. Other environmental issues also come up -- invasive species, for instance.

country where ecosystems had already been seriously damaged. Highlights include the extinction of Dutch elms; the massive die-off of robins in the American Midwest, as chronicled in a study on migration and population that started right Midwest when the change happened, because chemicals got into the worms that the robins ate; birds and DDT; the tendency for pesticides to kill off the natural predators to the pests more effectively than they target, exacerbating the pests, which ultimately results in more pests; problem; the extinction use of Dutch elms; using flower-killing herbicides that kill flowers to clear the view for on roads when all that would be was needed is was to cut down trees and scrub; the ease of using, and coming into contact with (and dying of, of) dangerous chemicals ''by accident''; and new chemicals spontaneously forming where chemicals have leaked into the water supply.

The final chapter is about how to fix things -- though, given the tone
unknown effects of the previous chapters, it's a multitude of compounds mingling and creating new, even more on how dangerous poisons.

The later chapters discuss alternatives
to keep them from getting even worse.

In short, this book is
chemical control such as the 1960s literary version introduction of ''Film/AnInconvenientTruth''.

The banning of DDT
natural predators, male sterilization, and its relatives is probably related generally more sustainable farming practices, calling for the public to this book. inform themselves and protest the poorly understood dangers they were being exposed to.



!!'''Tropes''':
* AnimalWrongsGroup - See StrawmanPolitical below.
* AuthorTract
* CrapsackWorld - The picture here is in some ways bleaker than the one in Film/AnInconvenientTruth.
* LiteraryAllusionTitle - The title refers to a poem that contains a description of a barren land where no birds sing. The first chapter is also titled "And No Birds Sing." Spring is silent because the birds are gone. (This book was written in a quieter age.)
* RuleOfSymbolism - It's one of the first environmental books, so Carson stresses the loss of beautiful things -- birds, flowers, butterflies...
* ScareEmStraight
* StrawmanPolitical - Environmentalists and this book are blamed for millions of malaria deaths, which supposedly "proves" that environmentalists care only about animals and hate people.

to:

!!'''Tropes''':
!!Although not a work of fiction, this book provides examples of:

* AnimalWrongsGroup - See StrawmanPolitical below.
CrapsackWorld: Defied, hopefully. Carson warns readers that such a world could arise from continued unregulated chemical spraying.
* AuthorTract
* CrapsackWorld - The picture here is in some ways bleaker than
GreenAesop: Before there were Green Aesops. Carson stresses the one in Film/AnInconvenientTruth.
importance of respect for the environment throughout, reminding readers of humans' place within much larger ecosystems they do not fully understand yet have the power to destroy if careless.
* LiteraryAllusionTitle - LiteraryAllusionTitle: The title refers to a poem that contains a description of a barren land where no birds sing. The first chapter is also titled "And No Birds Sing." Spring is silent because Sing", and the birds are gone. (This book was written in a quieter age.)
* RuleOfSymbolism - It's one
image of a silent, bird-less spring is woven throughout the chapters.
* {{Motif}}: From
the first environmental books, so chapter on, Carson stresses consistently likens the loss of beautiful things -- birds, flowers, butterflies...
* ScareEmStraight
* StrawmanPolitical - Environmentalists
effects and this book are blamed for millions nature of malaria deaths, chemicals to those of radiation--a danger which supposedly "proves" that environmentalists care only about animals already loomed large in the public consciousness in the 50s and hate people.60s.
* ScareEmStraight: The book is rightfully alarming at times, with the intention of impressing on readers the dangers of some of the compounds they were being exposed to.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added namespaces.


In short, this book is the 1960s literary version of ''AnInconvenientTruth''.

to:

In short, this book is the 1960s literary version of ''AnInconvenientTruth''.
''Film/AnInconvenientTruth''.



* CrapsackWorld - The picture here is in some ways bleaker than the one in AnInconvenientTruth.

to:

* CrapsackWorld - The picture here is in some ways bleaker than the one in AnInconvenientTruth.Film/AnInconvenientTruth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


A book by Rachel Carson, her MagnumOpus, written in 1963. It helped launch the environmental movement as we know it.

to:

A book by Rachel Carson, her MagnumOpus, Carson written in 1963. It helped launch the environmental movement as we know it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* StrawmanPolitical - Environmentalists and this book are blamed for millions of malaria deaths, which supposedly "proves" that environmentalists care only about animals and hate people. See HateDumb on the [[YMMV/SilentSpring YMMV]] page.

to:

* StrawmanPolitical - Environmentalists and this book are blamed for millions of malaria deaths, which supposedly "proves" that environmentalists care only about animals and hate people. See HateDumb on the [[YMMV/SilentSpring YMMV]] page.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
namespace move Silent Spring

Added DiffLines:

A book by Rachel Carson, her MagnumOpus, written in 1963. It helped launch the environmental movement as we know it.

The first chapter is a short story parable about a little town that was losing everything good it had -- its wildlife, its birds and birdsong, its beauty, its scenery, the health of its people -- and had no idea why. It ends with the notice of little white crystals of a herbicide that had just been dropped from a plane over the town...

The most memorable parts of this book are about the horrors of modern chemicals -- well, modern for 1963, but some of them are still on the market, and many of them have long half-lives. She describes what they do to nature, what they do to people, and how they are in the end not as effective at what they're ''supposed'' to do as the methods used before the chemicals were invented. Other environmental issues also come up -- invasive species, for instance.

Highlights include the die-off of robins in the American Midwest, as chronicled in a study on migration and population that started right when the change happened, because chemicals got into the worms that the robins ate; birds and DDT; the tendency for pesticides to kill off the natural predators to the pests more effectively than the pests, which ultimately results in more pests; the extinction of Dutch elms; using herbicides that kill flowers to clear the view for roads when all that would be needed is to cut down trees and scrub; the ease of using, and dying of, dangerous chemicals ''by accident''; and new chemicals spontaneously forming where chemicals have leaked into the water supply.

The final chapter is about how to fix things -- though, given the tone of the previous chapters, it's more on how to keep them from getting even worse.

In short, this book is the 1960s literary version of ''AnInconvenientTruth''.

The banning of DDT and its relatives is probably related to this book.
----
!!'''Tropes''':
* AnimalWrongsGroup - See StrawmanPolitical below.
* AuthorTract
* CrapsackWorld - The picture here is in some ways bleaker than the one in AnInconvenientTruth.
* LiteraryAllusionTitle - The title refers to a poem that contains a description of a barren land where no birds sing. The first chapter is also titled "And No Birds Sing." Spring is silent because the birds are gone. (This book was written in a quieter age.)
* RuleOfSymbolism - It's one of the first environmental books, so Carson stresses the loss of beautiful things -- birds, flowers, butterflies...
* ScareEmStraight
* StrawmanPolitical - Environmentalists and this book are blamed for millions of malaria deaths, which supposedly "proves" that environmentalists care only about animals and hate people. See HateDumb on the [[YMMV/SilentSpring YMMV]] page.

Top