Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / JonathanStrangeAndMrNorrell

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* FairyGodmother: The gentleman's interactions with Stephen Black can be considered a very dark deconstruction. Having an incredibly powerful being with a set of customs and morality far removed from humanity's intent on being your friend and champion is described as a hellish life - especially when said being insists on "helping" at times where his aid is not needed or wanted, and in manners that often make things worse while refusing to believe this no matter how many times he is told so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LostPropertyLiveDrop: Magical example; as Stephen Black finds himself being slotted further into the role of the [[TheFairFolk Gentleman With The Thistle-Down Hair]]'s PuppetKing, people are supernaturally manipulated into giving him various kingly objects, often while convinced that they belong to him. Stephen has no choice but to accept them, to the point that his room ends up hopelessly cluttered with items.

Added: 478

Changed: 852

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AgeGapRomance: A very mild example between Strange and Arabella, with six years between them. [[spoiler: Flora Greysteel is also noted as having had a serious crush on him, to the point of being interested in marrying him after Arabella's apparent death, despite the fact that she's 18 and by that point he was about 36. However, while he liked her and saw her as a MoralityPet, he wasn't interested - largely because he'd correctly deduced that Arabella was still alive - and they remain JustFriends.]]

to:

* AgeGapRomance: A very mild example between Strange and Arabella, with six years between them. [[spoiler: Flora Greysteel is also noted as having had a serious crush on him, to the point of being interested in marrying him after Arabella's apparent death, despite the fact that she's 18 and by that point he was about 36. However, while he liked her and her, saw her as a MoralityPet, and enjoyed her company (in the early noted theme of Strange generally preferring the company of intelligent women), he wasn't interested - largely because he'd correctly deduced that Arabella was still alive - and they remain JustFriends.]]



** Jonathan Strange. He plays a vital role in Wellington's campaign, armed with nothing more than chests of books.

to:

** Jonathan Strange. He plays a vital role in Wellington's campaign, armed with nothing more than chests of books.books and memories of fairytales.



* ControlFreak: One of Norrell's key flaws, tied into his characterisation as the Order part in the dynamic with Strange, is that he simply can't bear to allow the development of English magic beyond his control and outside of his perception of what it should be. He also goes to great efforts to destroy or discredit other magicians. The sole exception to this is Strange, the one man he sees as a peer, and he eventually tries that, too, when Strange formally breaks with him.



** Strange in his respect for women, servants and Jews (he criticises the DoubleStandard of SlutShaming, considers his Jewish student to be the most talented of the lot, and and states explicitly that if not for [[spoiler: Arabella's apparent death]], he'd take female students too - unfortunately, propriety would require chaperones etc).

to:

** Strange in his respect for women, servants and Jews (he criticises the DoubleStandard of SlutShaming, considers his Jewish student to be the most talented of the lot, is amiably respectful of Childermass and offers to take him on as a student and an equal, and and states explicitly that if not for [[spoiler: Arabella's apparent death]], he'd take female students too - unfortunately, propriety would require chaperones etc).etc). The women part is at least partially implied to be down to the fact that the happy parts of his childhood were spent growing up with his well-educated female cousins in Scotland, with Segundus noting in his later biography that Strange preferred the company of intelligent women.



* OneSteveLimit: Averted; there are [[https://www.tumblr.com/tellsadstoriesofthedeathofkings/177399328357/a-list-of-every-person-named-john-in-the-entirety 18 charcters named John or some variation thereof]]. This is [[ShownTheirWork more plausible]] than it might sound since [[https://www.galbithink.org/names.htm almost one in five men in the UK at the time were named John]].

to:

* OneSteveLimit: Averted; there are [[https://www.tumblr.com/tellsadstoriesofthedeathofkings/177399328357/a-list-of-every-person-named-john-in-the-entirety 18 charcters named John or some variation thereof]]. This is [[ShownTheirWork more plausible]] than it might sound since [[https://www.galbithink.org/names.htm almost one in five men in the UK at the time were named John]].John]], and given that the Raven King's name (assumed or otherwise) was John Uskglass, it would have had even more appeal.



* ReligionIsMagic: Throwaway lines indicate that religion shares some characteristics with magic. Hell and Heaven are apparently accepted as existing, and Strange mentions that a piece of the Host diminishes his powers. An InUniverse footnote wryly notes that magicians are more interested in how they can make use of Angels, Demons, and Fairies than their moral alignment while priests are scaresly interested in anything else. Its state that the Church was ''very'' quick to crush magic related heresies.

to:

* ReligionIsMagic: Throwaway lines indicate that religion shares some characteristics with magic. Hell and Heaven are apparently accepted as existing, and Strange mentions that a piece of the Host diminishes his powers. An InUniverse footnote wryly notes that magicians are more interested in how they can make use of Angels, Demons, and Fairies than their moral alignment while priests are scaresly scarcely interested in anything else. Its state that the Church was ''very'' quick to crush magic related heresies.



* RitualMagic: The most common form seen, and certainly Norrell's preference. However it weakened over the centuries as the natural world forgot its treaties with the Raven King. Some forms are stricter in their requirements for proper form and ritual to impose certainty, particularly summoning.

to:

* RitualMagic: The most common form seen, and certainly Norrell's preference. However it weakened over the centuries as the natural world forgot its treaties with the Raven King. [[spoiler: Strange brings back English magic by reminding them]]. Some forms are stricter in their requirements for proper form and ritual to impose certainty, particularly summoning.



* WithGreatPowerComesGreatInsanity: It's noted how fairies who have the most powerful magic often have the same level of sanity as humans in madhouses. On the other hand, Norrell and Strange weren't insane when they performed their greatest feats of magic, and neither were the Aureate magicians of the time of the Raven King.

to:

* WithGreatPowerComesGreatInsanity: It's noted how fairies who have the most powerful magic often have the same level of sanity as humans in madhouses. On the other hand, Norrell and Strange weren't insane when they performed their greatest feats of magic, and neither were the Aureate magicians of the time of the Raven King.King... but at the same time, the Aureates were often noted as being a bit odd by modern standards, and Strange only gets more powerful the madder he gets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InSpiteOfANail: In spite of the fact that Northern England was formerly a separate country, ruled by a magician-king for 300 years, and that fairies were demonstrably proven to have existed, England and Europe at the time of the novel are almost exactly as they were in history. Sir Creator/WalterScott, UsefulNotes/TheDukeOfWellington, Creator/FranciscoDeGoya, and Creator/LordByron all show up, and are shown or implied to be just as they were in RealLife. There also doesn't seem to be a tradition of magic in any other countries (such as France, which might otherwise have given Bonaparte an edge in the Peninsular War) even though it's shown that fairies are not confined to England.

to:

* InSpiteOfANail: In spite of the fact that Northern England was formerly a separate country, ruled by a magician-king for 300 years, and that fairies were demonstrably proven to have existed, England and Europe at the time of the novel are almost exactly as they were in history. Sir Creator/WalterScott, UsefulNotes/TheDukeOfWellington, Creator/FranciscoDeGoya, and Creator/LordByron all show up, and are shown or implied to be just as they were in RealLife. There also doesn't seem to be a tradition of magic in any other countries (such as France, which might otherwise have given Bonaparte an edge in the Peninsular War) War, or Ireland, which could have put a decided crimp in England's occupation of the country) even though it's shown that fairies are not by no means confined to England.

Changed: 398

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DancesAndBalls: PlayedForHorror Steven and Lady Poole end up spending '''years''' dancing the night away at Lost Hope as the "guests", read hostages, of the its master the gentleman with the thistle-down hair which leaves them utterly exhausted.

to:

* DancesAndBalls: PlayedForHorror Steven Stephen and Lady Poole end up spending '''years''' dancing the night away at Lost Hope as the "guests", read hostages, of the its master the gentleman with the thistle-down hair which leaves them utterly exhausted.



* OneSteveLimit: Averted with Jonathan Strange, John Segundus, John Childermass, and John Uskglass. There are other Johns as minor characters in the book as well.

to:

* OneSteveLimit: Averted with Jonathan Strange, Averted; there are [[https://www.tumblr.com/tellsadstoriesofthedeathofkings/177399328357/a-list-of-every-person-named-john-in-the-entirety 18 charcters named John Segundus, John Childermass, and John Uskglass. There are other Johns as minor characters or some variation thereof]]. This is [[ShownTheirWork more plausible]] than it might sound since [[https://www.galbithink.org/names.htm almost one in five men in the book as well.UK at the time were named John]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Pastiche}}: Of [[RegencyEngland Regency-era fiction]], right up to using period-appropriate spelling and references.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* VictorianNovelDisease: Miss Wintertown dies of this. [[spoiler: She gets better.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* UnwantedAssistance: It's dangerous to have a fairy mad at you, but a fairy who ''likes'' you is hardly any better. At best, they're generous but clueless at gift-giving, ranging from "nice but useless" (one fairy gave a favorite mortal a diamond-encrusted sailboat) to "actively a problem" (the Gentleman tries to give Arabella a pet tiger). At worst, they're, well, the Gentleman With the Thistledown Hair. He genuinely believes that his vict--er, dear friends--need to be "rescued" from people and situations they in fact like very much, and spirited away to the torm--er, joys--of Lost-Hope, and in the meantime, would Stephen care to be an Archbishop?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheFairFolk: They're so self-centered and hedonistic that if it wasn't for their powerful magic they'd quickly end up extinct. It's debatable whether the gentleman with the thistle-down hair even understood the concept that other people might have different opinions. It's stated that Julius Caesar once served as judge of the Fairies, because at the time ''every Faerie alive'' stood accused of some crime or had close ties to an accused, so none were fit to stand in judgment. Despite being a key element of the story, only two members appear.

to:

* TheFairFolk: Fairies live in a realm that's only magically connected to England, and during the rule of John Uskglass in the Middle Ages constantly came to the mortal realm to charm and beguile humans away for nefarious purposes. They're so self-centered and hedonistic that if it wasn't for their powerful magic they'd quickly end up extinct. It's extinct; it's debatable whether the gentleman with the thistle-down hair even understood the concept that other people might have different opinions. It's stated that Julius Caesar once served as judge of the Fairies, because at the time ''every Faerie alive'' stood accused of some crime or had close ties to an accused, so none were fit to stand in judgment. Despite being a key element of the story, only two members appear.appear in the narrative proper, although many of the aureate magicians of the past were known to employ them as servants.



* InSpiteOfANail: In spite of the fact that Northern England was formerly a separate country, ruled by a magician-king for 300 years, England and Europe at the time of the novel are almost exactly as they were in history. Sir Creator/WalterScott, Creator/LewisCarroll, Creator/FranciscoDeGoya, and Creator/LordByron all show up, and are shown or implied to be just as they were in RealLife.

to:

* InSpiteOfANail: In spite of the fact that Northern England was formerly a separate country, ruled by a magician-king for 300 years, and that fairies were demonstrably proven to have existed, England and Europe at the time of the novel are almost exactly as they were in history. Sir Creator/WalterScott, Creator/LewisCarroll, UsefulNotes/TheDukeOfWellington, Creator/FranciscoDeGoya, and Creator/LordByron all show up, and are shown or implied to be just as they were in RealLife.RealLife. There also doesn't seem to be a tradition of magic in any other countries (such as France, which might otherwise have given Bonaparte an edge in the Peninsular War) even though it's shown that fairies are not confined to England.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InSpiteOfANail: In spite of the fact that Northern England was formerly a separate country, ruled by a magician-king for 300 years, England and Europe at the time of the novel are almost exactly as they were in history. Sir Creator/WalterScott, Creator/LewisCarroll, Francisco Goya, and Creator/LordByron all show up, and are shown or implied to be just as they were in RealLife.

to:

* InSpiteOfANail: In spite of the fact that Northern England was formerly a separate country, ruled by a magician-king for 300 years, England and Europe at the time of the novel are almost exactly as they were in history. Sir Creator/WalterScott, Creator/LewisCarroll, Francisco Goya, Creator/FranciscoDeGoya, and Creator/LordByron all show up, and are shown or implied to be just as they were in RealLife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlackMagic: Strange practices some during the Napoleonic Wars, using it to raise slain Neapolitans from the dead as horrible, sapient zombies in order to get information from them. They are finally burned "alive" after the living soldiers are too creeped out to be around them - although, to his credit, Strange does try several times to reverse the spell on them (tragically, the reversal was quite simple, but no one remembered how). As a rather dark HistoricalInJoke, this act is suggested to have inspired the artist Goya's production of hellish paintings of war and witchcraft.

to:

* BlackMagic: Strange practices some during the Napoleonic Wars, using it to raise slain Neapolitans from the dead as horrible, sapient zombies in order to get information from them. They are finally burned "alive" after the living soldiers are too creeped out to be around them - although, to his credit, Strange does try several times to reverse the spell on them (tragically, the reversal was quite simple, but no one remembered how). As a rather dark HistoricalInJoke, this act is suggested to have inspired the artist Goya's Creator/FranciscoDeGoya's production of hellish paintings of war and witchcraft.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReligionIsMagic: Throwaway lines indicate that religion shares some characteristics with magic. Hell and Heaven are apparently accepted as existing, and Strange mentions that a piece of the Host diminishes his powers.

to:

* ReligionIsMagic: Throwaway lines indicate that religion shares some characteristics with magic. Hell and Heaven are apparently accepted as existing, and Strange mentions that a piece of the Host diminishes his powers. An InUniverse footnote wryly notes that magicians are more interested in how they can make use of Angels, Demons, and Fairies than their moral alignment while priests are scaresly interested in anything else. Its state that the Church was ''very'' quick to crush magic related heresies.

Added: 258

Changed: 1

Removed: 253

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS disambig


* PoisonousFriend: The gentleman's relationship toward Stephen Black, ruining his life and encouraging his resentment of Englishmen. Drawlight and Lascelles similarly drive away any possible influences on Norrell other than themselves, to his detriment.



* ToxicFriendInfluence: The gentleman's relationship toward Stephen Black, ruining his life and encouraging his resentment of Englishmen. Drawlight and Lascelles similarly drive away any possible influences on Norrell other than themselves, to his detriment.



* TrueLovesKiss: [[spoiler: In the BBC series, Strange releases Arabella from her enchantment with a BigDamnKiss, appropriately for a fairy tale.]]

to:

* TrueLovesKiss: [[spoiler: In [[spoiler:In the BBC series, Strange releases Arabella from her enchantment with a BigDamnKiss, appropriately for a fairy tale.]]

Added: 605

Changed: 210

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoubleStandard: At one point, Lascelles has an affair with a married woman, Maria Bullworth, who believes he will run away with her. Of course he does nothing of the sort, and when the affair becomes public her reputation is ruined, her husband casts her off and she is forced to live on her father's charity, secluded in the country. Lascelles, naturally, gets off scot free without any judgement from polite society. You can hardly blame Mrs. Bullworth for wanting to get revenge on him with magic.

to:

* DoubleStandard: At one point, Lascelles has an affair with a married woman, Maria Bullworth, who believes he will run away with her. Of course he does nothing of the sort, and when the affair becomes public her reputation is ruined, her husband casts her off and she is forced to live on her father's charity, secluded in the country. Lascelles, naturally, gets off scot free without any judgement from polite society. You can hardly blame Mrs. Bullworth for wanting to get revenge on him with magic.magic, and Strange certainly does not, remarking that he is entirely sympathetic to the desire (and profoundly dislikes the social double-standard) even if it's not the sort of magic he would ever willingly practice.


Added DiffLines:

* OneOfTheGirls: Strange, up to a point. This is explained as being the result of being primarily raised by his mother's family, among his aunts and female cousins (who spoiled him somewhat to make-up for his father's ParentalNeglect). A footnote remarks that his future biographer would observe that while he has a number of male friendships, even in adulthood he prefers the company of clever women. It also explains why he's perfectly happy with the idea of theoretically teaching women and girls, the only obstacle being the need for a chaperone, something that startles even his more liberal friends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
typo


''Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell'' is the highly acclaimed first novel by Susanna Clarke, published in 2004. The story shews, in historical fashion, the involvements of magicians and [[TheFairFolk fairies]] in [[AlternateHistory alternate]] [[GaslampFantasy Britain]] of the [[RegencyEngland Regency era]]. Being [[DoorStopper nearly 1000 pages long]], the book is well-known (and well-loved) for skillfully combining political intrigue, elaborate academic footnotes and [[GenreThrowback sweet charcoal illustrations]].

to:

''Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell'' is the highly acclaimed first novel by Susanna Clarke, published in 2004. The story shews, shows, in historical fashion, the involvements of magicians and [[TheFairFolk fairies]] in [[AlternateHistory alternate]] [[GaslampFantasy Britain]] of the [[RegencyEngland Regency era]]. Being [[DoorStopper nearly 1000 pages long]], the book is well-known (and well-loved) for skillfully combining political intrigue, elaborate academic footnotes and [[GenreThrowback sweet charcoal illustrations]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell'' is the highly acclaimed first novel by Susanna Clarke, published in 2004. The story shews, in historical fashion, the involvements of magicians and [[TheFairFolk fairies]] in [[AlternateHistory alternate]] [[GaslampFantasy Britain]] of the [[RegencyEngland Regency era]]. Being [[DoorStopper nearly 1000 pages long]], the book is well-known (and well-loved) for skillfully combining political intrigue, elaborate academic footnotes and [[GenreThrowback sweet charcoal illustrations]].

to:

''Jonathan Strange & Mr Mr. Norrell'' is the highly acclaimed first novel by Susanna Clarke, published in 2004. The story shews, in historical fashion, the involvements of magicians and [[TheFairFolk fairies]] in [[AlternateHistory alternate]] [[GaslampFantasy Britain]] of the [[RegencyEngland Regency era]]. Being [[DoorStopper nearly 1000 pages long]], the book is well-known (and well-loved) for skillfully combining political intrigue, elaborate academic footnotes and [[GenreThrowback sweet charcoal illustrations]].

Top