Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / KoeNoKatachi

Go To

OR

Changed: 591

Removed: 1291

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How did the judge who mocked Nagatsuka's movie at the assembly get away with that? He starts with a creepy comment about how if he wanted to see Nagatsuka masturbating he would have snuck into his room at night, and it only gets worse from there. It's understandable how in a classroom setting bullying might go unreported, but making graphic comments like that on stage in front of the entire faculty and student body and maybe even the press seems like it would become a major scandal, except it never occurs to any of the characters that they might be able to have him punished.
* Exactly why did the teacher, and classmates, look shocked about various little problems with Nishimiya's disability? It's quite common that deaf people end up mute and can't talk properly, because they don't get to learn words the way most people do, by hearing them first and they can't hear themselves, making it difficult for them to know how to pronounce words. It's the same thing with her being tone-deaf. Did they not figure that such things would be an issue to begin with?
** The kids probably hadn't had any interaction with people with disabilities similar to Nishimiya's before, and had no reason to research it. At their age (aren't they in elementary school or junior high at the beginning of the manga?), I myself didn't know deaf people didn't talk properly or at all until at least around fifth grade (when my mother explained it me so, and yes, I did felt very stupid since when she explained it seemed very obvious), since I had never interacted or seen a deaf person talking on any media (and given that this is Japan, I'm assuming there aren't many deaf people on TV as well). The teacher probably should've known better, but perhaps he never had a child with disabilities in his classes and didn't know how to deal with it now that a deaf girl was one of his students.

to:

* How did the judge who mocked Nagatsuka's movie at the assembly get away with that? He starts with a creepy comment about how if he wanted to see Nagatsuka masturbating he would have snuck into his room at night, and it only gets worse from there. It's understandable how in a classroom setting bullying might go unreported, but making graphic comments like that on stage in front of the entire faculty and student body and maybe even the press seems like it would become a major scandal, except it never occurs to any of the characters that they might be able to have him punished.
* Exactly why did the teacher, and classmates, look shocked about various little problems with Nishimiya's disability? It's quite common that deaf people end up mute and can't talk properly, because they don't get to learn words the way most people do, by hearing them first and they can't hear themselves, making it difficult for them to know how to pronounce words. It's the same thing with her being tone-deaf. Did they not figure that such things would be an issue to begin with?
** The kids probably hadn't had any interaction with people with disabilities similar to Nishimiya's before, and had no reason to research it. At their age (aren't they in elementary school or junior high at the beginning of the manga?), I myself didn't know deaf people didn't talk properly or at all until at least around fifth grade (when my mother explained it me so, and yes, I did felt very stupid since when she explained it seemed very obvious), since I had never interacted or seen a deaf person talking on any media (and given that this is Japan, I'm assuming there aren't many deaf people on TV as well). The teacher probably should've known better, but perhaps he never had a child with disabilities in his classes and didn't know how to deal with it now that a deaf girl was one of his students.
[[redirect:Headscratchers/ASilentVoice]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Exactly why did the teacher, and classmates, look shocked about various little problems with Nishimiya's disability? It's quite common that deaf people end up mute and can't talk properly, because they don't get to learn words the way most people do, by hearing them first and they can't hear themselves, making it difficult for them to know how to pronounce words. It's the same thing with her being tone-deaf. Did they not figure that such things would be an issue to begin with?

to:

* Exactly why did the teacher, and classmates, look shocked about various little problems with Nishimiya's disability? It's quite common that deaf people end up mute and can't talk properly, because they don't get to learn words the way most people do, by hearing them first and they can't hear themselves, making it difficult for them to know how to pronounce words. It's the same thing with her being tone-deaf. Did they not figure that such things would be an issue to begin with?with?
** The kids probably hadn't had any interaction with people with disabilities similar to Nishimiya's before, and had no reason to research it. At their age (aren't they in elementary school or junior high at the beginning of the manga?), I myself didn't know deaf people didn't talk properly or at all until at least around fifth grade (when my mother explained it me so, and yes, I did felt very stupid since when she explained it seemed very obvious), since I had never interacted or seen a deaf person talking on any media (and given that this is Japan, I'm assuming there aren't many deaf people on TV as well). The teacher probably should've known better, but perhaps he never had a child with disabilities in his classes and didn't know how to deal with it now that a deaf girl was one of his students.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How did the judge who mocked Nagatsuka's movie at the assembly get away with that? He starts with a creepy comment about how if he wanted to see Nagatsuka masturbating he would have snuck into his room at night, and it only gets worse from there. It's understandable how in a classroom setting bullying might go unreported, but making graphic comments like that on stage in front of the entire faculty and student body and maybe even the press seems like it would become a major scandal, except it never occurs to any of the characters that they might be able to have him punished.

to:

* How did the judge who mocked Nagatsuka's movie at the assembly get away with that? He starts with a creepy comment about how if he wanted to see Nagatsuka masturbating he would have snuck into his room at night, and it only gets worse from there. It's understandable how in a classroom setting bullying might go unreported, but making graphic comments like that on stage in front of the entire faculty and student body and maybe even the press seems like it would become a major scandal, except it never occurs to any of the characters that they might be able to have him punished.punished.
* Exactly why did the teacher, and classmates, look shocked about various little problems with Nishimiya's disability? It's quite common that deaf people end up mute and can't talk properly, because they don't get to learn words the way most people do, by hearing them first and they can't hear themselves, making it difficult for them to know how to pronounce words. It's the same thing with her being tone-deaf. Did they not figure that such things would be an issue to begin with?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* How did the judge who mocked Nagatsuka's movie at the assembly get away with that? He starts with a creepy comment about how if he wanted to see Nagatsuka masturbating he would have snuck into his room at night, and it only gets worse from there. It's understandable how in a classroom setting bullying might go unreported, but making graphic comments like that on stage in front of the entire faculty and student body and maybe even the press seems like it would become a major scandal, except it never occurs to any of the characters that they might be able to have him punished.

Top