Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / BlackPanther2018

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alternately, the defender fights one challenger at a time, and they rest and use Wakandan tech to heal back up to full strength. If multiple tribes want to challenge, they decide after each fight whether they want to challenge the victor. It's possible in that scenario that either the defender proves his mettle to the other challengers, or the challenger wins and the other challengers decide to back down because they don't have an issue with the victor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's plenty of evidence that shows Wakandans aren't stingy in taking some bits of Western trends and making it their own. The chief of the River Tribe has a Western style suit made from Wakandan textiles, and Shuri's 'sneakers' are directly drawn from Film/BackToTheFuture (plus she's into internet memes). There's no outright disdain for foreign influence, but anything foreign is likely to be Wakandanized to suit the preferences of its citizens.

to:

** There's plenty of evidence that shows Wakandans aren't stingy in taking some bits of Western trends and making it their own. The chief of the River Tribe has a Western style suit made from Wakandan textiles, and Shuri's 'sneakers' are directly drawn from Film/BackToTheFuture Franchise/BackToTheFuture (plus she's into internet memes). There's no outright disdain for foreign influence, but anything foreign is likely to be Wakandanized to suit the preferences of its citizens.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Who says? Could be, that's ''her'' nanotech battle-gear she's decked out in, complete with nanite-applied war paint and instant hairdo.

Added: 244

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the Black Panther movie, the world believes Wakanda is an isolationist Third World country with no rich resources and few exports yet in the other movies like Age of Ultron and Civil War, the world knows that Wakanda is rich with Vibranium since it was the metal Ultron used in his insane plans and what Captain America's shield is made of. So why does the movie have conflicting information about Wakanda pretending to be a poor nation with nothing when in secret it's technologically advanced and rich with Vibranium when the previous movies reveal it's that one isolationist nation the world knows has the rare but expensive Vibranium? Even Bruce was able to get old records of the Klaue family rivalry with the Black Panthers online.

to:

* In the Black Panther movie, the world believes Wakanda is an isolationist Third World country with no rich resources and few exports yet in the other movies like Age ''Age of Ultron Ultron'' and Civil War, ''Civil War'', the world knows that Wakanda is rich with Vibranium since it was the metal Ultron used in his insane plans and what Captain America's shield is made of. So why does the movie have conflicting information about Wakanda pretending to be a poor nation with nothing when in secret it's technologically advanced and rich with Vibranium when the previous movies reveal it's that one isolationist nation the world knows has the rare but expensive Vibranium? Even Bruce was able to get old records of the Klaue family rivalry with the Black Panthers online.


Added DiffLines:

** Being "rich with" a resource existing nowhere else on the planet could just as easily mean "has enough of it to (maybe) fill a car trunk" as "has a whole mountain of the stuff". Before this film, non-Wakandans had simply assumed the former.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Shuri's change of outfit]]
* Right before joining the final battle, Shuri has a complete change in her appearance. She changed her clothes, put her hair up into a bun, and has very detailed war paint all over her face. How was she able to do all of that in what appears to be 30 seconds in movie time, and why would she bother when the battle was already going? Honestly, I wouldn't even be caring about this if it wasn't for that moment earlier in the film where she made fun of T'Challa for having to physically put on his helmet. However long it took her to do all those things, it would have taken longer than it takes to put on a helmet.

Added: 369

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Killmonger's backstory is that he was a Navy SEAL and specifically one proficient at toppling governments. Irregular warfare is explicitly his strength. In his plan, Wakanda's War Dogs would behave exactly the way US Special Forces often do: training, arming, and directing a local resistance against the hostile government, which is part of the message of the film.



* W'Kabi's decision to instantly turn on T'Challa never made any sense to me. The two shared a friendship that seemed to extend beyond their stations, and T'Challa jumped at the opportunity to capture Klaue. T'Challa's failure would obviously be disappointing, but it seems counter-intuitive that it would inspire W'Kabi turning away from T'Challa and embracing the man who facilitated Klaue's escape in the first place. Even if W'Kabi didn't explicitly know Erik broke Klaue out, he's smart enough to be suspicious of a man who came out of nowhere with the body of his father's killer. And even if he wasn't, supporting Klaue's claim to the throne and the reordering of Wakanda's entire geopolitical mission is a huge leap.

to:

* W'Kabi's decision to instantly turn on T'Challa never made any sense to me. The two shared a friendship that seemed to extend beyond their stations, and T'Challa jumped at the opportunity to capture Klaue. T'Challa's failure would obviously be disappointing, but it seems counter-intuitive that it would inspire W'Kabi turning away from T'Challa and embracing the man who facilitated Klaue's escape in the first place. Even if W'Kabi didn't explicitly know Erik broke Klaue out, he's smart enough to be suspicious of a man who came out of nowhere with the body of his father's killer. And even if he wasn't, supporting Klaue's Erik's claim to the throne and the reordering of Wakanda's entire geopolitical mission is a huge leap.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
just putting this here for future editors

Added DiffLines:

'''As a Headscratchers subpage, all spoilers are unmarked [[Administrivia/SpoilersOff as per policy.]] Administrivia/YouHaveBeenWarned.'''
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is also a universe where people see aliens and take out their phones, instead of running away, as seen in ''Film/ThorTheDarkWorld''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Anyone who watched TheFalconAndTheWinterSoldier would knew this is a bad idea.

to:

** Anyone who watched TheFalconAndTheWinterSoldier Series/TheFalconAndTheWinterSoldier would knew this is a bad idea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Anyone who watched TheFalconAndTheWinterSoldier would knew this is a bad idea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** That whole scene is bordering on WhatAnIdiot, combined with HonorBeforeReason. Then again, T'Challa is obviously not in a right state of mind, what with having just learned how his father killed his uncle before abandoning his cousin to fend for himself in California.

to:

** That whole scene is bordering on WhatAnIdiot, combined with HonorBeforeReason. Then again, T'Challa is obviously not in a right state of mind, what with having just learned how his father killed his uncle before abandoning his cousin to fend for himself in California.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Heart-Shaped Herb is sacred in Wakandan culture. Even if the artificial serum was ''much'' more effective, the Herb's loss is still a tragedy that Wakandans would go to tremendous lengths to undo if they can.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** You have not seen any link to where Ryan ever said that. And if he didn't want to destroy Wakanda, he would not have ordered the burning of the source of power for future Black Panthers, kill or try to kill T'Challa's family members (which by the way, are also his own), loved ones and followers, and he wouldn't outright state that he doesn't care if Wakanda is destroyed so long as the world feels the same pain he felt, and that doesn't account for all the kills he tallied on his body (including that of his "own brothers and sisters on this continent."), him having worked alongside Wakanda's most hated enemy and killed not just him, but his own girlfriend as well. If he says it is lost and yet has the herb burned

to:

*** You have not seen any link to where Ryan ever said that. And if he Erik didn't want to destroy Wakanda, he would not have ordered the burning of the source of power for future Black Panthers, kill or try to kill T'Challa's family members (which by the way, are also his own), loved ones and followers, and he wouldn't outright state that he doesn't care if Wakanda is destroyed so long as the world feels the same pain he felt, and that doesn't account for all the kills he tallied on his body (including that of his "own brothers and sisters on this continent."), him having worked alongside Wakanda's most hated enemy and killed not just him, but his own girlfriend as well. If he says it is lost and yet has the herb burnedburned, which would make it even more lost with no kings after him, what do you think he gains from doing so? Righting the wrongs? How does that act make things better for anyone? As for not using other means to want to burn the world, you could say the same thing about not using other ways to change the status quo and end black oppression. (like the solution that T'Challa ends up using at the end of the movie to try to achieve that) There's a reason his own character page lists Killmonger as a NotSoWellIntentionedExtremist. He spilled it out in the final battle his true motivation when he dismisses being called out on how his plan would destroy the world, Wakanda included, because the world took everything from "him".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I'm not certain (and where in the world did the director even say it?) that taking on the world and wanting Wakanda destroyed is that different, especially given the above justifications he thinks he has to think it counts as an oppressor. Plus, him destroying the heart shaped herb and the consequences of doing so as mentioned above, should be proof enough at him directing his rage at Wakanda is accurate.


Added DiffLines:

*** You have not seen any link to where Ryan ever said that. And if he didn't want to destroy Wakanda, he would not have ordered the burning of the source of power for future Black Panthers, kill or try to kill T'Challa's family members (which by the way, are also his own), loved ones and followers, and he wouldn't outright state that he doesn't care if Wakanda is destroyed so long as the world feels the same pain he felt, and that doesn't account for all the kills he tallied on his body (including that of his "own brothers and sisters on this continent."), him having worked alongside Wakanda's most hated enemy and killed not just him, but his own girlfriend as well. If he says it is lost and yet has the herb burned

Top