Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / Watchmen

Go To

OR

Added: 164

Changed: 100

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The guy who tries to assassinate Veidt is named Roy Chess. Turned out he was just a pawn of Veidt.
** In the film, his box says "[[ForeShadowing A NEW WORLD IS DELIVERED]]". Also, the company he was an employee of/pretended to work for...is itself owned by Veidt.

Added: 4

Changed: 384

Removed: 68

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The incredible symmetry that slowly unveils itself over the course of the book.

to:

* The incredible symmetry that slowly unveils itself over the course book's use of the book. clocks as an ArcSymbol leads to some intricate subtext that's easy to miss on first reading.



** The term "Watchmen" refers to both costumed heroes and Jon's original desire to be a watchmaker.
*** Similarly, [[StealthPun "Minutemen"]] also fits the clock theme.

to:

** The term word "Watchmen" refers to both costumed heroes and Jon's original desire to can be interpreted as a watchmaker.
*** Similarly, [[StealthPun "Minutemen"]] also fits the
clock theme.pun, which is reinforced by the fact that Jon Osterman originally wanted to become a watchmaker. Not to mention that the world's first superhero team were called the "'''Minute'''men".



** Dr. Manhattan experiences time in a non-linear fashion. How is the story told? Primarily through flashback, i.e. non-linearly. In fact, since Dr. Manhattan can perceive all of time at once, it could be argued we're seeing the story from HIS perspective.

to:

** Dr. Doctor Manhattan experiences time in a non-linear fashion. How is the story told? Primarily through flashback, i.e. non-linearly. In fact, since Dr. Doctor Manhattan can perceive all of time at once, it could be argued we're seeing the story from HIS perspective.



* In a slight change from the comic book, Dr. Mahattan claims to not be omniscient despite retaining his ability to view the past, present, and future simultaneously. This makes sense given the different medium he's currently in. Unlike a comic book, where the reader could read and/or view two different events on different pages simultaneously, the same can't be said for watching a film; the viewer can only rewind and fast-forward to see a particular scene, and even using the "scene selection" feature only allows them to see the scene at a certain point.

to:

* In a slight change from the comic book, Dr. Mahattan claims to not be omniscient despite retaining his ability to view the past, present, and future simultaneously. This makes sense given the different medium he's currently in. Unlike a comic book, where the reader could read and/or view two different events on different pages simultaneously, the same can't be said for watching a film; the viewer can only rewind and fast-forward to see a particular scene, and even using the "scene selection" feature only allows them to see the scene at a certain point.point.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Rorschach is a pretty lousy detective, and it's entirely thanks to his black-and-white worldview. Instead of searching for evidence and judging without preconception, he makes wild, paranoid assumptions based off his own prejudices and hang-ups. He's more interested in confirming if Adrian is a closeted homosexual than confirming if he's a suspect. He even briefly thinks a former enemy is enacting their plan ''from beyond the grave'', [[EveryoneHasStandards which Rorschach quickly realizes is too far-fetched, even for him]]. It's only when the much more reasonable Dan joins the case that they start getting somewhere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alphabetizing example(s)


* A little bit of meta fun: comic-readers will know that the sequence of Ozymandias almost being assassinated was depicted in chapter 5, 'Fearful Symmetry', which is famed for its clever use of literal symmetry with the issue's events and even how the panels are laid out to be read, with Veidt flooring his would-be assassin in the dead-centre of the issue. Obviously the film was every chapter merged into one, and it would've been nearly impossible to lay the scenes out in the same way without just literally slapping the comic pages on the screen ala Ang Lee's 'Hulk'. Yet they still managed to make the assassination scene have a theme of symmetry... through the set. Two reception counters on either side, with identical looking receptionists, and a simple geometric fountain structure in the dead centre of the room, with a slew of elevators in the back, while Veidt stands in the middle of a group. The entire room is a mirror image down the middle.

to:

* A little bit of meta fun: comic-readers will know that the sequence of Ozymandias almost being assassinated was depicted in chapter 5, 'Fearful Symmetry', which is famed for its clever use of literal symmetry with the issue's events and even how the panels are laid out to be read, with Veidt flooring his would-be assassin in the dead-centre of the issue. Obviously the film was every chapter merged into one, and it would've been nearly impossible to lay the scenes out in the same way without just literally slapping the comic pages on the screen ala Ang Lee's 'Hulk'. Yet they still managed to make the assassination scene have a theme of symmetry... through the set. Two reception counters on either side, with identical looking receptionists, and a simple geometric fountain structure in the dead centre of the room, with a slew of elevators in the back, while Veidt stands in the middle of a group. The entire room is a mirror image down the middle.middle.
* In a slight change from the comic book, Dr. Mahattan claims to not be omniscient despite retaining his ability to view the past, present, and future simultaneously. This makes sense given the different medium he's currently in. Unlike a comic book, where the reader could read and/or view two different events on different pages simultaneously, the same can't be said for watching a film; the viewer can only rewind and fast-forward to see a particular scene, and even using the "scene selection" feature only allows them to see the scene at a certain point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Too much me me me


** And on a lesser extent, it also explains why he built that big weird glass thing on Mars in the style of a watch-- in some ways it's a glass prison, an extension of his detachment from reality, and how his fatalism has led him to believe everyone just runs like clockwork. Silk Spectre breaking it... well, I think you can figure that one out.
** People often wonder why Jon keeps the same personality, etc, etc, doesn't change sides from the US after he becomes Manhattan. It occurred to me: Manhattan is utterly a creature of physics. And Newton's First Law of physics is inertia: namely, that a body which is not acted on by an outside force will ''keep on doing what it was doing.''

to:

** And on a lesser extent, it also explains why he built that big weird glass thing on Mars in the style of a watch-- in some ways it's a glass prison, an extension of his detachment from reality, and how his fatalism has led him to believe everyone just runs like clockwork. Silk Spectre breaking it... well, I think you can figure that one out.
** People often wonder why Jon keeps the same personality, etc, etc, doesn't change sides from the US after he becomes Manhattan. It occurred to me: this troper: Manhattan is utterly a creature of physics. And Newton's First Law of physics is inertia: namely, that a body which is not acted on by an outside force will ''keep on doing what it was doing.''



** The first time I read through ''Comicbook/{{Watchmen}}'' I thought the pirate comic was fun and interesting (if [[{{Squick}} squicky]] story about the tale of a man trying to protect his loved ones and ultimately becoming the thing he tries to protect them from, but not terribly relevant to the story. It wasn't until a second read through that I realized that the "Tales" story is all about [[spoiler:Adrian]] doing the very thing he is trying to prevent (i.e. [[spoiler:killing millions of people in a single strike]]).

to:

** The first time I this troper read through ''Comicbook/{{Watchmen}}'' I thought the pirate comic was fun and interesting (if [[{{Squick}} squicky]] story about the tale of a man trying to protect his loved ones and ultimately becoming the thing he tries to protect them from, but not terribly relevant to the story. It wasn't until a second read through that I realized that the "Tales" story is all about [[spoiler:Adrian]] doing the very thing he is trying to prevent (i.e. [[spoiler:killing millions of people in a single strike]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Doctor Manhattan's method of "dispatching" foes (gangsters, soldiers, etc.) almost always involves him utterly disintegrating them. Certainly, a being with his vast abilities could certainly incapacitate enemies without reducing them to a red smear. But as Manhattan basically looks at "people" as being nothing more than a finite set of atomic particles arranged in a random, haphazard way, dispersing those particles is merely the most natural, efficient method. And it's not like "life" really ''means'' anything, right?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Now imagine other countries like the Soviet Union trying to replicate Osterman's accident. They are unaware that Osterman's knowledge of watchmaking and nuclear physics is what allows him to reassemble himself, so the poor bastards used in these experiments would just end up as disembodied consciousnesses incapable of interacting with the world for the rest of eternity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Rorschach douses himself in cologne, attempting (but failing) to hide his offensive body odor. One of the brands of cologne he's seen using is "Nostalgia" (by VEIDT), which he swipes from Dan's townhouse. Sure, he's just grabbing whatever's convenient, but the hidden meaning here could be that Rorschach (Kovacs), despite his terrible childhood and upbringing, still has at least some pleasant memories of President Truman and societal values being prevalent when women didn't (at least in his mind) dress and act like whores and the line between good and evil was clearly delineated. Rorschach (Walter Kovacs) is both literally and figuratively bathing in Nostalgia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Except for the fact that at one point just before he and Nite Owl II leave for Karnak, he states that he made a point to write as legibly as possible, so there's be less ambiguity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One might find the story's non-costumed characters boring. It always seemed like their plotlines were pointless compared to the "heroes." Later, during my umpteenth re-reading, I suddenly realized that ''this was the whole point''. All of the scenes of their lives in the previous chapters make you invested in their stories, [[spoiler:making it all the more harrowing when they are all violently killed by Ozy's scheme. Through their deaths, we are made to understand the enormity of what Ozy has done. Those dead characters are just a tiny fraction of the ''three million people'' that died in that horrible moment. Moore couldn't have made us feel every life (like Ozy claimed to do to himself), but though those characters that we came to know, we are able to better feel the true scale of the evil that Adrian has unleashed.]]

to:

* One might find the story's non-costumed characters boring. It always seemed like their plotlines were pointless compared to the "heroes." Later, during my umpteenth re-reading, I suddenly realized that ''this was the whole point''. All of the scenes of their lives in the previous chapters make you invested in their stories, [[spoiler:making it all the more harrowing when they are all violently killed by Ozy's scheme. Through their deaths, we are made to understand the enormity of what Ozy has done. Those dead characters are just a tiny fraction of the ''three million people'' that died in that horrible moment. Moore couldn't have made us feel every life (like Ozy claimed to do to himself), but though through those characters that we came to know, we are able to better feel the true scale of the evil that Adrian has unleashed.]]

Added: 284

Changed: 285

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Dr. Manhattan experiences time in a non-linear fashion. How is the story told? Primarily through flashback, i.e. non-linearly. In fact, since Dr. Manhattan can perceive all of time at once, it could be argued we're seeing the story from HIS perspective. * Over time Dr. Manhattan "loses touch" with humanity, and one of the ways this is illustrated is his dialogue: soon after his transformation, he asks Janey "What's up?", but when the TV host asks him the same question later, [[LiteralMinded he doesn't seem to appreciate the idiom.]]

to:

** Dr. Manhattan experiences time in a non-linear fashion. How is the story told? Primarily through flashback, i.e. non-linearly. In fact, since Dr. Manhattan can perceive all of time at once, it could be argued we're seeing the story from HIS perspective. perspective.
* Over time Dr. Manhattan "loses touch" with humanity, and one of the ways this is illustrated is his dialogue: soon after his transformation, he asks Janey "What's up?", but when the TV host asks him the same question later, [[LiteralMinded he doesn't seem to appreciate the idiom.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The Comedian's name could be read as a ShoutOut to ComicBook/TheJoker. If this was intentional, it may be one of the most scathing points about superheroes in the entire book: if superheroes actually existed in the real world, a violent sociopath like the Joker wouldn't have any need to become a supervillain--because he could just work out his violent impulses on petty criminals, and might even be [[VillainWithGoodPublicity treated like a hero]] by much of the public for doing so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Chekov's Gun not within the comic proper, but the supplemental pieces inbetween - Rorschach's arrest record makes a point to mention that the Rorschach's journal, the thing that the final twist revolves around, contains handwriting eccentric to the point of illegibility...

to:

* Chekov's Gun not within the comic proper, but the supplemental pieces inbetween - Rorschach's arrest record makes a point to mention that the Rorschach's journal, the thing that the final twist revolves around, his journal contains handwriting eccentric to the point of illegibility...illegibility. This is likely meant to be a hint that [[spoiler:Rorschach's plan to reveal the truth about the alien invasion [[AllForNothing won't work]]--because nobody will be able to read his journal]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Though that's assuming Bubastis' consciousness even survived the intrinsic field, and didn't just go to some afterlife if one believes in that, (which the troper who wrote this does.)

Changed: 284

Removed: 369

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
repetitive


** Dr. Manhattan experiences time in a non-linear fashion. How is the story told? Primarily through flashback, i.e. non-linearly. In fact, since Dr. Manhattan can perceive all of time at once, it could be argued we're seeing the story from HIS perspective.
** A watchman can refer to a guard. It can also refer to a person who repairs watches
* Over time Dr. Manhattan "loses touch" with humanity, and one of the ways this is illustrated is his dialogue: soon after his transformation, he asks Janey "What's up?", but when the TV host asks him the same question later, [[LiteralMinded he doesn't seem to appreciate the idiom.]]

to:

** Dr. Manhattan experiences time in a non-linear fashion. How is the story told? Primarily through flashback, i.e. non-linearly. In fact, since Dr. Manhattan can perceive all of time at once, it could be argued we're seeing the story from HIS perspective. \n** A watchman can refer to a guard. It can also refer to a person who repairs watches\n * Over time Dr. Manhattan "loses touch" with humanity, and one of the ways this is illustrated is his dialogue: soon after his transformation, he asks Janey "What's up?", but when the TV host asks him the same question later, [[LiteralMinded he doesn't seem to appreciate the idiom.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Near the end of the story, Adrian quotes the Egyptian pharaoh Merneptah's victory stele: "Canaan is devastated, Ashkelon is fallen, Gezer is ruined, Yenoam is reduced to nothing, Israel is desolate and her seed is no more, and Palestine has become a widow for Egypt - [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans All the countries are unified and pacified.]]" Like his superhero name, its a hint that his plans are doomed to fail in the long run - Merneptah's stele was carved in the year 1203 BCE, on the eve of the Late Bronze Age Collapse, which abruptly ended the prosperity of the New Kingdom and reduced Egypt to a shell of its former self. This began a downward spiral for ancient Egypt [[EndOfAnAge from which it never fully recovered]]: The century-long dark age that followed the LBA collapse was itself followed by the "Third Intermediate Period" in which Egypt fractured into several petty kingdoms, which was in turn followed by a period in which Egypt was controlled by a rotating cast of foreign conquerors; first Kushites, then Assyrians, then Persians, then Macedonians, then finally Romans.

to:

* Near the end of the story, Adrian quotes the Egyptian pharaoh Merneptah's victory stele: "Canaan is devastated, Ashkelon is fallen, Gezer is ruined, Yenoam is reduced to nothing, Israel is desolate and her seed is no more, and Palestine has become a widow for Egypt - [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans All the countries are unified and pacified.]]" Like his superhero name, its a hint that his plans are doomed to fail in the long run - Merneptah's stele was carved in the year 1203 BCE, on the eve of the Late Bronze Age Collapse, which abruptly ended the prosperity of the New Kingdom and reduced Egypt to a shell of its former self. This began a downward spiral for ancient Egypt [[EndOfAnAge from which it never fully recovered]]: The century-long dark age that followed the LBA collapse was itself followed by the "Third Intermediate Period" in which Egypt fractured into several petty kingdoms, which was in turn followed by a period in which Egypt was controlled by a rotating cast of foreign conquerors; first Kushites, then Assyrians, then Persians, then Macedonians, then the Kingdom of Kush, the Neo-Assyrian Empire, Achaemenid Persia, the Ptolemies, and finally Romans.the Roman Empire.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Near the end of the story, Adrian quotes the Egyptian pharaoh Merneptah's victory stele: "Canaan is devastated, Ashkelon is fallen, Gezer is ruined, Yenoam is reduced to nothing, Israel is desolate and her seed is no more, and Palestine has become a widow for Egypt - [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans All the countries are unified and pacified.]]" Like his superhero name, its a hint that his plans are doomed to fail in the long run - Merneptah's stele was carved in the year 1203 BCE, on the eve of the Late Bronze Age Collapse, which abruptly ended the prosperity of the New Kingdom and reduced Egypt to a shell of its former self. This began a downward spiral for ancient Egypt [[EndOfAnAge from which it never fully recovered]]: The century-long dark age that followed the LBA collapse was itself followed by the "Third Intermediate Period" in which Egypt fractured into several petty kingdoms, which was in turn followed by a period in which Egypt was controlled by a rotating cast of foreign conquerors; first Kushites, then Assyrians, then Persians, then Macedonians, then finally Romans.
Willbyr MOD

Changed: 402

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Rorschach's horrible hygiene isn't just him choosing to spend all his time fighting crime and forsaking self-care. He counters his stench by dousing himself in cologne, and since cologne use is typically a manly thing to do and he's very misogynistic due to his childhood traumas and mental illness, he very likely sees bathing and other hygienic practices as too feminine to associate himself with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Watchmen" originally ran for 12 issues, and there are 12 hands on a clock.

to:

** "Watchmen" originally ran for 12 issues, and there are 12 hands numbers on a clock.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:Fridge Brilliance]]

to:

[[AC:Fridge Brilliance]][[AC:FridgeBrilliance]]



[[AC:Fridge Horror]]

to:

[[AC:Fridge Horror]][[AC:FridgeHorror]]



[[AC:FridgeBrilliance]]

to:

[[AC:FridgeBrilliance]][[AC:Fridge Brilliance]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
the end is nigh

Added DiffLines:

**It could be non-diegetic, given Alan and Dave's use of sight gags: Rorschach (unmasked) with his "The End is Nigh" sign, for instance. The music is likely intended as a clue for anyone who's attentive enough to notice.

Added: 524

Changed: 788

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Adrian Veidt's plan at the climax hinges on fooling the people of the world into believing that [[spoiler:Earth has been visited by aliens]], forcing them to reckon with the fact that [[spoiler:they aren't alone in the universe]]. Even though [[spoiler:it's all an elaborate hoax]], the ending also implies that [[spoiler:humanity really ''isn't'' alone in the universe]]--since it's implied that [[spoiler:Doctor Manhattan goes on to create his own sentient race on another world after leaving Earth]], which happens as a result of Veidt's plan. In other words: Veidt tells a lie that ultimately becomes true after enough people believe it. Funnily enough, this one goes beyond ''Watchmen'', as it's a recurring motif in many of Creator/AlanMoore's other works. To name a few examples:
** ''ComicBook/FromHell'' features the PhonyPsychic Robert Lees, whose fake prophecies all end up mysteriously coming true.
** ''ComicBook/VForVendetta'', with its strong anarchist subtext, explores the idea that the authority of laws and governments is inherently based on a lie, but has power over people as long as they choose to believe in it.
** ''ComicBook/TheLeagueOfExtraordinaryGentlemen'' takes place in a world where all fiction is true, and explores the idea that society is shaped by the stories that people tell.

Changed: 20

Removed: 294

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
last point is restatement of above, correct typo


* Seeing the one-time "Mister Moloch" as an old man in a cheap apartment who's dying of cancer really seems to take the wind out of Rorschach's monochrome "evil must be punished" sails... after he went to the trouble of ''ambushing him from inside his refrigerator.'' Rorschach probably ''wanted'' a super-villain to fight, not, as he is finally faced with, downbeat old Edgar Jacobi.

to:

* Seeing the one-time "Mister Moloch" "Moloch the Mystic" as an old man in a cheap apartment who's dying of cancer really seems to take the wind out of Rorschach's monochrome "evil must be punished" sails... after he went to the trouble of ''ambushing him from inside his refrigerator.'' Rorschach probably ''wanted'' a super-villain to fight, not, as he is finally faced with, downbeat old Edgar Jacobi.



* A little bit of meta fun: comic-readers will know that the sequence of Ozymandias almost being assassinated was depicted in chapter 5, 'Fearful Symmetry', which is famed for it's clever use of literal symmetry with the issue's events and even how the panels are laid out to be read, with Veidt flooring his would-be assassin in the dead-centre of the issue. Obviously the film was every chapter merged into one, and it would've been nearly impossible to lay the scenes out in the same way without just literally slapping the comic pages on the screen ala Ang Lee's 'Hulk'. Yet they still managed to make the assassination scene have a theme of symmetry... through the set. Two reception counters on either side, with identical looking receptionists, and a simple geometric fountain structure in the dead centre of the room, with a slew of elevators in the back, while Veidt stands in the middle of a group. The entire room is a mirror image down the middle
* Unlike the comic, the movie actually showed us the Comedian's death, starting with his unknown killer entering his apartment. If you've read the comic then you'll already know who it is, but if you haven't there's a small hint [[spoiler:from the advert on the television for a Veidt perfume]]

to:

* A little bit of meta fun: comic-readers will know that the sequence of Ozymandias almost being assassinated was depicted in chapter 5, 'Fearful Symmetry', which is famed for it's its clever use of literal symmetry with the issue's events and even how the panels are laid out to be read, with Veidt flooring his would-be assassin in the dead-centre of the issue. Obviously the film was every chapter merged into one, and it would've been nearly impossible to lay the scenes out in the same way without just literally slapping the comic pages on the screen ala Ang Lee's 'Hulk'. Yet they still managed to make the assassination scene have a theme of symmetry... through the set. Two reception counters on either side, with identical looking receptionists, and a simple geometric fountain structure in the dead centre of the room, with a slew of elevators in the back, while Veidt stands in the middle of a group. The entire room is a mirror image down the middle
* Unlike the comic, the movie actually showed us the Comedian's death, starting with his unknown killer entering his apartment. If you've read the comic then you'll already know who it is, but if you haven't there's a small hint [[spoiler:from the advert on the television for a Veidt perfume]]
middle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How was Jon Osterman capable of rebuilding himself into Doctor Manhattan after his intrinsic field was removed? I think most of us agree it was his background as both a watchmaker and a nuclear physicist which allowed him to do that, but I'm talking about a more basic concept here: somehow, his conscience must have remained alive, without a body, for him to be able to apply all his knowledge into his own reconstruction, right? Now, it's horrible enough to imagine what Osterman's life must have been during those months he spent trying to reassemble himself, but think about poor [[spoiler: Bubastis]], drifting in nothingness for who knows how many months (or years, or forever), unable to rebuild [[spoiler: herself]] or even understand what's happening...

to:

* How was Jon Osterman capable of rebuilding reassembling himself into Doctor Manhattan after his intrinsic field was removed? I think most of us agree it was his background as both a watchmaker and a nuclear physicist which allowed him to do that, but I'm talking about a more basic concept here: somehow, his conscience consciousness must have remained alive, without a body, for him to be able to apply all his knowledge into his own reconstruction, right? Now, it's horrible enough to imagine what Osterman's life must have been during those months he spent trying to reassemble himself, but think about poor [[spoiler: Bubastis]], drifting in nothingness for who knows how many months (or years, or forever), unable to rebuild [[spoiler: herself]] or even understand what's happening...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* How was Jon Osterman capable of rebuilding himself into Doctor Manhattan after his intrinsic field was removed? I think most of us agree it was his background as both a watchmaker and a nuclear physicist which allowed him to do that, but I'm talking about a more basic concept here: somehow, his conscience must have remained alive, without a body, for him to be able to apply all his knowledge into his own reconstruction, right? Now, it's horrible enough to imagine what Osterman's life must have been during those months he spent trying to reassemble himself, but think about poor [[spoiler: Bubastis]], drifting in nothingness for who knows how many months (or years, or forever), unable to rebuild [[spoiler: herself]] or even understand what's happening...

Changed: 275

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Chekov's Gun not within the comic proper, but the supplemental pieces inbetween - Rorschach's arrest record makes a point to mention that the Rorschach's journal, the thing that the final twist revolves around, contains handwriting eccentric to the point of illegibility...

Top