Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / TheGreatMouseDetective

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Believe it or not, Dawson's WhatTheHellHero speech to Basil as the latter is suffering from a bad case of HeroicBSOD and doesn't actively look for a way out of their deathtrap also is similar to Holmes and Watson's relationship. Thanks to [[Creator/NigelBruce Nigel Bruce's]] portrayal of Watson against [[Creator/BasilRathbone Basil Rathbone's]] Holmes, many people have the mistaken notion that Watson in the Holmes Canon hero-worships Holmes and sees him as an absolute paragon of virtue...when in reality, there are a few times when Watson chews Holmes out for his self-destructive tendencies (mainly involving his use of morphine and cocaine as recreational drugs to cure his boredom) and even argues with Holmes about refusing to learn common sense things in ''A Study In Scarlet''. And, like Basil does in this scene, Holmes listens to Watson.

to:

** Believe it or not, Dawson's WhatTheHellHero speech to Basil as the latter is suffering from a bad case of HeroicBSOD and doesn't actively look for a way out of their deathtrap also is similar to Holmes and Watson's relationship. Thanks to [[Creator/NigelBruce Nigel Bruce's]] portrayal of Watson against [[Creator/BasilRathbone Basil Rathbone's]] Holmes, many people have the mistaken notion that Watson in the Holmes Canon hero-worships Holmes and sees him as an absolute paragon of virtue...when in reality, there are a few times when Watson chews Holmes out for his self-destructive tendencies (mainly involving his use of morphine and cocaine as recreational drugs to cure his boredom) boredom between cases) and even argues with Holmes about refusing to learn common sense things in ''A Study In Scarlet''. And, like Basil does in this scene, Holmes listens to Watson. It doesn't mean he always takes his advice to heart, but Holmes respects Watson enough to at least heart him out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* There's more to the onslaught of Basil's HeroicBSOD right before the climax than just Ratigan outsmarting him again. While understandably frustrated at the beginning when the ballistic evidence doesn't line up and when Olivia gets captured by Fidget at the toy shop, Basil is back on the case as soon as a new lead (such as Olivia's mentioning that her father had been kidnapped by a bat or Dawson finding the list) comes up. So what makes this time different? It's not just Ratigan proclaiming that he's won. It's Ratigan, Fidget and the rest of the minions ''laughing'' at him. Why? Remember, Basil has shown touches of arrogance. What is arrogance often a mask for? Believe it or not, insecurity. Deep down, Basil doesn't just fear being outsmarted. It's ''everyone seeing he's been outsmarted and mocking him because of it''. That's why he completely crumples; his worst fear has literally come true.

to:

* There's more to the onslaught of Basil's HeroicBSOD right before the climax than just Ratigan outsmarting him again. While understandably frustrated at the beginning when the ballistic evidence doesn't line up and when Olivia gets captured by Fidget at the toy shop, Basil is back on the case as soon as a new lead (such as Olivia's mentioning that her father had been kidnapped by a bat or Dawson finding the list) comes up. So what makes this time different? It's not just Ratigan proclaiming that he's won. It's Ratigan, Fidget and the rest of the minions ''laughing'' at him. Why? Remember, Basil has shown touches of arrogance. What is arrogance often a mask for? Believe it or not, insecurity. Deep down, Basil doesn't just fear being outsmarted. It's ''everyone seeing he's been outsmarted and mocking him because of it''. That's why he completely crumples; crumples this time as opposed to the first two times around Olivia and Dawson (who didn't laugh at him); his worst fear has literally come true.

Added: 853

Changed: 988

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Fridge-Awesome: It's cool enough that Basil and Ratigan's final battle takes place atop Big Ben. But the climax of their fight becomes even more meaningful when their fall to their deaths is a homage to "The Reichenbach Falls".

to:

* Fridge-Awesome: It's cool enough that Basil and Ratigan's final battle takes place atop Big Ben. But the climax of their fight becomes even more meaningful when their fall to their deaths is a homage to "The Final Problem" (the short story where Holmes and Moriarty fight to the death at Reichenbach Falls".Falls).



** Believe it or not, Dawson's WhatTheHellHero speech to Basil as the latter is suffering from a bad case of HeroicBSOD and doesn't actively look for a way out of their deathtrap also is similar to Holmes and Watson's relationship. Thanks to [[Creator/NigelBruce Nigel Bruce's]] portrayal of Watson against [[Creator/BasilRathbone Basil Rathbone's]] Holmes, many people have the mistaken notion that Watson in the Holmes Canon hero-worships Holmes and sees him as an absolute paragon of virtue...when in reality, there are a few times when Watson chews Holmes out for his self-destructive tendencies (mainly involving his use of morphine and cocaine as recreational drugs to cure his boredom) and even argues with Holmes about refusing to learn common sense things in ''A Study In Scarlet''. And, like Basil does in this scene, Holmes listens to Watson.




to:

* There's more to the onslaught of Basil's HeroicBSOD right before the climax than just Ratigan outsmarting him again. While understandably frustrated at the beginning when the ballistic evidence doesn't line up and when Olivia gets captured by Fidget at the toy shop, Basil is back on the case as soon as a new lead (such as Olivia's mentioning that her father had been kidnapped by a bat or Dawson finding the list) comes up. So what makes this time different? It's not just Ratigan proclaiming that he's won. It's Ratigan, Fidget and the rest of the minions ''laughing'' at him. Why? Remember, Basil has shown touches of arrogance. What is arrogance often a mask for? Believe it or not, insecurity. Deep down, Basil doesn't just fear being outsmarted. It's ''everyone seeing he's been outsmarted and mocking him because of it''. That's why he completely crumples; his worst fear has literally come true.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After Fidget is sent to get the items on Ratigan's list (including Olivia), he manages to find her with relative speed and ease in the relative safety of Baker Street (although he is unable to capture her right at that moment). Given that Ratigan is established as someone with enough resources and loyal minions to plot an (almost) successful coup, Fidget probably talked to his contacts and got a good idea about where Olivia was and how to find her...

to:

* After Fidget is sent to get the items on Ratigan's list (including Olivia), he manages to find her with relative speed and ease in the relative safety of Baker Street (although he is unable to capture her right at that moment). Given that Ratigan is established as someone with enough resources and loyal minions to plot an (almost) successful coup, Fidget probably talked to his contacts and got a good idea about where Olivia was and how to find her...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* After Fidget is sent to get the items on Ratigan's list (including Olivia), he manages to find her with relative speed and ease in the relative safety of Baker Street (although he is unable to capture her right at that moment). Given that Ratigan is established as someone with enough resources and loyal minions to plot an (almost) successful coup, Fidget probably talked to his contacts and got a good idea about where Olivia was and how to find her...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* During the bar fight, several mice are shown lying motionless. Since several of the patrons had guns, knives and other lethal weapons, were these mice ''KILLED''?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Felicia, Ratigan's pet cat, is ''very'' fat. And given that she seems to dine exclusively [[NightmareFuel on mice given to her by Ratigan...]]

to:

* Felicia, Ratigan's pet cat, is ''very'' fat. And given that she seems to dine exclusively [[NightmareFuel on mice given to her by Ratigan...]]]]and the reactions of terror and fear in the henchmen when Ratigan pulls out his signature bell certainly speaks to that too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Thanks to the SquareCubeLaw, Ratigan is actually very likely to have survived his DisneyVillainDeath. And if he landed in water? Rats can tread water for as long as 3 days.

to:

* Thanks to the SquareCubeLaw, Ratigan is actually [[HesJustHiding very likely to have survived survived]] his DisneyVillainDeath. And if he landed in water? Rats can tread water for as long as 3 days.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* While it's never outright stated, it's heavily implied Basil idolizes Sherlock Holmes; not only does he clearly model himself after the human detective, his own home is located within the walls of Baker Street. This is in stark contrast to Ratigan, who shows no such fondness for Moriarty despite their obvious similarities. And this makes perfect sense, because just like James Moriarty, Ratigan is a psychotic monster who doesn't care about anything other than himself and proving himself superior to Basil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
no justifying edits!


** That doesn't work. Ratigan lost his cape earlier in the fight. The entire back of his outfit was ripped off in fact
*** He actually ''doesn't'' lose the cape. He rips it to get free from the gears but it's still visible as he's scurrying through Big Ben and during his fight with Basil. It's most prominently seen as he's gloating about having apparently killed Basil, tattered but still there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*One of the phrases Ratigan says to Basil when he leaves [[HeroicBSOD the depressed detective]] and Dawson tied into his DeathTrap is "Arrivederci;" while the phrase is used as "goodbye" in Italian, it literally translates to "Until we meet again." And Ratigan and Basil indeed DO meet again...after Basil manages to overcome his funk, get himself and the doctor out of the trap, and thwart the professor's evil plan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When Ratigan details his changes under the guise of serving the queen, one of his changes is taxing the elderly, infirmed and children. Hiriam and Olivia fit the first and last. In essence, Ratigan was never actually planning to let the Flavershams free, and would keep antagonizing them in some way even after completing his coup.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** He actually ''doesn't'' lose the cape. He rips it to get free from the gears but it's still visible as he's scurrying through Big Ben and during his fight with Basil. It's most prominently seen as he's gloating about having apparently killed Basil, tattered but still there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**That doesn't work. Ratigan lost his cape earlier in the fight. The entire back of his outfit was ripped off in fact

Top