Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheCrossing

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Washington denounces the Hessians as "Mercenaries" and "Men who kill for profit". In real life, the Hessians were traditional German soldiers, no different than the Redcoats, who had simply been hired out by their German overlords to serve the British Empire.

to:

** Washington denounces the Hessians as "Mercenaries" and "Men who kill for profit". In real life, the The Hessians were traditional German soldiers, no different than the Redcoats, who had simply been ''were'' hired out by for profit, but it was their German overlords to serve who got paid, not themselves--they were regular troops not unlike the British Empire.Redcoats and didn't have much say in being sent out to fight.



* PsychoForHire: Washington's opinion of the Hessians. In truth, most of the foot soldiers were ill-treated conscripts who had no say in being shipped off to fight in America (in fact, the epilogue states that after the war, some Hessians actually chose to stay in America and went on to become American citizens).

to:

* PsychoForHire: Washington's opinion of the Hessians. In truth, most of The Pennsylvania Dutch troops in the foot soldiers Continental Army are so terrified of them (having experience with them or their reputations prior to the war) that their captain got special dispensation to warn his lads so that they wouldn't freeze up on learning who they were up against. While the Hessians did earn their reputation for vicious behavior, they were also ill-treated conscripts who had no didn't have a say in being shipped off sent to fight in America (in the Continentals. (In fact, the epilogue states that after the war, some Hessians actually chose a good chunk of them decided to stay in America remain and went on to become became American citizens).citizens.)

Added: 475

Changed: 46

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalDomainCharacter: All of named characters in the story are real historical figures. The movie made a deliberate effort to portray Washington not as the deified patriarch of the nation he was turned into after his death, but as an actual human who had good and bad qualities. His temper (as noted by contemporaries) could be short and sharp, he enjoyed a glass of wine, and rather than being glorious and victorious, he knew defeat in 1776 far oftener than victory.



* TheSpymaster: We see hints of Washington's information network, both in letters and an in-person meeting with a contact.[[note]]Though not shown, Washington also had one of his spies convince the British that the Continental Army was terribly ragged and demoralized--which was easy to believe, being true--and so there was no way they would ever attack Trenton.[[/note]]

to:

* TheSpymaster: We see hints of Washington's information network, both in letters and an in-person meeting with a contact.[[note]]Though not shown, Washington also had one of his spies convince the British that the Continental Army was terribly ragged and demoralized--which was easy to believe, being true--and so true--so there was ''of course'' no way they would ever need to worry that they'd attack Trenton.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Foil}}: The Continental Army and the Hessians are portrayed as this. The Hessians are disciplined, well-drilled, ''professional'' soldiers in crisp uniforms. The Continentals are argumentative militiamen who don't even share a single language and many dress in their own clothes. In the climactic battle, however, the Hessians' rigid discipline hampers them because they're too busy preparing their uniforms and martialing into neat battle lines, while the Continentals don't bother with that and attack before the Hessians are prepared to respond.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: As with most portrayals of Washington, ''The Crossing'' ignores his status as a slaveholder by failing to include his enslaved valet, William Lee, who was with Washington for most of the war.

Added: 664

Changed: 250

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The prelude to the battle is condensed. Washington actually began attacking the Hessian perimeter a week before the attack, shortly after having a spy of his spread disinformation about how the Continental Army was too demoralized to even consider attacking Trenton. (It helped that it was ''almost'' true.) Also, an independent American force had attacked a Hessian outpost during the final march and Rall took that for the attack he had feared, leading him to let down his guard.



* BayonetYa: Discussed in the strategy sessions. Washington elects to start the battle with a bayonet charge because the cold, wet conditions will inevitably spoil their gunpowder.



* TheSpymaster: We see hints of Washington's information network, both in letters and an in-person meeting with a contact.

to:

* TheSpymaster: We see hints of Washington's information network, both in letters and an in-person meeting with a contact.[[note]]Though not shown, Washington also had one of his spies convince the British that the Continental Army was terribly ragged and demoralized--which was easy to believe, being true--and so there was no way they would ever attack Trenton.[[/note]]

Added: 263

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The film claims America suffered no casualties in the Battle of Trenton. This is not quite true, although casualties were remarkably light. In real life, two American soldiers froze to death on the march to Trenton, while another five were wounded during the battle itself. One of them was an 18-year old lieutenant named James Monroe, who would go on become governor of Virginia and the President of the United States.

to:

** The film General Mercer claims America suffered no casualties in the Battle of Trenton. This is not quite true, although casualties were remarkably light. In real life, two American soldiers froze to death on the march to Trenton, while another five were wounded during the battle itself. One of them was an 18-year old lieutenant named James Monroe, who would go on become governor of Virginia and the President of the United States.States.
** Washington denounces the Hessians as "Mercenaries" and "Men who kill for profit". In real life, the Hessians were traditional German soldiers, no different than the Redcoats, who had simply been hired out by their German overlords to serve the British Empire.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLincenseHistory:

to:

* ArtisticLincenseHistory:ArtisticLicenseHistory:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLincenseHistory:
** While Horatio Gates did oppose Washington's plan and claimed illness as an excuse not to participate, he was not marched out of camp at gunpoint as the film depicted.
** The film claims America suffered no casualties in the Battle of Trenton. This is not quite true, although casualties were remarkably light. In real life, two American soldiers froze to death on the march to Trenton, while another five were wounded during the battle itself. One of them was an 18-year old lieutenant named James Monroe, who would go on become governor of Virginia and the President of the United States.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PsychoForHire: Washington's opinion of the Hessians. In truth, most of the foot soldiers were ill-treated conscripts who had no say in being shipped off to fight in America.

to:

* PsychoForHire: Washington's opinion of the Hessians. In truth, most of the foot soldiers were ill-treated conscripts who had no say in being shipped off to fight in America.America (in fact, the epilogue states that after the war, some Hessians actually chose to stay in America and went on to become American citizens).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the movie, the Americans suffer no casualties. In the real battle, two men died of hypothermia during the march, while two were killed and two were wounded in the battle itself. (Which is still an astoundingly low number, but not EverybodyLives.)

to:

** In the movie, the Americans suffer no casualties. In the real battle, two men died of hypothermia during the march, while two were killed and two five were wounded in the battle itself. (Which is still an astoundingly low number, but not EverybodyLives.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Mercer:''' They say the General [Howe] has her flat on her back every afternoon, fornicating like a fifteen-year-old.
--> '''Washington:''' [{{beat}}.] Well that's very stimulating, Hugh, but what does it have to do with me?

to:

--> '''Mercer:''' They say the General [Howe] [General Howe] has her flat on her back in his bed every afternoon, night, glassy-eyed and fornicating like a fifteen-year-old.
--> '''Washington:''' [{{beat}}.] Well that's very stimulating, Hugh, but what does it have to do with me?where's the connection?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* NotSoDifferent: Washington is disgusted by the Hessians, as they are only hired mercenaries fighting for profit; while the British at least have an excuse to not want the Colonials to be free. Gen. Nathaniel Greene gives a little speech on the matter, pointing out that one of their own chief complaints is overtaxation, and that everyone ultimately fights for profit.

to:

* NotSoDifferent: NotSoDifferentRemark: Washington is disgusted by the Hessians, as they are only hired mercenaries fighting for profit; while the British at least have an excuse to not want the Colonials to be free. Gen. Nathaniel Greene gives a little speech on the matter, pointing out that one of their own chief complaints is overtaxation, and that everyone ultimately fights for profit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LastWords: After he is mortally wounded, Colonel Rall requests to speak to Washington. Washington initially refuses to see him, but is convinced to go by his officers. Washington approaches him and says only, "I am Washington." Colonel Rall requests that Washington treat his defeated Hessian soldiers with honor, and promptly dies. Washington, without a word, simply turns on his heels and walks out.

to:

* LastWords: After he is mortally wounded, Colonel Rall requests to speak to Washington. Washington initially refuses to see him, but is convinced to go by his officers. Washington approaches him and says only, "I am Washington." Colonel Rall requests that Washington treat his defeated Hessian soldiers with honor, and promptly dies. Washington, without a word, Washington simply turns on his heels and walks out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LastWords: After he is wounded, Colonel Rall requests to speak to Washington before he dies. Washington initially refuses to see him, but is convinced to go by his officers. Washington approaches him and says only, "I am Washington." Colonel Rall requests that Washington treat his defeated Hessian troops with honor, and promptly dies. Washington, without a word, simply turns on his heels and walks out.

to:

* LastWords: After he is mortally wounded, Colonel Rall requests to speak to Washington before he dies.Washington. Washington initially refuses to see him, but is convinced to go by his officers. Washington approaches him and says only, "I am Washington." Colonel Rall requests that Washington treat his defeated Hessian troops soldiers with honor, and promptly dies. Washington, without a word, simply turns on his heels and walks out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LastWords: After he is wounded, Colonel Rall requests to speak to Washington before he dies. Washington initially refuses to see him, but is convinced to go by his officers. Washington approaches him and says only, "I am Washington." Colonel Rall requests that Washington treat his defeated Hessian troops with honor, and promptly dies. Washington, without a word, simply turns on his heels and walks out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhereAreTheyNow: Sort of anyway. The characters are all long dead (of course), but the epilogue reveals their fates.

to:

* WhereAreTheyNow: Sort of anyway. The characters are all long dead (of course), but the epilogue reveals their fates. (Hugh Mercer was killed less than two weeks later at the Battle of Princeton.)

Added: 699

Removed: 174

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrazyEnoughToWork: This is essentially Washington's plan. He's throwing the whole of his forces (which are not in any good condition) against a garrison that is made up of the enemy's most feared troops (who are in very good condition). It's certainly true that the British wouldn't expect such a thing, but every single person Washington explains the plan to stops at the "crazy" part.



* IdiotBall: General Howe withdrawing all of his troops except for the 1200 Hessians. Washington is both incredulous and insulted to realize that his army is NotWorthKilling.


Added DiffLines:

* NotWorthKilling: General Howe, the British commander, withdraws all of his troops except for the 1200 Hessians in Trenton because he's written the Americans off as already defeated. (Historically, Rall's superiors also refused numerous requests to bolster defenses.) Washington is shocked, and also insulted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Although it takes some liberties with the facts of the battle (see HollywoodHistory for details) ''The Crossing'' portrays the struggles of Washington and the Continental Army in a realistic and unromantic way.

to:

Although it takes some liberties with the facts of the battle (see HollywoodHistory for details) ''The Crossing'' portrays takes a distinctly human view of the struggles of Washington and the struggle. The Continental Army is portrayed not as a plucky band of irregulars but a weary, demoralized remnant in a realistic dire need of supplies and unromantic way.
a boost to morale. Washington, who is known for being mythologized as much as he is for his historical significance, is shown as a human being who is frustrated and at his wits' end trying to keep what's left of his army from disintegrating while his generals, loyal and plotters alike, question his admittedly desperate plan. The result makes it clear how close the Revolution came to dying before it was even a year old, which makes the victory at Trenton even more impressive.



* AnAssKickingChristmas: Yup. Actually a part of Washington's plans, at least in the movie and popular legend.

to:

* AnAssKickingChristmas: Yup. Actually a part of Washington's plans, at least in The river crossing begins on Christmas night, and the movie and battle itself the morning of the 26th. The film goes with the popular legend.legend that the Hessians were too hungover from their celebrations to mount an effective defense and that Washington timed the battle to take advantage of this.



** Very much so. It's actually one reason he feels obligated to make one final attempt at a victory, because he feels he owes it to the lads who have not deserted.

to:

** Very much so. It's actually one reason he Washington feels obligated to make one final attempt at a victory, because he feels he owes it to the lads who have not deserted.deserted. He also shouts at a group of officers who are huddling inside rather than freezing alongside their troops.

Added: 1651

Changed: 1875

Removed: 266

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadassBookworm: Henry Knox, who is mocked by Glover for being fat and ran a bookshop before the war, is an ''excellent'' artilleryman.
** "Excellent" doesn't quite cover it. General Knox (for whom Fort Knox, Kentucky was named) was considered a natural genius in the use of artillery by his British enemies, and has come to be considered one of the greatest artillery officers the world has ever seen.

to:

* BadassBookworm: Henry Knox, Knox (the namesake of Fort Knox) who is mocked by Glover for being fat and ran a bookshop before the war, is an ''excellent'' artilleryman.
** "Excellent" doesn't quite cover it. General Knox (for whom Fort Knox, Kentucky was named)
artilleryman. In fact, he was considered a natural genius in the use of artillery by his British enemies, and has come to be considered one of the greatest artillery officers the world has ever seen.



* DarkestHour: The American Revolution had a lot of very, very low points, but the end titles state that this was the worst of them.

to:

* DarkestHour: In December 1776, the Continental Army under Washington has been enduring defeat and retreat for many months, pushed out of New York and across New Jersey, and the few who haven't deserted are still going to be gone once their enlistments run out at the end of the month. The American Revolution had a lot of very, very low points, but the end titles state that this was the worst of them.them.
* DawnAttack: Washington ''wants'' this, but the crossing proceeds so slowly that it's past sunrise by the time his army arrives.



* DistractedByTheSexy: General Howe, apparently. According to Mercer, Howe's torrid affair with a married woman is the main reason he hasn't totally crushed the Continental Army.



* AFatherToHisMen: Very much so. It's actually one reason he feels obligated to make one final attempt at a victory, because he feels he owes it to the lads who have not deserted.

to:

* AFatherToHisMen: AFatherToHisMen:
**
Very much so. It's actually one reason he feels obligated to make one final attempt at a victory, because he feels he owes it to the lads who have not deserted.



* FeeFiFauxPas: When Washington's officers dine with the wealthy couple who have offered their home up for army headquarters, Glover gives a brief speech about how he wears his own clothes and not a uniform, and his hair is his own and not a powdered wig. Their wig-wearing host and his wife look uncomfortable until Washington smooths things over.



* FourStarBadass: Washington, front and center.

to:

* FourStarBadass: FourStarBadass:
**
Washington, front and center.



** A key part of Washington's plan (and why it still succeeds despite running into daylight) is that the Hessians are hungover from their Christmas celebrations. Although some of Washington's staff ''did'' truly think this would be the case, the Hessians had been warned that the Continentals were planning something and apparently did not revel, although they were still caught off-guard.

to:

** A key part of Washington's plan (and why it still succeeds despite running into daylight) is The common wisdom that the Hessians are hungover from their lost because of German Christmas celebrations. Although some of Washington's staff ''did'' truly think this would be In actuality, it had more to do with the case, the Hessians had been warned fact that the Continentals they'd stopped routine precautions (such as distance patrols). Even though they were planning tipped off that something was going on and apparently did not revel, although thus suspended their revelries, they were still caught off-guard.unprepared for the magnitude of the assault. Some of the Continental officers consequently did believe that Hessian hangovers contributed to their victory and said so in their letters, which is probably why the myth survives.



** In the movie, the Americans suffer no casualties. In the real battle, two men died of hypothermia during the march, while two were killed and two were wounded in the battle itself. (Which is still an astoundingly low number, but not EverybodyLives.)



* ItsPersonal: Washington is absolutely livid at the Hessians for killing his retreating troops in Brooklyn.

to:

* ImADoctorNotAPlaceholder: Mercer says "I'm more physician than general" before entering into a summation of how dire the army's condition is.
* INeedAFreakingDrink: An Irish innkeeper (and Patriot spy) at first refuses to drink from the bottle of Madeira he's just given Washington. Then Washington tells him about the plan. The innkeeper immediately asks if he can have a glass.
* ItsPersonal: Washington is absolutely livid at the Hessians for killing his retreating troops in Brooklyn.Brooklyn, bayoneting them in the back as they tried to flee or surrender. The regular soldiers feel the same way; during the final battle they are merciless to the Hessians and Washington watches without sympathy.



* PsychoForHire: Washington's opinion of the Hessians. In reality, most of the foot soldiers were ill-treated conscripts who had no say in being shipped off to fight in America.

to:

* PsychoForHire: Washington's opinion of the Hessians. In reality, truth, most of the foot soldiers were ill-treated conscripts who had no say in being shipped off to fight in America.



* RealityIsUnrealistic: A battle against ''Hessians'' fought by ill-trained, dispirited farmers and militiamen and [[spoiler:and there were no Continental casualties? Yeah right!]][[labelnote:*]]In fact, there were two casualties... but they died of hypothermia, not Hessians.[[/labelnote]]
* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Gates gives one to Washington. Washington more or less responds with "go to hell" and takes his troops.

to:

* RealityIsUnrealistic: A battle against ''Hessians'' fought by ill-trained, dispirited farmers and militiamen and [[spoiler:and there were no Continental casualties? Yeah right!]][[labelnote:*]]In fact, there were two casualties... but they died of hypothermia, not Hessians.[[/labelnote]]
* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech:
TheReasonYouSuckSpeech:
**
Gates gives one to Washington. Washington more or less responds with "go to hell" and takes his troops.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Crossing'' is a 2000 made-for-TV movie that aired on A&E, depicting the first Battle of Trenton in UsefulNotes/TheAmericanRevolution. It stars Jeff Daniels as UsefulNotes/GeorgeWashington and follows him through December, 1776 as he tries to find a way to save his army and the Revolution from disintegration after a desperate retreat across the Delaware.

to:

''The Crossing'' is a 2000 made-for-TV movie that aired on A&E, depicting the first Battle of Trenton in UsefulNotes/TheAmericanRevolution. It stars Jeff Daniels Creator/JeffDaniels as UsefulNotes/GeorgeWashington and follows him through December, 1776 as he tries to find a way to save his army and the Revolution from disintegration after a desperate retreat across the Delaware.

Top