Follow TV Tropes

Live Blogs Modelland: A Blind Sporking
LadyMomus2012-03-17 17:40:49

Go To


The idea for Modelland came to me while I was in the car on the FDR Drive in New York City. I jotted it down on a piece of scratch paper and tucked it into my purse. Four years later, that scrap of paper had transformed into the book (or digital thingamajig) you now hold in your hands.

Ebook. The term is ebook. (I get the impression that Modelland's prose is written in the way that Tyra actually talks.)

Tyra says that she has many people and places to thank. And she does list quite a few places, including restaurants, hotels, diner room tables, cafés, and vacation spots.

She also mentions some behavior that's a bit rude.

The notebook material then made its way into my laptop, and I squatted at many cafés, for longer than the average dining period should last, and none of you complained (to my face).

And a special thanks to the Crosby Street Hotel restaurant. Sometimes I'd sit in one seat for eight hours at a time, ordering breakfast, lunch, then dinner, only getting up for bio breaks. I know I abused the privilege of that corner window seat.

Look, I know that society is often willing to bend over backwards for famous people, but taking up a table all day is rude, regardless of whether you're famous. It's rude towards your waiter/waitress, since one of their tables is being monopolized, which cuts into their tips. (And if shifts change while you're there, you may be depriving someone of a tip entirely). It's also rude to other patrons, who have to stand around waiting for a table to free up.

My other life, being the chairwoman and CEO of The Tyra Banks Company, did not stop, and the pressure I was under was intense. At times, I had to get away so I could focus on Modelland. I went on a few kinda swanky retreats, camping out at hotels and doing nothing but writing.

I wish I had a job that let me go on "swanky" retreats to write a novel instead of actually working.

Lake Como, thank you for providing me with a beautiful landscape in which to create and for inspiring the creation of Abigail Goode. As I gazed over your water, she popped into my mind. Hair? Water? Not sure what the connection is, but thanks anyway. (It didn't hurt that George Clooney lived a few doors down....)

I can relate to ideas coming from strange places.

But when you start listing all kinds of exotic locales as backdrops for your writing (Lake Como is in Italy), it's hard not to take it as bragging.

During the writing process, she went to Morocco for several weeks.

Thank you to the wonderful people of the Berber village I visited. It was a real treat for me to read a section of Modelland for half an hour to children who didn't speak English. I thought that if I could hold their attention that long, maybe my book had a chance at success.

Why would you read to someone who couldn't understand you? Isn't that kind of wasting their time and yours? Maybe she just liked hearing herself talk. Also: Tyra, you're famous. Publishers will jump at the chance to publish your work regardless of quality. Normal people don't get that kind of treatment.

She says that a majority of her time writing was spent in libraries. Which I heartily approve of. Libraries are awesome. She thanks the librarians and apologizes for eating fudge under the table.

She thanks some her professors. She thanks one professor for teaching her about Hindi and Indian culture (which shows up extremely briefly in Kamalini's flashback).

Professor Robert Steven Kaplan, my leadership prof, thanks for suggesting I give the Unicas' richer, more vulnerable backstories.

An English professor would have been a better choice for writing advice. And I seriously doubt someone told you to shoehorn tragic backstories that don't actually a noticeable impact on the characters. And if someone did tell you that, they were wrong. There's nothing wrong with a tragic backstory, but if you are going to include them, it should help shape your character and help explain their motivation. Not just be tacked on.

She thanks her book agent for suggesting that "supermodel" is overused and suggesting coming up with something else. So now you know where "Intoxibella" came from.

To Matt Johnson, my wonderful attorney (I know, you look nothing like Guru MattJoe and you have nothing in common with him, but I wanted to get your name in the manuscript somehow. Yep, yep.)

Uh, okay.

Laura Brown, thanks for allowing me to hole you up in your Harper's Bazaar office while you schooled me on "low-flying duck" Aussie-speak.

So now we know where the name Lauro Brown came from.

She thanks Stephen King and his book On Writing. And apparently she did read the book, since she apologizes for her overuse of adjectives and adverbs.

But Modelland is so splendiferously, kaleidoscopically, out-of-this-world colorful, I couldn't help myself! Please forgive me!

Given the way the book goes, I'm also going to assume she followed Stephen King's advice to write without outlining or plotting out the story first. No disrespect intended to Stephen King, but that method does not work for all writers. Tyra seems to be a writer who would have greatly benefitted from a detailed outline to help her not lose focus on the plot.

The Tyra Banks Company. My kick-ass team that keeps our company running, thank you for understanding that I had to check out for months at a time to work on my Modelland baby. EYE SEE YOUR BEAUTY!

If you could leave the company for months without repercussions, why was running it and working on Modelland so stressful?

To my editor, Wendy Loggia. Thank you for taking my first thousand-page manuscript (I know, insane) and making it this. How the heck do you know how to do that and not sacrifice the story?

1000 pages? That's over 400 pages longer than the book ended up being. And it explains so much when it comes to all the plot threads that never get resolved and things that get mentioned and never seen again. I'd say the book still needed a lot of pruning, though.

She thanks the reader for spending time reading her book.

I'm nervous and curious about how each chapter makes you feel, which characters speak to you. Which ones you love, hate, or love to hate.

Well, this liveblog contains most of my feelings about the book, so if you really want to know, just read the liveblog. I doubt you're going to appreciate what I have to say, though. Just know that my criticisms aren't directed at you, they're directed at your writing. I think you had good intentions, even if the end result wasn't very good.

Tyra then thanks her family, finishing with her mother.

And thank you so much for carving out a huge block of your precious time to read every last word of that first thousand-page manuscript and giving me the harsh, unfiltered truth. You are truly the world's most lovely, most beautiful, most loyal and caring Intoxibella who ever was and ever will be. Long live the original Ci~L.

So Tookie was based off of Tyra, and Ci~L was based on her mom. That explains a lot about why the book was focused on almost exclusively Ci~L and Tookie. It also explains why the two characters are pretty much allowed to do anything they wanted without consequence or being called out on their questionable actions. (All while everyone who isn't obviously evil thinks they're wonderful.) It's insanely hard to write insert characters objectively.


Well, I'm off to reread Modelland. See you in a week or two for my final thoughts.

Comments

FreezairForALimitedTime Since: Dec, 1969
Mar 17th 2012 at 8:54:41 PM
You know, I have no problems with writing who you know, but you should probably change more than one letter of their name if you're going to include them in your book.

I will say, though, that this does make me feel a little bad for ragging on Tyra. Her intentions were good, and she had a story she really wanted to tell. I can relate, bigtime. But still... But still. When the end product is so... so Modelland...
147.253.100.117 Since: Dec, 1969
Mar 18th 2012 at 9:16:34 AM
I'm kind of sad you didn't mention her first acknowledgement went out to the Hudson River. Not her family, not a significant other, not a business partner, not even her PET, but the freakin' Hudson. I could only sit and stare at the line for awhile, trying to imagine what kind of impact a river must have had on her for it to get top billing.

I do agree that Tyra's intentions are admirable and she has her heart in all the right places when it comes to young girls' self-esteem issues. She's also smarter than she seems, and her quirkiness is rather charming—in her shows. In her writing, however, her messages get confused and her quirkiness makes everything look dumb. I agree, Momus, an outline would have really helped Tyra organize the story. Maybe we'd still have Hunchy if she'd planned better.
76.69.21.53 Since: Dec, 1969
Mar 18th 2012 at 3:32:48 PM
When I first heard of this book, I assumed that Tyra was trying to tell girls that beauty isn't all that matters, that every person can be beautiful in their own way. I didn't think it would be any good, but I didn't expect the hypocritical drivel that the book turned out to be. Even at the end of the book, Tookie is still concerned about feeling "beautiful", even though she has the forced letter to the reader which contradicts Tookie's actions and attitude throughout the entire story. The worst example is Abigail, who is portrayed as being repulsive because of all of her hair, yet as soon as she conforms to the norms of appearance, she's suddenly stunningly beautiful. The book's moral seems to be that all that matters in life is that other people find you beautiful.

I don't think Tyra's quite in touch with reality based on this book and the acknowledgement section. It's if she thinks she's larger than life, that just because she's famous means that everything she does is great. If Tyra really thinks that what's inside Modelland is about "empowering girls", I have to wonder if she believes a word of her impromptu preaching to the reader.

I do have to wonder one thing about Tyra after reading this book... what exactly does she have against actresses?
gekkolexicon Since: Dec, 1969
Mar 18th 2012 at 7:31:41 PM
I agree, what's her sctick with acting? I think she has good intentions, but she's obviously screwed up in the head.
Top