Crowner

Go To

PageAction: FailOSuckyname

24th Jul '13 11:24:59 AM

Crown Description:

How should we fix the trope and related pages? Fail O Suckyname is often mixed with Unfortunate Name. Fail O Suckyname is supposed to be a subtrope of Unfortunate Name that only applies to a superhero's chosen name, or if a character willingly chooses an ugly name.

17 (Yeas:17 Nays:0)

Rename to make it clear that it's a name chosen by the character. New name will be decided by another crowner. (Note: Fail O'Suckyname is a catchy trope name and could be re-cycled; Unfortunate Name could be using it.)

7 (Yeas:9 Nays:2) 4.50 : 1

Improve description. It's written as Example As Thesis and focuses on superheroes, while the trope's much broader in fiction.

2 (Yeas:7 Nays:5) 1.40 : 1

Unfortunate Name should be for names viewed unfortunate or embarrassing in-universe.

-5 (Yeas:3 Nays:8)

Merge Fail O Suckyname into Unfortunate Name;

there's no need to have a separate page for "the same trope but for superheroes"
we would lose distinction when the hero willingly chooses horrible name and when it is the parents' doing/just unfortunate surname

-9 (Yeas:0 Nays:9)

Do nothing.