Line #52 Main/SpaceIsAir


1	[[quoteright:300:[[Pinball/TheEmpireStrikesBack https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/xwing-bank-in-space_3348.jpg]]]]
2	[[caption-width-right:300:Do a [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_tailslide Tailslide,]] Luke!]]
3
4	Space Is Air when a work treats spacecraft as if they were aircraft; they bank into turns, keep their engines firing at all times, and may even have wings built into their design. Aircraft-style design can be [[JustifiedTrope justified]] if the spacecraft is capable of operating in atmosphere as well as in space (like the space shuttle), but the ''main'' reason that this trope exists is because audiences are more familiar with how airplanes work than with how spaceships work. Thus, creators treat spaceships as if they are simply airplanes [[RecycledInSpace in space]] instead of using realistic physics, in order to avoid [[ViewersAreMorons confusing the audience]]. This [[Administrivia/TropesAreTools isn't necessarily a bad thing]] -- after all, it can be used to great effect to make things [[RuleOfCool look really cool]] -- but it does push things down toward the softer end of sci-fi.
5
6	The way airplanes work is dependent on the fact that they're travelling through the atmosphere. Wings provide lift, flaps and rudders can reorient the plane by redirecting airflow, and their engines must be on constantly in order to counteract the effects of friction and gravity — wings generate lift only when there's airflow across them, so a certain minimum airspeed is absolutely necessary for them to work. Because space is a vacuum, none of these things apply to spaceships -- wings and flaps are useless, and the engine only needs to be on when the ship is changing speed or direction. This means that spacecraft use dedicated thrusters to reorient themselves, and change direction in sharp bursts rather than gradually. If you see a spaceship changing direction without using maneuvering rockets, or making wide, sweeping turns, then that's because Space Is Air. Many movies who feel obliged to acknowledge the lack of [[SpaceIsNoisy sound in space]] will nonetheless accompany motions of spacecraft or planets with deep, low frequency whooshing sounds, as if they were creating rushing currents of air. This trope occasionally extends to natural phenomena; for instance, the Sun is sometimes depicted, particularly in children's fiction, as literally on fire, implying that space is full of air to let it burn. Comets are almost always shown moving in the opposite direction to their tails, as if they were moving through air and their tails were the trails they left behind.
7
8	A subtrope of ArtisticLicenseSpace, and sister trope to SpaceIsAnOcean. Also a frequent cause of SpaceFriction, and may be why BatmanCanBreatheInSpace. If you see {{Old School Dogfight}}ing in space, it's usually because this trope is in effect; it also dictates the appearance of many {{Space Fighter}}s.
9
10	----
11	!!Examples
12
13	[[foldercontrol]]
14
15	[[folder:Anime and Manga]]
16	* ''Anime/CowboyBebop'' uses fairly realistic Newtonian physics for the most part, but during combat, RuleOfCool pitches the laws of physics out the window and they revert to {{Old School Dogfight}}ing. Though, in the dogfights, many of the ships do in fact drift a bit and disengage and re-engage thrusters for turning.
17	* ''Franchise/{{Gundam}}'':
18	** The franchise often shows realistic space maneuvering using oriented thrusters, however once action/battle starts, physics takes a back seat.
19	** ''Anime/MobileSuitVictoryGundam'': [[spoiler:Oliver]]'s [[BurialInSpace ashes are scattered into space]] by having the mourners hold them out in their open hands, as if the vacuum of space was providing a gust of wind.
20	* ''Anime/SpaceBattleshipYamato'' combines it with SpaceIsAnOcean; capital ships act like sea-going vessels, while smaller craft act like airplanes, to the point of having dive bombers and torpedo bombers. Given that the show is very much in the style of UsefulNotes/WorldWarII's Pacific theater RecycledInSpace, it's to be expected.
21	* ''Anime/SuperdimensionFortressMacross'': Given that the Valkyries can literally [[TransformingMecha turn into]] planes, it's no surprise that they act like planes even in space.
22	** The novelization of ''SDF''[='s=] Westernized form ''{{Anime/Robotech}}'' [[{{Handwave}} handwaves]] it as the fighters being thought-controlled. Since most of the pilots were used to atmospheric craft first and foremost, their veritechs moved as if they were in an atmosphere.
23	** Later ''Anime/{{Macross}}'' installments do their best to avert this, showing their fighters using verniers and thrusters to move in space, as well as pulling off maneuvers that wouldn't work in an atmosphere.
24	[[/folder]]
25
26	[[folder:Comic Books]]
27	* At the end of ''ComicBook/{{Pouvoirpoint}}'', the large starship ''Entreprise-2061'' is assaulted by a [[SpaceFighter small coastguard fighter]], faster and better armed, which turns around him and hassles him [[OldSchoolDogfight like an annoying biplane around a zeppelin]].
28	* ''ComicBook/{{Superman}}'' story "ComicBook/TheSuperDuelInSpace", which features a manned spaceflight, came out three years before Yuri Gagarin's flight, so the writer couldn't know how much he got wrong. To sum up, the rocket makes u-turns as if it was a plane, nobody wears spacesuits, the single pilot wears an airline pilot costume, and several untrained people (journalists, scientists...) have been invited to join the flight and are sitting on rows as if it was a commercial flight.
29	* ''ComicBook/WonderWoman1942'': During UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks the Amazons had an entire fleet of {{space plane}}s which maneuvered the same in space as in atmosphere, and at one point they fought villains from the sun who were able to carry ''open flame'' in space without explanation.
30	[[/folder]]
31
32	[[folder:Films -- Live-Action]]
33	* ''Franchise/StarWars'' may actually be the TropeCodifier, particularly with the OldSchoolDogfight between {{Space Fighter}}s.
34	* The ''Film/WingCommander'' movie takes this trope even further than Star Wars by having fighters take off from runways the same way airships take off from Aircraft Carriers and ships drop down when they leave the runway.
35	[[/folder]]
36
37	[[folder:Literature]]
38	* The ''Franchise/StarWars'' [[Franchise/StarWarsExpandedUniverse Expanded Universe]] has a lot of this, reflecting the films.
39	* The Elder Things from Creator/HPLovecraft's ''Literature/AtTheMountainsOfMadness'' fly through space with their wings. Note that this ''isn't'' ScienceMarchesOn, as Lovecraft knew perfectly well that "aether" was a debunked concept, despite referring to it in-story to justify this trope; he just liked the idea of space being full of aether more than that of it being vacuum.
40	* Justified in ''Literature/{{Polystom}}'', which is set in a star system in which the space between the planets really is filled with air.
41	* While ''TabletopGame/{{Warhammer 40000}}'' normally tries to avert this trope, the novel ''Pandorax'' plays it dead staight with no excuse or shame.
42	* Taken to a literal extreme in ''Literature/TheLittlePrince'', in which the Prince leaves his planet by catching migrating birds. Still, the story is less a science fiction tale and more a FairyTale with planets in it.
43	* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'': ''Literature/TheLastHero'' has the Disc's one-and-only spacecraft leaving its atmosphere and making an (unplanned) trip to the Moon. in the flat earth [[InJoke continuinuinuum]], the atmosphere of the disc never completely ends, it thins, but does not diminish to a point where it is virtually non-existent. The intrepid travellers discover they can still breathe on the Discworld's moon, for instance. As the spacecraft has wings to steer with, this comes in very handy.
44	[[/folder]]
45
46	[[folder:Live-Action TV]]
47	* Although the earlier incarnations of ''Franchise/StarTrek'' tend more toward SpaceIsAnOcean, later shows start to treat ships as much like airplanes as like sailing ships. Not only are there shots of ships making expansive, banking turns like an atmospheric craft, but combat between ships is increasingly depicted as an OldSchoolDogfight.
48	%% * Used extensively ''Series/BuckRogersInTheTwentyFifthCentury''. With the same stock footage almost every time.
49	* ''Series/DoctorWho'' both plays this straight AND subverts it in "Victory of the Daleks". World War 2 aircraft (Spitfires actually) are given air-containing force fields and engine modifications that actually allow them to fly into space and attack the Dalek mothership (the air inside the force field allowing the propeller to function and perform the usual airplane banks and rolls). The whole thing is hand waved by saying the force field generators and engine modifications were made with Dalek technology.
50	[[/folder]]
51
52	[[folder:Pinball]]
53	* In Hankin's ''Pinball/TheEmpireStrikesBack'' pinball game, every single aircraft and spaceship is shown leaving a swooping red-and-orange exhaust trail, including the Rebel Snowspeeders, Imperial TIE Fighters, Luke's X-Wing, and the ''Millennium Falcon.''
54	%% * Played straight with the {{Space Fighter}}s in ''Pinball/StellarWars''
55	[[/folder]]
56
57	[[folder:Tabletop Games]]
58	* This is how ''everything'' works in ''TabletopGame/XWingMiniatures''; if your fighter doesn't move like a plane, you're probably playing Scum and Villainy and sprung for Inertial Dampeners, because everyone else has to be in constant motion and can almost never turn on the spot. Justified on grounds of it being a Franchise/StarWars tie-in; piloting in space is ''always'' identical to piloting in atmosphere in the Galaxy Far Far Away.
59	* In ''TabletopGame/{{Warhammer40000}}'' [=RPGs=] from (at least) ''TabletopGame/BlackCrusade'' onwards, the skill Operate (Aeronautica) covers everything that moves in three dimensions and can be controlled by a single pilot (and copilot), be it in air or space. Capital ships however require a separate skill.
60	[[/folder]]
61
62	[[folder:Theme Parks]]
63	* Zigzagged in ''Ride/RaceThroughNewYorkStarringJimmyFallon'' at Ride/UniversalStudios. When on the moon, Jimmy moves around as if there’s no gravity, but upon roller coasteering back to Earth, everything moves exactly as it would if it were under Earth’s atmosphere.
64	[[/folder]]
65
66	[[folder:Video Games]]
67	* Practically every space combat sim in history uses this, since most of them are just [[FollowTheLeader following the example]] set by ''Franchise/StarWars''. Examples include ''VideoGame/{{X}}'', ''VideoGame/StrikeSuitZero'', ''VideoGame/TachyonTheFringe'', ''VideoGame/TerminalVelocity1995''...
68	* ''Franchise/MassEffect'': Averted for the most part, though the [[CoolStarship Normandy]] makes some suspiciously aerodynamic-looking maneuvers on occasion. [[LampshadeHanging Lampshaded]] by the pilot:
69	-->'''Joker:''' It takes skill to make a ship bank in a vacuum. Don't think it doesn't.
70	** An InUniverse explanation is given -- ''Mass Effect'' spaceships use [[AppliedPhlebotinum Element Zero]] to travel by manipulating gravity, and while this doesn't provide any atmosphere, it does allow ships to pull off manoeuvrers that would otherwise be impossible in the vacuum of space.
71	** There is an conversation option that allows Shepherd to commiserate with another character about common space flight misconceptions (e.g. a passenger mistaking the ship turning around halfway to a destination in order to decelerate by burning off momentum as returning to their destination) but no actual maneuvers like this are actually seen in game.
72	* ''Franchise/StarWars'' games make extensive use of the trope, as with the films and the novels.
73	* ''VideoGame/StarFox'' has its [[SpaceFighter Arwings]] handle exactly the same in space as they do in atmosphere -- to the point where, in some incarnations (such as ''Videogame/StarFox64''), it shows the ailerons moving on the wings when you turn... which would do absolutely nothing in space.
74	* ''VideoGame/Allegiance2000'' tries to find a sort of compromise between this trope and realistic physics, mainly by including SpaceFriction, but turning it ''down'' compared to most games: ships still move like they're immersed in a medium, but inertia is important as well. The overall effect ends up being that spaceships feel like they're moving through ''water'', rather than air. Most of them still look like aircraft, though.
75	* Optional in ''VideoGame/SpaceEngineers'' - if one engages a (small) ship's [[AntiFrustrationFeatures inertial dampeners]] it will handle like a plane, if one does not...steering will be difficult.
76	* Starfighters in the ''VideoGame/WingCommander'' series default to flying like airplanes. However, beginning with ''Wing Commander III'', some of the fighters gain the ability to disengage their inertial cancellers and "slide" without experiencing friction.
77	* ''VideoGame/KerbalSpaceProgram'' averts this as its entire raison d'etre. The game is essentially a rocketry simulator, complete with accurate Newtonian physics.
78	** There ''are'' parts for {{Space Plane}}s (for mixed atmospheric/space flight) and even regular planes and it's possible to build spacecraft that look like planes, but these function realistically -- i.e. the aerodynamics are only important while flying in the atmosphere during take-off and landing, and in vacuum {{Space Plane}}s function purely as rockets (and all the wings, jet engines, and other plane bits become expensive dead weight until you're back in atmosphere).
79	[[/folder]]
80
81	[[folder:Webcomics]]
82	* ''Webcomic/CrimsonDark'' has space fighters and bombers which act like planes.
83	* ''Webcomic/{{Angels 2200}}'' is about the pilots of carrier-based space fighters which look and fly like planes.
84	[[/folder]]
85
86	[[folder:Western Animation]]
87	* Parodied in the ''very low'' budget show [[ShowWithinAShow ''The Planet from Outer Space'']], that appears in ''WesternAnimation/{{The Simpsons}}'' episode ''She of Little Faith'', in which the crew of a ship chokes because of "space air"... until they put their goggles on.
88	* The Octalians from ''WesternAnimation/MiloMurphysLaw'' can survive the vacuum of space as long as they hold their breath and shapeshift into another living being or object.
89	[[/folder]]

Context Main / SpaceIsAir