History YMMV / YoungJustice2019

* UnexpectedCharacter: Even for people who were expecting or hoping to see more obscure characters, the announcement that Young Justice will be teaming up with ComicBook/TheWarlordDC came off as a surprise.

* UnexpectedCharacter: Even for people who were expecting or hoping to see more obscure characters announcement Young Justice will be teaming up with ComicBook/TheWarlordDC came off as a surprise.

** Amethyst and Wonder Girl got few moments that can be seen as subtly hinting some romantic tension - upon their first meeting the art for a scene when they're supposed to be talking to Tim shows them starring in each other's eyes and Cassie can be seen affectionately comforting distraught Amy few issues later.

* UnexpectedCharacter: Even for people who were expecting or hoping to see more obscure characters announcement Young Justice will be teaming up with ComicBook/TheWarlord came off as a surprise.

* AuthorsSavingThrow:
** Fans were not enthused with the idea that a Pre-Teen could somehow hack into Green Lantern Tech, both due to its nigh-impossibility and how it wasn't initially elaborated on. The revelation that it was tech salvaged from what was strongly implied to be a GL imposter, settled some of these issues.
*** Furthermore a kid running around with such a weapon should have drawn immediate concern from any Green Lantern especially John Stewart who’s known to be way more responsible than the other 5 human lanterns. This addressed in the final issue.
** Tim dropping the Drake identity and becoming Robin again in issue #18 after fans' negative response to both the name and costume. It even gets mocked at the same time.

* AngstWhatAngst:
** The series manages to somehow entirely avoid the angst that would come Bart returning to a world where his sidekick role has been filled by Wallace West, his grandpa and grandma are no longer married, his favourite parental figure Linda Park no longer remembers anything about her life with the Flash Family, Jay Garrick doesn't even exist '''and''' the fact that Wally West, his preferred partner Flash, has committed manslaughter and is imprisoned.

** While Tim's new identity and costume were widely disliked, some fans were still disappointed that to see him slide back into the Robin role, as they felt that he was long overdue for a sidekick graduation that stuck.

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: The story mostly focuses on aspects of the status quo that have already been explained (like Bart and Connor missing New 52 because they weren't in mainstream reality during the reset), while leaving aside the implications of Tim getting his memories of pre-Flashpoint back but Stephanie's appearing to have been wiped entirely.

** After the initial excitement of YJ's return wore off, fan reaction to the series generally fell into two camps. Some thought that Bendis wrote the OG members well, and appreciated the addition of a diverse set of supporting characters; others thought that he mishandled the dynamics between the OGs and failed to give the new members distinctive personalities, resulting in a book that felt slow and overstuffed.
** Some Franchise/GreenLantern fans were unimpressed by the addition of a "Teen Lantern" to the franchise, as there are already six human Lanterns (seven, if we include Jo from ComicBook/FarSector) and ComicBook/HalJordanAndTheGreenLanternCorps made it clear that the Corps has a policy against recruiting underage members, making it especially implausible that John Stewart would allow a pre-teen to keep a weapon that hacks into the power battery. Others didn't mind the idea; but even among those fans, many felt that Bendis failed to make Keli interesting and thought that Tai Pham from Green Lantern: Legacy would have been a better pick.

* SoOkayItsAverage: The general consensus about the series after the BrokenBase controversy is scraped away. While the book isn't exactly bad, it moves very slowly and accumulates too many characters to flesh them all out.

** Tim dropping the Drake identity and becoming Robin again in issue #18 after fans negative response to both the name and costume.

* {{Narm}}: The alternate universe Tim Drake that regular Tim meets mocks Tim for still being ''a'' Robin. When Tim asks him what's ''his'' name then? '''Drake'''. Not only is it just sort of dumb to be using his real name, the way he justifies it is, "It's one of the most dangerous birds. It's who I am." A drake is a male duck, which isn't exactly dangerous when the criminals of Gotham could distract Tim by throwing bread on the floor. Bonus for Tim agreeing that it's a good name. And even more so when it becomes ''Tim's'' new identity. This was ultimately touched upon in issue 18 after Tim goes back to being Robin.

* {{Narm}}: The alternate universe Tim Drake that regular Tim meets mocks Tim for still being ''a'' Robin. When Tim asks him what's ''his'' name then? '''Drake'''. Not only is it just sort of dumb to be using his real name, the way he justifies it is, "It's one of the most dangerous birds. It's who I am." A drake is a male duck, which isn't exactly dangerous when the criminals of Gotham could distract Tim by throwing bread on the floor. Bonus for Tim agreeing that it's a good name. And even moreso when it becomes ''Tim's'' new identity. This was ultimately touched upon in issue 18 after Tim goes back to being Robin.

* HilariousInHindsight: Early in the 2003 run of the ''Comicbook/TeenTitans'', when the team (who was half-made up of members of the original Young Justice) get into a misunderstanding with the Justice League, John Stewart quips on the kids' stubbornness with "And people ask why there's no 'Teen Lantern'". Well, now there ''is'' a Teen Lantern (granted, she's not a Corps member, but close enough).

* WinBackTheCrowd: The announcement of this series and the return of Conner Kent has made a lot of Young Justice fans who were disappointed over the cast’s sidelining over the years very happy.

* HoYay: Amethyst and Wonder Girl got few moments that can be seen as subtly hinting some romantic tension - upon their first meeting the art for a scene when they're supposed to be talking to Tim shows them starring in each other's eyes and Cassie can be seen affectionately comforting distraught Amy few issues later.

* SugarWiki/FunnyMoments:
** Issue 6 has Amethyst explaining about Dark Opal's powers and connection to his gem and how hardcore it will be to gets it... only for Impulse, in true Impulse fashion, disappear and reappear (in just two panels!) with said gem, leaving Amethyst and the rest of YJ gobsmacked. He then makes sure it's the right one by confirming it was next to a supposedly mind-destroying horrifying EldritchAbomination Amethyst was trying to warn the team about.
*** Another Bart moment comes when Dark Opal brings a piece of Kryptonite to bring Conner to his knees...only for Bart to jump him, grab it, carry it thousands of miles away and be back before Dark Opal can even comprehend what just happened.
** Teen Lantern reveals she hacked into a Green Lantern Power Battery so she could get an internship at the Hall of Justice. The older kids tell her she might get into spot of trouble for this.
** Issue 7 has Jinny and Teen Lantern speechless as they travel the multiverse. Landing in the world of Captain Carrot and the Zoo Crew leads Superboy to refuse to talk the entire time he was there.
** After landing in the world of ''ComicBook/KingdomCome'' and getting superheroes of that reality to send them home, we get a scene of Doctor Fate casually informing other heroes he screwed up and sent Young Justice to a wrong world, in a way like if he caused a minor inconvenience. Wonder Woman takes a deep breath, like if she was trying to calm herself down listening to his excuses.
** In issue 17, Batman takes Drake aside to talk with Impulse and Superboy watching from a distance. We don’t hear what was said but when Batman walks away Drake just looks down seeming kind of bummed out. This may sound like a TearJerker, except the following issue makes it clear that he was just telling Tim that he hated his new costume and identity.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Tim dropping the Drake identity and becoming Robin again in issue #18 after fans negative response to both the name and costume.

* In issue 17, Batman takes Drake aside to talk with Impulse and Superboy watching from a distance. We don’t hear what was said but when Batman walks away Drake just looks down seeming kind of bummed out. This may sound like a TearJerker, except the following issue makes it clear that he was just telling Tim that he hated his new costume and identity.

* {{Adorkable}}:
** Robin has his moments, especially when he gets nervous and flustered when put in charge of leading team alpha and his facial expressions to his teammates' antics.* AuthorsSavingThrow: Fans were not enthused with the idea that a Pre-Teen could somehow hack into Green Lantern Tech, both due to its nigh-impossibility and how it wasn't initially elaborated on. The revelation that it was tech salvaged from what was strongly implied to be a GL imposter, settled some of these issues.
** After Red Arrow spends the first two seasons as rather uptight and angry, by the third season his demeanor's completely changed. He makes bad puns and jokes about diarrhea, is openly worried about his insurance premiums when Brick attacks his car, and gets adorably flustered during his time with the moms in "Home Fires." In short, he is such a ''dad''.
** Zatanna in Season 1, at least, where she shares Robin's love of wordplay and occasionally mixes BuffySpeak into her magic spells.
** Wonder Girl's cluelessness, general clumsiness and idolization of Wonder Woman make her very endearing.
** Wally's expansive scientific knowledge is appealing to many fans.
** Thirteen gets so excited about visiting an alien planet that she ''jumps'' into a Boom Tube, and accidentally throws off the destination with her magic.
** AmnesiacsAreInnocent is in full effect for Violet, which means Halo/Violet is curious, excitable, and seemingly oblivious to many social cues ([[DistractedByTheSexy like idly commenting on Brion's naked body]]). She's endearingly awkward.