Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / WeirdSchoolRulesInHongKong

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GeniusBonus: In Episode 16, the cop that shows up to arrest the senior-year students [[DisproportionateRetribution for taking photos for too long on their last day of school]] has the police ID "[=D7689=]". This references [[https://evchk.fandom.com/zh/wiki/%E6%B8%A3%E6%89%93%E9%A6%AC%E6%8B%89%E6%9D%BE#PUMA.E3.80.8CD7689.E3.80.8D.E8.99.9F.E7.A2.BC.E5.B8.83 a previous controversy in the 2015 Standard Chartered Hong Kong Marathon]]--"D" and "7" sound like curse words in Cantonese, and "689" was a nickname for the Chief Executive at the time of the marathon, C.Y. Leung[[labelnote:*]]The reason behind the nickname is because he only got 689 votes out of 1200 during the 2012 Election[[/labelnote]], so the PUMA runner-tag [=D7689=] in their marketing scheme was presumed to be a StealthInsult against the then-Chief Executive, who was widely unpopular for his pro-CCP political allegiance.

to:

* GeniusBonus: In Episode 16, the cop that shows up to arrest the senior-year students [[DisproportionateRetribution for taking photos for too long on their last day of school]] has the police ID "[=D7689=]". This references [[https://evchk.fandom.com/zh/wiki/%E6%B8%A3%E6%89%93%E9%A6%AC%E6%8B%89%E6%9D%BE#PUMA.E3.80.8CD7689.E3.80.8D.E8.99.9F.E7.A2.BC.E5.B8.83 a previous controversy in the 2015 Standard Chartered Hong Kong Marathon]]--"D" Marathon]] -- "D" and "7" sound like curse words in Cantonese, and "689" was a nickname for the Chief Executive at the time of the marathon, C.Y. Leung[[labelnote:*]]The reason behind the nickname is because he only got 689 votes out of 1200 during the 2012 Election[[/labelnote]], so the PUMA runner-tag [=D7689=] in their marketing scheme was presumed to be a StealthInsult against the then-Chief Executive, who was widely unpopular for his pro-CCP political allegiance.

Added: 4

Changed: 10

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrossesTheLineTwice: In Episode 16, one of the skits features two of Magic Boy's classmates [[TalkingDownTheSuicidal talking him down]] while he was considering jumping off a building. That's not funny. What can be considered funny, is what happens after that: [[spoiler:Magic Boy reveals the "strict" regulation that caused him to be DrivenToSuicide is that the school was planning to make an app for the students to record how many times they raised their hands in class, the more times they raise their hands, the higher of a grade they'll get... and [[InsufferableGenius Magic Boy]] was annoyed that "idiots" like his classmates (who would raise their hands more often because they didn't understand the subject matter) [[SkewedPriorities would get a higher score than him]]. In response to being called an "idiot", the male classmate ''pushes Magic Boy off the building'', effectively helping him commit SuicideByCop, while declaring that being called an "idiot" was his (and [[AccompliceByInaction the female classmate's]]) BerserkButton. The skit ends with a dramatic cartoony crash in the distance.]]

to:

* CrossesTheLineTwice: In Episode 16, one of the skits features two of Magic Boy's classmates [[TalkingDownTheSuicidal talking him down]] while he was considering jumping off a building. That's not funny. What can be considered funny, is what happens after that: [[spoiler:Magic Boy reveals the "strict" regulation that caused him to be DrivenToSuicide is that the school was planning to make an app for the students to record how many times they raised their hands in class, the more times they raise their hands, the higher of a grade they'll get... and [[InsufferableGenius Magic Boy]] was annoyed that "idiots" like his classmates (who would raise their hands more often because they didn't understand the subject matter) [[SkewedPriorities would get a higher score than him]]. In response to being called an "idiot", the male classmate ''pushes Magic Boy off the building'', effectively helping him commit die from SuicideByCop, while declaring that being called an "idiot" was his (and [[AccompliceByInaction the female classmate's]]) BerserkButton. The skit ends with a dramatic cartoony crash in the distance.]]



* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: The episodes with Tonie hosting the series have ''significantly'' fewer Likes than those hosted by Na-mei, implying this.

to:

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: The episodes with Tonie hosting the series have ''significantly'' fewer Likes than those hosted by Na-mei, implying this.this.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Episode 3: The crossdressing male student in the Casual Dress Day skit. Does this bring a bad reputation on the school for having a ''crossdressing'' student (especially since LGBTQ+ people are still relatively stigmatized in Hong Kong, where the skit takes place), or is the student brave and willing to speak out against the reinforced gender binary in school uniforms? This especially applies when the student states his reasoning for crossdressing--he said it's because [[LoopholeAbuse there's nothing in the school rules against it]], so whether he's doing it to prove a point, to troll others while adhering by ExactWords, or because he genuinely likes crossdressing and saw the opportunity to do so, etc. are all not stated.

to:

** Episode 3: The crossdressing male student in the Casual Dress Day skit. Does this bring a bad reputation on the school for having a ''crossdressing'' student (especially since LGBTQ+ people are still relatively stigmatized in Hong Kong, where the skit takes place), or is the student brave and willing to speak out against the reinforced gender binary in school uniforms? This especially applies when the student states his reasoning for crossdressing--he crossdressing -- he said it's because [[LoopholeAbuse there's nothing in the school rules against it]], so whether he's doing it to prove a point, to troll others while adhering by ExactWords, or because he genuinely likes crossdressing and saw the opportunity to do so, etc. are all not stated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GeniusBonus: In Episode 16, the cop that shows up to arrest the senior-year students [[DisproportionateRetribution for taking photos for too long on their last day of school]] has the police ID "[=D7689=]". This references [[https://evchk.fandom.com/zh/wiki/%E6%B8%A3%E6%89%93%E9%A6%AC%E6%8B%89%E6%9D%BE#PUMA.E3.80.8CD7689.E3.80.8D.E8.99.9F.E7.A2.BC.E5.B8.83 a previous controversy in the 2015 Standard Chartered Hong Kong Marathon]]--"D" and "7" sound like curse words in Cantonese, and "689" was a nickname for the Chief Executive at the time of the marathon, C.Y. Leung, so the PUMA runner-tag [=D7689=] in their marketing scheme was presumed to be a StealthInsult against the then-Chief Executive, who was widely unpopular for his pro-CCP political allegiance.

to:

* GeniusBonus: In Episode 16, the cop that shows up to arrest the senior-year students [[DisproportionateRetribution for taking photos for too long on their last day of school]] has the police ID "[=D7689=]". This references [[https://evchk.fandom.com/zh/wiki/%E6%B8%A3%E6%89%93%E9%A6%AC%E6%8B%89%E6%9D%BE#PUMA.E3.80.8CD7689.E3.80.8D.E8.99.9F.E7.A2.BC.E5.B8.83 a previous controversy in the 2015 Standard Chartered Hong Kong Marathon]]--"D" and "7" sound like curse words in Cantonese, and "689" was a nickname for the Chief Executive at the time of the marathon, C.Y. Leung, Leung[[labelnote:*]]The reason behind the nickname is because he only got 689 votes out of 1200 during the 2012 Election[[/labelnote]], so the PUMA runner-tag [=D7689=] in their marketing scheme was presumed to be a StealthInsult against the then-Chief Executive, who was widely unpopular for his pro-CCP political allegiance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrossesTheLineTwice: In Episode 16, one of the skits features two of Magic Boy's classmates [[TalkingDownTheSuicidal talking him down]] while he was considering jumping off a building. That's not funny. What can be considered funny, is what happens after that: [[spoiler:Magic Boy reveals the "strict" regulation that caused him to be DrivenToSuicide is that the school was planning to make an app for the students to record how many times they raised their hands in class, the more times they raise their hands, the higher of a grade they'll get... and [[InsufferableGenius Magic Boy]] was annoyed that "idiots" like his classmates (who would raise their hands more often because they didn't understand the subject matter) [[SkewedPriorities would get a higher score than him]]. In response to being called an "idiot", the male classmate ''pushes Magic Boy off the building'', effectively helping him consider SuicideByCop, while declaring that being called an "idiot" was his (and [[AccompliceByInaction the female classmate's]]) BerserkButton. The skit ends with a dramatic cartoony crash in the distance.]]

to:

* CrossesTheLineTwice: In Episode 16, one of the skits features two of Magic Boy's classmates [[TalkingDownTheSuicidal talking him down]] while he was considering jumping off a building. That's not funny. What can be considered funny, is what happens after that: [[spoiler:Magic Boy reveals the "strict" regulation that caused him to be DrivenToSuicide is that the school was planning to make an app for the students to record how many times they raised their hands in class, the more times they raise their hands, the higher of a grade they'll get... and [[InsufferableGenius Magic Boy]] was annoyed that "idiots" like his classmates (who would raise their hands more often because they didn't understand the subject matter) [[SkewedPriorities would get a higher score than him]]. In response to being called an "idiot", the male classmate ''pushes Magic Boy off the building'', effectively helping him consider commit SuicideByCop, while declaring that being called an "idiot" was his (and [[AccompliceByInaction the female classmate's]]) BerserkButton. The skit ends with a dramatic cartoony crash in the distance.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Episode 3: The crossdressing male student in the Casual Dress Day skit. Does this bring a bad reputation on the school for having a ''crossdressing'' student (especially since LGBTQ+ people are still relatively stigmatized in Hong Kong, where the skit takes place), or is the student brave and willing to speak out against the reinforced gender binary in school uniforms? This especially applies when the student states his reasoning for crossdressing--he said it's because [[LoopholeAbuse there's nothing in the school rules against it]], so whether he's doing it to prove a point, to troll others while adhering by ExactWords, or because he genuinely likes crossdressing, etc. are all not stated.

to:

** Episode 3: The crossdressing male student in the Casual Dress Day skit. Does this bring a bad reputation on the school for having a ''crossdressing'' student (especially since LGBTQ+ people are still relatively stigmatized in Hong Kong, where the skit takes place), or is the student brave and willing to speak out against the reinforced gender binary in school uniforms? This especially applies when the student states his reasoning for crossdressing--he said it's because [[LoopholeAbuse there's nothing in the school rules against it]], so whether he's doing it to prove a point, to troll others while adhering by ExactWords, or because he genuinely likes crossdressing, crossdressing and saw the opportunity to do so, etc. are all not stated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Episode 3: The crossdressing student in the Casual Dress Day skit. Does this bring a bad reputation on the school for having a ''crossdressing'' student (especially since LGBTQ+ people are still relatively stigmatized in Hong Kong, where the skit takes place), or is the student brave and willing to speak out against the reinforced gender binary in school uniforms?

to:

** Episode 3: The crossdressing male student in the Casual Dress Day skit. Does this bring a bad reputation on the school for having a ''crossdressing'' student (especially since LGBTQ+ people are still relatively stigmatized in Hong Kong, where the skit takes place), or is the student brave and willing to speak out against the reinforced gender binary in school uniforms?uniforms? This especially applies when the student states his reasoning for crossdressing--he said it's because [[LoopholeAbuse there's nothing in the school rules against it]], so whether he's doing it to prove a point, to troll others while adhering by ExactWords, or because he genuinely likes crossdressing, etc. are all not stated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Related: If it's a ''staff member'' who's religious, then is the staff member forcing their dietary laws on the student population, or was it a genuinely well-meaning attempt to cater to them?

to:

*** Related: If it's a ''staff member'' who's religious, then is the staff member forcing their dietary laws on the student population, or was it a genuinely well-meaning attempt to cater to them?the staff member in particular?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation:
** One of the "weird" rules cited at the end of Episode 1 is that some schools ban the consumption of pork and soda for religious reasons. However, whether the ban on pork in particular is reasonable [[AmbiguousSituation depends on]] one factor [[PoorCommunicationKills unstated in the episode]]: how many of the students in the school are Muslims or Jews, or otherwise religious in that their religion has a ban on pork in their dietary laws?
*** If it's a ''majority'' who are, or the school specifically caters to Muslims or Jews, then it's a fairly reasonable rule by all means.
*** If it's a minority who are, then is the school's ban on it a well-meaning attempt to respect the minority's dietary laws, especially if the school serves its lunches in a canteen and has to know what foods they can or can't use to prepare? Or does it restrict the freedom of the students who ''don't'' have to follow those dietary laws? If it's the canteen situation, do the school lunches offer multiple options for the students to choose from? All of this can make the situation seem a lot more understandable from the school's perspective.
*** Or if there are ''no'' students who are religious in this way, is the school preparing for the what-if situation for if a religious student is enrolled at the school? Or is it a completely arbitrary decision?
*** Related: If it's a ''staff member'' who's religious, then is the staff member forcing their dietary laws on the student population, or was it a genuinely well-meaning attempt to cater to them?
** Episode 3: The crossdressing student in the Casual Dress Day skit. Does this bring a bad reputation on the school for having a ''crossdressing'' student (especially since LGBTQ+ people are still relatively stigmatized in Hong Kong, where the skit takes place), or is the student brave and willing to speak out against the reinforced gender binary in school uniforms?
* CrossesTheLineTwice: In Episode 16, one of the skits features two of Magic Boy's classmates [[TalkingDownTheSuicidal talking him down]] while he was considering jumping off a building. That's not funny. What can be considered funny, is what happens after that: [[spoiler:Magic Boy reveals the "strict" regulation that caused him to be DrivenToSuicide is that the school was planning to make an app for the students to record how many times they raised their hands in class, the more times they raise their hands, the higher of a grade they'll get... and [[InsufferableGenius Magic Boy]] was annoyed that "idiots" like his classmates (who would raise their hands more often because they didn't understand the subject matter) [[SkewedPriorities would get a higher score than him]]. In response to being called an "idiot", the male classmate ''pushes Magic Boy off the building'', effectively helping him consider SuicideByCop, while declaring that being called an "idiot" was his (and [[AccompliceByInaction the female classmate's]]) BerserkButton. The skit ends with a dramatic cartoony crash in the distance.]]
* GeniusBonus: In Episode 16, the cop that shows up to arrest the senior-year students [[DisproportionateRetribution for taking photos for too long on their last day of school]] has the police ID "[=D7689=]". This references [[https://evchk.fandom.com/zh/wiki/%E6%B8%A3%E6%89%93%E9%A6%AC%E6%8B%89%E6%9D%BE#PUMA.E3.80.8CD7689.E3.80.8D.E8.99.9F.E7.A2.BC.E5.B8.83 a previous controversy in the 2015 Standard Chartered Hong Kong Marathon]]--"D" and "7" sound like curse words in Cantonese, and "689" was a nickname for the Chief Executive at the time of the marathon, C.Y. Leung, so the PUMA runner-tag [=D7689=] in their marketing scheme was presumed to be a StealthInsult against the then-Chief Executive, who was widely unpopular for his pro-CCP political allegiance.
* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: The episodes with Tonie hosting the series have ''significantly'' fewer Likes than those hosted by Na-mei, implying this.

Top