History YMMV / TheKiteRunner

26th Jun '17 3:32:22 AM shonengirl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Is Amir a misunderstood boy who [[WellDoneSonGuy wants his father’s affections]]? A coward who always runs from his problems? Or a selfish but still caring person? It seems that everyone sees Amir differently.
* BaseBreakingCharacter: Some people see Amir as a protagonist everyone can relate to who has to tackle the obstacles in his path, while others see him as a spineless jerk who only cares about himself.

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Is Amir a misunderstood boy who just [[WellDoneSonGuy wants his father’s affections]]? A coward who always runs from his problems? Or a selfish but still caring person? It seems that everyone sees Amir differently.
differently. However, this it's made clear that he's actually all of the above in the novel.
* BaseBreakingCharacter: Some people see Amir as a protagonist everyone can relate to who has to tackle the obstacles in his path, while others see him as a spineless jerk who only cares about himself. Granted, as said above, this is actually more clear in the novel since the reader is privy to his internal thoughts, and his whole arc is growing out of being spineless jerk who only cares for himself.



* CompleteMonster: [[DepravedBisexual Assef]] begins life as a brass knuckle-brandishing sociopath and a racist {{bully}} with a virulent [[PoliticallyIncorrectVillain hatred of the Hazaras]]. Possessed of an admiration for UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler himself and considering him a visionary, Assef is already known as an [[EarAche ear-eating]] savage around his area and shows his true colors by raping Hassan alongside his friends after the boy humiliates him. Assef [[SchoolyardBullyAllGrownUp graduates from bully to a member of the Taliban]] who introduces himself stoning a blindfolded man to death and [[WouldHurtAChild taking orphans to be sold into sexual slavery]], among them the now-deceased Hassan's son Sohrab as his personal SexSlave. Assef is no less adamant about his mission to massacre the Hazaras, and proudly accepts the term "ethnic cleansing" as one he likes. Assef views himself as taking out "garbage" around Afghanistan, but when everything is clear, Assef is little more than a domineering, depraved, remorseless bully from youth to adulthood.
* HollywoodHomely: In the book, Ali is described as having his face muscles damaged by a sickness, and Hassan having a harelip. Neither are present in the film.
* JerkassWoobie: Amir is shown to be stubborn and often outwit on Hassan with tricks for his amusement. But he has a father who doesn’t appreciate the way he is, feels guilt about “killing” his mom when she gave birth to him and Hassan is his only friend. He may be a jerk sometimes, but what Amir had to go through was rough.

to:

* CompleteMonster: At the earliest stage of life we see [[DepravedBisexual Assef]] begins life as in, he is the living embodiment of KidsAreCruel, a brass knuckle-brandishing sociopath and a racist {{bully}} with a virulent [[PoliticallyIncorrectVillain hatred of the Hazaras]]. Possessed of Hazaras in particular]]. Possessing an admiration for UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler himself and considering him a visionary, Assef is already known as an [[EarAche ear-eating]] savage around his area and shows his true colors by raping Hassan alongside helped by his friends "[[GangOfBullies friends]]" after the boy humiliates him. Assef [[SchoolyardBullyAllGrownUp graduates from bully to a member of the Taliban]] who introduces himself stoning a blindfolded man to death and [[WouldHurtAChild taking orphans to be sold into sexual slavery]], among them the now-deceased Hassan's son Sohrab as his personal SexSlave. Assef is no less adamant about his mission to massacre the Hazaras, [[ReminiscingAboutYourVictims reminisces about how "liberating" it was to massacre the Hazaras at Mazar-i-Sharif]], and proudly accepts the term "ethnic cleansing" as one he likes. Assef views himself as taking out "garbage" around Afghanistan, but when everything is clear, Assef is little more than a domineering, depraved, remorseless bully from youth to adulthood.
* HollywoodHomely: In the book, Ali is described as having his face muscles damaged by a sickness, and Hassan as having a harelip. Neither are present in the film.
film; despite both of these things, ''especially'' the latter, being kind of really important details about said characters, with Hassan's harelip being bought up multiple times in the novel.
* JerkassWoobie: As a child, Amir is shown to be stubborn and to often outwit on Hassan with tricks [[{{Troll}} for his amusement. amusement]]. But he has a father who doesn’t appreciate the way he is, feels guilt about “killing” his mom when she gave birth to him him, has a massive GuiltComplex in general, and Hassan is and Rahim Kahn are his only friend. friends. He may be a jerk sometimes, but what Amir had to go through was rough.rough; and it only gets worse for him from there. So, so much worse.
** General Tahiri, while not a "jerkass" per se, is an overprotective father who is restrictive about what he wants his daughter to do, once crumples up one of Amir's manuscripts and throws it in the trash in front of him, doesn't sleep in the same room as his wife anymore, and is way too snooty to want to get a job in America. However, one has to feel sorry for him, considering his constant headaches, and especially how he went from a general to some poor nobody, as he waits for the day that he can go back to Afghanistan that never comes.
** Baba, sort of. He's a nice person to everyone but Amir, who he is extremely neglectful towards and puts the full expectations of a "true Afghan man" on. However, once his backstory is revealed, and seeing him actually ''cry'' when Hassan and Ali leave, one also has to feel somewhat sorry for him. It also helps that he TookALevelInKindness after moving to America.



* MoralEventHorizon: Assef, see [[spoiler: RapeAsDrama]] on the Main page.

to:

** Also, Sohrab, for being a massive {{Woobie}} and having a very UncannyFamilyResemblance to Hassan.
* MoralEventHorizon: Assef, see Assef crosses it... And then struts through it several more times while laughing. See [[spoiler: RapeAsDrama]] on the Main page.page and CompleteMonster above for more details.



** ''Sohrab.''

to:

** ''Sohrab.'''' Sadly, his situation isn't unique for children orphaned in Afghanistan during Taliban rule.
29th Oct '16 7:02:16 AM ACW
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* CompleteMonster: Assef [[spoiler:rapes Amir's servant, Hassan, because he wouldn't give him a kite, and then goes on to become a member of the Taliban, where he takes small children from orphanages to become sex slaves, one of them the orphaned son of Hassan!]]. As a cherry on top, he [[PoliticallyIncorrectVillain actually ''admires'' Adolf Hitler.]] By that point he's already shown himself to be a nasty villain in many respects.

to:

* CompleteMonster: Assef [[spoiler:rapes Amir's servant, Hassan, because he wouldn't give him [[DepravedBisexual Assef]] begins life as a kite, brass knuckle-brandishing sociopath and then goes on to become a member of the Taliban, where he takes small children from orphanages to become sex slaves, one of them the orphaned son of Hassan!]]. As racist {{bully}} with a cherry on top, he virulent [[PoliticallyIncorrectVillain actually ''admires'' Adolf Hitler.]] By that point he's hatred of the Hazaras]]. Possessed of an admiration for UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler himself and considering him a visionary, Assef is already shown known as an [[EarAche ear-eating]] savage around his area and shows his true colors by raping Hassan alongside his friends after the boy humiliates him. Assef [[SchoolyardBullyAllGrownUp graduates from bully to a member of the Taliban]] who introduces himself stoning a blindfolded man to death and [[WouldHurtAChild taking orphans to be sold into sexual slavery]], among them the now-deceased Hassan's son Sohrab as his personal SexSlave. Assef is no less adamant about his mission to massacre the Hazaras, and proudly accepts the term "ethnic cleansing" as one he likes. Assef views himself as taking out "garbage" around Afghanistan, but when everything is clear, Assef is little more than a nasty villain in many respects.domineering, depraved, remorseless bully from youth to adulthood.
12th Aug '16 4:54:20 AM Lancelot07
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenBase: Over the film as to whether it's a good adaptation of the book or not.
4th Aug '16 7:54:33 PM Anddrix
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* BaseBreaker: Some people see Amir as a protagonist everyone can relate to who has to tackle the obstacles in his path, while others see him as a spineless jerk who only cares about himself.

to:

* BaseBreaker: BaseBreakingCharacter: Some people see Amir as a protagonist everyone can relate to who has to tackle the obstacles in his path, while others see him as a spineless jerk who only cares about himself.
28th Mar '16 3:47:03 PM TheJester
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Is Amir a misunderstood boy who [[WellDoneSonGuy wants his father’s affections]]? A coward who always runs from his problems? Or a selfish but still caring person? It seems that everyone sees Amir differently depending on how they view him.

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Is Amir a misunderstood boy who [[WellDoneSonGuy wants his father’s affections]]? A coward who always runs from his problems? Or a selfish but still caring person? It seems that everyone sees Amir differently depending on how they view him.differently.
28th Apr '15 5:55:18 PM TakingItOnTheOtherside
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* OneHitWonder: Zekeria Ebrahimi and Ahmad Khan Mahmidzada, the Afghan child actors who played young Amir and young Hassan respectively, had never acted before and have never acted again. In fact, acting in the movie caused major problems after shooting finished, because many questioned sending them back to Kabul, where their families feared attacks because of the homosexual themes in the movie. They were relocated to the United Arab Emirates.
16th Jan '15 2:06:23 PM rt2012
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* CompleteMonster: Assef [[spoiler:rapes Amir's servant, Hassan, because he wouldn't give him a kite, and then goes on to become a member of the Taliban, where he takes small children from orphanages to become sex slaves, one of them the orphaned son of Hassan!]]. As a cherry on top, he actually ''admires'' UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler. By that point he's already shown himself to be a nasty villain in many respects.

to:

* CompleteMonster: Assef [[spoiler:rapes Amir's servant, Hassan, because he wouldn't give him a kite, and then goes on to become a member of the Taliban, where he takes small children from orphanages to become sex slaves, one of them the orphaned son of Hassan!]]. As a cherry on top, he [[PoliticallyIncorrectVillain actually ''admires'' UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler. Adolf Hitler.]] By that point he's already shown himself to be a nasty villain in many respects.
14th Nov '14 1:35:39 PM MagBas
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* UnfortunateImplications: Assef is [[ButNotTooForeign half-German]], has blonde hair and blue eyes and wishes that Hazaras were wiped out of existence. And it’s implied that he sees Hitler as a role model if his birthday present for Amir is anything to go by. This was probably the reason why that changed Assef’s hair brown and never mentioned anything else aside from still being a bully and hating Hazaras.
25th Oct '14 3:49:52 PM TheOneWhoTropes
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* CompleteMonster: Assef [[spoiler:rapes Amir's servant, Hassan, because he wouldn't give him a kite, and then goes on to become a member of the Taliban, where he takes small children from orphanages to become sex slaves, one of them the orphaned son of Hassan!]]. As a cherry on top, he actually ''admires'' AdolfHitler. By that point he's already shown himself to be a nasty villain in many respects.

to:

* CompleteMonster: Assef [[spoiler:rapes Amir's servant, Hassan, because he wouldn't give him a kite, and then goes on to become a member of the Taliban, where he takes small children from orphanages to become sex slaves, one of them the orphaned son of Hassan!]]. As a cherry on top, he actually ''admires'' AdolfHitler.UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler. By that point he's already shown himself to be a nasty villain in many respects.
28th Feb '14 9:08:39 AM Ecclytennysmithylove
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* TearJerker: ''For you, a thousand times over.'' Doubles as a CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming
** [[spoiler:Hassan's]] death, for obvious reasons.
This list shows the last 10 events of 30. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=YMMV.TheKiteRunner