Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheHobbitTheBattleOfTheFiveArmies

Go To

OR

Added: 303

Changed: 162

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the Gundabad scene, the orc army emerges from the fortress--all well and good. Then a visibly different group of orcs breaks ranks and charges out in front. This might have worked dramatically, except they're not actually ''charging at anything'', so they were apparently just doing that for fun.



** Bard shoots Smaug down with a makeshift bow made by jamming the broken halves of his bow into the pillars of the tower he's standing on. If a spear-sized steel arrow could be launched with enough force to bury itself to the feathers into a dragon's body, and it all hinges on two pieces of wood lodged into two bigger pieces of wood by one man using his bare hands (one hand per piece of bow!), it means Bard has superhuman strength.

to:

** Bard shoots Smaug down with a makeshift bow made by jamming the broken halves of his bow into the pillars of the tower he's standing on. If a spear-sized steel arrow could be launched with enough force to bury itself to the feathers into a dragon's body, and it all hinges on two pieces of wood lodged into two bigger pieces of wood by one man using his bare hands (one hand per piece of bow!), it means Bard has superhuman strength. Ironically, the whole concept was likely to make it more plausible that Bard could kill a dragon that size with one arrow, but it mostly has the opposite effect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Billy Boyd's "The Last Goodbye". At once a heartwarming and tear-jerker piece, it is nigh impossible not to be moved while listening to it, especially if one is also watching the videoclip.

to:

** Billy Boyd's "The Last Goodbye". At once a heartwarming and tear-jerker piece, it is nigh impossible not to be moved while listening to it, especially if one is also watching the videoclip.videoclip or the credits with character's portraits.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicking Just For Pun


** Smaug is only in the first several minutes of the movie, but [[NightmareFuel he leaves one hell]] [[JustForPun of an impact]] with his rampage.

to:

** Smaug is only in the first several minutes of the movie, but [[NightmareFuel he leaves one hell]] [[JustForPun hell of an impact]] with his rampage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler:Smaug getting impaled and killed with the spear after how destructive he was]]...especially with the moment being teased not only since the beginning of the first movie, but the second one [[spoiler:ending with the cliffhanger of him escaping and going after the town]] as well.

to:

** [[spoiler:Smaug getting impaled and killed with the spear Black Arrow after how destructive he was]]...especially with the moment being teased not only since the beginning of the first movie, but the second one [[spoiler:ending with the cliffhanger of him escaping and going after the town]] Laketown]] as well.



* SugarWiki/VisualEffectsOfAwesome: While some viewers would take issues with the cases of SpecialEffectsFailure listed above, they are few and above, considering that 96% of all shots had some GCI in them and 25% of the entire movie was CGI entirely. Some specific examples:

to:

* SugarWiki/VisualEffectsOfAwesome: While some viewers would take issues with the cases of SpecialEffectsFailure listed above, they are few and above, considering that 96% of all shots had some GCI CGI in them and 25% of the entire movie was CGI entirely. Some specific examples:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FanPreferredCutContent: One of the few extended edition scenes that people wish was kept for the theatrical cut was Alfrid's death as he actually gets his comeuppance rather than him getting away as a massive KarmaHoudini.

Top