Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheCrown2016

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Philip, who is brusque and condescending to nearly everyone he meets. But then come the revelations that he had to give up his career ambitions and nearly all of his self-worth in order to support his wife in an age when men were expected to be the absolute heads of their households, leaving him with nothing to do but socialize and pursue various hobbies to occupy his time.

to:

** Philip, who is brusque and condescending to nearly everyone he meets. But then come the revelations that he had to give up his career ambitions and nearly all of his self-worth in order to support his wife in an age when men were expected to be the absolute heads of their households, leaving him with nothing to do but socialize and pursue various hobbies to occupy his time. This grows even more in the second season, when his rough and unsympathetic treatment towards Charles is paralleled with his own traumatic childhood -- his exile, his father's abandonment in favor of his mistress, his mother's insanity, and eventually the death of his beloved older sister, inadvertently caused by his actions at his tough boarding school. At said sister's funeral, his father even blames him for her death in front of the whole audience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FandomRivalry: After Netflix cancelled several of their most expensive shows in 2017, their fans were furious that ''The Crown'', the service's actual ''most'' expensive show, got to stay around. A big part of the resentment is that the company's president had recently made a statement about how proud they are of the risks they're taking with their original programming, yet ''The Crown'' is by far the most "safe" of the shows in question, being a highbrow period drama about a bunch of straight white people.

to:

* FandomRivalry: After Netflix cancelled several of their most expensive shows in 2017, their fans were furious that ''The Crown'', the service's actual ''most'' expensive show, got to stay around. A big part of the resentment is that the company's president had recently made a statement about how proud they are of the risks they're taking with their original programming, yet ''The Crown'' is by far the most "safe" of the shows in question, being a highbrow period drama about a bunch of straight white people. This outrage seemingly ignores the very real success of ''The Crown'' versus other original programming.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HollywoodHomely: Halfway through Season 2 Elizabeth worries that she's starting to look old, while still being played by a not uglied up in the slightest Claire Foy. Especially jarring as it had already been announced that the decade older Olivia Colman would take over the role the following season.

Added: 209

Changed: 551

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Squick}}: The show depicts King George VI's illness and death in very graphic detail. Some highlights include:
** A closeup of the operation to remove one of his lungs, showing his beating heart and the surgeons cutting away at his lung.
** Philip walks into the room being used as a makeshift operating theater in time to see King George VI's diseased lung being laid out on a tray.
** Margaret walking in on his body being embalmed.

to:

* {{Squick}}: {{Squick}}:
**
The show depicts King George VI's illness and death in very graphic detail. Some highlights include:
** *** A closeup of the operation to remove one of his lungs, showing his beating heart and the surgeons cutting away at his lung.
** *** Philip walks into the room being used as a makeshift operating theater in time to see King George VI's diseased lung being laid out on a tray.
** *** Margaret walking in on his body being embalmed.embalmed.
** Season 2 depicts the birth of Prince Andrew, involving the midwife reaching in with medical forceps and pulling the baby out (a common method at the time).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DuelingShows: Many comparisons have been drawn between the Crown, and ITV's Victoria, as both series about the early reigns of two of Britain's most famous Queens, their struggles of balancing their marriages and family life with their royal duties, their relationships with their ministers and both featuring former Series/DoctorWho co-stars Creator/MattSmith and Creator/JennaColeman, respectively [[note]]as well as Alex Jennings as scheming royal uncles The Duke of Windsor and King Leopold of the Belgians, respectively[[/note]]. The Crown's producer even [[http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2016-10-03/the-crown-producer-says-soapy-rival-royal-drama-victoria-isnt-in-the-same-league fanned the flames by saying Victoria is not in the same league as The Crown]]. For what it's worth, ''The Crown'' made a global splash and ended up winning Best Drama and Claire Foy won Best Dramatic Actress at the 2016 Golden Globes while ''Victoria'' seemingly faded into the background.

to:

* DuelingShows: Many comparisons have been drawn between the Crown, and ITV's Victoria, Series/{{Victoria}}, as both series about the early reigns of two of Britain's most famous Queens, their struggles of balancing their marriages and family life with their royal duties, their relationships with their ministers and both featuring former Series/DoctorWho co-stars Creator/MattSmith and Creator/JennaColeman, respectively [[note]]as well as Alex Jennings as scheming royal uncles The Duke of Windsor and King Leopold of the Belgians, respectively[[/note]]. The Crown's producer even [[http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2016-10-03/the-crown-producer-says-soapy-rival-royal-drama-victoria-isnt-in-the-same-league fanned the flames by saying Victoria is not in the same league as The Crown]]. For what it's worth, ''The Crown'' made a global splash and ended up winning Best Drama and Claire Foy won Best Dramatic Actress at the 2016 Golden Globes while ''Victoria'' has seemingly faded into the background.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FandomRivalry: After Netflix cancelled several of their most expensive shows in 2017, their fans were furious that ''The Crown'', the service's actual ''most'' expensive show, got to stay around. A big part of the resentment is that the company's president had recently made a statement about how proud they are of the risks they're taking with their original programming, yet ''The Crown'' is by far the most "safe" of the shows in question, being a highbrow period drama about a bunch of straight white people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DuelingShows: Many comparisons have been drawn between the Crown, and ITV's Victoria, as both series about the early reigns of two of Britain's most famous Queens, their struggles of balancing their marriages and family life with their royal duties, their relationships with their ministers and both featuring former Series/DoctorWho co-stars Creator/MattSmith and Creator/JennaColeman, respectively [[note]]as well as Alex Jennings as scheming royal uncles The Duke of Windsor and King Leopold of the Belgians, respectively[[/note]]. The Crown's producer even [[http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2016-10-03/the-crown-producer-says-soapy-rival-royal-drama-victoria-isnt-in-the-same-league fanned the flames by saying Victoria is not in the same league as The Crown]].

to:

* DuelingShows: Many comparisons have been drawn between the Crown, and ITV's Victoria, as both series about the early reigns of two of Britain's most famous Queens, their struggles of balancing their marriages and family life with their royal duties, their relationships with their ministers and both featuring former Series/DoctorWho co-stars Creator/MattSmith and Creator/JennaColeman, respectively [[note]]as well as Alex Jennings as scheming royal uncles The Duke of Windsor and King Leopold of the Belgians, respectively[[/note]]. The Crown's producer even [[http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2016-10-03/the-crown-producer-says-soapy-rival-royal-drama-victoria-isnt-in-the-same-league fanned the flames by saying Victoria is not in the same league as The Crown]]. For what it's worth, ''The Crown'' made a global splash and ended up winning Best Drama and Claire Foy won Best Dramatic Actress at the 2016 Golden Globes while ''Victoria'' seemingly faded into the background.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[UsefulNotes/HMTheQueen Queen Elizabeth II]], who'd hoped to have had at least ten or twenty years to raise her family before ascending to the throne. But her father's failing health meant that she had to quickly start taking more responsibility and unexpectedly become Queen well before she was 30, resulting in the deterioration of her marriage and family life as [[StiffUpperLip she steadfastly grows into her position and refuses to let the strain show to the public]].

to:

** [[UsefulNotes/HMTheQueen Queen Elizabeth II]], who'd hoped to have had at least ten or twenty years to raise her family family, and allow Philip to enjoy a legitimate naval career, before ascending to the throne. But her father's failing health meant that she had to quickly start taking more responsibility and unexpectedly become Queen well before she was 30, resulting in the deterioration of her marriage and family life as [[StiffUpperLip she steadfastly grows into her position and refuses to let the strain show to the public]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added another example of comparison between "The Crown" and ITV's "Victoria," but hid it as a note for space considerations.


* DuelingShows: Many comparisons have been drawn between the Crown, and ITV's Victoria, as both series about the early reigns of two of Britain's most famous Queens, their struggles of balancing their marriages and family life with their royal duties, their relationships with their ministers and both featuring former Series/DoctorWho co-stars Creator/MattSmith and Creator/JennaColeman respectively. The Crown's producer even [[http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2016-10-03/the-crown-producer-says-soapy-rival-royal-drama-victoria-isnt-in-the-same-league fanned the flames by saying Victoria is not in the same league as The Crown]].

to:

* DuelingShows: Many comparisons have been drawn between the Crown, and ITV's Victoria, as both series about the early reigns of two of Britain's most famous Queens, their struggles of balancing their marriages and family life with their royal duties, their relationships with their ministers and both featuring former Series/DoctorWho co-stars Creator/MattSmith and Creator/JennaColeman respectively.Creator/JennaColeman, respectively [[note]]as well as Alex Jennings as scheming royal uncles The Duke of Windsor and King Leopold of the Belgians, respectively[[/note]]. The Crown's producer even [[http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2016-10-03/the-crown-producer-says-soapy-rival-royal-drama-victoria-isnt-in-the-same-league fanned the flames by saying Victoria is not in the same league as The Crown]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DuelingShows: Many comparisons have been drawn between the Crown, and ITV's Victoria, as both series about the early reign of two of Britain's most famous Queens, their struggles of balancing their marriages and family life with their royal duties, their relationships with their ministers and both starring former Series/DoctorWho alumni Creator/MattSmith and Creator/JennaColeman respectively. The Crown's producer even [[http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2016-10-03/the-crown-producer-says-soapy-rival-royal-drama-victoria-isnt-in-the-same-league fanned the flames by saying Victoria is not in the same league as The Crown]].

to:

* DuelingShows: Many comparisons have been drawn between the Crown, and ITV's Victoria, as both series about the early reign reigns of two of Britain's most famous Queens, their struggles of balancing their marriages and family life with their royal duties, their relationships with their ministers and both starring featuring former Series/DoctorWho alumni co-stars Creator/MattSmith and Creator/JennaColeman respectively. The Crown's producer even [[http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2016-10-03/the-crown-producer-says-soapy-rival-royal-drama-victoria-isnt-in-the-same-league fanned the flames by saying Victoria is not in the same league as The Crown]].

Added: 321

Changed: 174

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Squick}}: Philip walks into the room being used as a makeshift operating theater in time to see King George VI's diseased lung being laid out on a tray.

to:

* {{Squick}}: The show depicts King George VI's illness and death in very graphic detail. Some highlights include:
** A closeup of the operation to remove one of his lungs, showing his beating heart and the surgeons cutting away at his lung.
**
Philip walks into the room being used as a makeshift operating theater in time to see King George VI's diseased lung being laid out on a tray.tray.
** Margaret walking in on his body being embalmed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DuelingShows: Many comparisons have been drawn between the Crown, and ITV's Victoria, as both series about the early reign of two of Britain's most famous Queens, their struggles of balancing their marriages and family life with their royal duties, their relationships with their ministers and both starring former Series/DoctorWho alumni Creator/MattSmith and Creator/JennaColeman respectively. The Crown's producer even [[http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2016-10-03/the-crown-producer-says-soapy-rival-royal-drama-victoria-isnt-in-the-same-league fanned the flames by saying Victoria is not in the same league as The Crown]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IdiotPlot: The alterations to history turn the separation of Margaret and Peter Townsend into one. Despite being previously noted as a foremost authority on British constitutional law, Elizabeth has no idea of the second half of the Royal Marriages Act that's being hidden from her, nor does it apparently ever once occur to her to look it up and make sure she's getting the whole story in the two years before Margaret turns 25. Indeed, the conspirators even have as a ready-made excuse that the law was there for her to study whenever she wanted. And nor do Margaret or Peter themselves think to make sure of what they're signing on for, or even any of the journalists informing the public about the highly popular couple.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Philip is much too close to Matt Smith's style for this trope. He's not exactly playing a Hells Angel.


* WTHCastingAgency: Arguably, Creator/MattSmith as Prince Phillip - Smith's time on ''Series/DoctorWho'' has given him a reputation as a young, {{Adorkable}} GeekyTurnOn sex symbol, not attributes with which Prince Phillip is associated in real life. Others would argue that playing Prince Philip would allow Smith [[PlayingAgainstType to dilute that image]], as Smith is [[AbilityOverAppearance quite talented despite not being like Prince Philip in real life]]. Plus, he's a ''very'' close physical match.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WTHCastingAgency: Arguably, Creator/MattSmith as Prince Phillip - Smith's time on ''Series/DoctorWho'' has given him a reputation as a young, {{Adorkable}} GeekyTurnOn sex symbol, not attributes with which Prince Phillip is associated in real life. Others would argue that playing Prince Philip would allow Smith [[PlayingAgainstType to dilute that image]], as Smith is [[AbilityOverAppearance quite talented despite not being like Prince Philip in real life]].

to:

* WTHCastingAgency: Arguably, Creator/MattSmith as Prince Phillip - Smith's time on ''Series/DoctorWho'' has given him a reputation as a young, {{Adorkable}} GeekyTurnOn sex symbol, not attributes with which Prince Phillip is associated in real life. Others would argue that playing Prince Philip would allow Smith [[PlayingAgainstType to dilute that image]], as Smith is [[AbilityOverAppearance quite talented despite not being like Prince Philip in real life]]. Plus, he's a ''very'' close physical match.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WTHCastingAgency: Arguably, Creator/MattSmith as Prince Phillip - Smith's time on ''Series/DoctorWho'' has given him a reputation as a young, {{Adorkable}} GeekyTurnOn sex symbol, not attributes with which Prince Phillip is associated in real life.

to:

* WTHCastingAgency: Arguably, Creator/MattSmith as Prince Phillip - Smith's time on ''Series/DoctorWho'' has given him a reputation as a young, {{Adorkable}} GeekyTurnOn sex symbol, not attributes with which Prince Phillip is associated in real life. Others would argue that playing Prince Philip would allow Smith [[PlayingAgainstType to dilute that image]], as Smith is [[AbilityOverAppearance quite talented despite not being like Prince Philip in real life]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: Princess Margaret's breakup with Peter Townsend is this, doubly so when one considers that in RealLife, the Queen and the cabinet actually ''supported'' their relationship. The princess's actual marriage later ended in divorce.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: Princess Margaret's breakup with Peter Townsend is this, doubly so when one considers that in RealLife, the Queen and the Eden cabinet actually ''supported'' their relationship. The princess's actual marriage later ended in divorce.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HarsherInHindsight: Princess Margaret's breakup with Peter Townsend is this, doubly so when one considers that in RealLife, the Queen and the cabinet actually ''supported'' their relationship. The princess's actual marriage later ended in divorce.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WTHCastingAgency: Arguably, Creator/MattSmith as Prince Phillip - Smith's time on ''Series/DoctorWho'' has given him a reputation as a young, {{Adorkable}} GeekyTurnOn sex symbol, not attributes with which Prince Phillip is associated in real life.

to:

* WTHCastingAgency: Arguably, Creator/MattSmith as Prince Phillip - Smith's time on ''Series/DoctorWho'' has given him a reputation as a young, {{Adorkable}} GeekyTurnOn sex symbol, not attributes with which Prince Phillip is associated in real life.life.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HoYay: Palpable between the Duke of Edinburgh and his Private Secretary, Michael Parker, who, when seeing Philip in his white tie, demands that he give a twirl before remarking "you look beautiful". He then affectionately pats Philip on the bottom before both men head out partying, leaving a dejected Queen Elizabeth in their wake. Philip later bitches to Elizabeth that Mike doesn't have a personal 'phone line to the Palace.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: In a meta-example thanks to Eileen Atkins playing Queen Mary here after having previously done so in the movie ''Film/BertieAndElizabeth''. In that movie, Queen Mary was more of a CoolOldLady who mainly provided sarcastic comedy. Here, she's a GrandeDame who acts as a mentor to Elizabeth and embodies the traditionalism of the Windsor family--one of her most notable scenes is when she appears after George's death in full mourning regalia and curtseying to now-Queen Elizabeth.

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: In a meta-example thanks to Eileen Atkins playing Queen Mary here after having previously done so in the movie ''Film/BertieAndElizabeth''. In that movie, Queen Mary was more of a CoolOldLady who mainly provided sarcastic comedy. Here, she's a GrandeDame who acts as a mentor to Elizabeth and embodies the traditionalism of the Windsor family--one House of Windsor--one of her most notable scenes is when she appears after George's death in full mourning regalia and curtseying performs a very deep curtsy to the now-Queen Elizabeth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: In a meta-example thanks to Eileen Atkins playing Queen Mary here after having previously done so in the movie ''Film/BertieAndElizabeth''. In that movie, Queen Mary was more of a CoolOldLady who mainly provided sarcastic comedy. Here, she's a GrandeDame who acts as a mentor to Elizabeth and embodies the traditionalism of the Windsor family--one of her most notable scenes is when she appears after George's death in full mourning regalia and curtseying to now-Queen Elizabeth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Philip, who is brusque and condescending to nearly everyone he meets. But then comes the revelations that he had to give up his career ambitions and nearly all of his self-worth in order to support his wife in an age when men were expected to be the absolute heads of their households, leaving him with nothing to do but socialize and pursue various hobbies to occupy his time.
** David, the Duke of Windsor, who is as much BitchInSheepsClothing as he his portrayed, but the abdication weighs on him heavily. He has to endure, what he feels is, the constant disrespect towards his wife by being denied the style of Her Royal Highness, the British Establishment making it clear they will never forgive him for the Abdication, his own family despises him for the same, and yet he remains devoted to the institution of the Crown, even as he admits that he lacked the strength to bear it.

to:

** Philip, who is brusque and condescending to nearly everyone he meets. But then comes come the revelations that he had to give up his career ambitions and nearly all of his self-worth in order to support his wife in an age when men were expected to be the absolute heads of their households, leaving him with nothing to do but socialize and pursue various hobbies to occupy his time.
** David, the Duke of Windsor, who is as much BitchInSheepsClothing as he his portrayed, but the abdication weighs on him heavily. He has to endure, endure what he feels is, is the constant disrespect towards his wife by being denied the style of Her Royal Highness, the British Establishment making it clear they will never forgive him for the Abdication, and his own family despises despising him for the same, and same. And yet he remains devoted to the institution of the Crown, even as he admits that he lacked the strength to bear it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[UsefulNotes/HMTheQueen Queen Elizabeth II]], who'd hoped to have had at least ten or twenty years to raise her family before ascending to the throne. But her father's failing health meant that she had to quickly start taking more responsibility and unexpectedly become Queen well before she was 30, resulting in the deterioration of her marriage and family life as [[StiffUpperLip steadfastly grows into her position and refuses to let the strain show to the public]].

to:

** [[UsefulNotes/HMTheQueen Queen Elizabeth II]], who'd hoped to have had at least ten or twenty years to raise her family before ascending to the throne. But her father's failing health meant that she had to quickly start taking more responsibility and unexpectedly become Queen well before she was 30, resulting in the deterioration of her marriage and family life as [[StiffUpperLip she steadfastly grows into her position and refuses to let the strain show to the public]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Philip, who is brusque and condescending to nearly everyone he meets. But then comes the revelations that he had to give up his career ambitions and nearly all of his self-worth in order to support his wife in an age when men were expected to be the absolute heads of their households.

to:

** Philip, who is brusque and condescending to nearly everyone he meets. But then comes the revelations that he had to give up his career ambitions and nearly all of his self-worth in order to support his wife in an age when men were expected to be the absolute heads of their households.households, leaving him with nothing to do but socialize and pursue various hobbies to occupy his time.

Added: 795

Changed: 285

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkassWoobie: Philip, who is brusque and condescending to nearly everyone he meets. But then comes the revelations that he had to give up his career ambitions and nearly all of his self-worth in order to support his wife in an age when men were expected to be the absolute heads of their households.

to:

* JerkassWoobie: JerkassWoobie:
**
Philip, who is brusque and condescending to nearly everyone he meets. But then comes the revelations that he had to give up his career ambitions and nearly all of his self-worth in order to support his wife in an age when men were expected to be the absolute heads of their households.households.
** David, the Duke of Windsor, who is as much BitchInSheepsClothing as he his portrayed, but the abdication weighs on him heavily. He has to endure, what he feels is, the constant disrespect towards his wife by being denied the style of Her Royal Highness, the British Establishment making it clear they will never forgive him for the Abdication, his own family despises him for the same, and yet he remains devoted to the institution of the Crown, even as he admits that he lacked the strength to bear it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Squick}}: Philip walks into the room being used as a makeshift operating theater in time to see King George VI's diseased lung being laid out on a tray.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JerkassWoobie: Philip, who is brusque and condescending to nearly everyone he meets. But then comes the revelations that he had to give up his career ambitions and nearly all of his self-worth in order to support his wife in an age when men were expected to be the absolute heads of their households.
* IronWoobie:
** [[UsefulNotes/TheHouseOfWindsor King George VI]], who wanted nothing more than a military career and a quiet life at home with his family, was thrust into the role of head of state with little preparation. But he stepped up and served admirably, to the great love and affection of his people, even though he was never comfortable or happy as King and suffered ill-health due to the stresses of his position.
** [[UsefulNotes/HMTheQueen Queen Elizabeth II]], who'd hoped to have had at least ten or twenty years to raise her family before ascending to the throne. But her father's failing health meant that she had to quickly start taking more responsibility and unexpectedly become Queen well before she was 30, resulting in the deterioration of her marriage and family life as [[StiffUpperLip steadfastly grows into her position and refuses to let the strain show to the public]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WTHCastingAgency: Arguably, Creator/MattSmith as Prince Phillip - Smith's time on ''Series/DoctorWho'' has given him a reputation as a young, {{Adorkable}} GeekyTurnOn sex symbol, not attributes with which Prince Phillip is associated in real life.

Top