Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheColourOfMagic

Go To

OR

Added: 478

Changed: 1597

Removed: 41

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not enough context (ZCE), fixing indentation, natter


* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: The part where Rincewind [[spoiler:accidentally teleports himself and Twoflower onto an airplane in our world and ends up thinking that he is Dr. Rjinswand, (33, a bachelor, born in Sweden, raised in New Jersey, and a specialist in the breakaway oxidation phenomena of certain nuclear reactors [a fancy way of saying that they're uncontrollably on fire])... only for the Luggage to interrupt the whole scene]].
** Becomes FridgeBrilliance when you realize that it's all an extended pun: [[spoiler:They were transported to another plane.]]
** Also an EarlyBirdCameo for [[spoiler: Roundworld]], once ''The Science of Discworld'' makes [[spoiler: our world]] a canon part of the Verse's reality.

to:

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: BigLippedAlligatorMoment:
**
The part where Rincewind [[spoiler:accidentally teleports himself and Twoflower onto an airplane in our world and ends up thinking that he is Dr. Rjinswand, (33, a bachelor, born in Sweden, raised in New Jersey, and a specialist in the breakaway oxidation phenomena of certain nuclear reactors [a fancy way of saying that they're uncontrollably on fire])... only for the Luggage to interrupt the whole scene]].
**
scene]]. Becomes FridgeBrilliance when you realize that it's all an extended pun: [[spoiler:They were transported to another plane.]]
** Also an An EarlyBirdCameo for [[spoiler: Roundworld]], once ''The Science of Discworld'' makes [[spoiler: our world]] a canon part of the Verse's reality.



* HarsherInHindsight: The plane being hijacked by a swarthy, bearded man. At the time, airplane hijackings were most often done by escaping criminals trying to get to a country they could seek asylum in -- Cuba was particularly popular for those with Communist sympathies or mistaken belief that the country would harbour people who commit crimes in America. The act didn't become associated with Muslim extremists until the late '80s, or using the plane for suicide attacks until later than that.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: HarsherInHindsight:
**
The plane being hijacked by a swarthy, bearded man. At the time, airplane hijackings were most often done by escaping criminals trying to get to a country they could seek asylum in -- Cuba was particularly popular for those with Communist sympathies or mistaken belief that the country would harbour people who commit crimes in America. The act didn't become associated with Muslim extremists until the late '80s, or using the plane for suicide attacks until later than that.



* MoralEventHorizon: Galder Weatherwax trying to outright ''kill'' his former student via magical arrow in the film. I mean, he had to take the spell back by force but that is ''harsh''.
* QuestionableCasting: Many are displeased by the fact that Rincewind is played by an old man, rather than Eric Idle like in [[VideoGame/{{Discworld}} the games]].
** Though Eric Idle is only four years younger than David Jason, and still would have been twice Rincewind's age from the books at the time of filming, so that wouldn't have resolved the issue. Casting someone in their thirties with no prior connection to Discworld adaptations probably wouldn't have gone down well with fans of the game either, to be fair.

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: Galder Weatherwax trying to outright ''kill'' his former student via magical arrow in the film. I mean, he He had to take the spell back by force but that is ''harsh''.
* QuestionableCasting: QuestionableCasting:
**
Many are displeased by the fact that Rincewind is played by an old man, rather than Eric Idle like in [[VideoGame/{{Discworld}} the games]].
**
games]]. Though Eric Idle is only four years younger than David Jason, and still would have been twice Rincewind's age from the books at the time of filming, so that wouldn't have resolved the issue. Casting someone in their thirties with no prior connection to Discworld adaptations probably wouldn't have gone down well with fans of the game either, to be fair.






* SpecialEffectsFailure: In the two-part film from Sky One, please pay no attention to Cohen's clearly visible teeth.

to:

* %%* SpecialEffectsFailure: In the two-part film from Sky One, please pay no attention to Cohen's clearly visible teeth.
teeth.



** It doesn't sound Dutch either, though.

Added: 1325

Changed: 168

Removed: 1162

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed trope


* QuestionableCasting: Many are displeased by the fact that Rincewind is played by an old man, rather than Eric Idle like in [[VideoGame/{{Discworld}} the games]].
** Though Eric Idle is only four years younger than David Jason, and still would have been twice Rincewind's age from the books at the time of filming, so that wouldn't have resolved the issue. Casting someone in their thirties with no prior connection to Discworld adaptations probably wouldn't have gone down well with fans of the game either, to be fair.
** There was also some displeasure over the casting of American actor Sean Astin as Twoflower, which was viewed by some as an unnecessary attempt to attract more American viewers at the expense of some of the original book's very British-y humour, and by others as whitewashing, since the books had firmly established that Twoflower is the Disc's equivalent of Japanese. However, Terry Pratchett defended the decision by pointing out that Twoflower was a blend of Japanese, American, and British tourist stereotypes in his first couple of appearances. And, since every [[Creator/{{Sky}} Sky One]] ''Discworld'' adaptation has re-cast every character anyway, presumably if ''Interesting Times'' does get made they'll cast actors of Japanese/Chinese descent as Agateans when it becomes relevant to the plot.



* WhatTheHellCastingAgency: Many are displeased by the fact that Rincewind is played by an old man, rather than Eric Idle like in [[VideoGame/{{Discworld}} the games]].
** Though Eric Idle is only four years younger than David Jason, and still would have been twice Rincewind's age from the books at the time of filming, so that wouldn't have resolved the issue. Casting someone in their thirties with no prior connection to Discworld adaptations probably wouldn't have gone down well with fans of the game either, to be fair.
** There was also some displeasure over the casting of American actor Sean Astin as Twoflower, which was viewed by some as an unnecessary attempt to attract more American viewers at the expense of some of the original book's very British-y humour, and by others as whitewashing, since the books had firmly established that Twoflower is the Disc's equivalent of Japanese. However, Terry Pratchett defended the decision by pointing out that Twoflower was a blend of Japanese, American, and British tourist stereotypes in his first couple of appearances. And, since every [[Creator/{{Sky}} Sky One]] ''Discworld'' adaptation has re-cast every character anyway, presumably if ''Interesting Times'' does get made they'll cast actors of Japanese/Chinese descent as Agateans when it becomes relevant to the plot.

to:

* WhatTheHellCastingAgency: Many are displeased by the fact that Rincewind is played by an old man, rather than Eric Idle like in [[VideoGame/{{Discworld}} the games]].
** Though Eric Idle is only four years younger than David Jason, and still would have been twice Rincewind's age from the books at the time of filming, so that wouldn't have resolved the issue. Casting someone in their thirties with no prior connection to Discworld adaptations probably wouldn't have gone down well with fans of the game either, to be fair.
** There was also some displeasure over the casting of American actor Sean Astin as Twoflower, which was viewed by some as an unnecessary attempt to attract more American viewers at the expense of some of the original book's very British-y humour, and by others as whitewashing, since the books had firmly established that Twoflower is the Disc's equivalent of Japanese. However, Terry Pratchett defended the decision by pointing out that Twoflower was a blend of Japanese, American, and British tourist stereotypes in his first couple of appearances. And, since every [[Creator/{{Sky}} Sky One]] ''Discworld'' adaptation has re-cast every character anyway, presumably if ''Interesting Times'' does get made they'll cast actors of Japanese/Chinese descent as Agateans when it becomes relevant to the plot.

Added: 4

Changed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpecialEffectsFailure: In the two-part film from [=SkyOne=], please pay no attention to Cohen's clearly visible teeth.

to:

* SpecialEffectsFailure: In the two-part film from [=SkyOne=], Sky One, please pay no attention to Cohen's clearly visible teeth.



** There was also some displeasure over the casting of American actor Sean Astin as Twoflower, which was viewed by some as an unnecessary attempt to attract more American viewers at the expense of some of the original book's very British-y humour, and by others as whitewashing, since the books had firmly established that Twoflower is the Disc's equivalent of Japanese. However, Terry Pratchett defended the decision by pointing out that Twoflower was a blend of Japanese, American, and British tourist stereotypes in his first couple of appearances. And, since every Creator/Sky1 ''Discworld'' adaptation has re-cast every character anyway, presumably if ''Interesting Times'' does get made they'll cast actors of Japanese/Chinese descent as Agateans when it becomes relevant to the plot.

to:

** There was also some displeasure over the casting of American actor Sean Astin as Twoflower, which was viewed by some as an unnecessary attempt to attract more American viewers at the expense of some of the original book's very British-y humour, and by others as whitewashing, since the books had firmly established that Twoflower is the Disc's equivalent of Japanese. However, Terry Pratchett defended the decision by pointing out that Twoflower was a blend of Japanese, American, and British tourist stereotypes in his first couple of appearances. And, since every Creator/Sky1 [[Creator/{{Sky}} Sky One]] ''Discworld'' adaptation has re-cast every character anyway, presumably if ''Interesting Times'' does get made they'll cast actors of Japanese/Chinese descent as Agateans when it becomes relevant to the plot.



** It doesn't sound Dutch either, though.

to:

** It doesn't sound Dutch either, though.though.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Shout Out isn't subjective


* ShoutOut: Rincewind's explanation of hydrophobic wizards' ability to levitate over water is a rewording of the way levitation was controlled by the protagonist of Creator/RandallGarrett's ''What The Left Hand Was Doing'':
-->''The Colour of Magic'': “You mean they hate water?” said Twoflower. “No, that wouldn’t work,” said Rincewind. “Hate is an attracting force, just like love. They really loathe it, the very idea of it revolts them.”
-->''What The Left Hand Was Doing'': He didn’t hate it. That would be deadly, for hate implies as much attraction as love... Only loathing could save him. The earth beneath was utterly repulsive to him.
** Garrett's levitator ended up flying home over an ocean that he'd persuaded himself to loath.
** Garrett is not usually listed among Pratchett's influencers but was in the right time and genre to be one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The film adaptation also has a drawn out scene that copies the BolivianArmyEnding of ''Film/ButchCassidyAndTheSundanceKid'', with Rincewind grabbing a pair of twigs that are vaguely pistol-shaped, and we get a variation of the same dialogue just before they charge out and... "shoot" at the wizards surrounding them in slow motion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut: Rincewind's explanation of hydrophobic wizards' ability to levitate over water is extremely similar to the way levitation was controlled by the protagonist of Creator/RandallGarrett's short story ''What The Left Hand Was Doing'':

to:

* ShoutOut: Rincewind's explanation of hydrophobic wizards' ability to levitate over water is extremely similar to a rewording of the way levitation was controlled by the protagonist of Creator/RandallGarrett's short story ''What The Left Hand Was Doing'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShoutOut: Rincewind's explanation of hydrophobic wizards' ability to levitate over water is extremely similar to the way levitation was controlled by the protagonist of Creator/RandallGarrett's short story ''What The Left Hand Was Doing'':
-->''The Colour of Magic'': “You mean they hate water?” said Twoflower. “No, that wouldn’t work,” said Rincewind. “Hate is an attracting force, just like love. They really loathe it, the very idea of it revolts them.”
-->''What The Left Hand Was Doing'': He didn’t hate it. That would be deadly, for hate implies as much attraction as love... Only loathing could save him. The earth beneath was utterly repulsive to him.
** Garrett's levitator ended up flying home over an ocean that he'd persuaded himself to loath.
** Garrett is not usually listed among Pratchett's influencers but was in the right time and genre to be one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The sheer number of adventurers reported to be competing for quests takes on a more melancholy note in-Verse, for those who've also read "Troll Bridge" or ''Literature/TheLastHero'', which make it clear that such heroes are rapidly exterminating the Disc's monsters and thereby putting themselves out of business.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: The plane being hijacked by a swarthy, bearded man. At the time, airplane hijackings were most often done by escaping criminals trying to get to a country they could seek asylum in -- Cuba was particularly popular for those with Communist sympathies or mistaken belief that the country would harbour people who commit crimes in America. The act didn't become associated with Muslim extremists until the late '80s.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: The plane being hijacked by a swarthy, bearded man. At the time, airplane hijackings were most often done by escaping criminals trying to get to a country they could seek asylum in -- Cuba was particularly popular for those with Communist sympathies or mistaken belief that the country would harbour people who commit crimes in America. The act didn't become associated with Muslim extremists until the late '80s.'80s, or using the plane for suicide attacks until later than that.

Changed: 59

Removed: 82

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RetroactiveRecognition: Liessa is now [[WesternAnimation/{{Aladdin}} Princess Jasmine]] in ''Series/OnceUponATime''!
** She was also [[{{LoveInterest}} Princess Isabella]] on ''Series/{{Galavant}}''.

to:

* RetroactiveRecognition: Liessa is now has been [[WesternAnimation/{{Aladdin}} Princess Jasmine]] in ''Series/OnceUponATime''!
** She was also [[{{LoveInterest}}
''Series/OnceUponATime'' and Princess Isabella]] Isabella on ''Series/{{Galavant}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RetroactiveRecognition: Liessa is now [[Disney/{{Aladdin}} Princess Jasmine]] in ''Series/OnceUponATime''!

to:

* RetroactiveRecognition: Liessa is now [[Disney/{{Aladdin}} [[WesternAnimation/{{Aladdin}} Princess Jasmine]] in ''Series/OnceUponATime''!

Added: 219

Changed: 671

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HilariousInHindsight: Rincewind muses on how there are too many heroes in Ankh-Morpork, and how the notable questing-grounds are so busy during high season that they plan to introduce a rota. A scene familiar to anyone who ever played a regular {{MMORPG}}, all of which came out well after this book was published (with the exception of certain MUD games).
** Plus, the troll encounter plays out exactly like a random encounter in a console RPG.

to:

* HilariousInHindsight: HilariousInHindsight:
**
Rincewind muses on how there are too many heroes in Ankh-Morpork, and how the notable questing-grounds are so busy during high season that they plan to introduce a rota. A scene familiar to anyone who ever played a regular {{MMORPG}}, all of which came out well after this book was published (with the exception of certain MUD games).
** Plus, the The troll encounter plays out exactly like a random encounter in a console RPG.RPG, complete with a distortion of the air and a weird swishing sound, followed by the troll appearing out of nowhere in front of the heroes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* EarWorm: the theme to the film.
** "Rincewind's Theme" as well.

Top