Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheABCMurders

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: The killer sends taunting letters announcing the dates in which he is going to kill someone. One letter announces his next killing will be on ''September 11th''! Hastings even says that, "I shall, I think, remember that 11th of September all my life. Indeed, whenever I see a mention of the St. Leger my mind flies automatically not to horse-racing but to murder."

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: The killer sends taunting letters announcing the dates in which he is going to kill someone. One letter announces his next killing will be on ''September 11th''! ''[[UsefulNotes/TheWarOnTerror September 11th]]''! Hastings even says that, "I shall, I think, remember that 11th of September all my life. Indeed, whenever I see a mention of the St. Leger my mind flies automatically not to horse-racing but to murder."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved to main page.


* CastingGag: Two retroactive examples:
** Creator/ShirleyHenderson, who plays Rose Marbury, would go on to play Creator/AgathaChristie herself in ''Film/SeeHowTheyRun''.
** Creator/HenryGoodman has a minor role as Mr. Prynne. In 2022, he played Poirot in a stage production of ''Literature/MurderOnTheOrientExpress''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved to trivia.


* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a fairly ordinary white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added casting gag


** Creator/HenryGoodman has a minor role as Mr. Prynne. In 2022, he played Poirot himself in a stage production of ''Literature/MurderOnTheOrientExpress''.

to:

** Creator/HenryGoodman has a minor role as Mr. Prynne. In 2022, he played Poirot himself in a stage production of ''Literature/MurderOnTheOrientExpress''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added casting gag

Added DiffLines:

* CastingGag: Two retroactive examples:
** Creator/ShirleyHenderson, who plays Rose Marbury, would go on to play Creator/AgathaChristie herself in ''Film/SeeHowTheyRun''.
** Creator/HenryGoodman has a minor role as Mr. Prynne. In 2022, he played Poirot himself in a stage production of ''Literature/MurderOnTheOrientExpress''.

Added: 1241

Changed: 433

Removed: 789

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added heading


* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a fairly ordinary white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable.

to:

* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a fairly ordinary white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable.!!The novel



* HoYay: In the BBC adaptation, [[spoiler:Franklin's]] final speech to Poirot feels like this throughout, but when he gets to the ending section it positively ''reeks'' of HoYay, with the ending being [[spoiler:Franklin]] ''caressing Poirot's scar and saying he's going to miss him''.
* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: The general reaction to the 2018 BBC adaption, which makes a lot of changes to the material for the sake of being DarkerAndEdgier which are unnecessary like getting rid of Inspector Japp and Captain Hastings and makes it so bleak it's almost unwatchable. And that's not even getting into the replacement of Poirot's iconic moustaches, with a generic looking goatee beard. Between this, and his AdaptationalPersonalityChange, there's little of the original character left at all.


Added DiffLines:

!!The BBC series
* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a fairly ordinary white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable.
* HoYay: In the BBC adaptation, [[spoiler:Franklin's]] final speech to Poirot feels like this throughout, but when he gets to the ending section it positively ''reeks'' of HoYay, with the ending being [[spoiler:Franklin]] ''caressing Poirot's scar and saying he's going to miss him''.
* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: The general reaction to the 2018 BBC adaption, which makes a lot of changes to the material for the sake of being DarkerAndEdgier which are unnecessary like getting rid of Inspector Japp and Captain Hastings and makes it so bleak it's almost unwatchable. And that's not even getting into the replacement of Poirot's iconic moustaches, with a generic looking goatee beard. Between this, and his AdaptationalPersonalityChange, there's little of the original character left at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correcting the quote and removing the subsequent remark, which is now a bit of a stretch.


* HarsherInHindsight: The killer sends taunting letters announcing the dates in which he is going to kill someone. One letter announces his next killing will be on ''September 11th''! Hastings even says that, "From now on the date September 11th will always mean a day of murder to me." Yeah, that's true of pretty much everybody now, Hastings.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: The killer sends taunting letters announcing the dates in which he is going to kill someone. One letter announces his next killing will be on ''September 11th''! Hastings even says that, "From now on the date "I shall, I think, remember that 11th of September 11th will always mean all my life. Indeed, whenever I see a day mention of murder the St. Leger my mind flies automatically not to me.horse-racing but to murder." Yeah, that's true of pretty much everybody now, Hastings.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removed repetitive info


* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a fairly ordinary white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable. Between this, and his AdaptationalPersonalityChange, there's little of Poirot to recognise here.

to:

* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a fairly ordinary white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable. Between this, and his AdaptationalPersonalityChange, there's little of Poirot to recognise here.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added to ability over appearance


* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a fairly ordinary white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable. Between this, and his AdaptationalPersonalityChange

to:

* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a fairly ordinary white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable. Between this, and his AdaptationalPersonalityChangeAdaptationalPersonalityChange, there's little of Poirot to recognise here.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added to they changed it now it sucks


* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a fairly ordinary white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable.

to:

* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a fairly ordinary white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable. Between this, and his AdaptationalPersonalityChange
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added to they changed it now it sucks.


* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: The general reaction to the 2018 BBC adaption, which makes a lot of changes to the material for the sake of being DarkerAndEdgier which are unnecessary like getting rid of Inspector Japp and Captain Hastings and makes it so bleak it's almost unwatchable. And that's not even getting into the replacement of Poirot's iconic moustaches, with a generic looking goatee beard.

to:

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: The general reaction to the 2018 BBC adaption, which makes a lot of changes to the material for the sake of being DarkerAndEdgier which are unnecessary like getting rid of Inspector Japp and Captain Hastings and makes it so bleak it's almost unwatchable. And that's not even getting into the replacement of Poirot's iconic moustaches, with a generic looking goatee beard. Between this, and his AdaptationalPersonalityChange, there's little of the original character left at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added ability over appearance


* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable.

to:

* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a fairly ordinary white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added ability over appearance

Added DiffLines:

* AbilityOverAppearance: Franchise/HerculePoirot is described in the books as 5'4", black-haired, plump, and sporting a pair of meticulously styled moustaches. Creator/JohnMalkovich is 5'11", bald, thin, and wears a white goatee beard, although he briefly dyes it black. Onscreen, Poirot's clothing style is quite bland and understated. His literary counterpart dresses more stylishly, and is always neat and impeccable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added to they changed it now it sucks


* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: The general reaction to the 2018 BBC adaption, which makes a lot of changes to the material for the sake of being DarkerAndEdgier which are unnecessary like getting rid of Inspector Japp and Captain Hastings and makes it so bleak it's almost unwatchable.

to:

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: The general reaction to the 2018 BBC adaption, which makes a lot of changes to the material for the sake of being DarkerAndEdgier which are unnecessary like getting rid of Inspector Japp and Captain Hastings and makes it so bleak it's almost unwatchable. And that's not even getting into the replacement of Poirot's iconic moustaches, with a generic looking goatee beard.

Top