Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Surrogates

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: [[spoiler:Was Greer right to allow the surrogates to be destroyed, or has he caused more porblems than he solved and brought about mass chaos?]]

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: [[spoiler:Was Greer right to allow the surrogates to be destroyed, or has he caused more porblems problems than he solved and brought about mass chaos?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixed typo


** [[spoiler: Surrogates were originally invented to help disabled people, for whom this was not just for fun (or even wanting to) but instead to provide support in their day to day lives. Now with it universally shut down, these people are all abruptly left without that. Some viewers consider the main character [[UnitentionallyUnsympathetic very unsympathetic]] for not giving this aspect any consideration at all.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Surrogates were originally invented to help disabled people, for whom this was not just for fun (or even wanting to) but instead to provide support in their day to day lives. Now with it universally shut down, these people are all abruptly left without that. For those who may have been using surrogates to help maintain their flesh-and-blood bodies instead of relying on human caregivers, things could get messy. Some viewers consider the main character [[UnitentionallyUnsympathetic [[UnintentionallyUnsympathetic very unsympathetic]] for not giving this aspect any consideration at all.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AcceptableTargets: The non-surrogate-using populace in the Dread reservations (or the one we see) is primarily composed of various species of hillbillies. Downplayed, however, in that they are depicted sympathetically and their viewpoint is understandable, if not vindicated by the end. Also, their leader is a charismatic hippie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Coming from seeing significant discussion on this specific topic about the movie.

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: Surrogates were originally invented to help disabled people, for whom this was not just for fun (or even wanting to) but instead to provide support in their day to day lives. Now with it universally shut down, these people are all abruptly left without that. Some viewers consider the main character [[UnitentionallyUnsympathetic very unsympathetic]] for not giving this aspect any consideration at all.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InferredHolocaust: Somebody sets up a plot to destroy all the surrogates and kill the humans linked into them in the process. The hero manually engages the safety overrides on all the pods, but at the last minute, decides to have the weapon go off anyway, destroying the surrogates while leaving human beings intact. So one billion surrogates conducting business, operating machines, driving cars, etc, suddenly shut down and one billion atrophied shut-ins must now emerge to try to deal with the ensuing mayhem. In addition to people living lives via surrogate clearly suffering from sunlight deprivation, malnutrition, and the ill effects of sedentary lives, it's obvious that people have lost interest in having sex with their actual bodies or with actual people. Birthrates would have probably fallen to near extinction levels. The [[ComicBook/TheSurrogates graphic novel]] at least plays the ending for ambiguity — sure, all the shut-ins are back out in the real world, but it's only a matter of time until someone redevelops the Surrogate technology. The main character's wife [[DrivenToSuicide kills herself]] because she can't stand the idea of being seen as-is.

to:

* InferredHolocaust: Somebody sets up a plot to destroy all the surrogates and kill the humans linked into them in the process. The [[spoiler:The hero manually engages the safety overrides on all the pods, but at the last minute, decides to have the weapon go off anyway, destroying the surrogates while leaving human beings intact. So one billion surrogates conducting business, operating machines, driving cars, etc, suddenly shut down and one billion atrophied shut-ins must now emerge to try to deal with the ensuing mayhem. ]] In addition to people living lives via surrogate clearly suffering from sunlight deprivation, malnutrition, and the ill effects of sedentary lives, it's obvious that people have lost interest in having sex with their actual bodies or with actual people. Birthrates would have probably fallen to near extinction levels. The [[ComicBook/TheSurrogates graphic novel]] at least plays the ending for ambiguity — sure, [[spoiler:sure, all the shut-ins are back out in the real world, but it's only a matter of time until someone redevelops the Surrogate technology. The main character's wife [[DrivenToSuicide kills herself]] because she can't stand the idea of being seen as-is.as-is]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AcceptableTargets: The non-surrogate-using populace in the Dread reservations (or the one we see) is primarily composed of various species of hillbillies. Downplayed, however, in that they are depicted sympathetically and their viewpoint is understandable, if not vindicated by the end. Also, their leader is a charismatic hippie

to:

* AcceptableTargets: The non-surrogate-using populace in the Dread reservations (or the one we see) is primarily composed of various species of hillbillies. Downplayed, however, in that they are depicted sympathetically and their viewpoint is understandable, if not vindicated by the end. Also, their leader is a charismatic hippiehippie.

Changed: 462

Removed: 244

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AcceptableTargets: The non-surrogate-using populace in the Dread reservations (or the one we see) is primarily composed of various species of hillbillies. As well, the first half of [[RulesOfTheInternet Rule #29]] is played with -- twice.

to:

* AcceptableTargets: The non-surrogate-using populace in the Dread reservations (or the one we see) is primarily composed of various species of hillbillies. As well, Downplayed, however, in that they are depicted sympathetically and their viewpoint is understandable, if not vindicated by the first half of [[RulesOfTheInternet Rule #29]] end. Also, their leader is played with -- twice.a charismatic hippie



* FridgeHorror: [[spoiler: Anyone being driven by a Surrogate, anyone being operated on by a surrogate Surgeon, which would be common as Surrogate surgeons would have enhanced senses and capabilities. Anyone anywhere who is stuck in a building because their Surrogate had the keys or because they were just too careless to take paranoid safety precautions. Anyone who was paralyzed and in an [[AndIMustScream unbearable state.]] Everyone who was killed, made to return to being handicapped. and to put a final topper on it, the fact that the entire economy is going to take a serious hit as VSI, probably the biggest company on the market was severely compromised and every company worldwide that had Surrogate employees, The ultimate work-from-home option, was just crippled.]]
** Not to mention that the person who [[spoiler: killed a pregnant woman, and as a cult leader, likely killed more people essentially got exactly what he wanted. While the person who single-handedly stopped an instance of domestic abuse lost.]]

to:

* FridgeHorror: [[spoiler: Anyone [[spoiler:Anyone being driven by a Surrogate, anyone being operated on by a surrogate Surgeon, which would be common as Surrogate surgeons would have enhanced senses and capabilities. Anyone anywhere who is stuck in a building because their Surrogate had the keys or because they were just too careless to take paranoid safety precautions. Anyone who was paralyzed and in an [[AndIMustScream unbearable state.]] Everyone who was killed, made to return to being handicapped. and to put a final topper on it, the fact that the entire economy is going to take a serious hit as VSI, probably the biggest company on the market was severely compromised and every company worldwide that had Surrogate employees, The ultimate work-from-home option, was just crippled.]]
**
]] Not to mention that the person who [[spoiler: killed a pregnant woman, and as a cult leader, likely killed more people essentially got exactly what he wanted. While wanted, while the person who single-handedly stopped an instance of domestic abuse lost.]]lost]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Pretty sure this intentional/In Universe, so moving to main page.


%%* TookTheBadFilmSeriously: We salute you Bruce Willis and Radha Mitchell. (ZCE)
* UncannyValley: The surrogates in the film. They have a shiny, overly made-up look and clearly aren't quite people.
** A number of the actors portraying surrogates appeared to take special care moving just a ''hair'' more stiffly, and to not look like they were breathing. And while certain surrogates are indistinguishable from real people [[spoiler:like the Prophet]], the "life-like" appearance varied according to the quality and model of the surrogate. Cam's landlord, for instance, is using a cheap, temporary model.

to:

%%* TookTheBadFilmSeriously: We salute you Bruce Willis and Radha Mitchell. (ZCE)
* UncannyValley: The surrogates in the film. They have a shiny, overly made-up look and clearly aren't quite people.
** A number of the actors portraying surrogates appeared to take special care moving just a ''hair'' more stiffly, and to not look like they were breathing. And while certain surrogates are indistinguishable from real people [[spoiler:like the Prophet]], the "life-like" appearance varied according to the quality and model of the surrogate. Cam's landlord, for instance, is using a cheap, temporary model.
(ZCE)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Greer, good guy or bad guy? [[spoiler: In the end, We mean.]]

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Greer, good guy or bad guy? [[spoiler: In [[spoiler:Was Greer right to allow the end, We mean.]]surrogates to be destroyed, or has he caused more porblems than he solved and brought about mass chaos?]]



* InferredHolocaust: In addition to people living lives via surrogate clearly suffering from sunlight deprivation, malnutrition, and the ill effects of sedentary lives, it's obvious that people have lost interest in having sex with their actual bodies or with actual people. Birthrates would have probably fallen to near extinction levels.

to:

* InferredHolocaust: Somebody sets up a plot to destroy all the surrogates and kill the humans linked into them in the process. The hero manually engages the safety overrides on all the pods, but at the last minute, decides to have the weapon go off anyway, destroying the surrogates while leaving human beings intact. So one billion surrogates conducting business, operating machines, driving cars, etc, suddenly shut down and one billion atrophied shut-ins must now emerge to try to deal with the ensuing mayhem. In addition to people living lives via surrogate clearly suffering from sunlight deprivation, malnutrition, and the ill effects of sedentary lives, it's obvious that people have lost interest in having sex with their actual bodies or with actual people. Birthrates would have probably fallen to near extinction levels. The [[ComicBook/TheSurrogates graphic novel]] at least plays the ending for ambiguity — sure, all the shut-ins are back out in the real world, but it's only a matter of time until someone redevelops the Surrogate technology. The main character's wife [[DrivenToSuicide kills herself]] because she can't stand the idea of being seen as-is.



* TookTheBadFilmSeriously: We salute you Bruce Willis and Radha Mitchell.

to:

* %%* TookTheBadFilmSeriously: We salute you Bruce Willis and Radha Mitchell.Mitchell. (ZCE)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: While the audience doesn't know it's [[spoiler: Lionel Canter]] operating the surrogate at the time, people seem to forget that he [[spoiler: murdered Greer's partner in while she was asleep]], and that [[spoiler:she was ''pregnant'']].

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: While the audience doesn't know it's [[spoiler: Lionel [[spoiler:Lionel Canter]] operating the surrogate at the time, people seem to forget that he [[spoiler: murdered has Greer's partner in while she was asleep]], and that [[spoiler:she was ''pregnant'']].partner, who is ''pregnant'', murdered, so their plan can continue using her surrogate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
You don't use first person sentence as an example.


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Greer, good guy or bad guy? [[spoiler: In the end, I mean.]]

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Greer, good guy or bad guy? [[spoiler: In the end, I We mean.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I am pretty sure this is a Rule Of Cautious Editing Judgement violation, given how controversial the whole situation has beenz


* HeartwarmingInHindsight: The premise of people using synthetic pseudo-bodies to go out and live their lives while remaining at home, originally a satire of internet addiction and social alienation in general, abruptly became a ''lot'' more appealing - indeed, ''envied'' - with the 2020 COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic. In an era of compulsory online interaction, "social distancing" and self-quarantine, the prospect of going out to party in a plague-proof robot shell becomes ''extremely'' tempting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeartwarmingInHindsight: The premise of people using synthetic pseudo-bodies to go out and live their lives while remaining at home, originally a satire of internet addiction and social alienation in general, abruptly became a ''lot'' more appealing - indeed, ''envied'' - with the 2019/2020 COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic. In an era of compulsory online interaction, "social distancing" and self-quarantine, the prospect of going out to party in a plague-proof robot shell becomes ''extremely'' tempting.

to:

* HeartwarmingInHindsight: The premise of people using synthetic pseudo-bodies to go out and live their lives while remaining at home, originally a satire of internet addiction and social alienation in general, abruptly became a ''lot'' more appealing - indeed, ''envied'' - with the 2019/2020 2020 COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic. In an era of compulsory online interaction, "social distancing" and self-quarantine, the prospect of going out to party in a plague-proof robot shell becomes ''extremely'' tempting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeartwarmingInHindsight: The premise of people using synthetic pseudo-bodies to go out and live their lives while remaining at home, originally a satire of internet addiction and social alienation in general, abruptly became a ''lot'' more appealing - indeed, ''envied'' - with the emergence of the COVID-10 coronavirus: in an era of compulsory online interaction, "social distancing" and self-quarantine, the prospect of going out to party in a plague-proof robot shell becomes ''extremely'' tempting.

to:

* HeartwarmingInHindsight: The premise of people using synthetic pseudo-bodies to go out and live their lives while remaining at home, originally a satire of internet addiction and social alienation in general, abruptly became a ''lot'' more appealing - indeed, ''envied'' - with the emergence of the COVID-10 coronavirus: in 2019/2020 COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic. In an era of compulsory online interaction, "social distancing" and self-quarantine, the prospect of going out to party in a plague-proof robot shell becomes ''extremely'' tempting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeartwarmingInHindsight: The notion of people using synthetic pseudo-bodies to go out and live their lives while remaining at home, originally a satire of internet addiction and social alienation in general, abruptly became a ''lot'' more appealing - indeed, ''envied'' - with the emergence of the COVID-10 coronavirus: in an era of compulsory online interaction, "social distancing" and self-quarantine, the prospect of going out to party in a plague-proof robot shell becomes ''extremely'' tempting.

to:

* HeartwarmingInHindsight: The notion premise of people using synthetic pseudo-bodies to go out and live their lives while remaining at home, originally a satire of internet addiction and social alienation in general, abruptly became a ''lot'' more appealing - indeed, ''envied'' - with the emergence of the COVID-10 coronavirus: in an era of compulsory online interaction, "social distancing" and self-quarantine, the prospect of going out to party in a plague-proof robot shell becomes ''extremely'' tempting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeartwarmingInHindsight: The notion of people using synthetic pseudo-bodies to go out and live their lives while remaining at home, originally a satire of internet addiction and social alienation in general, abruptly became a ''lot'' more appealing - indeed, ''envied'' - with the emergence of the COVID-10 coronavirus: in an era of compulsory online interaction, "social distancing" and self-quarantine, the prospect of going out to party in a plague-proof robot shell becomes ''extremely'' tempting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*InferredHolocaust: In addition to people living lives via surrogate clearly suffering from sunlight deprivation, malnutrition, and the ill effects of sedentary lives, it's obvious that people have lost interest in having sex with their actual bodies or with actual people. Birthrates would have probably fallen to near extinction levels.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AcceptableTargets: The non-surrogate-using populace in the Dread reservations (or the one we see) is primarily composed of various species of hillbillies. As well, the first half of Rule #29 is played with--twice.

to:

* AcceptableTargets: The non-surrogate-using populace in the Dread reservations (or the one we see) is primarily composed of various species of hillbillies. As well, the first half of [[RulesOfTheInternet Rule #29 #29]] is played with--twice.with -- twice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeHorror: [[spoiler: Anyone being driven by a Surrogate, anyone being operated on by a surrogate Surgeon, which would be common as Surrogate surgeons would have enhanced senses and capabilities. Anyone anywhere who is stuck in a building because their Surrogate had the keys or because they were just too careless to take paranoid safety precautions. Anyone who was paralyzed and in an [[Literature/IHaveNoMouthAndIMustScream unbearable state.]] Everyone who was killed, made to return to being handicapped. and to put a final topper on it, the fact that the entire economy is going to take a serious hit as VSI, probably the biggest company on the market was severely compromised and every company worldwide that had Surrogate employees, The ultimate work-from-home option, was just crippled.]]

to:

* FridgeHorror: [[spoiler: Anyone being driven by a Surrogate, anyone being operated on by a surrogate Surgeon, which would be common as Surrogate surgeons would have enhanced senses and capabilities. Anyone anywhere who is stuck in a building because their Surrogate had the keys or because they were just too careless to take paranoid safety precautions. Anyone who was paralyzed and in an [[Literature/IHaveNoMouthAndIMustScream [[AndIMustScream unbearable state.]] Everyone who was killed, made to return to being handicapped. and to put a final topper on it, the fact that the entire economy is going to take a serious hit as VSI, probably the biggest company on the market was severely compromised and every company worldwide that had Surrogate employees, The ultimate work-from-home option, was just crippled.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeHorror: [[spoiler: Anyone being driven by a Surrogate, anyone being operated on by a surrogate Surgeon, which would be common as Surrogate surgeons would have enhanced senses and capabilities. Anyone anywhere who is stuck in a building because their Surrogate had the keys or because they were just too careless to take paranoid safety precautions. Anyone who was paralyzed and in an [[IHaveNoMouthAndIMustScream unbearable state.]] Everyone who was killed, made to return to being handicapped. and to put a final topper on it, the fact that the entire economy is going to take a serious hit as VSI, probably the biggest company on the market was severely compromised and every company worldwide that had Surrogate employees, The ultimate work-from-home option, was just crippled.]]

to:

* FridgeHorror: [[spoiler: Anyone being driven by a Surrogate, anyone being operated on by a surrogate Surgeon, which would be common as Surrogate surgeons would have enhanced senses and capabilities. Anyone anywhere who is stuck in a building because their Surrogate had the keys or because they were just too careless to take paranoid safety precautions. Anyone who was paralyzed and in an [[IHaveNoMouthAndIMustScream [[Literature/IHaveNoMouthAndIMustScream unbearable state.]] Everyone who was killed, made to return to being handicapped. and to put a final topper on it, the fact that the entire economy is going to take a serious hit as VSI, probably the biggest company on the market was severely compromised and every company worldwide that had Surrogate employees, The ultimate work-from-home option, was just crippled.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A number of the actors portraying surrogates appeared to take special care moving just a ''hair'' more stiffly, and to not look like they were breathing. And while certain surrogates are indistinguishable from real people [[spoiler:like the Prophet]], the "life-like" appearance varied according to the quality and model of the surrogate. The landlord, for instance, is using a cheap, temporary model.

to:

** A number of the actors portraying surrogates appeared to take special care moving just a ''hair'' more stiffly, and to not look like they were breathing. And while certain surrogates are indistinguishable from real people [[spoiler:like the Prophet]], the "life-like" appearance varied according to the quality and model of the surrogate. The Cam's landlord, for instance, is using a cheap, temporary model.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved from the film page.

Added DiffLines:

* FridgeHorror: [[spoiler: Anyone being driven by a Surrogate, anyone being operated on by a surrogate Surgeon, which would be common as Surrogate surgeons would have enhanced senses and capabilities. Anyone anywhere who is stuck in a building because their Surrogate had the keys or because they were just too careless to take paranoid safety precautions. Anyone who was paralyzed and in an [[IHaveNoMouthAndIMustScream unbearable state.]] Everyone who was killed, made to return to being handicapped. and to put a final topper on it, the fact that the entire economy is going to take a serious hit as VSI, probably the biggest company on the market was severely compromised and every company worldwide that had Surrogate employees, The ultimate work-from-home option, was just crippled.]]
** Not to mention that the person who [[spoiler: killed a pregnant woman, and as a cult leader, likely killed more people essentially got exactly what he wanted. While the person who single-handedly stopped an instance of domestic abuse lost.]]
* FridgeLogic: See the [[Headscratchers/{{Surrogates}} Headscratchers page]].

Top