History YMMV / ScottPilgrimTakesOff

* HePannedItNowHeSucks: An interesting case with the website ''My Anime List'', as it's not a review that has gotten everybody angry with them, but the site's absolute refusal to add the show to its list. This is despite the fact that ''Scott Pilgrim: Takes Off'' hits every criteria for an anime that the site itself has posted and that the reasons for not listing it don't make much sense given there are many anime that are listed that would fall under those exclusionary reasons.

** Todd and Wallace. [[spoiler:Many fans found Todd whipped love towards the usually cold and narcissistic Wallace to be very entertaining and their pairing very cute, which made them a couple the fans preferred much more than Wallace's eventual canon relationship with Mobile, a character that the viewers barely have time to meet and get to know.]]
** Despite the immediate ShipSink due to them failing to feel any chemistry, and the former seemingly having a ShipTease with Lucas Lee and possibly Hollie Hawkes, [[spoiler:Kim and Roxie is a somewhat popular ship due to them sharing a BigDamnKiss at the end of "Ramona Rents A Video"]]

* LauncherOfAThousandShips: Kim Pine is, as usual, a fan favorite to ship various characters with; Scott, Ramona, Roxie, Hollie, Lucas, and to a small set of older comic fans Knives as well.

* NoYay: While Kim and Knives were a fan favorite pairing in the past it has been mostly rejected by the current fanbase as many see it as just as problematic as Scott dating Knives due to Kim still being around Scott's age. This trope comes into play with Kim and Knives' jam session. The scene is full of "sparks" which are used multiple times in the series to denote romance as well as a big heart shown between the two as they play. A lot of fans do not like the implications.

** Ramona supplanting Scott as the starring character may seem like a weird choice to play out, but this is not the first time it has happened. In ''VideoGame/ScottPilgrimVsTheWorldTheGame'', you can play with the starring characters of the books/movie, but playing with Scott will NOT give you the comics' (canon) ending, but rather an ending about how Scott learning absolutely nothing from his experiences. Playing with ''Ramona'', on the other hand actually gives you the canon ending where Scott and Ramona learn about their mistakes and end up in a healthy relationship, meaning she ''is'' the starring character in the titular character's own game.

* FanPreferredCouple: Todd and Wallace. [[spoiler:Many fans found Todd whipped love towards the usually cold and narcissistic Wallace to be very entertaining and their pairing very cute, which made them a couple the fans preferred much more than Wallace's eventual canon relationship with Mobile, a character that the viewers barely have time to meet and get to know.]]

* LauncherOfAThousandShips: Kim Pines is, as usual, a fan favorite to ship various characters with; Scott, Ramona, Roxie, Hollie, Lucas, and to a small set of older comic fans Knives as well.