Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Napoleon2023

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Robespierre's arrest is downright nuts, with people getting knocked over and tackled as if they were in a wrestling match, all in an effort to arrest just one man. And then there's the awkward pause after he shoots himself in the jaw that wouldn't be out of place in an episode of Series/ItsAlwaysSunnyInPhiladelphia if one were to add the music and title cards from that series.

to:

** Robespierre's arrest is downright nuts, with people getting knocked over and tackled as if they were in a wrestling match, all in an effort to arrest just one man. And then there's the awkward pause after he shoots himself in the jaw that wouldn't be out of place in an episode of Series/ItsAlwaysSunnyInPhiladelphia ''Series/ItsAlwaysSunnyInPhiladelphia'' if one were to add the music and title cards from that series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FetishRetardant: The various sex scenes in the film were criticised for being awkward and cringe-worthy, even more so than Film/HouseOfGucci, which got the same criticisms for it's sex scenes. According to Ridley, they were improvised as he finds sex scenes boring and decided to make them amusing and funny as to add sensuality to them, but many noted that it didn't work and just made it even more cringy and uncomfortable.

to:

* FetishRetardant: The various sex scenes in the film were criticised for being awkward and cringe-worthy, even more so than Film/HouseOfGucci, ''Film/HouseOfGucci'', which got the same criticisms for it's sex scenes. According to Ridley, they were improvised as he finds sex scenes boring and decided to make them amusing and funny as to add sensuality to them, but many noted that it didn't work and just made it even more cringy and uncomfortable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FranchiseOriginalSin: Ridley Scott's previous forays into epic historical film, ''Film/{{Gladiator}}'', and ''[[Film/{{KingdomOfHeaven}} Kingdom of Heaven]]'' were, if anything, even ''more'' [[ArtisticLicenseHistory inaccurate]] than ''Napoleon'' has been widely criticised as being. Notably, [[{{ArtisticLicenseHistory/Gladiator}} all]] [[{{ArtisticLicenseHistory/KingdomOfHeaven}} three]] [[{{ArtisticLicenseHistory/Napoleon2023}} have]] dedicated pages for their sheer numbers of historical inaccuracies. However, those two were covering [[SmallReferencePools relatively obscure]] periods of and events in history, greatly helping to popularise and bring attention to relatively undernoted figures and acting as significantly more well-researched works than many previous [[EpicFilm epic movies]]. ''Napoleon'', on the other hand, covers an ''extremely'' well-known figure, in an era when historical knowledge is far more widespread, discovering inaccuracies far easier, and fictional accuracy far more highly prized than it was in the 2000s. The result? A '''much''' more [[BrokenBase contentious]] film than its precedessors.

to:

* FranchiseOriginalSin: Ridley Scott's previous forays into epic historical film, ''Film/{{Gladiator}}'', ''Film/{{Gladiator}}'' and ''[[Film/{{KingdomOfHeaven}} Kingdom of Heaven]]'' were, if anything, even ''more'' [[ArtisticLicenseHistory inaccurate]] than ''Napoleon'' has been widely criticised as being. Notably, [[{{ArtisticLicenseHistory/Gladiator}} all]] [[{{ArtisticLicenseHistory/KingdomOfHeaven}} three]] [[{{ArtisticLicenseHistory/Napoleon2023}} have]] dedicated pages for their sheer numbers of historical inaccuracies. However, those two were covering [[SmallReferencePools relatively obscure]] periods of and events in history, greatly helping to popularise and bring attention to relatively undernoted figures and acting as significantly more well-researched works than many previous [[EpicFilm epic movies]]. ''Napoleon'', on the other hand, covers an ''extremely'' well-known figure, in an era when historical knowledge is far more widespread, discovering inaccuracies far easier, and fictional accuracy far more highly prized than it was in the 2000s. The result? A '''much''' more [[BrokenBase contentious]] film than its precedessors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Egypt campaign is chock full of these, with Napoleon firing cannons at the pyramids before a battle (which didn’t even happen in real life), having a particular interest in a mummy and even affectionally touching it’s face (we even get a musical buildup to it), saying “No dessert. You may go.” to Junot after he tells Napoleon of Josephine cheating on him, and then him abandoning his entire campaign just to go back to France and confront her, despite his men warning that it’ll be seen as desertion.

to:

** The Egypt campaign is chock full of these, with Napoleon firing cannons at the pyramids before a battle (which didn’t even happen in real life), having a particular interest in a mummy and even affectionally touching it’s face (we even get a musical buildup to it), saying “No dessert. You may go.leave.” to Junot (akin to a parent disciplining his child) after he tells Napoleon of Josephine cheating on him, and then him abandoning his entire campaign just to go back to France and confront her, despite his men warning that it’ll be seen as desertion.

Added: 292

Changed: 248

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* {{Narm}}:
%%** Robespierre’s arrest is downright nuts, with people getting knocked over and tackled as if they were in a wrestling match, all in an effort to arrest just one man. And then there’s the awkward pause after he shoots himself in the jaw that wouldn’t be out of place in an episode of Series/ItsAlwaysSunnyInPhiladelphia if one were to add the music and title cards from that series.
%%** The aforementioned line "You think you're so great because you have BOATS!".
%%** The Egypt campaign is chock full of these, with Napoleon firing cannons at the pyramids before a battle (which didn’t even happen in real life), having a particular interest in a mummy and even affectionally touching it’s face (we even get a musical buildup to it), saying “No dessert. You may go.” to Junot after he tells Napoleon of Josephine cheating on him, and then him abandoning his entire campaign just to go back to France and confront her, despite his men warning that it’ll be seen as desertion.
%%** Napoleon’s death, where we get a still shot of him staring out at the sea……..and then he slowly keels over out of frame as if he had passed out drunk in a way that wouldn’t be out of place in a comedy skit. Even worse is that it’s the final shot of the movie before it cuts to the credits.

to:

%%* * {{Narm}}:
%%** ** Robespierre’s arrest is downright nuts, with people getting knocked over and tackled as if they were in a wrestling match, all in an effort to arrest just one man. And then there’s the awkward pause after he shoots himself in the jaw that wouldn’t be out of place in an episode of Series/ItsAlwaysSunnyInPhiladelphia if one were to add the music and title cards from that series.
%%** ** The aforementioned line "You think you're so great because you have BOATS!".
%%** ** The Egypt campaign is chock full of these, with Napoleon firing cannons at the pyramids before a battle (which didn’t even happen in real life), having a particular interest in a mummy and even affectionally touching it’s face (we even get a musical buildup to it), saying “No dessert. You may go.” to Junot after he tells Napoleon of Josephine cheating on him, and then him abandoning his entire campaign just to go back to France and confront her, despite his men warning that it’ll be seen as desertion.
%%** ** Speaking of Josephine’s affair, the scene where she returns home and finds her belongings on the lawn wouldn’t be out of place in a soap opera.
**
Napoleon’s death, where we get a still shot of him staring out at the sea……..and then he slowly keels over out of frame as if he had passed out drunk in a way that wouldn’t be out of place in a comedy skit. Even worse is that it’s the final shot of the movie before it cuts to the credits.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%** The Egypt campaign is chock full of these, with Napoleon firing cannons at the pyramids before a battle (which didn’t even happen in real life), having a particular interest in a mummy and even affectionally touching it’s face (we even get a musical buildup to it), saying “No dessert. You may go.” to Junot after he receives word of Josephine cheating on him, and then him abandoning his entire campaign just to go back to France and confront her.

to:

%%** The Egypt campaign is chock full of these, with Napoleon firing cannons at the pyramids before a battle (which didn’t even happen in real life), having a particular interest in a mummy and even affectionally touching it’s face (we even get a musical buildup to it), saying “No dessert. You may go.” to Junot after he receives word tells Napoleon of Josephine cheating on him, and then him abandoning his entire campaign just to go back to France and confront her.her, despite his men warning that it’ll be seen as desertion.

Added: 534

Changed: 44

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Apparently, Napoleon really, ''really'' [[MakesJustAsMuchSenseInContext likes mummies...]]

to:

** Apparently, Napoleon really, ''really'' [[MakesJustAsMuchSenseInContext likes mummies...]]]] And firing at the pyramids before a battle.


Added DiffLines:

%%** The aforementioned line "You think you're so great because you have BOATS!".
%%** The Egypt campaign is chock full of these, with Napoleon firing cannons at the pyramids before a battle (which didn’t even happen in real life), having a particular interest in a mummy and even affectionally touching it’s face (we even get a musical buildup to it), saying “No dessert. You may go.” to Junot after he receives word of Josephine cheating on him, and then him abandoning his entire campaign just to go back to France and confront her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

%%** Robespierre’s arrest is downright nuts, with people getting knocked over and tackled as if they were in a wrestling match, all in an effort to arrest just one man. And then there’s the awkward pause after he shoots himself in the jaw that wouldn’t be out of place in an episode of Series/ItsAlwaysSunnyInPhiladelphia if one were to add the music and title cards from that series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FetishRetardant: The various sex scenes in the film were criticised for being awkward and cringe-worthy, even more so than Film/HouseOfGucci, which got the same criticisms for it’s sex scenes.

to:

* FetishRetardant: The various sex scenes in the film were criticised for being awkward and cringe-worthy, even more so than Film/HouseOfGucci, which got the same criticisms for it’s sex scenes. According to Ridley, they were improvised as he finds sex scenes boring and decided to make them amusing and funny as to add sensuality to them, but many noted that it didn’t work and just made it even more cringy and uncomfortable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FetishRetardant: The various sex scenes in the film were criticised for being awkward and cringe-worthy, even more so than Film/HouseOfGucci, which got the same criticisms for it’s sex scenes.

Top