Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Moonlight2016

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: The movie is a deeply personal story of a gay black man who grew up in poverty, potentially driving away audiences that weren't interested in such a narrative.

Added: 2521

Changed: 1267

Removed: 362

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AndYouThoughtItWouldFail: On paper, ''Moonlight'' is about as niche and indie as you can get - a microbudget (1.5 million) coming-of-age art film about a gay black man growing up in poverty, featuring an all-black cast with no big name actors. But the sheer positive word of mouth the film generated throughout its release propelled it into mainstream success.



* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''La La Land'' fans has sprung up, especially after an envelope mix-up at the UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}}s resulted in the ''La La Land'' crew almost taking home ''Moonlight'''s Best Picture trophy.[[note]]When the time came for Creator/WarrenBeatty and Faye Dunaway to announce the Best Picture winner, a stagehand accidentally handed Beatty the second copy of the envelope containing the Best Actress recipient's name and movie. After Beatty found Creator/EmmaStone's name in the envelope, the confused speaker (Stone had already collected her Oscar, and the first copy of the Best Actress envelope, earlier that evening) passed it to Dunaway, who proceeded to read "''La La Land''" aloud into the microphone. That movie's crew had already either started or finished delivering their acceptance speeches by the time the envelope listing ''Moonlight'' as the true Best Picture victor reached the podium.[[/note]] Not helping were several news articles that were accused of an inordinate focus on ''La La Land'' losing the award with only a token mention of the movie that actually won. They were especially outraged by a Boston Globe article that said Jordan Horowitz was a hero for simply giving the award to its rightful owner rather than running off into the night with it.

to:

* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''LaLaLand''
** In the lead-up to the Oscars both films were considered the frontrunners for winning Best Picture, with many feeling the award would go to
''La La Land'' fans has Land''. Given their subject matter (Low budget indie about a young gay black man growing up in poverty vs glitzy musical about Hollywood with a predominantly white cast) a [[http://www.salon.com/2017/02/26/moonlight-vs-la-la-land-fighting-for-symbolism-or-more/ narrative]] quickly sprung up, especially after up presenting the contest as a [[WhatDoYouMeanItsNotPolitical statement]] on Hollywood's complex relationship with inclusivity and diversity.
** Tensions between fans ''skyrocketed'' when
an envelope mix-up at the UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}}s resulted in the ''La La Land'' crew almost taking home ''Moonlight'''s Best Picture trophy.[[note]]When the time came for Creator/WarrenBeatty and Faye Dunaway to announce the Best Picture winner, a stagehand accidentally handed Beatty the second copy of the envelope containing the Best Actress recipient's name and movie. After Beatty found Creator/EmmaStone's name in the envelope, the confused speaker (Stone had already collected her Oscar, and the first copy of the Best Actress envelope, earlier that evening) passed it to Dunaway, who proceeded to read "''La La Land''" aloud into the microphone. That movie's crew had already either started or finished delivering their acceptance speeches by the time the envelope listing ''Moonlight'' as the true Best Picture victor reached the podium.[[/note]] [[/note]] The accidental symbolism of the moment was not [[http://www.thefader.com/2017/02/27/moonlight-oscars-la-la-land-best-picture-winner lost]] on some viewers.
**
Not helping were several news articles that were accused of an inordinate focus on [[SpotlightStealingSquad focusing more on]] ''La La Land'' losing the award with only a token mention of the movie that how ''Moonlight'' actually won. They were especially outraged by a Boston Globe article that said Jordan Horowitz was a hero for simply giving the award to its rightful owner rather than running off into the night with it.



%%OvershadowedByControversy: Still too early to determine whether Moonlight will be remembered for itself or for the Oscar botch-up.



* TheWoobie: Chiron, especially as a child and a teenager.
* AndYouThoughtItWouldFail: On paper, ''Moonlight'' is about as niche and indie as you can get - a microbudget (1.5 million) coming-of-age art film about a gay black man growing up in poverty, featuring an all-black cast with no big name actors. But the sheer positive word of mouth the film generated throughout its release propelled it into mainstream success.

to:

* TheWoobie: Chiron, especially as a child and a teenager.
* AndYouThoughtItWouldFail: On paper, ''Moonlight'' is about as niche and indie as you can get - a microbudget (1.5 million) coming-of-age art film about a gay black man growing up in poverty, featuring an all-black cast with no big name actors. But the sheer positive word of mouth the film generated throughout its release propelled it into mainstream success.
teenager.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWoobie: Chiron, especially as a child and a teenager.

to:

* TheWoobie: Chiron, especially as a child and a teenager.teenager.
* AndYouThoughtItWouldFail: On paper, ''Moonlight'' is about as niche and indie as you can get - a microbudget (1.5 million) coming-of-age art film about a gay black man growing up in poverty, featuring an all-black cast with no big name actors. But the sheer positive word of mouth the film generated throughout its release propelled it into mainstream success.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Still too premature.


* OvershadowedByControversy: Actress Naomie Harris, and film critic Andrew Farago, have both stated that they fear ''Moonlight'' will only be mostly remembered for the "Best Picture" gaffe, where ''La La Land'' was initially announced as the winner of the Oscar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Invoking Steve Harvey's infamous Miss Universe mixup from last year, where he also announced the wrong winner.

to:

** Invoking Steve Harvey's infamous Miss Universe mixup from last year, where he also announced the wrong winner. (Even Jimmy Kimmel, that year's Oscar host, drew the comparison shortly after TheReveal.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OvershadowedByControversy: Actress Naomie Harris, and film critic Andrew Farago, have both stated that they fear ''Moonlight'' will only be mostly remembered for the "Best Picture" gaffe, where ''La La Land'' was initially announced as the winner.

to:

* OvershadowedByControversy: Actress Naomie Harris, and film critic Andrew Farago, have both stated that they fear ''Moonlight'' will only be mostly remembered for the "Best Picture" gaffe, where ''La La Land'' was initially announced as the winner.winner of the Oscar.

Changed: 191

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''La La Land'' fans has sprung up, especially after an envelope mix-up at the UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}}s resulted in the ''La La Land'' crew almost taking home ''Moonlight'''s Best Picture trophy.[[note]]When the time came for Creator/WarrenBeatty and Faye Dunaway to announce the Best Picture winner, a stagehand accidentally handed Beatty the second copy of the envelope containing the Best Actress recipient's name and movie. After Beatty found Creator/EmmaStone's name in the envelope, the confused speaker (Stone had already collected her Oscar, and the first copy of the Best Actress envelope, earlier that evening) passed it to Dunaway, who proceeded to read "''La La Land''" aloud into the microphone. That movie's crew had already either started or finished delivering their acceptance speeches by the time the envelope listing ''Moonlight'' as the true Best Picture victor reached the podium.[[/note]] Not helping were several news articles that were accused of an inordinate focus on ''La La Land'' losing the award with only a token mention of the movie that actually won.

to:

* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''La La Land'' fans has sprung up, especially after an envelope mix-up at the UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}}s resulted in the ''La La Land'' crew almost taking home ''Moonlight'''s Best Picture trophy.[[note]]When the time came for Creator/WarrenBeatty and Faye Dunaway to announce the Best Picture winner, a stagehand accidentally handed Beatty the second copy of the envelope containing the Best Actress recipient's name and movie. After Beatty found Creator/EmmaStone's name in the envelope, the confused speaker (Stone had already collected her Oscar, and the first copy of the Best Actress envelope, earlier that evening) passed it to Dunaway, who proceeded to read "''La La Land''" aloud into the microphone. That movie's crew had already either started or finished delivering their acceptance speeches by the time the envelope listing ''Moonlight'' as the true Best Picture victor reached the podium.[[/note]] Not helping were several news articles that were accused of an inordinate focus on ''La La Land'' losing the award with only a token mention of the movie that actually won. They were especially outraged by a Boston Globe article that said Jordan Horowitz was a hero for simply giving the award to its rightful owner rather than running off into the night with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OvershadowedByControversy: Actress Naomie Harris, and film critic Andrew Farago, have both stated that they fear ''Moonlight'' will only be mostly remembered for the "Best Picture" gaffe, where ''La La Land'' was initially announced as the winner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TearJerker: SO MUCH

to:

* TearJerker: SO MUCHMUCH.

Changed: 173

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''La La Land'' fans has sprung up, especially after an envelope mix-up at the UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}}s resulted in the ''La La Land'' crew almost taking home ''Moonlight'''s Best Picture trophy.[[note]]When the time came for Creator/WarrenBeatty and Faye Dunaway to announce the Best Picture winner, a stagehand accidentally handed Beatty the second copy of the envelope containing the Best Actress recipient's name and movie. After Beatty found Creator/EmmaStone's name in the envelope, the confused speaker (Stone had already collected her Oscar, and the first copy of the Best Actress envelope, earlier that evening) passed it to Dunaway, who proceeded to read "''La La Land''" aloud into the microphone. That movie's crew had already either started or finished delivering their acceptance speeches by the time the envelope listing ''Moonlight'' as the true Best Picture victor reached the podium.[[/note]]

to:

* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''La La Land'' fans has sprung up, especially after an envelope mix-up at the UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}}s resulted in the ''La La Land'' crew almost taking home ''Moonlight'''s Best Picture trophy.[[note]]When the time came for Creator/WarrenBeatty and Faye Dunaway to announce the Best Picture winner, a stagehand accidentally handed Beatty the second copy of the envelope containing the Best Actress recipient's name and movie. After Beatty found Creator/EmmaStone's name in the envelope, the confused speaker (Stone had already collected her Oscar, and the first copy of the Best Actress envelope, earlier that evening) passed it to Dunaway, who proceeded to read "''La La Land''" aloud into the microphone. That movie's crew had already either started or finished delivering their acceptance speeches by the time the envelope listing ''Moonlight'' as the true Best Picture victor reached the podium.[[/note]][[/note]] Not helping were several news articles that were accused of an inordinate focus on ''La La Land'' losing the award with only a token mention of the movie that actually won.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''La La Land'' fans has sprung up, especially after an envelope mix-up at the UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}}s resulted in the ''La La Land'' crew almost taking home ''Moonlight'''s Best Picture trophy.[[note]]When the time came for Creator/WarrenBeatty and Faye Dunaway to announce the Best Picture winner, a stagehand accidentally handed Beatty the envelope containing the Best Actress recipient's name and movie. After Beatty found Creator/EmmaStone's name in the envelope, the confused speaker passed it to Dunaway, who proceeded to read "''La La Land''" aloud into the microphone. That movie's crew had already either started or finished delivering their acceptance speeches by the time the envelope listing ''Moonlight'' as the true Best Picture victor reached the podium.[[/note]]

to:

* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''La La Land'' fans has sprung up, especially after an envelope mix-up at the UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}}s resulted in the ''La La Land'' crew almost taking home ''Moonlight'''s Best Picture trophy.[[note]]When the time came for Creator/WarrenBeatty and Faye Dunaway to announce the Best Picture winner, a stagehand accidentally handed Beatty the second copy of the envelope containing the Best Actress recipient's name and movie. After Beatty found Creator/EmmaStone's name in the envelope, the confused speaker (Stone had already collected her Oscar, and the first copy of the Best Actress envelope, earlier that evening) passed it to Dunaway, who proceeded to read "''La La Land''" aloud into the microphone. That movie's crew had already either started or finished delivering their acceptance speeches by the time the envelope listing ''Moonlight'' as the true Best Picture victor reached the podium.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''La La Land'' fans has sprung up, especially after an envelope mix-up at the UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}}s resulted in the ''La La Land'' crew almost taking home ''Moonlight'''s Best Picture trophy.[[note]]When the time came for Creator/WarrenBeatty and Faye Dunaway to announce the Best Picture winner, a stagehand accidentally handed Beatty the envelope containing the Best Actress recipient's name and movie. After Beatty found Creator/EmmaStone's name in the envelope, the confused speaker passed it to Dunaway, who proceeded to read "''La La Land''" aloud into the microphone. That movie's crew had already either started or finished delivering their acceptance speeches by the time the envelope listing ''Moonlight'' as the true victor reached the podium.[[/note]]

to:

* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''La La Land'' fans has sprung up, especially after an envelope mix-up at the UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}}s resulted in the ''La La Land'' crew almost taking home ''Moonlight'''s Best Picture trophy.[[note]]When the time came for Creator/WarrenBeatty and Faye Dunaway to announce the Best Picture winner, a stagehand accidentally handed Beatty the envelope containing the Best Actress recipient's name and movie. After Beatty found Creator/EmmaStone's name in the envelope, the confused speaker passed it to Dunaway, who proceeded to read "''La La Land''" aloud into the microphone. That movie's crew had already either started or finished delivering their acceptance speeches by the time the envelope listing ''Moonlight'' as the true Best Picture victor reached the podium.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not everyone has seen this ceremony - Apparently it received the second-lowest ratings ever recorded for the Oscars.


* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''La La Land'' fans has sprung up, especially in light of the Best Picture announcement goof.

to:

* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''La La Land'' fans has sprung up, especially after an envelope mix-up at the UsefulNotes/{{Academy Award}}s resulted in light of the ''La La Land'' crew almost taking home ''Moonlight'''s Best Picture trophy.[[note]]When the time came for Creator/WarrenBeatty and Faye Dunaway to announce the Best Picture announcement goof.winner, a stagehand accidentally handed Beatty the envelope containing the Best Actress recipient's name and movie. After Beatty found Creator/EmmaStone's name in the envelope, the confused speaker passed it to Dunaway, who proceeded to read "''La La Land''" aloud into the microphone. That movie's crew had already either started or finished delivering their acceptance speeches by the time the envelope listing ''Moonlight'' as the true victor reached the podium.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MemeticMutation: The Internet had an absolute ''field day'' with the botched Best Picture presentation for ''Moonlight''. Highlights include:
** [[http://www.vox.com/culture/2017/2/27/14748584/moonlight-oscar-envelope-meme This image]] of ''La La Land'' producer Fred Berger holding up the announcement envelope to prove that yes, ''Moonlight'' really did win, with different movies and artists filled in.
** Invoking Steve Harvey's infamous Miss Universe mixup from last year, where he also announced the wrong winner.
** [[https://www.buzzfeed.com/lyapalater/this-is-what-everyones-faces-looked-like-when-the?utm_term=.xy4lDEQaY#.meYDyJ6lm Various reaction shots]] of the audience realizing what happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWoobie: Chiron, especially as a child and a teenager.
* AndYouThoughtItWouldFail: On paper, ''Moonlight'' is about as niche and indie as you can get - a microbudget (1.5 million) coming-of-age art film about a gay black man growing up in poverty, featuring an all-black cast with no big name actors. But the sheer positive word of mouth the film generated throughout its release propelled it into mainstream success.

to:

* TheWoobie: Chiron, especially as a child and a teenager.
* AndYouThoughtItWouldFail: On paper, ''Moonlight'' is about as niche and indie as you can get - a microbudget (1.5 million) coming-of-age art film about a gay black man growing up in poverty, featuring an all-black cast with no big name actors. But the sheer positive word of mouth the film generated throughout its release propelled it into mainstream success.
teenager.

Added: 666

Removed: 363

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Figured out a way to make that sorta fit.


* AndYouThoughtItWouldFail: On paper, ''Moonlight'' is about as niche and indie as you can get - a microbudget (1.5 million) coming-of-age art film about a gay black man growing up in poverty, featuring an all-black cast with no big name actors. But the sheer positive word of mouth the film generated throughout its release propelled it into mainstream success.



* LGBTFanbase: Unsurprising considering the movie is in some ways ComingOutStory, but ''Moonlight'''s success was viewed by many Black and LGBTQ people as an enormously validating moment, showing that stories about those communities could break into the mainstream and win the film world's highest honor.



* TheWoobie: Chiron, especially as a child and a teenager.

to:

* TheWoobie: Chiron, especially as a child and a teenager.teenager.
* AndYouThoughtItWouldFail: On paper, ''Moonlight'' is about as niche and indie as you can get - a microbudget (1.5 million) coming-of-age art film about a gay black man growing up in poverty, featuring an all-black cast with no big name actors. But the sheer positive word of mouth the film generated throughout its release propelled it into mainstream success.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Taking this to discussion...


* OvershadowedByControversy: [[http://www.cnn.com/2017/02/27/opinions/oscars-error-blocked-out-the-moonlight-seymour-opinion/ Some commentators]] worry that ''Moonlight'' will go down in Oscar and film history for its epically botched award pronouncement, rather than its historic achievements in black and LGBTQ cinema.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AndYouThoughtItWouldFail: On paper, ''Moonlight'' is about as niche and indie as you can get - a microbudget (1.5 million) coming-of-age art film about a gay black man growing up in poverty, featuring an all-black cast with no big name actors. But the sheer positive word of mouth the film generated throughout its release propelled it into mainstream success.


Added DiffLines:

* FandomRivalry: A big one between ''Moonlight'' and ''La La Land'' fans has sprung up, especially in light of the Best Picture announcement goof.
* OvershadowedByControversy: [[http://www.cnn.com/2017/02/27/opinions/oscars-error-blocked-out-the-moonlight-seymour-opinion/ Some commentators]] worry that ''Moonlight'' will go down in Oscar and film history for its epically botched award pronouncement, rather than its historic achievements in black and LGBTQ cinema.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It is not right for many, many reasons.


* On a meta level the film's Best Picture win was view by many Black and LGBTQ people as an enormously validating moment, showing that stories about those communities could break into the mainstream and win the film world's highest honor
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Delete it if it's not right, but I figured it's worth noting

Added DiffLines:

* On a meta level the film's Best Picture win was view by many Black and LGBTQ people as an enormously validating moment, showing that stories about those communities could break into the mainstream and win the film world's highest honor
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
As much as I love this, it is a misuse and we don't provide awesome moments for real life events or meta-moments.


* AwesomeMoments: The film's especially dramatic Best Picture win at the Oscars, where Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway were accidentally handed Emma Stone's winning envelope for Best Actress, leading them to announce ''La La Land'' as the winner. One of the producers was literally thanking his "blue-eyed wife" when they got the word they actually hadn't won.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnsembleDarkhorse: Juan. An incredibly charming and warm performance from Creator/MahershalaAli combined with [[spoiler: an offscreen death one third into the movie]] have made him the movie's most memorable character for many moviegoers.

to:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Juan. An incredibly charming and warm performance from Creator/MahershalaAli combined with [[spoiler: an offscreen death one third into the movie]] have made him the movie's most memorable character for many moviegoers. This resulted in Ali winning the Oscar for Best Supporting Actor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AwesomeMoments: The film's especially dramatic Best Picture win at the Oscars, where Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway were accidentally handed Emma Stone's winning envelope for Best Actress, leading them to announce ''La La Land'' as the winner. One of the producers was literally thanking his "blue-eyed wife" when they got the word they actually hadn't won.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnsembleDarkhorse: Juan. An incredibly charming and warm performance from Creator/MahershahaAli combined with [[spoiler: an offscreen death one third into the movie]] have made him the movie's most memorable character for many moviegoers.

to:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Juan. An incredibly charming and warm performance from Creator/MahershahaAli Creator/MahershalaAli combined with [[spoiler: an offscreen death one third into the movie]] have made him the movie's most memorable character for many moviegoers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: Juan. An incredibly charming and warm performance from Creator/MahershahaAli combined with [[spoiler: an offscreen death one third into the movie]] have made him the movie's most memorable character for many moviegoers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HateSink: In a movie full of complex characters who operate on WhiteAndGrayMorality, Terrel is probably the only outright evil or sadistic one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CatharsisFactor: After all the shit Terrel puts Chiron through, [[spoiler: Chiron finally cracking a chair over him is a sight to behold. There are reports of audience members cheering at the scene]].
* HateSink: In a movie full of complex characters who operate on WhiteAndGrayMorality, Terrel is probably the only outright evil or sadistic one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: Paula's last dialogue with Chiron in the film
-->'''Paula:''' You ain't got to love me, but you gonna know that I love you.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Paula's last dialogue with Chiron in the film
-->'''Paula:'''
film]]
-->[[spoiler: '''Paula:'''
You ain't got to love me, but you gonna know that I love you.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TearJerker: SO MUCH
** [[spoiler: Paula's last dialogue with Chiron in the film
-->'''Paula:''' You ain't got to love me, but you gonna know that I love you.]]
** [[spoiler: The final shot of Kevin hugging Chiron, after Chiron admits he still loves him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheWoobie: Chiron, especially as a child and a teenager.

Top