Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / MegLangslowMysteries

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed one trope.


* ItsTheSameSoItSucks: The formulaic use of Meg (or, on rare occasions, someone else she has to save) somehow ending up AloneWithThePsycho right when the case is solved and only surviving due to her ActionGirl skills or the intervention of another character can get boring after a while. The only proper SummationGathering so far is in the first book, and even then, Meg gets taken hostage as the killer tries to escape, while there has yet to be a SympatheticMurderer sympathetic enough to instantly give up rather than at least consider killing again to stay out of prison.

to:

* ItsTheSameSoItSucks: ItsTheSameNowItSucks: The formulaic use of Meg (or, on rare occasions, someone else she has to save) somehow ending up AloneWithThePsycho right when the case is solved and only surviving due to her ActionGirl skills or the intervention of another character can get boring after a while. The only proper SummationGathering so far is in the first book, and even then, Meg gets taken hostage as the killer tries to escape, while there has yet to be a SympatheticMurderer sympathetic enough to instantly give up rather than at least consider killing again to stay out of prison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not YMMV, Move it to the Main page


* AuthorTract: Several books have a journalist character who is obnoxious, self-centered, and only interested in telling negative stories, scorning anything positive or uplifting as not real journalism. It's so consistent that it makes the reader wonder just what a journalist did to the author to earn such hatred.
* HarsherInHindsight: ''Terns of Endearment'' was published in mid-2019, and involves several members of Meg's family on a truly disastrous cruise ship voyage - it turns out the major cause of this is an outbreak of horrific food poisoning among the crew (because the management were such penny-pinchers that it forced the crew to eat food past its expiry date that they couldn't serve passengers); the description of the small, cramped crew quarters stuffed to the gill with sick people borders on NightmareFuel. Less than a year later, the COVID-19 pandemic has lead to several cruise ships being revealed as either having the virus on board, careless passengers let off the ship without testing causing new outbreak clusters, or even cruise ship passengers being forced to stay on ships with resources getting low because countries won't allow them to dock due to the virus.

to:

* AuthorTract: Several books have a journalist character who is obnoxious, self-centered, and only interested in telling negative stories, scorning anything positive or uplifting as not real journalism. It's so consistent that it makes the reader wonder just what a journalist did to the author to earn such hatred.
* HarsherInHindsight:
HarsherInHindsight:
**
''Terns of Endearment'' was published in mid-2019, and involves several members of Meg's family on a truly disastrous cruise ship voyage - it turns out the major cause of this is an outbreak of horrific food poisoning among the crew (because the management were such penny-pinchers that it forced the crew to eat food past its expiry date that they couldn't serve passengers); the description of the small, cramped crew quarters stuffed to the gill with sick people borders on NightmareFuel. Less than a year later, the COVID-19 pandemic has lead to several cruise ships being revealed as either having the virus on board, careless passengers let off the ship without testing causing new outbreak clusters, or even cruise ship passengers being forced to stay on ships with resources getting low because countries won't allow them to dock due to the virus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Let It Crow'' introduces Alec, a blacksmith whom Meg's mentor Faulk introduced her to and wanted her to teach. This could have set up an interesting MasterApprenticeChain (especially since Meg rarely, if ever, gets to be a mentor figure in the series to anyone but youths) and given Meg some unique moments watching her protégé struggle at his trade and be a murder suspect ([[spoiler:whether or not he was guilty, like he is in that book]]), but it's quickly revealed that Alec failed to learn from Meg and only made some progress as a blacksmith with Faulk as his mentor.
* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Meg’s parents are treated as lovable, charming comic relief characters, and they do provide a lot of laughs. However, watching Mrs. Langslow be passively snobby and Mr. Langslow constantly volunteering Meg’s house for difficult visitors and projects (and his sense of excitement about murders that he gets to investigate) can make them feel tiring at times.

to:

** ''Let It Crow'' introduces Alec, a blacksmith whom Meg's mentor Faulk introduced her to and wanted her to teach. This could have set up an interesting MasterApprenticeChain (especially since Meg rarely, if ever, gets to be a mentor figure in the series to anyone but youths) and given Meg some unique moments watching her protégé struggle at his trade and be a murder suspect ([[spoiler:whether or not he was guilty, guilty like he is in that the finished book]]), but it's quickly revealed that Alec failed to learn from Meg and only made some progress as a blacksmith with Faulk as his mentor.
* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Meg’s Meg's parents are treated as lovable, charming comic relief characters, and they do provide a lot of laughs. However, watching Mrs. Langslow be passively snobby and Mr. Langslow constantly volunteering Meg’s Meg's house for difficult visitors and projects (and his sense of excitement about murders that he gets to investigate) can make them feel tiring at times.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AuthorTract: Several books have a journalist character who is obnoxious, self-centered, and only interested in telling negative stories, scorning anything positive or uplifting as not real journalism. It's so consistent that it makes the reader wonder just what a journalist did to the author to earn such hatred.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ItsTheSameSoItSucks: The formulaic use of Meg (or, on rare occasions, someone else she has to save) somehow ending up AloneWithThePsycho right when the case is solved and only surviving due to her ActionGirl skills or the intervention of another character can get boring after a while. The only proper SummationGathering so far is in the first book, and even then, Meg gets taken hostage as the killer tries to escape, while there has yet to be a SympatheticMurderer sympathetic enough to instantly give up rather than at least consider killing again to stay out of prison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** For that matter, making Pratherton's story the backdrop of a Prohibition-era mystery where Meg was RevisitingTheColdCase could have been a more unique and exciting entry in the series than the decent but by-the-numbers ''Lord of the Wings''.


Added DiffLines:

** ''Let It Crow'' introduces Alec, a blacksmith whom Meg's mentor Faulk introduced her to and wanted her to teach. This could have set up an interesting MasterApprenticeChain (especially since Meg rarely, if ever, gets to be a mentor figure in the series to anyone but youths) and given Meg some unique moments watching her protégé struggle at his trade and be a murder suspect ([[spoiler:whether or not he was guilty, like he is in that book]]), but it's quickly revealed that Alec failed to learn from Meg and only made some progress as a blacksmith with Faulk as his mentor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The previous book has Meg at an owl-themed scientific conference which goes OffTheRails and she muses if there will be an Owl Fest 2020...

to:

** The previous book has Meg at an owl-themed scientific conference which goes OffTheRails and she muses if there will be an Owl Fest 2020...2020 while being unaware of the quarantine lockdowns that will fill up the year...



** ''Lord of the Wings'' never does explain how and why [[spoiler:William Henry Harrison Brimfield, a wealthy heir and idealistic early WWI volunteer, became Billy Pratherton, the most ruthless bootlegger in Caerphilly County, or how or why he and/or his family faked his death in the war and kept the rest of the small town from recognizing him after his return as Pratherton.]]

to:

** ''Lord of the Wings'' never does explain how and why [[spoiler:William William Henry Harrison Brimfield, a wealthy heir and idealistic early WWI volunteer, became Billy Pratherton, the most ruthless bootlegger in Caerphilly County, or how or why he and/or his family faked his death in the war and kept the rest of the small town from recognizing him after his return as Pratherton.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''Lord of the Wings'' never does explain how and why [[spoiler:William Henry Harrison Brimfield, a wealthy heir and idealistic early WWI volunteer, became Billy Pratherton, the most ruthless bootlegger in Caerphilly County, or how or why he and/or his family faked his death in the war and kept the rest of the small town from recognizing him after his return as Pratherton.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The search for a long-missing slave graveyard in ''Birder She Wrote'' is prominently mentioned in the marketing for the book and feels like it could have made a good central story or subplot throughout the book. Instead, the searchers find the graveyard in chapter 5, the scene mainly just serves to set up the discovery of the dead VictimOfTheWeek, and the cemetery is barely mentioned for the rest of the book.

Added: 1220

Changed: 31

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot:
** Dr. Blake's first appearance mentions he had a legitimate son and grandson who died before he learned of Mr. Langslow's existence and became a part of Meg's family. This could have been an interesting recurring aspect of his character, but neither he, Meg, her dad, nor anyone else in the family ever seems to reflect on those dead relatives.
** Taking a close look at the Pruitts' adjustment to their fall from grace after Randall becomes mayor (ending their century-long period of being able to claim that IOwnThisTown) could have been an interesting storyline. Unfortunately, it's barely brought up except in the book right after the one where they lose power, with the Pruitts being a mostly offscreen but apparently sullen interchangeable mass besides one suspect working a FallenOnHardTimesJob and a BitCharacter who is said to be a WhiteSheep of the family but has little about his position in the community or views on the clan's downfall revealed. Subsequent books are inconsistent about whether the Pruitts remain in Caerphilly and don't mention whether the next generation of Pruitts, such as kids in the same softball league as Meg’s son, is shaping up to be like the old ones or is learning from the past.

Added: 391

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler:Francine]] in ''[[spoiler:The Real Macaw]]'' is [[spoiler:ostracized by most of the town due to being a newcomer from up north and being the wife of a man working for the local {{Corrupt Politician}}s. She tries to be a good mother to her stepson and make friends, but, implicitly due to loneliness, cheats on her husband and then finds out that her lover is just using her to steal city files and may expose the affair, causing her to snap and kill him.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:Francine]] in ''[[spoiler:The Real Macaw]]'' is [[spoiler:ostracized by most of the town due to being a shy newcomer from up north and being the wife of a man working for the local {{Corrupt Politician}}s. She tries to be a good mother to her stepson and make friends, but, implicitly due to loneliness, cheats on her husband and then finds out that her lover is just using her to steal city files and may expose the affair, causing her to snap and kill him.]]]]
** In ''[[spoiler:Die Like an Eagle]]'', the killer is a [[spoiler:StrugglingSingleMother whose son was an avid little league player before he got pitcher's shoulder due to the corrupt and overcompetitive coach overplaying him, with the coach and his cronies refusing to pay medical bills or make other restitution and lying that the boy wasn't being forced to pitch more than was healthy]].

Added: 457

Changed: -8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Meg’s parents are treated as lovable, charming comic relief characters, and they do provide a lot of laughs. However, watching Mrs. Langslow be passively snobby and Mr. Langslow constantly volunteering Meg’s house for difficult visitors and projects (and his sense of excitement about murders that he gets to investigate) can make them feel tiring at times.

to:

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Meg’s parents are treated as lovable, charming comic relief characters, and they do provide a lot of laughs. However, watching Mrs. Langslow be passively snobby and Mr. Langslow constantly volunteering Meg’s house for difficult visitors and projects (and his sense of excitement about murders that he gets to investigate) can make them feel tiring at times.times.
* TheWoobie: Grad student Ramon Desoto does not have it easy in ''Stork Raving Mad''. His dissertation and studies are sabotaged by a vindictive professor in highly stressful ways, he learns that his beloved girlfriend has a bad case of ItsAllAboutMe, and at the end of the book, he faces reckless endangerment charges that may destroy his academic future due to ATragedyOfImpulsiveness that led him to drug his antagonist to try to make her miss a meeting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The previous book has Meg at an owl-themed scientific conference which goes OffTheRails and she muses if there will be an Owl Fest 2020...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JerkassWoobie: Some killers can be surprisingly pitiable after their motives come out, although they generally cross the MoralEventHorizon by trying to kill Meg.
** [[spoiler:Ichabod Dilley]] in ''[[spoiler:We'll Always have Parrots]]'' spends thirty years [[spoiler:in hiding, working jobs he hates, while being too afraid to take up the artwork he loves because he thinks {{Loan Shark}}s are after him. Then he finds out that the loan sharks got paid off years ago, but his ex-girlfriend never told him, and that she abandoned the original themes of his masterpiece when she turned it into a TV show, for which she didn't even give him official credit, causing him to kill her.]]
** [[spoiler:Francine]] in ''[[spoiler:The Real Macaw]]'' is [[spoiler:ostracized by most of the town due to being a newcomer from up north and being the wife of a man working for the local {{Corrupt Politician}}s. She tries to be a good mother to her stepson and make friends, but, implicitly due to loneliness, cheats on her husband and then finds out that her lover is just using her to steal city files and may expose the affair, causing her to snap and kill him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: ''Terns of Endearment'' was published in mid-2019, and involves several members of Meg's family on a truly disastrous cruise ship voyage - it turns out the major cause of this is an outbreak of horrific food poisoning among the crew (because the management were such penny-pinchers that it forced the crew to eat food past its expiry date that they couldn't serve passengers); the description of the small, cramped crew quarters stuffed to the gill with sick people borders on NightmareFuel. Less than a year later, the COVID-19 pandemic has lead to several cruise ships being revealed as either having the virus on board, careless passengers let off the ship without testing causing new outbreak clusters, or even cruise ship passengers being forced to stay on ships with resources getting low because countries won't allow them to dock due to the virus.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: ''Terns of Endearment'' was published in mid-2019, and involves several members of Meg's family on a truly disastrous cruise ship voyage - it turns out the major cause of this is an outbreak of horrific food poisoning among the crew (because the management were such penny-pinchers that it forced the crew to eat food past its expiry date that they couldn't serve passengers); the description of the small, cramped crew quarters stuffed to the gill with sick people borders on NightmareFuel. Less than a year later, the COVID-19 pandemic has lead to several cruise ships being revealed as either having the virus on board, careless passengers let off the ship without testing causing new outbreak clusters, or even cruise ship passengers being forced to stay on ships with resources getting low because countries won't allow them to dock due to the virus.virus.
* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Meg’s parents are treated as lovable, charming comic relief characters, and they do provide a lot of laughs. However, watching Mrs. Langslow be passively snobby and Mr. Langslow constantly volunteering Meg’s house for difficult visitors and projects (and his sense of excitement about murders that he gets to investigate) can make them feel tiring at times.

Removed: 160

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: ''Terns of Endearment'' was published in mid-2019, and involves several members of Meg's family on a truly disastrous cruise ship voyage - it turns out the major cause of this is an outbreak of horrific food poisoning among the crew (because the management were such penny-pinchers that it forced the crew to eat food past its expiry date that they couldn't serve passengers); the description of the small, cramped crew quarters stuffed to the gill with sick people borders on NightmareFuel. Less than a year later, the COVID-19 pandemic has lead to several cruise ships being revealed as either having the virus on board, careless passengers let off the ship without testing causing new outbreak clusters, or even cruise ship passengers being forced to stay on ships with resources getting low because countries won't allow them to dock due to the virus.
* MST3KMantra: Some of the more outrageous scenarios in these books really tax WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief, but it's a lot more fun if you just roll with them.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: ''Terns of Endearment'' was published in mid-2019, and involves several members of Meg's family on a truly disastrous cruise ship voyage - it turns out the major cause of this is an outbreak of horrific food poisoning among the crew (because the management were such penny-pinchers that it forced the crew to eat food past its expiry date that they couldn't serve passengers); the description of the small, cramped crew quarters stuffed to the gill with sick people borders on NightmareFuel. Less than a year later, the COVID-19 pandemic has lead to several cruise ships being revealed as either having the virus on board, careless passengers let off the ship without testing causing new outbreak clusters, or even cruise ship passengers being forced to stay on ships with resources getting low because countries won't allow them to dock due to the virus.
* MST3KMantra: Some of the more outrageous scenarios in these books really tax WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief, but it's a lot more fun if you just roll with them.
virus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HarsherInHindsight: ''Terns of Endearment'' was published in mid-2019, and involves several members of Meg's family on a truly disastrous cruise ship voyage - it turns out the major cause of this is an outbreak of horrific food poisoning among the crew (because the management were such penny-pinchers that it forced the crew to eat food past its expiry date that they couldn't serve passengers); the description of the small, cramped crew quarters stuffed to the gill with sick people borders on NightmareFuel. Less than a year later, the COVID-19 pandemic has lead to several cruise ships being revealed as either having the virus on board, careless passengers let off the ship without testing causing new outbreak clusters, or even cruise ship passengers being forced to stay on ships with resources getting low because countries won't allow them to dock due to the virus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*MST3KMantra: Some of the more outrageous scenarios in these books really tax WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief, but it's a lot more fun if you just roll with them.

Top