History YMMV / MakingFiends

* CultClassic: The Nick version had under ten episodes, but it remains one of their most popular shows from the mid-to-late 2000s. This is made even more surprising by how it never even aired on their main channel.

** Vendetta's side of it isn't exactly nonexistent, either. While Vendetta does hate Charlotte, it seems to border on obsession, as Vendetta is a little bit ''too'' invested in Charlotte's life on occasion. During a parent-teacher conference in "Parents", Vendetta's parents off-handedly mention that Vendetta talks about her constantly, which means she's thinking about Charlotte even when she has no real reason to. Quite a few fans interpret this as [[{{Tsundere}} Vendetta secretly having feelings for Charlotte but refusing to admit for fear of looking weak to the townsfolk.]]

** Vendetta's side of it isn't exactly nonexistent, either. Vendetta does hate Charlotte, but it also seems to border on obsession, and Vendetta is a little bit ''too'' invested in Charlotte's life on occasion. During a parent teacher conference, Vendetta's parents offhandedly mention that Vendetta talks about her constantly, which means she’s thinking about Charlotte even when she has no real reason to. Quite a few fans interpret this as [[{{Tsundere}} Vendetta secretly having feelings for Charlotte but refusing to admit for fear of looking weak to the townsfolk.]]

** Charlotte is rather... interested in Vendetta sometimes, and more than she usually is with other people. She insists that her and Vendetta are going to be the "best of friends", and is probably the only person who tries to be nice to Vendetta (mostly because everyone else fears her). It wouldn't be too out there to see Charlotte as a LoveMartyr whose interested in Vendetta despite the latter's terrible personality. In "Mama Vendetta", Charlotte even mentions being the "dad" of Vendetta's fiends, so make of that what you will.

** Fans are torn on how oblivious Charlotte really is. Is she a StepfordSmiler? Does she realize Vendetta hates her but doesn't care? Is she desperately trying to befriend Vendetta because she has no friends, or in the hope of changing her? Does she ignore Vendetta's open hatred for her, because she has an attraction to her she doesn't quite understand yet? Is she really just that dumb and innocent? Or, D), All of the above. One episode (''Middle Manager Marvin'') implies that she might have some awareness that Vendetta wants to kill her and even went along with it but ain't readily clear.

* MoralEventHorizon: As if terrorizing an entire town with a non-stop flow of fiends and most likely causing a few deaths wasn't enough for Vendetta, she also plans all the time the murder of the only child who'd come within five feet of her in every single episode.

** Fans are torn on how oblivious Charlotte really is. Is she a StepfordSmiler? Does she realize Vendetta hates her but doesn't care? Is she desperately trying to befriend Vendetta because she has no friends, or in the hope of changing her? Does she ignore Vendetta's open hatred for her, because she has an attraction to her she doesn't quite understand yet? Is she really just that dumb and innocent?

* TastesLikeDiabetes: Any scene with Charlotte, especially when she sings.

* UncannyValley: Considering this show's characters never usually show teeth, Vendetta's toothy [[TheUnsmile un-smile]] in "Super Evil" is rather jarring and off-putting.

* FoeYay: In one episode, we find Vendetta [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything hiding in a closet, traumatized over Charlotte]].

* {{Adorkable}}: Charlotte. She's cheerful, naive, and endearing.

** There is also a subset that think Charlotte ''really is'' "super evil", as Vendetta was lead to believe in the episode of the same name and the naive and dimwitted NiceGirl she presents herself as, is really just a cover she uses while she covertly torments people. Usually Vendetta.

** Charlotte is rather... interested in Vendetta sometimes, and more than she usually is with other people. She insists that her and Vendetta are going to be the "best of friends", and is probably the only person who tries to be nice to Vendetta (mostly because everyone else fears her). It wouldn't be too out there to see Charlotte as a LoveMartyr whose interested in Vendetta despite the latter's terrible personality. At one point, Charlotte even mentions being the "dad" of Vendetta's fiends, so make of that what you will.

%%* SugarWiki/MostWonderfulSound: [[PickACard Pick a song. Any song.]] It'll either [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments be hilarious]] or will [[SugarWiki/SweetDreamsFuel make your heart melt with cuteness]].

* AngstWhatAngst: Charlotte has repeatedly and narrowly avoided death at the hands of Vendetta, [[spoiler: barring one incident which happened several hundred times in the same episode,]] and yet she ''still'' has no hard feelings towards her? In the words of Maggie, "Charlotte's dumb."

** Vendetta's side of it isn't exactly nonexistent, either. Vendetta does hate Charlotte, but it also seem to border on obsession, and Vendetta is a little bit ''too'' invested in Charlotte's life on occasion. During a parent teacher conference, Vendetta's parents offhandedly mention that Vendetta talks about her constantly, which means she’s thinking about Charlotte even when she has no real reason to. Quite a few fans interpret this as [[{{Tsundere}} Vendetta secretly having feelings for Charlotte but refusing to admit for fear of looking weak to the townsfolk.]]

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Fans are torn on how oblivious Charlotte really is. Is she a StepfordSmiler? Does she realize Vendetta hates her but doesn't care? Is she desperately trying to befriend Vendetta because she has no friends, or in the hope of changing her? Does she ignore Vendetta's open hatred for her, because she has an attraction to her she doesn't quite understand yet? Is she really just that dumb and innocent?
** Skim through the comments section on any given episode uploaded to [=YouTube=] and you're garunteed to find at least one comment claiming Charlotte's actually a {{Troll}} playing dumb to mess with Vendetta, either as a form punishment for her cruel rule of the town, to drive her out/insane for the sake of the town, or just ForTheLulz.

** They're is, of course, also the fans who think Charlotte's a {{Yandere}} for Vendetta. Considering Charlotte regularly breaks into Vendetta's house despite her doing '''everything''' in her power to make it clear she doesn't want Charlotte near her, it's not hard to see where they're coming from.
*** In a similar vein there is portraying Charlotte as something of a LoveMartyr. The fact that even after all the numerous attempts on her life Charlotte never ceases to try befriending Vendetta does not help.

* LesYay: Charlotte is rather... interested in Vendetta sometimes, and more than she usually is with other people.
** Charlotte insists that her and Vendetta are going to be the “best of friends”, and is probably the only person who tries to be nice to Vendetta (mostly because everyone else fears her). It wouldn’t be too out there to see Charlotte as a LoveMartyr whose interested in Vendetta despite the latter’s terrible personality. At one point, Charlotte even mentions being the “dad” of Vendetta’s fiends, so make of that what you will.
** Vendetta’s side of it isn’t exactly nonexistent, either. Vendetta does hate Charlotte, but it also seem to border on obsession and Vendetta is a little bit too invested in Charlotte’s life on occasion. During a parent teacher conference, Vendetta’s parents offhandedly mention that Vendetta talks about her a LOT, which means she’s thinking about Charlotte even when she has no real reason to. Quite a few fans interpret this as [[{{Tsundere}} Vendetta secretly having feelings for Charlotte but refusing to admit for fear of looking weak to the townsfolk.]]

* SugarWiki/MostWonderfulSound: [[PickACard Pick a song. Any song.]] It'll either [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments be hilarious]] or will [[SugarWiki/SweetDreamsFuel make your heart melt with cuteness]].
* NoYay: Grudge and Rubella with Vendetta.

** Charlotte insists that her and Vendetta are going to be the “best of friends”, and is probably the only person who tries to be nice to Vendetta (mostly because everyone else fears her). It wouldn’t be too out there to see Charlotte as a LoveMartyr whose interested in Vendetta despite the latter’s personality.
** Vendetta’s side of it isn’t exactly nonexistent, either. Vendetta does hate Charlotte, but it also seem to border on obsession and Vendetta is a little bit too invested in Charlotte’s life on occasion. During a parent teacher conference, Vendetta’s parents offhandedly mention that Vendetta talks about her a LOT, which means she’s thinking about Charlotte even when she has no real reason to.

* UncannyValley: Considering this show's characters never usually show teeth, Vendetta's toothy UnSmile in "Super Evil" is rather jarring and off-putting.