Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / LawAndOrderS9E8Punk

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Simonelli may feel like even more of a victim and less of someone with a NeverMyFault attitude to anyone who believes that she really was an oblivious bystander at the drug buy who never had a name to give up for immunity in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: While Alice Simonelli ''absolutely'' did not deserve to be a sex slave to a prison guard, the circumstances behind her imprisonment are the results of her own poor choices. She refused to roll on the drug dealer she was pulled over with, even though Carmichael offered her a deal with no prison time. When the two meet again for the murder trial, Simonelli blames all her woes on Abby, the prosecutor who offered her probation. It is later revealed Simonelli was transferred to a tougher prison farther away from her daughter and denied parole for being caught smoking weed, despite her constant crying about wanting to get out and raise her little girl. What happened to her was unforgivable and her desperation to escape the sexual abuse is understandable, but her own decisions and her refusal to take any responsibility doesn't make the viewer take her side against Carmichael.

to:

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: While Alice Simonelli ''absolutely'' did not deserve to be a sex slave to a prison guard, the circumstances behind her imprisonment are the results of her own poor choices. She refused to roll on the drug dealer she was pulled over with, even though Carmichael offered her a deal with no prison time. When the two meet again for the murder trial, Simonelli blames all her woes on Abby, the prosecutor who offered her probation. It is later revealed Simonelli was transferred to a tougher prison farther away from her daughter and denied parole for being caught smoking weed, despite her constant crying about wanting to get out and raise her little girl. What happened to her was unforgivable and her desperation to escape the sexual abuse is understandable, but her own decisions and her refusal to take any responsibility doesn't make the viewer take her side against Carmichael.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
adding to the page

Added DiffLines:

UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: While Alice Simonelli ''absolutely'' did not deserve to be a sex slave to a prison guard, the circumstances behind her imprisonment are the results of her own poor choices. She refused to roll on the drug dealer she was pulled over with, even though Carmichael offered her a deal with no prison time. When the two meet again for the murder trial, Simonelli blames all her woes on Abby, the prosecutor who offered her probation. It is later revealed Simonelli was transferred to a tougher prison farther away from her daughter and denied parole for being caught smoking weed, despite her constant crying about wanting to get out and raise her little girl. What happened to her was unforgivable and her desperation to escape the sexual abuse is understandable, but her own decisions and her refusal to take any responsibility doesn't make the viewer take her side against Carmichael.

Top