Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / KimbaTheWhiteLion

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenAesop:
** Episode 14 of the 1965 anime is ''supposed'' to be an episode that teaches children racism is bad. Kimba is picked on for having white fur and called an inferior/fake lion, and much of the episode is focused on him accepting and proving himself as a real lion. The message is broken the minute the story reveals Kimba's ancestor drank a special potion that gave him super intelligence and strength, therefore making the ''entire white lion race genetically superior'' to all others by default.
** In the 1989 remake, an arc involves Kimba learning how to enforce the law of his jungle: "Animals should not fight each other." Of course, not everybody follows his rules and try to eat each other anyway, so Kimba is caught in a dilemma: either he fights to enforce the law of his jungle and breaks them in the process or doesn't fight at all and lets everyone kill each other as they please. [[spoiler:The moral we learn as the arc is concluded is that you shouldn't fight, ''at all'', even in self-defense. Meanwhile, the antagonists continue to ignore that rule and try to kill each other while Kimba refuses to stop them.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OvershadowedByControversy: Outside of a few select countries, people in the West mostly remember Kimba because of the controversy surrounding ''WesternAnimation/TheLionKing1994''. As it turns out, there are far more people who are aware of the controversy than there are people who actually watched the show.

to:

* OvershadowedByControversy: Outside of a few select countries, people in the West mostly remember Kimba because of the controversy surrounding ''WesternAnimation/TheLionKing1994''.''WesternAnimation/TheLionKing1994'' allegedly plagiarizing it. As it turns out, there are far more people who are aware of the controversy than there are people who actually watched the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The voice actors not understanding something out of context is definitely not this trope.


* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: For the voice actors anyway. Knowing absolutely nothing of how the original story was supposed to evolve, a woolly mammoth coming out of nowhere sort of threw them for a loop.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
messed up my edit, see the last edit for the edit reason


* AmericansHateTingle: The series is a hugely beloved classic in Japan, easily being one of Osamu Tezuka's most famous works. In America, however, it spent decades flying under the radar, with almost no decent exports and most people only vaguely remembering aspects of it (such as the title and theme song), if that. But then in TheNew10s, it gained recognition in the US when old rumors resurfaced via internet memes, videos, and articles, claiming ''The Lion King'' was really a shameless rip-off of Kimba. These accusations ballooned out with more and more exposure online, which eventually led ''WebVideo/YourMovieSucksDotOrg'' to look into the Kimba franchise to see if the plagiarism claims held any water, only to find that not only were they grossly exaggerated and [[CommonKnowledge/KimbaTheWhiteLion filled with misinformation]], but that the series itself was a great deal weirder, [[WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids darker]], and [[ValuesDissonance more dated]] than we had been led to believe. Opinion in America turned against Kimba almost overnight, and it is now regarded by a not-insignificant amount of people as [[SoBadItsGood a cheesy mess]] that proves even someone like Osamu Tezuka could have off-days.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
misuse, Americans Hate Tingle would somehow require an entire *franchise* to be a scrappy, which Kimba is not. Because most Americans have just never seen it unless they're an anime historian because its such a pain in the butt to acquire in English. Fans of a single You Tuber who in good faith just wanted to answer a question of plagiarism suddenly declaring its the worst show they've (never) seen is not enough for this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Widget Series has been renamed to Quirky Work as per TRS


* AmericansHateTingle: The series is a hugely beloved classic in Japan, easily being one of Osamu Tezuka's most famous works. In America, however, it spent decades flying under the radar, with almost no decent exports and most people only vaguely remembering aspects of it (such as the title and theme song), if that. But then in TheNew10s, it gained recognition in the US when old rumors resurfaced via internet memes, videos, and articles, claiming ''The Lion King'' was really a shameless rip-off of Kimba. These accusations ballooned out with more and more exposure online, which eventually led ''WebVideo/YourMovieSucksDotOrg'' to look into the Kimba franchise to see if the plagiarism claims held any water, only to find that not only were they grossly exaggerated and [[CommonKnowledge/KimbaTheWhiteLion filled with misinformation]], but that the series itself was a great deal [[WidgetSeries weirder]], [[WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids darker]], and [[ValuesDissonance more dated]] than we had been led to believe. Opinion in America turned against Kimba almost overnight, and it is now regarded by a not-insignificant amount of people as [[SoBadItsGood a cheesy mess]] that proves even someone like Osamu Tezuka could have off-days.

to:

* AmericansHateTingle: The series is a hugely beloved classic in Japan, easily being one of Osamu Tezuka's most famous works. In America, however, it spent decades flying under the radar, with almost no decent exports and most people only vaguely remembering aspects of it (such as the title and theme song), if that. But then in TheNew10s, it gained recognition in the US when old rumors resurfaced via internet memes, videos, and articles, claiming ''The Lion King'' was really a shameless rip-off of Kimba. These accusations ballooned out with more and more exposure online, which eventually led ''WebVideo/YourMovieSucksDotOrg'' to look into the Kimba franchise to see if the plagiarism claims held any water, only to find that not only were they grossly exaggerated and [[CommonKnowledge/KimbaTheWhiteLion filled with misinformation]], but that the series itself was a great deal [[WidgetSeries weirder]], weirder, [[WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids darker]], and [[ValuesDissonance more dated]] than we had been led to believe. Opinion in America turned against Kimba almost overnight, and it is now regarded by a not-insignificant amount of people as [[SoBadItsGood a cheesy mess]] that proves even someone like Osamu Tezuka could have off-days.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS


* SoBadItsGood: While they do have genuine fans, many have started watching the 1965 anime and its 1966 sequel purely for ironic enjoyment, due to their [[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs off-the-wall storytelling]], [[WatchItForTheMeme memetic moments]], [[MoodWhiplash unsettlingly dark elements]] such as the elephant genocide episode and Kimba keeping his dead father’s pelt as a keepsake, [[DesignatedHero the title character's]] [[MoralMyopia often unheroic actions]] ([[AbusiveParent especially]] [[{{Hypocrite}} in the sequel]]), and the unabashedly outdated aspects, [[BlackFace such as the ridiculously racist depictions of Africans]]. The sequel more so, as it doubles down on many of these elements, especially the last two, on top of having a hilariously terrible English dub.

to:

* SoBadItsGood: While they do have genuine fans, many have started watching the 1965 anime and its 1966 sequel purely for ironic enjoyment, due to their [[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs off-the-wall storytelling]], storytelling, [[WatchItForTheMeme memetic moments]], [[MoodWhiplash unsettlingly dark elements]] such as the elephant genocide episode and Kimba keeping his dead father’s pelt as a keepsake, [[DesignatedHero the title character's]] [[MoralMyopia often unheroic actions]] ([[AbusiveParent especially]] [[{{Hypocrite}} in the sequel]]), and the unabashedly outdated aspects, [[BlackFace such as the ridiculously racist depictions of Africans]]. The sequel more so, as it doubles down on many of these elements, especially the last two, on top of having a hilariously terrible English dub.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Kimba IS a series for kids


* AmericansHateTingle: The series is a hugely beloved classic in Japan, easily being one of Osamu Tezuka's most famous works. In America, however, it spent decades flying under the radar, with almost no decent exports and most people only vaguely remembering aspects of it (such as the title and theme song), if that. But then in TheNew10s, it gained recognition in the US when old rumors resurfaced via internet memes, videos, and articles, claiming ''The Lion King'' was really a shameless rip-off of Kimba. These accusations ballooned out with more and more exposure online, which eventually led ''WebVideo/YourMovieSucksDotOrg'' to look into the Kimba franchise to see if the plagiarism claims held any water, only to find that not only were they grossly exaggerated and [[CommonKnowledge/KimbaTheWhiteLion filled with misinformation]], but that the series itself was a great deal [[WidgetSeries weirder]], [[WhatDoYouMeanItsNotForKids darker]], and [[ValuesDissonance more dated]] than we had been led to believe. Opinion in America turned against Kimba almost overnight, and it is now regarded by a not-insignificant amount of people as [[SoBadItsGood a cheesy mess]] that proves even someone like Osamu Tezuka could have off-days.

to:

* AmericansHateTingle: The series is a hugely beloved classic in Japan, easily being one of Osamu Tezuka's most famous works. In America, however, it spent decades flying under the radar, with almost no decent exports and most people only vaguely remembering aspects of it (such as the title and theme song), if that. But then in TheNew10s, it gained recognition in the US when old rumors resurfaced via internet memes, videos, and articles, claiming ''The Lion King'' was really a shameless rip-off of Kimba. These accusations ballooned out with more and more exposure online, which eventually led ''WebVideo/YourMovieSucksDotOrg'' to look into the Kimba franchise to see if the plagiarism claims held any water, only to find that not only were they grossly exaggerated and [[CommonKnowledge/KimbaTheWhiteLion filled with misinformation]], but that the series itself was a great deal [[WidgetSeries weirder]], [[WhatDoYouMeanItsNotForKids [[WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids darker]], and [[ValuesDissonance more dated]] than we had been led to believe. Opinion in America turned against Kimba almost overnight, and it is now regarded by a not-insignificant amount of people as [[SoBadItsGood a cheesy mess]] that proves even someone like Osamu Tezuka could have off-days.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmericansHateTingle: The series is a hugely beloved classic in Japan, easily being one of Osamu Tezuka's most famous works. In America, however, it spent decades flying under the radar, with almost no decent exports and most people only vaguely remembering aspects of it (such as the title and theme song), if that. But then in TheNew10s, it gained recognition in the US when old rumors resurfaced via internet memes, videos, and articles, claiming ''The Lion King'' was really a shameless rip-off of Kimba. These accusations ballooned out with more and more exposure online, which eventually led ''[=YourMovieSucks.org=]'' to look into the Kimba franchise to see if the plagiarism claims held any water, only to find that not only were they grossly exaggerated and [[CommonKnowledge/KimbaTheWhiteLion filled with misinformation]], but that the series itself was a great deal [[WidgetSeries weirder]], [[WhatDoYouMeanItsNotForKids darker]], and [[ValuesDissonance more dated]] than we had been led to believe. Opinion in America turned against Kimba almost overnight, and it is now regarded by a not-insignificant amount of people as [[SoBadItsGood a cheesy mess]] that proves even someone like Osamu Tezuka could have off-days.

to:

* AmericansHateTingle: The series is a hugely beloved classic in Japan, easily being one of Osamu Tezuka's most famous works. In America, however, it spent decades flying under the radar, with almost no decent exports and most people only vaguely remembering aspects of it (such as the title and theme song), if that. But then in TheNew10s, it gained recognition in the US when old rumors resurfaced via internet memes, videos, and articles, claiming ''The Lion King'' was really a shameless rip-off of Kimba. These accusations ballooned out with more and more exposure online, which eventually led ''[=YourMovieSucks.org=]'' ''WebVideo/YourMovieSucksDotOrg'' to look into the Kimba franchise to see if the plagiarism claims held any water, only to find that not only were they grossly exaggerated and [[CommonKnowledge/KimbaTheWhiteLion filled with misinformation]], but that the series itself was a great deal [[WidgetSeries weirder]], [[WhatDoYouMeanItsNotForKids darker]], and [[ValuesDissonance more dated]] than we had been led to believe. Opinion in America turned against Kimba almost overnight, and it is now regarded by a not-insignificant amount of people as [[SoBadItsGood a cheesy mess]] that proves even someone like Osamu Tezuka could have off-days.

Added: 327

Removed: 327

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MemeticMolester: Claw became this after the episode ''Battle at Dead River'' where he tried to marry Kitty. When they first meet, he creepily asks her to become his bride. When she refuses, he orders his hyenas to capture her.
-->'''Kitty''': Claw, I really don't understand what's going on.
-->'''Claw''': (chuckles) You will!



* MemeticMolester: Claw became this after the episode ''Battle at Dead River'' where he tried to marry Kitty. When they first meet, he creepily asks her to become his bride. When she refuses, he orders his hyenas to capture her.
-->'''Kitty''': Claw, I really don't understand what's going on.
-->'''Claw''': (chuckles) You will!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmericansHateTingle: The series is a hugely beloved classic in Japan, easily being one of Osamu Tezuka's most famous works. In America, however, it spent decades flying under the radar, with almost no decent exports and most people only knowing it as "that lion cartoon made by the guy who did Astro Boy", if that. But then in TheNew10s, it gained recognition in the US when old rumors resurfaced via internet memes, videos, and articles that started claiming ''The Lion King'' was really a shameless rip-off of Kimba. These accusations ballooned out with more and more exposure online, which eventually led ''[=YourMovieSucks.org=]'' to look into the Kimba franchise to see if the plagiarism claims held any water, only to find that not only were they grossly exaggerated and filled with misinformation, but that the series itself was a great deal weirder, darker, and more dated than we had been led to believe. Opinion in America turned against Kimba almost overnight, and it is now regarded by a not-insignificant amount of people as [[SoBadItsGood a cheesy mess]] that proves even someone like Osamu Tezuka could have off-days.

to:

* AmericansHateTingle: The series is a hugely beloved classic in Japan, easily being one of Osamu Tezuka's most famous works. In America, however, it spent decades flying under the radar, with almost no decent exports and most people only knowing vaguely remembering aspects of it (such as "that lion cartoon made by the guy who did Astro Boy", title and theme song), if that. But then in TheNew10s, it gained recognition in the US when old rumors resurfaced via internet memes, videos, and articles that started articles, claiming ''The Lion King'' was really a shameless rip-off of Kimba. These accusations ballooned out with more and more exposure online, which eventually led ''[=YourMovieSucks.org=]'' to look into the Kimba franchise to see if the plagiarism claims held any water, only to find that not only were they grossly exaggerated and [[CommonKnowledge/KimbaTheWhiteLion filled with misinformation, misinformation]], but that the series itself was a great deal weirder, darker, [[WidgetSeries weirder]], [[WhatDoYouMeanItsNotForKids darker]], and [[ValuesDissonance more dated dated]] than we had been led to believe. Opinion in America turned against Kimba almost overnight, and it is now regarded by a not-insignificant amount of people as [[SoBadItsGood a cheesy mess]] that proves even someone like Osamu Tezuka could have off-days.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmericansHateTingle: The series is a hugely beloved classic in Japan, easily being one of Osamu Tezuka's most famous works. In America, however, it spent decades flying under the radar, with almost no decent exports and most people only knowing it as "that lion cartoon made by the guy who did Astro Boy", if that. But then in TheNew10s, it gained recognition in the US when old rumors and internet memes started claiming The Lion King was really a shoddy rip-off of Kimba. These accusations caused people like [=YourMovieSucks.org=] to start actually looking into Kimba to see if the plagiarism claims were true, only to find that not only were they false (Kimba and Lion King have barely anything in common), but that the series itself was a great deal weirder, darker, and more dated than they had been led to believe. Opinion in America turned against Kimba almost overnight, and it is now regarded by a not-insignificant amount of people as [[SoBadItsGood a cheesy mess]] that proves even someone like Osamu Tezuka could have off-days.

to:

* AmericansHateTingle: The series is a hugely beloved classic in Japan, easily being one of Osamu Tezuka's most famous works. In America, however, it spent decades flying under the radar, with almost no decent exports and most people only knowing it as "that lion cartoon made by the guy who did Astro Boy", if that. But then in TheNew10s, it gained recognition in the US when old rumors and resurfaced via internet memes memes, videos, and articles that started claiming The ''The Lion King King'' was really a shoddy shameless rip-off of Kimba. These accusations caused people like [=YourMovieSucks.org=] ballooned out with more and more exposure online, which eventually led ''[=YourMovieSucks.org=]'' to start actually looking look into the Kimba franchise to see if the plagiarism claims were true, held any water, only to find that not only were they false (Kimba grossly exaggerated and Lion King have barely anything in common), filled with misinformation, but that the series itself was a great deal weirder, darker, and more dated than they we had been led to believe. Opinion in America turned against Kimba almost overnight, and it is now regarded by a not-insignificant amount of people as [[SoBadItsGood a cheesy mess]] that proves even someone like Osamu Tezuka could have off-days.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmericansHateTingle: The series is a hugely beloved classic in Japan, easily being one of Osamu Tezuka's most famous works. In America, however, it spent decades flying under the radar, with almost no decent exports and most people only knowing it as "that lion cartoon made by the guy who did Astro Boy", if that. But then in TheNew10s, it gained recognition in the US when old rumors and internet memes started claiming The Lion King was really a shoddy rip-off of Kimba. These accusations caused people like [=YourMovieSucks.org=] to start actually looking into Kimba to see if the plagiarism claims were true, only to find that not only were they false (Kimba and Lion King have barely anything in common), but that the series itself was a great deal weirder, darker, and more dated than they had been led to believe. Opinion in America turned against Kimba almost overnight, and it is now regarded by a not-insignificant amount of people as [[SoBadItsGood a cheesy mess]] that proves even someone like Osamu Tezuka could have off-days.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One incarnation has this sequence showing Rune (wearing a bowtie and helmet) [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=agUNI49A-n8 riding on robotic legs as he's visiting various people and animals]]. The music during that sequence is trippy and very upbeat at the same time.

to:

** One incarnation The 1997 movie has this sequence showing Rune (wearing a bowtie and helmet) [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=agUNI49A-n8 riding on robotic legs as he's visiting various people and animals]]. The music during that sequence is trippy and very upbeat at the same time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DontShootTheMessage: Kimba, much like any other Tezuka production, was very progressive for its time and tried to convey a strong anti-discrimination message, which in modern times is heavily undermined by the fact Tezuka has chosen to depict African natives as racist caricatures in the original manga. The original anime adaptation thankfully avoids this, but its 1966 sequel wasn't so lucky.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SoBadItsGood: While they do have genuine fans, many have started watching the 1965 anime and its 1966 sequel purely for ironic enjoyment, due to their [[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs off-the-wall storytelling]], [[WatchItForTheMeme memetic moments]], [[MoodWhiplash unsettlingly dark elements]] such as the elephant genocide episode, [[PedoHunt Claw’s infatuation with Kitty]], and Kimba keeping his dead father’s pelt as a keepsake, [[DesignatedHero the title character's]] [[MoralMyopia often unheroic actions]] ([[AbusiveParent especially]] [[{{Hypocrite}} in the sequel]]), and the unabashedly outdated aspects, [[BlackFace such as the ridiculously racist depictions of Africans]].

to:

* SoBadItsGood: While they do have genuine fans, many have started watching the 1965 anime and its 1966 sequel purely for ironic enjoyment, due to their [[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs off-the-wall storytelling]], [[WatchItForTheMeme memetic moments]], [[MoodWhiplash unsettlingly dark elements]] such as the elephant genocide episode, [[PedoHunt Claw’s infatuation with Kitty]], episode and Kimba keeping his dead father’s pelt as a keepsake, [[DesignatedHero the title character's]] [[MoralMyopia often unheroic actions]] ([[AbusiveParent especially]] [[{{Hypocrite}} in the sequel]]), and the unabashedly outdated aspects, [[BlackFace such as the ridiculously racist depictions of Africans]].Africans]]. The sequel more so, as it doubles down on many of these elements, especially the last two, on top of having a hilariously terrible English dub.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SoBadItsGood: While they do have genuine fans, many have started watching the 1965 anime and its 1966 sequel purely for ironic enjoyment, due to their [[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs off-the-wall storytelling]], [[WatchItForTheMeme memetic moments]], [[MoodWhiplash unsettlingly dark elements]] such as the elephant genocide episode, [[PedoHunt Claw’s infatuation with Kitty]], and Kimba keeping his dead father’s pelt as a keepsake, [[DesignatedHero the title character's]] [[MoralMyopia often unheroic actions]] ([[AbusiveParent especially]] [[{{Hypocrite}} in the sequel]]), and the unabashedly outdated aspects, [[BlackFace such as the ridiculously racist depictions of Africans]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CommonKnowledge: [[CommonKnowledge/KimbaTheWhiteLion Has its own page]].

Top