Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / KarateShoukoushiKohinataMinoru

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrazyAwesome: Kasumi, being a bona fide ninja with all the related powers (somewhat) in a series with realistic fighting, can be either this or BunnyEarsLawyer.

to:

* CrazyAwesome: CrazyIsCool: Kasumi, being a bona fide ninja with all the related powers (somewhat) in a series with realistic fighting, can be either this or BunnyEarsLawyer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NeverLiveItDown: As mentioned above in DesignatedHero, Pedro is this to readers for his introduction arc that portrays him as a rapist...[[KarmaHoudini and gets away with his actions]].

to:

* NeverLiveItDown: As mentioned above in DesignatedHero, Pedro is this to readers for his introduction arc that portrays him as a rapist...[[KarmaHoudini and gets away with his actions]].actions]].
* StrangledByTheRedString: Some of the early couples can look like this given how little development they were given initially. Mutou/Haruka and Mamiya/Yukiko were the ones that stood out the most. While the former advanced pretty quickly, the latter is actually the slowest-growing couple.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: Saizo and Jiraiya's fight is seen as this by nearly everyone since it features two ninjas (though one turned into a BJJ fighter later on) fighting in a stance completely different from everyone else, named attacks, ninpo (dirty ninja tricks), [[spoiler: and ''fire breathing''!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NeverLiveItDown: As mentioned above in DesignatedHero, Pedro is this to readers for his introduction arc that portrays him as a rapist...[[KarmaHoudini and gets away with his actions]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkAssWoobie: Kevin Norton, once you learn his backstory.

to:

* JerkAssWoobie: JerkassWoobie: Kevin Norton, once you learn his backstory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArcFatigue: Minoru vs. Tabuse of the Genesis tournament lasted ''way'' too long.

to:

* ArcFatigue: Minoru vs. Tabuse of the Genesis tournament lasted ''way'' too long.long for its own good. Hardly anyone found the "pro-wrestling" gimmick easy to take seriously.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArcFatigue: Minoru vs. Tabuse of the Genesis tournament lasted ''way'' too long.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CrazyAwesome: Kasumi, being a bona fide ninja with all the related powers (somewhat) in a series with realistic fighting, can be either this or BunnyEarsLawyer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
unfortunate implications need citations


* UnfortunateImplications: ''Hoo, boy...''
** The manga eventually introduces a transgender woman. No one refers to her by her preferred pronoun after this fact is revealed, and when Pedro pulls her pants down in front of them, the characters aren't upset with Pedro, but with ''her. '' The it's actually implied that she didn't mind being exposed in front of a bunch of strangers, which in itself opens up a whole new can of worms.
** Speaking of Pedro, many western fans have pointed out that his cartoonish appearance, when compared to the otherwise realistically drawn cast, along with being a literal rapist, is unsettlingly reminiscent of Blackface. Let's not forget that Pedro, a rapist, is also the manga's only major gay character...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkAssWoobie: Kevin Norton, once you learn his backstory.

to:

* JerkAssWoobie: Kevin Norton, once you learn his backstory.backstory.
* UnfortunateImplications: ''Hoo, boy...''
** The manga eventually introduces a transgender woman. No one refers to her by her preferred pronoun after this fact is revealed, and when Pedro pulls her pants down in front of them, the characters aren't upset with Pedro, but with ''her. '' The it's actually implied that she didn't mind being exposed in front of a bunch of strangers, which in itself opens up a whole new can of worms.
** Speaking of Pedro, many western fans have pointed out that his cartoonish appearance, when compared to the otherwise realistically drawn cast, along with being a literal rapist, is unsettlingly reminiscent of Blackface. Let's not forget that Pedro, a rapist, is also the manga's only major gay character...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pedro. The guy's an unrepentant rapist, has attempted to sexually assault Minoru three times, deludes himself into thinking that Minoru's being a {{Tsundere}} towards him, and later has the gall to consider Nana, a girl who has been Minoru's best friend for years and stuck with him through thick and thin, [[{{Hypocrite}} a "depraved stalker woman"]].

to:

** Pedro. The guy's an unrepentant rapist, rapist (or at least one who's [[KarmaHoudini never paid seriously for his crimes]]), has attempted to sexually assault Minoru three times, deludes himself into thinking that Minoru's being a {{Tsundere}} towards him, and later has the gall to consider Nana, a girl who has been Minoru's best friend for years and stuck with him through thick and thin, [[{{Hypocrite}} a "depraved stalker woman"]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
unfortunate implications need citations


* JerkAssWoobie: Kevin Norton, once you learn his backstory.
* UnfortunateImplications:
** The only openly gay character in the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly isn't interested in him.
** Virtually all of the foreign characters, from the American soldiers stationed in Okinawa, to Samart, to the above-mentioned Filipino gay male, have ''very'' unfavorable depictions.
** There's also the first transgener character to appear, who is mainly treated as comic relief and whom suddenly stops being treated so nicely once the fact that she was born a he is revealed. The scene is depicted in a way that makes it seem like we should sympathize with the greater cast, who were "tricked" about her "true" gender, rather than the transgender woman who had her pants pulled down in front of a bunch of strangers.
** Let's also not forget the double-standard depictions of sexual assault. When it's a woman being assaulted, it's treated with the utmost seriousness--and rightfully so. When a ''man'' is both the perpetrator and victim however, it's comedy.

to:

* JerkAssWoobie: Kevin Norton, once you learn his backstory.
* UnfortunateImplications:
** The only openly gay character in the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly isn't interested in him.
** Virtually all of the foreign characters, from the American soldiers stationed in Okinawa, to Samart, to the above-mentioned Filipino gay male, have ''very'' unfavorable depictions.
** There's also the first transgener character to appear, who is mainly treated as comic relief and whom suddenly stops being treated so nicely once the fact that she was born a he is revealed. The scene is depicted in a way that makes it seem like we should sympathize with the greater cast, who were "tricked" about her "true" gender, rather than the transgender woman who had her pants pulled down in front of a bunch of strangers.
** Let's also not forget the double-standard depictions of sexual assault. When it's a woman being assaulted, it's treated with the utmost seriousness--and rightfully so. When a ''man'' is both the perpetrator and victim however, it's comedy.
backstory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The only openly gay character for most of the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly isn't interested in him.

to:

** The only openly gay character for most of in the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly isn't interested in him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pedro. The guy's an unrepentant rapist, has attempted to sexually assault Minoru three times, deludes himself into thinking that Minoru's being a {{Tsundere}} towards him, and later has the gall to assume that Nana, who has been Minoru's best friend for years and stuck with him through thick and thin, [[{{Hypocrite}} is a depraved stalker]].

to:

** Pedro. The guy's an unrepentant rapist, has attempted to sexually assault Minoru three times, deludes himself into thinking that Minoru's being a {{Tsundere}} towards him, and later has the gall to assume that consider Nana, a girl who has been Minoru's best friend for years and stuck with him through thick and thin, [[{{Hypocrite}} is a depraved stalker]]."depraved stalker woman"]].

Added: 676

Changed: 1176

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnfortunateImplications: The only openly gay character for most of the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly isn't interested in him.
** Virtually all of the foreign characters, from the American soldiers stationed in Okinawa, to Samart, to the above-mentioned Filipino gay male, have ''very'' unfavorable depictions. There's also the first transgener character to appear, who is mainly treated as comic relief and whom suddenly stops being treating so nicely once the fact that she was born a he is revealed. The scene is depicted in a way that makes it seem like we should sympathize with the greater cast, who were "tricked" about her "true" gender, rather than the transgender woman who had her pants pulled down in front of a bunch of strangers.
** Lets also not forget the double-standard depictions of sexual assault. When it's a woman being assaulted, it's treated with the utmost seriousness--and rightfully so. When a ''man'' is both the perpetrator and victim however, it's comedy.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications: UnfortunateImplications:
**
The only openly gay character for most of the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly isn't interested in him.
** Virtually all of the foreign characters, from the American soldiers stationed in Okinawa, to Samart, to the above-mentioned Filipino gay male, have ''very'' unfavorable depictions. depictions.
**
There's also the first transgener character to appear, who is mainly treated as comic relief and whom suddenly stops being treating treated so nicely once the fact that she was born a he is revealed. The scene is depicted in a way that makes it seem like we should sympathize with the greater cast, who were "tricked" about her "true" gender, rather than the transgender woman who had her pants pulled down in front of a bunch of strangers.
** Lets Let's also not forget the double-standard depictions of sexual assault. When it's a woman being assaulted, it's treated with the utmost seriousness--and rightfully so. When a ''man'' is both the perpetrator and victim however, it's comedy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Virtually all of the foreign characters, from the American soldiers stationed in Okinawa, to Samart, to the above-mentioned Filipino gay male, have ''very'' unfavorable depictions. There's also the first transgener character to appear, who is mainly treated as comic relief and whom suddenly stops being treating so nicely once the fact that she was born a he is revealed. The scene is depicted in a way that makes it seem like we should sympathize with the greater cast, who were "tricked" about her "true" gender, rather than the transgender woman who had her pants pulled down in front of a bunch of strangers.

to:

** Virtually all of the foreign characters, from the American soldiers stationed in Okinawa, to Samart, to the above-mentioned Filipino gay male, have ''very'' unfavorable depictions. There's also the first transgener character to appear, who is mainly treated as comic relief and whom suddenly stops being treating so nicely once the fact that she was born a he is revealed. The scene is depicted in a way that makes it seem like we should sympathize with the greater cast, who were "tricked" about her "true" gender, rather than the transgender woman who had her pants pulled down in front of a bunch of strangers.strangers.
** Lets also not forget the double-standard depictions of sexual assault. When it's a woman being assaulted, it's treated with the utmost seriousness--and rightfully so. When a ''man'' is both the perpetrator and victim however, it's comedy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Virtually all of the foreign characters, from the American soldiers stationed in Okinawa, to Samart, to the above-mentioned gay Filipino gay male, have ''very'' unfavorable depictions.

to:

** Virtually all of the foreign characters, from the American soldiers stationed in Okinawa, to Samart, to the above-mentioned gay Filipino gay male, have ''very'' unfavorable depictions.depictions. There's also the first transgener character to appear, who is mainly treated as comic relief and whom suddenly stops being treating so nicely once the fact that she was born a he is revealed. The scene is depicted in a way that makes it seem like we should sympathize with the greater cast, who were "tricked" about her "true" gender, rather than the transgender woman who had her pants pulled down in front of a bunch of strangers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnfortunateImplications: The only openly gay character for most of the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly isn't interested in him.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications: The only openly gay character for most of the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly isn't interested in him.him.
** Virtually all of the foreign characters, from the American soldiers stationed in Okinawa, to Samart, to the above-mentioned gay Filipino gay male, have ''very'' unfavorable depictions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DesignatedHero:
** Mutou at first. He assaults and badly injures the judo club captain [[BloodKnight just for the hell of it]], and it's reported that he's been carrying out similar attacks on other students and even teachers at the university. And during the masked rapist incident, Mutou only wants to catch the guy [[SkewedPriorities because of him ruining Mutou's reputation, rather than due to the guy being a rapist]] (although this mentality is shared by the rest of the club, except Ibuki).

to:

* DesignatedHero:
DesignatedHero: Or at least, Designated Character-we're-meant-to-like.
** Mutou at first. He assaults and badly injures the judo club captain [[BloodKnight just for the hell of it]], and it's reported that he's been carrying out similar attacks on other students and even teachers at the university. And during the masked rapist incident, Mutou only wants to catch the guy [[SkewedPriorities because of him ruining Mutou's reputation, rather than due to the guy being a rapist]] (although this mentality is shared by the rest of the club, except Ibuki). Once this arc is over, [[SubvertedTrope he has less of these moments]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnfortunateImplications: Pedro, the only openly gay character in the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly isn't interested in him.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications: Pedro, the The only openly gay character in for most of the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly isn't interested in him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pedro. The guy's an unrepentant rapist, has attempted to sexually assault Minoru three times, and later has the gall to assume that Minoru's being a {{Tsundere}} towards him, and that Nana, who has been Minoru's best friend for years and stuck with him through thick and thin, [[{{Hypocrite}} is a depraved stalker]].

to:

** Pedro. The guy's an unrepentant rapist, has attempted to sexually assault Minoru three times, and later has the gall to assume deludes himself into thinking that Minoru's being a {{Tsundere}} towards him, and later has the gall to assume that Nana, who has been Minoru's best friend for years and stuck with him through thick and thin, [[{{Hypocrite}} is a depraved stalker]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mutou at first. He assaults and badly injures the judo club captain, and it's reported that he's been carrying out similar attacks on other students and even teachers at the university. And during the masked rapist incident, Mutou only wants to catch the guy [[SkewedPriorities because of him ruining Mutou's reputation, rather than due to the guy being a rapist]] (although this mentality is shared by the rest of the club, except Ibuki).

to:

** Mutou at first. He assaults and badly injures the judo club captain, captain [[BloodKnight just for the hell of it]], and it's reported that he's been carrying out similar attacks on other students and even teachers at the university. And during the masked rapist incident, Mutou only wants to catch the guy [[SkewedPriorities because of him ruining Mutou's reputation, rather than due to the guy being a rapist]] (although this mentality is shared by the rest of the club, except Ibuki).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mutou at first. He assaults and badly injures the judo club captain, and it's reported that he's been carrying out similar attacks on other students and even teachers at the university. And during the masked rapist incident, Mutou only wants to catch the guy [[SkewedPriorities because of him ruining Mutou's reputation, rather than due to the guy being a rapist]] (although this mentality is shared by the rest of the club).

to:

** Mutou at first. He assaults and badly injures the judo club captain, and it's reported that he's been carrying out similar attacks on other students and even teachers at the university. And during the masked rapist incident, Mutou only wants to catch the guy [[SkewedPriorities because of him ruining Mutou's reputation, rather than due to the guy being a rapist]] (although this mentality is shared by the rest of the club).club, except Ibuki).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DesignatedHero:
** Mutou at first. He assaults and badly injures the judo club captain, and it's reported that he's been carrying out similar attacks on other students and even teachers at the university. And during the masked rapist incident, Mutou only wants to catch the guy [[SkewedPriorities because of him ruining Mutou's reputation, rather than due to the guy being a rapist]] (although this mentality is shared by the rest of the club).
** Pedro. The guy's an unrepentant rapist, has attempted to sexually assault Minoru three times, and later has the gall to assume that Minoru's being a {{Tsundere}} towards him, and that Nana, who has been Minoru's best friend for years and stuck with him through thick and thin, [[{{Hypocrite}} is a depraved stalker]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnfortunateImplications: Pedro, the only openly gay character in the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly doesn't want it. To make things worse, no one ever calls Pedro out for his behaviour.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications: Pedro, the only openly gay character in the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly doesn't want it. To make things worse, no one ever calls Pedro out for his behaviour.isn't interested in him.

Changed: 250

Removed: 252

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnfortunateImplications:
* Pedro, the only openly gay character in the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly doesn't want it. To make things worse, no one ever calls Pedro out for his behaviour.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications:
*
UnfortunateImplications: Pedro, the only openly gay character in the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly doesn't want it. To make things worse, no one ever calls Pedro out for his behaviour.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkAssWoobie: Kevin Norton, once you learn his backstory.

to:

* JerkAssWoobie: Kevin Norton, once you learn his backstory.backstory.
* UnfortunateImplications:
* Pedro, the only openly gay character in the series is a former rapist and makes sexual advances towards Minoru nearly every chance he gets, even when Minoru clearly doesn't want it. To make things worse, no one ever calls Pedro out for his behaviour.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This isn\'t YMMV. Moving.


* FanDisservice: Minoru's fight scene with Kevin. Minoru, a {{Bishonen}}, [[ShirtlessScene being shirtless]] would normally be a pretty good thing. Except he's getting the crap beat out of him by an equally shirtless, [[AxCrazy insane]] and rather {{Gonk}}ish Kevin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* JerkAssWoobie: Kevin Norton, once you learn his backstory.
* RuinedForever: The fact that Pedro, initially a villain, becomes part of the Karate club and his assasults are PlayedForLaughs, is a sticking point for more than a few readers.

to:

* JerkAssWoobie: Kevin Norton, once you learn his backstory.
* RuinedForever: The fact that Pedro, initially a villain, becomes part of the Karate club and his assasults are PlayedForLaughs, is a sticking point for more than a few readers.
backstory.

Added: 238

Changed: 337

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RuinedForever: The fact that Pedro, initially a villain, becomes part of the Karate club and his assasults are PlayedForLaughs, is a sticking point for more than a few readers.

to:

* FanDisservice: Minoru's fight scene with Kevin. Minoru, a {{Bishonen}}, [[ShirtlessScene being shirtless]] would normally be a pretty good thing. Except he's getting the crap beat out of him by an equally shirtless, [[AxCrazy insane]] and rather {{Gonk}}ish Kevin.
* JerkAssWoobie: Kevin Norton, once you learn his backstory.
* RuinedForever: The fact that Pedro, initially a villain, becomes part of the Karate club and his assasults are PlayedForLaughs, is a sticking point for more than a few readers.

Top