History YMMV / HesJustNotThatIntoYou

* UnintentionalPeriodPiece: This film is practically a time capsule of what dating was like right before the explosive popularity of smartphones in TheNewTens, and with them the rise of dating websites and apps, specifically in Gigi's story.

* WhatAnIdiot: Ben leaving cigarettes not only in his pants pocket but in the pocket of the sole pair of pants left out basically assuring that Janine will find it.

-->'''Gigi''': So, what? Now I'm jut supposed to run from every guy who doesn't like me?

-->'''Gigi''': What, so you're saying I should just run away from any guy who doesn't like me?

-->'''Alex''': [[BluntYes ''Yes''.]]

-->'''Gigi''': What, so you're saying I just run away from any guy who doesn't like me?
-->'''Alex''': ''Yes''.

'''Gigi''': What, so you're saying I just run away from any guy who doesn't like me?
'''Alex''': ''Yes''.
'''Gigi''': ...There won't be anyone left.

* TheWoobie: It's easy to feel bad for Gigi when Alex tells her yet another guy doesn't like her. She replies sadly, "There won't be anyone left..."

* TearJerker: Janine, upon discovering that her husband cheated on her with Anna, immediately starts assuming it's ''her'' fault for not being "fun" anymore, even when Gigi and Beth try to tell her it's not.

* WhatAnIdiot: Ben leaving cigarettes not only in his pants pocket, but in the pocket of the sole pair of pants left out basically assuring that Janine will find it.
* TheWoobie: It's easy to feel bad for Gigi when Alex tells her yet another guy doesn't like her, replies sadly, "There won't be anyone left..."

** AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Unless he subconsciously ''wanted'' her to find it out of guilt.

* UnfortunateImplications: Alex tells Gigi that Connor is [[TitleDrop just not that into her]], which is true and she needed to hear it, since Gigi has a habit of getting kinda stalker-y towards men she's interest in. However, Alex then tells Gigi that if a man wants to be with you, ''he will make it happen''. He gives examples like calling every florist in the city until he found the right one and comments on a LoveTriangle he spots across the bar, criticising a woman for talking to a guy who obviously isn't interested her while ignoring the DoggedNiceGuy. But the way he phrases all this makes it sound like he's trying to say that only ''men'' [[NoGuyWantsToBeChased should pursue a relationship and it's creepy for women to do it]], but a man chasing after a woman who isn't interested is acceptable. Of course, Alex is later shown to be pushing Gigi away because he doesn't want to admit he likes her beyond JustFriends, but his advice to her is generally treated as worldly wisdom and not a ridiculous DoubleStandard.

** Ben: Didn't have the balls to tell Janine that he wasn't that interested in her and married her rather than breaking up with her, then cheated on her rather than having the balls to divorce her first.

* TearJerker: Janine, upon discovering that her husband cheated on her with Anna, [[UsefulNotes/VictimBlaming immediately starts assuming it's ''her'' fault for not being "fun" anymore]], even when Gigi and Beth try to tell her it's not.

* TearJerker: Jennifer Connelly's character, upon discovering that her husband cheated on her with Anna, [[VictimBlaming immediately starts assuming it's ''her'' fault for not being "fun" anymore]], even when Gigi and Beth try to tell her it's not.

* TheWoobie: It's easy to feel bad for Gigi when Alex tells her yet another guy doesn't like her, replies sadly, "There won't be anyone left..."

* {{Tearjerker}}: Jennifer Connelly's character, upon discovering that her husband cheated on her with Anna, [[VictimBlaming immediately starts assuming it's ''her'' fault for not being "fun" anymore]], even when Gigi and Beth try to tell her it's not.

* UnfortunateImplications: AllGaysArePromiscuous. The gay men at Conor's party basically say this outright.

* Tearjerker: Jennifer Connelly's character, upon discovering that her husband cheated on her with Anna, [[VictimBlaming immediately starts assuming it's ''her'' fault for not being "fun" anymore]], even when Gigi and Beth try to tell her it's not.

* UnfortunateImplications: AllGaysArePromiscous. The gay men at Conor's party basically say this outright.

* UnfortunateImplications: AllGaysArePromiscous. The gay men at Conor's party basically say this outright.

BrokenAesop: Neil and Beth's storyline- when Beth leaves Neil and then realises that she loves him and he's a much better partner than her sister's lazy husbands, takes him back after accepting that they don't have to get married and that their relationship was fine before...only for that to totally get undone when Neil does propose to her, even if he was the one against it in the first place.

* Tearjerker: Jennifer Connelly's character, upon discovering that her husband cheated on her with Anna, [[VictimBlaming immediately starts assuming it's ''her'' fault for not being "fun" anymore]]e, even when Gigi and Beth try to tell her it's not.

* UnfortunateImplications: AllGayArePromiscous. The gay men at Conor's party basically say this outright.

BrokenAesop: Neil and Beth's storyline- when Beth leaves Neil and then realises that she loves him and he's a much better partner than her sister's lazy husbands, takes him back after accepting that they don't have to get married and that their relationship was fine before...only for that to totally get undone when Neil does propose to her, even if he was the one against it in the first place.