History YMMV / BadSisters

* CatharsisFactor: We all knew John-Paul’s death was coming and was rightfully deserved. He was a bigoted, abusive, lying, hypocritical sadistic, petty, bully and [[spoiler:rapist]], but [[spoiler: the fact that it was Grace, the most frequent victim of his abuse is icing on the cake, especially since it was in reaction to his most heinous act.]]
* FridgeBrilliance: Watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IZUrhfCl0Xc the trailer]] again. Every time Thomas talks about murder or foul play, [[spoiler: Grace]] appears on screen immediately afterwards. The trailer was telling us who the killer was all along.
* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: On another TV show, insurer Thomas Claffin would be the underdog main character investigating the insurance claim of a man who died under mysterious circumstances under threat of bankrupcy with a convalescent wife and a baby on the way, but in this one, while he's [[JerkassHasAPoint right in suspecting foul play]] from the Garvey sisters, the manner in which he approaches his investigation feels completely unprofessional, up to including dragging his reluctant brother Matthew into the investigation, barging into the sisters' houses as if he was an actual detective, invading their privacy (like taking their garbage and taking pictures of their belongings without permission), and being as patronizing and belittling to them as John Paul was.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: On another TV show, insurer Thomas Claffin would be the underdog main character investigating the insurance claim of a man who died under mysterious circumstances under threat of bankrupcy with a convalescent wife and a baby on the way, but in this one, while he's [[JerkassHasAPoint right in suspecting foul play]] from the Garvey sisters, the manner in which he approaches his investigation feels completely unprofessional, up to including dragging his reluctant brother Matthew into the investigation, barging into the sisters' houses as if he was an actual detective, invading their privacy (like taking their garbage and taking pictures of their belongings without permission), and being as patronizing and belittling to them as John Paul was.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: On another TV show, insurer Thomas Claffin would be the underdog main character investigating the insurance claim of a man who died under mysterious circunstances under threat of bankrupcy with a convalescent wife and a baby on the way, but in this one, while he's [[JerkassHasAPoint right in suspecting foul play]] from the Garvey sisters, the manner in which he approaches his investigation feels completely unprofessional, up to including dragging his reluctant brother Matthew into the investigation, barging into the sisters' houses as if he was an actual detective, invading their privacy (like taking their garbage and taking pictures of their belongings without permission), and being as patronizing and belittling to them as John Paul was.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: On another TV show, insurer Thomas Claffin would be the underdog main character investigating the insurance claim of a man who died under mysterious circunstances under threat of bankrupcy with a convalescent wife and a baby on the way, but in this one, while he's [[JerkassHasAPoint right in suspecting foul play]] from the Garvey sisters, the manner in which he approaches his investigation feels completely unprofessional, up to including dragging his reluctant brother Matthew into the investigation, barging into the sisters' houses as if he was an actual detective and invading their privacy (like taking their garbage and taking pictures of their belongings without permission), and being as patronizing to them as John Paul was.

* CatharsisFactor: We all knew John-Paul’s death was coming and was rightfully deserved. He was a bigoted, abusive, hypocritical sadistic, petty bully and [[spoiler:rapist]], but [[spoiler: the fact that it was Grace, the most frequent victim of his abuse is icing on the cake, especially since it was in reaction to his most heinous act.]]

* FridgeBrilliance: Watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IZUrhfCl0Xc the trailer]] again. Every time Thomas talks about murder or foul play, Grace appears on screen immediately afterwards. The trailer was telling us who the killer was all along.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: on another TV show, insurer Thomas Claffin would be the main character the insurance claim of a man who died under mysterious circunstances against the odds of him losing his insurance company business, but in this one, while he's [[JerkassHasAPoint in the right to suspect foul play]] from the Garvey sisters, the manner in which he approaches his investigations feels completely unprofessional, up to including dragging his reluctant brother in barge into the sisters' houses as if he was a cop,