Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WhatCouldHaveBeen / Survivor

Go To

OR

Added: 1365

Changed: 1

Removed: 452

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s), and since Survivor 41 had two iterations, I had to differentiate with the people who were on the original and what we eventually saw


* ''Survivor 41'' was going to be called ''Dawn of a New Era'' before they decided to stop using sub-titles for this season and beyond.
* Speaking of ''41'', due to the COVID-19 Pandemic causing several travel restrictions, there was talk of shooting the season within the United States, with Hawaii and Georgia being considered. However, it was decided they would simply delay filming until the Fijian government would allow them to travel there again.



* In ''Phlippines'', the players originally wanted to name the merge tribe "Fuckinrayne" but the producers told them they had to change it as they would have to censor the tribe name. Allegedly, the production crew found it ActuallyPrettyFunny.
* [[Characters/SurvivorBorneo Richard Hatch]] was considered for ''Winners at War'', but was cut due to the Dan Spilo incident as he had (whether it was on purpose or an accident is still debated to this day) a similar incident with Sue Hawk in ''All Stars''.

to:

* In ''Phlippines'', ''Philippines'', the players originally wanted to name the merge tribe "Fuckinrayne" but the producers told them they had to change it as they would have to censor the tribe name. Allegedly, the production crew found it ActuallyPrettyFunny.
* [[Characters/SurvivorBorneo Richard Hatch]] was considered for ''Winners at War'', but was cut due to the Dan Spilo incident as he had (whether it was on purpose or an accident is still debated to this day) a similar incident with Sue Hawk in ''All Stars''.Stars''.
* ''Survivor 41'' has ''plenty'' of What Could Have Beens:
** It was going to be called ''Dawn of a New Era'' before they decided to stop using subtitles for this season and beyond.
** Due to the COVID-19 Pandemic causing several travel restrictions, there was talk of shooting the season within the United States, with Hawaii and Georgia being considered. However, it was decided they would simply delay filming until the Fijian government would allow them to travel there again.
** Several contestants were cast on pre-COVID ''Survivor 41'' before filming was suspended, and were pushed to future seasons. Erika Casupanan, Danny [=McCray=], Heather Aldret, Brad Reese, and David Voce were retained for the post-pandemic ''41'', Zach Wurtenberger, Tori Meehan, and Jonathan Young were pushed to ''42'', Jesse Lopez and Cassidy Clark to ''43'', and Matthew Grinstead-Mayle and Bruce Perreault in ''44''.
** Lindsay Dolashewich from ''42'' was supposed to compete on post-pandemic ''41'', but contracted COVID and was replaced by Tiffany Seely. [[HistoryRepeats Coincidentally]], another Lindsay, Lindsay Carmine, was cast for ''42'', but also contracted COVID and was pushed to ''43''.
** Shan Smith, who was on the Ua tribe[[note]]and who also applied and was cast on the post-pandemic ''41''[[/note]], was originally placed on Yase before Tiffany Seely took her place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* As related by the man himself on his podcast, Jeff Probst's first concept for ''41'' involved money entering the ''Survivor'' society, with a currency system that would allow players to buy supplies and advantages from a shopkeeper. As part of the ''Survivor'' Retool, it would also have had a narrative introduction about Winner's at War "war" destroying the old ''Survivor'' society and a new one being born from the ashes. The concept was ultimately dropped for "not being fun enough".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Additionally it was rumored that this was supposed to have a similar tribe split as in Cook Islands, which is further hinted to by the fact there were 5 Caucasian-American castaways (Gary, Melissa, Rocky, Boo, and Jessica), 5 Hispanic-American castaways (Liliana, Lisi, Alex, Rita, and Edgardo), 5 Asian-American castaways (Sylvia, Michelle, Mookie, Yau-Man, and Stacy), and 5 African American castaways (Anthony, Erica, Cassandra, Dreamz, and Earl) though this was changed after Melissa dropped out. Given the UnfortunateImplications this created last time, this wasn't necessarily a bad thing.

to:

** Additionally it was rumored that this was supposed to have a similar tribe split as in Cook Islands, which is further hinted to by the fact there were 5 Caucasian-American castaways (Gary, Melissa, Rocky, Boo, and Jessica), 5 Hispanic-American castaways (Liliana, Lisi, Alex, Rita, and Edgardo), 5 Asian-American castaways (Sylvia, Michelle, Mookie, Yau-Man, and Stacy), and 5 African American castaways (Anthony, Erica, Cassandra, Dreamz, and Earl) though this was changed after Melissa dropped out. Given the UnfortunateImplications controversy this created last time, this wasn't necessarily a bad thing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Phlippines'', the players originally wanted to name the merge tribe "Fuckinrayne" but the producers told them they had to change it as they would have to censor the tribe name. Allegedly, the production crew found it ActuallyPrettyFunny.

to:

* In ''Phlippines'', the players originally wanted to name the merge tribe "Fuckinrayne" but the producers told them they had to change it as they would have to censor the tribe name. Allegedly, the production crew found it ActuallyPrettyFunny.ActuallyPrettyFunny.
* [[Characters/SurvivorBorneo Richard Hatch]] was considered for ''Winners at War'', but was cut due to the Dan Spilo incident as he had (whether it was on purpose or an accident is still debated to this day) a similar incident with Sue Hawk in ''All Stars''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* On Cambodia, had Kass made it to the family visit she would have brought on J'Tia as her loved one and Stephen wanted to bring JT as his loved one but production thought that having a past winner come back would have been an unfair advantage.

to:

* On Cambodia, had Kass made it to the family visit she would have brought on J'Tia as her loved one and Stephen wanted to bring JT as his loved one but production thought that having a past winner come back would have been an unfair advantage.advantage.
* In ''Phlippines'', the players originally wanted to name the merge tribe "Fuckinrayne" but the producers told them they had to change it as they would have to censor the tribe name. Allegedly, the production crew found it ActuallyPrettyFunny.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Speaking of ''41'', due to the COVID-19 Pandemic causing several travel restrictions, there was talk of shooting the season within the United States, with Hawaii and Georgia being considered. However, it was decided they would simply delay filming until the Fijian government would allow them to travel there again.

Added: 133

Changed: 142

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jerri Manthey and her sister were asked to compete in ''Blood vs. Water'', but had to back out when Jerri's sister became pregnant.



* [[Characters/SurvivorPhilippines Abi-Maria]] [[Characters/SurvivorCambodia Gomes]] was originally going to be on ''Tocantins'' but because of production feeling that she had a good layout of the land, they didn't put her on the season.

to:

* [[Characters/SurvivorPhilippines Abi-Maria]] [[Characters/SurvivorCambodia Gomes]] was originally going to be on ''Tocantins'' but ended up getting cut because of she was from the filming area and production feeling that she had a good layout of the land, they didn't put thought it would give her on the season.an unfair advantage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[Characters/SurvivorTocantins Sierra Reed]] was asked to join ''Heroes vs. Villains'' and said yes, but had to step down after getting engaged to a producer from her season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A [[https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/survivor/images/a/a3/Unused_Palau_Merge_Buff.JPG/revision/latest?cb=20190702030125 green buff]] was made for, but not used in ''Palau''. Presumably, it would've been the merged tribe buff had [[FlawlessVictory Koror]] not've steamrolled Ulong.

to:

* A [[https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/survivor/images/a/a3/Unused_Palau_Merge_Buff.JPG/revision/latest?cb=20190702030125 [[https://i.imgur.com/vnlx5KC.jpeg green buff]] was made for, but not used in ''Palau''. Presumably, it would've been the merged tribe buff had [[FlawlessVictory Koror]] not've steamrolled Ulong.



* Similarly to ''Palau'', there was also an [[https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/survivor/images/5/50/S39_Unused_Frog_Buff.png/revision/latest?cb=20201020035814 unused green buff]] in ''Island of the Idols''. Judging by the seasons before it; it would've most likely been used for a third auxiliary tribe like Angkor or Ikabula.

to:

* Similarly to ''Palau'', there was also an [[https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/survivor/images/5/50/S39_Unused_Frog_Buff.png/revision/latest?cb=20201020035814 [[https://i.imgur.com/LPmOH4L.jpeg unused green buff]] in ''Island of the Idols''. Judging by the seasons before it; it would've most likely been used for a third auxiliary tribe like Angkor or Ikabula.

Added: 244

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Production wanted Ethan to be on Heroes vs. Villains but he was going through chemotherapy at the time, he and Jenna were asked to be on South Pacific as captains but they declined as they didn't want to compete against each other so Coach and Ozzy were asked instead, he was once again asked to come back for Game Changers but had to turn it down becuase he would only arrive home two days before his wedding.
* ''Survivor 41'' was going to be called ''Dawn of a New Era'' before they decided to stop using sub-titles for this season and beyond.

to:

* Production wanted Ethan to be on Heroes vs. Villains but he was going through chemotherapy at the time, he and Jenna were asked to be on South Pacific as captains but they declined as they didn't want to compete against each other so Coach and Ozzy were asked instead, he was once again asked to come back for Game Changers but had to turn it down becuase because he would only arrive home two days before his wedding.
* ''Survivor 41'' was going to be called ''Dawn of a New Era'' before they decided to stop using sub-titles for this season and beyond.beyond.
* On Cambodia, had Kass made it to the family visit she would have brought on J'Tia as her loved one and Stephen wanted to bring JT as his loved one but production thought that having a past winner come back would have been an unfair advantage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

'''WARNING''': Spoilers ahead are unmarked. You have been warned.


!!! For the TV series:
* The hosting job for ''Survivor'' came down to Jeff Probst and [[Series/TheAmazingRace Phil Keoghan]]. Probst got it due to his live TV work and due to an interview on Access Hollywood where he flirted with Sandra Bullock. However, if Probst hadn't been chosen, imagine what both Survivor and The Amazing Race would be like with Phil as the Survivor host.
* ''Survivor'' beat out an attempted revival of ''Series/WhatsMyLine'' for a prime time slot. Imagine how different television would have been had CBS picked that up instead...
* Shane Powers was actually intended to return ''twice'', but both times, got replaced. He was intended to return in ''Micronesia'', but was replaced by Jonny Fairplay. Shane was ''also'' intended to return in ''Heroes vs. Villains'', but was replaced by Russell.
** He also could have been voted into ''Cambodia'', but didn't get enough votes.
** He also turned down ''Blood vs. Water'' because he didn't want to have to play against his son.
* Other people were considered to return for the show. Sandra was actually one of the people dropped at the last moment in ''Micronesia''. Tom Westman was asked to come back to ''Micronesia'', but he declined the offer.
** Sandra was also asked to come back for ''All-Stars'', but she declined as she was recovering from parasites that she picked up from her time in ''Pearl Islands''.
* The original filming location intended for Season 4 was the country of Jordan, but due to [[UsefulNotes/TheWarOnTerror a certain event in America in 2001]], it was changed to Marquesas.
* A [[https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/survivor/images/a/a3/Unused_Palau_Merge_Buff.JPG/revision/latest?cb=20190702030125 green buff]] was made for, but not used in ''Palau''. Presumably, it would've been the merged tribe buff had [[FlawlessVictory Koror]] not've steamrolled Ulong.
* Season 11 was originally planned to be set in an Indian Ocean locale (UsefulNotes/{{Madagascar}}, [[UsefulNotes/{{India}} southern India]], and UsefulNotes/SriLanka were all scouted), but it was changed to Guatemala due to the Boxing Day tsunami.
* Some castaways, prior to being eventually selected for ''Survivor'', initially applied for ''Series/TheAmazingRace'' first. Some examples are [[Characters/SurvivorCookIslands Parvati Shallow]], [[Characters/SurvivorFiji Earl Cole]], [[Characters/SurvivorSamoa Natalie White]], [[Characters/SurvivorOneWorld Monica]] & [[Characters/SurvivorBloodVsWater Brad Culpepper]], and [[Characters/SurvivorSanJuanDelSur Kelley Wentworth, Jon Misch, and Jaclyn Schultz]].
* Richard Hatch was supposed to be on ''Heroes vs. Villains'' as well, but he was under house arrest at the time and wasn't able to get permission from the courts to leave the country to film it. Additionally, both Yau-Man Chan and Corinne Kaplan had to turn down coming back due to work obligations.
* [[Characters/SurvivorPanama Tina Scheer]] was going to be in ''Guatemala'' but her son died through a car accident and [[Characters/SurvivorGuatemala Amy O'Hara]] went on to replace her.
* ''Redemption Island'' was originally planned as Russell vs. Richard, with the tribes comprised of returning players chosen in a draft. After Richard was denied permission to leave the country again, the draft idea was scrapped and Boston Rob, Russell's rival from ''Heroes vs. Villains'', was chosen as Richard's replacement.
* ''Fiji'' is so far the only season with an odd number of players as well as the first with a gender imbalance, due to one of the players quitting and not being replaced.
** Additionally it was rumored that this was supposed to have a similar tribe split as in Cook Islands, which is further hinted to by the fact there were 5 Caucasian-American castaways (Gary, Melissa, Rocky, Boo, and Jessica), 5 Hispanic-American castaways (Liliana, Lisi, Alex, Rita, and Edgardo), 5 Asian-American castaways (Sylvia, Michelle, Mookie, Yau-Man, and Stacy), and 5 African American castaways (Anthony, Erica, Cassandra, Dreamz, and Earl) though this was changed after Melissa dropped out. Given the UnfortunateImplications this created last time, this wasn't necessarily a bad thing.
* [[Characters/SurvivorAfrica Kelly Goldsmith]] was an alternate for the ''All-Stars'' season but was replaced with Shii-Ann at the last minute. She was also approached for ''Heroes vs. Villains'', but declined when casting wouldn't tell her the concept behind the season. She was approached a third time, for ''Blood vs. Water'', and had planned on playing, but had to decline when none of the loved ones she had chosen were able to play.
* [[Characters/SurvivorBloodvsWater Hayden]] [[Characters/BigBrother12 Moss]] was going to be on ''Nicaragua'' but they put Fabio on that season instead and they went on to put Hayden on ''Series/BigBrother''.
* [[Characters/SurvivorPhilippines Abi-Maria]] [[Characters/SurvivorCambodia Gomes]] was originally going to be on ''Tocantins'' but because of production feeling that she had a good layout of the land, they didn't put her on the season.
* [[Characters/SurvivorPhilippines R.C. Saint-Amour]] was originally going to compete in ''Blood vs. Water'' with her father, Craig. However, just before the game started, Craig's blood pressure shot up too high, and they were unable to compete. Instead, Candice and her husband John were brought in as a last minute replacement. In fact, the season's original theme was going to be "blood tribes" vs. "water tribes" before they were pulled out and the theme was switched to "returning players vs. their families". This makes ''Blood vs. Water'' something of an ArtifactTitle. She was also asked for ''Cambodia'', but declined.
* Two players have left ''San Juan del Sur'' just before filming, resulting in the "redemption island" twist being played axed altogether, and forcing the players to have a gender imbalance for the first time since Fiji. Probst confirmed this in an interview, and did not state why they had to leave. (Fans assume something similar to what happened to Craig Saint-Amour or in [[Series/TheAmazingRace The Amazing Race 24]].) One of the supposed players, So Kim, then eventually competed in the following season.
* According to Jeff Probst, some players declined to return for ''Cambodia'', including Greg Buis from ''Borneo'', Elisabeth Hasselbeck from ''The Australian Outback'', Ian Rosenberger from ''Palau'', Brett Clouser and Shambo Waters from ''Samoa'', Jeff Kent and RC Saint-Amour from ''Phillipines'', and Josh Canfield from ''San Juan Del Sur''. CBS contacted Jon Misch, also from ''San Juan Del Sur'', about participating, but he missed the call and didn't check his voicemail in time.
** Speaking of ''Cambodia'', it has been confirmed that had Mike Holloway not invalided himself by winning ''Worlds Apart'', he would have made the roster of the season.
* [[Characters/SurvivorMillennialsVsGenX Adam Klein]] and his mother applied to be on ''San Juan Del Sur'' but had to withdraw due to her cancer diagnosis. He was given a standing invitation to appear on a later season.
* [[Characters/SurvivorSanJuanDelSur Natalie Anderson]] was supposed to come back for ''Game Changers'', however, she suffered a serious concussion just before she was due to fly out to Fiji and was forced to pull out as a result.
* [[Characters/SurvivorDavidVsGoliath Davie Rickenbacker]] was never originally intended to be on ''David vs. Goliath'', but on the following season. Instead, somebody else cast for that season left during the pre-season press interviews for unknown reasons, causing Davie to take his spot at the very last minute.
* [[Characters/SurvivorIslandOfTheIdols Dan Spilo]] was originally cast for ''Edge of Extinction'', but broke his foot a few days before he was supposed to leave for Fiji, and so was bumped to the following season. Yeah, let's just say the girls on ''Edge'' may have dodged a ''huge'' bullet there...
* Similarly to ''Palau'', there was also an [[https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/survivor/images/5/50/S39_Unused_Frog_Buff.png/revision/latest?cb=20201020035814 unused green buff]] in ''Island of the Idols''. Judging by the seasons before it; it would've most likely been used for a third auxiliary tribe like Angkor or Ikabula.
* ''Fiji'' winner Earl Cole declined to return for ''Winners at War'' because it would've meant missing the birth of his child.
* Production wanted Ethan to be on Heroes vs. Villains but he was going through chemotherapy at the time, he and Jenna were asked to be on South Pacific as captains but they declined as they didn't want to compete against each other so Coach and Ozzy were asked instead, he was once again asked to come back for Game Changers but had to turn it down becuase he would only arrive home two days before his wedding.
* ''Survivor 41'' was going to be called ''Dawn of a New Era'' before they decided to stop using sub-titles for this season and beyond.

Top