Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WhatCouldHaveBeen / PokemonGoldAndSilver

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Tense correction


* The map in the 1997 demo is significantly more expansive than Johto or Kanto (although not as big as the two regions combined) and had a much larger scale, being based on the entire Japanese archipelago instead of just the Kansai, Chubu and Kanto regions. There are even cities based on Kyushu (Hoenn) and Hokkaido (Sinnoh). Kanto is already present, but it's more cut down than in the final game, being reduced to just one large map with a vaguely similar layout and a few notable landmarks (Pallet Town, the department store, the Silph Co. building, Mt. Moon, the Pokémon Tower, etc). It would have worked as a city (the last one visited before traveling to the Pokémon League, if its position on the world map is any indication), and Red (possibly named "Blue" here; not to be confused with the Gen I rival, who went by "Green") would have served as its Gym Leader.[[note]]Interestingly, toward the end of the [=Red/Green/Blue=] saga, Pokémon Adventures implied that Red would become a Gym Leader in the future. The manga had been showing clear Gen II influences by this point, such as cameos of Ho-Oh and the Firebreather trainer class. Similarly, the beginning of the Yellow saga seemed to be setting up for it to happen, with Misty revealing that Red had asked her for help in getting official permission to become a Gym Leader. It's likely that these were [[EarlyDraftTieIn remnants of early plans to have Red as a Leader in the incoming Gold and Silver saga,]] to coincide with his role in early versions of the game (the manga's writer implied that he has access to builds of Pokémon games during their development). When the GSC saga finally happened, it was revealed that [[AbortedArc Red was allowed to become a Leader but had to decline due to certain health issues related to the time spent frozen in ice,]] so Blue took the position instead, mimicking the game's final version.[[/note]]

to:

* The map in the 1997 demo is significantly more expansive than Johto or Kanto (although not as big as the two regions combined) and had a much larger scale, being based on the entire Japanese archipelago instead of just the Kansai, Chubu and Kanto regions. There are even cities based on Kyushu (Hoenn) and Hokkaido (Sinnoh). Kanto is already present, but it's more cut down than in the final game, being reduced to just one large map with a vaguely similar layout and a few notable landmarks (Pallet Town, the department store, the Silph Co. building, Mt. Moon, the Pokémon Tower, etc). It would have worked as a city (the last one visited before traveling to the Pokémon League, if its position on the world map is any indication), and Red (possibly named "Blue" here; not to be confused with the Gen I rival, who went by "Green") would have served as its Gym Leader.[[note]]Interestingly, toward the end of the [=Red/Green/Blue=] saga, Pokémon Adventures implied that Red would become a Gym Leader in the future. The manga had been showing clear Gen II influences by this point, such as cameos of Ho-Oh and the Firebreather trainer class. Similarly, the beginning of the Yellow saga seemed to be setting up for it to happen, with Misty revealing that Red had asked her for help in getting official permission to become a Gym Leader. It's likely that these were [[EarlyDraftTieIn remnants of early plans to have Red as a Leader in the incoming Gold and Silver saga,]] to coincide with his role in early versions of the game (the manga's writer implied that he has had access to builds of Pokémon games during their development). When the GSC saga finally happened, it was revealed that [[AbortedArc Red was allowed to become a Leader but had to decline due to certain health issues related to the time spent frozen in ice,]] so Blue took the position instead, mimicking the game's final version.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixed weird way of saying something


* The 1997 Space World demo featured completely different starters (the above-mentioned ones), different Japanese names for the Pokémon, and a vastly different overworld. It also had the starting town as named "Silent Hills". Some of the original names were: "Elebaby" for Elekid, "Pukuu" for Harisen (Qwilfish), "Sunny" for Kimawari (Sunflora), "Painter" for Doble (Smeargle), and "Yoroidori" for Airmd (Skarmory).

to:

* The 1997 Space World demo featured completely different starters (the above-mentioned ones), different Japanese names for the Pokémon, and a vastly different overworld. It also had the The starting town as was named "Silent Hills". Hills." Some of the original names were: "Elebaby" for Elekid, "Pukuu" for Harisen (Qwilfish), "Sunny" for Kimawari (Sunflora), "Painter" for Doble (Smeargle), and "Yoroidori" for Airmd (Skarmory).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


** Pinsir and Ditto were also originally going to get new evolutions. Pinsir's evolution being Scizor's counterpart: it evolved via trading (at one point with a Metal Coat), was a Bug/Steel-type, and used the same BST as it's pre-evolution but with different stat distribution. It was likely scrapped due being ''too'' similar to Scizor and was later reworked into Heracross.

to:

** Pinsir and Ditto were also originally going to get new evolutions. Pinsir's evolution being Scizor's counterpart: it evolved via trading (at one point with a Metal Coat), was a Bug/Steel-type, and used the same BST as it's its pre-evolution but with different stat distribution. It was likely scrapped due being ''too'' similar to Scizor and was later reworked into Heracross.

Changed: 92

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* There was a cut DeliveryStork Pokémon.

to:

* There was a cut DeliveryStork Pokémon.Pokémon, which may eventually have been revisited as [[VideoGame/PokemonScarletAndViolet Bombirdier]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Originally there were two towns between Violet City and Goldenrod City, later merged into Azalea Town. There was also no Cianwood City -- the sea routes beyond Olivine City would instead go south and then east, connecting to Goldenrod City.

to:

* The Johto region itself went under many changes:
**
Originally there were two towns between Violet City and Goldenrod City, based on the cities of Shingu and Arida in Wakayama Prefecture. Both of them were later merged into Azalea Town. Town.
**
There was also no Cianwood City -- the sea routes beyond Olivine City would instead go south and then east, connecting to Goldenrod City.City.
** Cherrygrove City was originally ''much'' larger, looking far more like an actual city.
* The internal trainer class list suggests that the order of the Gym Leaders was different: Whitney was 2nd, Bugsy was 3rd, Pryce was 5th, and Chuck was 7th. Whitney and Bugsy later swapped places, as did Pryce and Chuck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The demo features two cut Gym Leaders named Gama (which may have been a prototype of Clair) and Okera. Both use generic sprites from other classes rather than individual sprites.

to:

** The demo features two cut Gym Leaders named Gama (which may have been a prototype of Clair) and Okera. Okera (who is thought to be a prototype of Pryce, due to several leaked files referring to him as Okera[[note]]for reference, Pryce’s final Japanese name is Yanagi[[/note]]). Both respectively use generic the Gen I Camper and Super Nerd sprites from other classes rather than individual sprites.as placeholders.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pinsir and Ditto were also originally going to get new evolutions. Pinsir's evolution being Scizor's counterpart: it evolved via trading (at one point with a Metal Coat), was a Bug/Steel-type, and used the same BST as it's pre-evolution but with different stat distribution. It was likely scrapped due being ''too'' similar to Scizor.

to:

** Pinsir and Ditto were also originally going to get new evolutions. Pinsir's evolution being Scizor's counterpart: it evolved via trading (at one point with a Metal Coat), was a Bug/Steel-type, and used the same BST as it's pre-evolution but with different stat distribution. It was likely scrapped due being ''too'' similar to Scizor.Scizor and was later reworked into Heracross.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* The Steel type had practically nothing to do with the one we know. It was weak to Water and Electric (which merely resist Steel-type attacks now), resisted Poison (instead of being immune), Fighting (instead of being weak) and Rock (the only interaction that was kept), and was notably immune to itself (whereas it's now a resistance).

to:

* The Steel type was originally Metal, and had practically nothing to do with the one we know. It was weak to Water and Electric (which merely resist Steel-type attacks now), resisted Poison (instead of being immune), Fighting (instead of being weak) and Rock (the only interaction that was kept), and was notably immune to itself (whereas it's now a resistance).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Confirmed not true


* In an "Iwata Asks" interview, it was confirmed that ''Gold & Silver'' were intended to be the last installments in the series, hence the final battle with Red, as the developers felt that they were too much of a ToughActToFollow. However, they were so popular that the developers created ''Pokémon Crystal'', and the rest is history.

Top