Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WhatAnIdiot / LiveActionTVSToU

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Instead:''' Lestrade shows up himself with a handful of officers, ''none of whom are armed.'' When the mastermind pulls a gun on Sherlock, the police are literally powerless to intervene, and Mary is killed taking the bullet for Sherlock.

to:

'''Instead:''' Lestrade shows up himself with a handful of officers, ''none ''[[TheGreatBritishCopperCapture none of whom are armed.armed]].'' When the mastermind pulls a gun on Sherlock, the police are literally powerless to intervene, and Mary is killed taking the bullet for Sherlock.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving to its page.



* ''Series/SesameStreet'': From Seasons 3-16, Big Bird's friend Mr. Snuffleupagus was [[NotSoImaginaryFriend thought to be his imaginary friend]] by the adults of the street, despite not even bothering to see him (or made aware of his presence for that matter). Big Bird tries constantly to prove he's not imagining by bringing the adults to show Snuffy to them, but Snuffy has a habit of leaving early due to forgetting something or remembering he has to be somewhere.\\
'''You'd Expect:''' For Big Bird to get someone else who knows Snuffy to stay and watch over him so he does not leave.\\
'''Instead:''' He never bothers to do this and right when the adults come, Snuffy's gone. It's only by the time of the Season 17 premiere does Gordon suggest this advice, which in turn helps Big Bird succeed at last with Elmo's help.\\
'''Alternatively You'd Expect:''' Snuffy to shout or holler at the adults to get them to turn around when he passes by.\\
'''Instead:''' He just keeps silent, likely due to his shy nature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/{{Siren}}'':

to:

* ''Series/{{Siren}}'':''Series/Siren2018'':



*** '''Instead''': They linger and investigate until Donna and her hunting party attack, [[spoiler: which results in the senior McClure's death]].
** Xander McClure has just found out that the Merman who murdered his father is back in town, and has his gun [[ItsPersonal with intent to kill]]. Ryn has just defused the situation with Donna and Katrina, but Xander is still armed and out for blood.

to:

*** '''Instead''': They linger and investigate until Donna and her hunting party attack, [[spoiler: which results in the senior McClure's [=McClure's=] death]].
** Xander McClure [=McClure=] has just found out that the Merman who murdered his father is back in town, and has his gun [[ItsPersonal with intent to kill]]. Ryn has just defused the situation with Donna and Katrina, but Xander is still armed and out for blood.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/{{Siren}}'':
** The series starts off with a fishing boat crewman (Chris) and a Mermaid (Donna) being abducted by the Federal Government, the former for clandestine healing, the latter to be subjected to human experimentation.
*** '''You'd Expect''': Xander and/or Ben to contact a Lawyer, invoke Whistleblower Protections, and file an information request regarding the fate of their friend.
*** '''Instead''': They keep quiet and instead plan to break into a government facility and break Chris out.
** Almost as soon as Ryn first crawls out of the water onto land, Mermaids and Mermen start committing crimes and causing legal trouble.
*** '''You'd Expect''': Ben and/or Maddie to eventually wisen up and contact a Lawyer to represent Ryn and the rest of her clan.
*** '''Instead''': Ben and Maddie decide to keep up TheMasquerade and keep the Mermaids a secret, telling only Maddie's father (the sherriff) and local shopkeeper Helen Hawkins (who was already in the know [[spoiler: due to being the descendant of a Mermaid]]).
** Ben & company's upholding of TheMasquerade frequently uses lame excuses or non-answers in response to legal questions over Mermaids (and Mermen) stealing or breaking things, or even assaulting or killing people.
*** '''You'd Expect''': Ben to contact a Lawyer to represent Ryn and the others, and provide plausible explanations that don't involve Mermaids (eg. self-defense, a shipment of refugees, escapee from a Federal Black Site, etc.).
*** '''Instead''': Ben and Maddie continue to uphold the Masquerade, relying on HeroInsurance as a form of Plot Armor, even when it costs Maddie's father his position as Sherriff of Bristol Cove.
** Decker is in command of the facility where Donna is being experimented on and where Chris is in recovery, and is having ethical concernes about his superiors' behavior.
*** '''You'd Expect''': Decker to contact a Lawyer and invoke the Whistleblower Act, [[ToUnmasqueTheWorld tearing down the cover-up about Mermaids]] [[InhumanableAlienRights to ensure the rights of sapient beings are protected]].
*** '''Or Better Yet''': Decker could have contacted a Lawyer ''immediately'', conducted tests to confirm that Donna was sapient, and then called in more lawyers to ensure the fair treatment of Mermaids.
*** '''Instead''': Decker [[JustFollowingOrders meekly obeys his Navy superiors and continues experimenting]].
*** '''Even Worse''': Donna manages to escape on her own, and Decker's attempt to resolve the situation peacefully [[spoiler: gets both of them killed]].
** Ben, Xander, and Xander's father have just discovered an abandoned fishing boat in the ocean.
*** '''You'd expect''': Them to call the Coast Guard ''immediately'' and then [[ScrewThisImOuttaHere get the hell out of dodge]].
*** '''Instead''': They linger and investigate until Donna and her hunting party attack, [[spoiler: which results in the senior McClure's death]].
** Xander McClure has just found out that the Merman who murdered his father is back in town, and has his gun [[ItsPersonal with intent to kill]]. Ryn has just defused the situation with Donna and Katrina, but Xander is still armed and out for blood.
*** '''You'd expect''': Ben to shout "GET DOWN!" or try to defuse the situation verbally.
*** '''Instead''': Ben engages in a GunStruggle with Xander [[spoiler: that gets Donna killed by a stray bullet]].
** The inciting incident of season 2 starts when an oil company starts doing loud sonar tests to find off-shore oil, displacing Ryn's entire mermaid clan from their homes. The clan need to return to the sea periodically, or suffer adverse health effects.
*** '''You'd Expect''': Ben to contact a Lawyer and file a Noise Pollution lawsuit against the oil company, citing more mundane effects of noise pollution (eg. sea lions being forced out of the water, risk of injury or death to scuba divers, adverse effects on Bristol Cove's tourism industry, etc.).
*** '''Instead''': Ben keeps Ryn and her clan sheltered in a cabin, without directly confronting the oil company.
** About half of the problems the protagonists in the series face could have been averted if someone had [[BrokenMasquerade wizened up about the counter-productivity of the Masquerade]] and contacted a Lawyer instead. [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot Just think of the legal drama that could be promised from the show's premise]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Result:''' The judges give her a mediocre review.

to:

'''Result:''' The judges give her a mediocre review.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
wasn't he trying to kill them?


** In the third episode, Cho Sang-woo realizes what game they're about to play, and that Gi-hun and Il-nam are almost certainly heading to their deaths.\\
'''You'd expect:''' He warns them to choose the triangle, so that he won't lose his two closest allies in the second game out of six.\\
'''Instead:''' He lets them choose difficult shapes, knowing that the penalty for losing is death.\\
'''The Result:''' They both survive by the skin of their teeth with mere seconds to spare. Things worked out for him this time, but he almost sacrificed two people he would need to survive later rounds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/SechsAufEinenStreich'':
** In ''Prinzessin Maleen'', probably to avoid being too sympathetic in the audience's eyes, Walpurga brings her downfall on herself by several bouts of utter idiocy:
*** She needs to get married to inherit her wealth. However, she plans to kill her future husband Konrad because she has no wish to be tied to a poor Landgraf.\\
'''You'd Expect''': Her to do so gradually to avoid suspicion.\\
'''Instead''': She plans to kill him right on the wedding day.
*** Afraid of being found out to be ugly before the marriage is finalized, she sends Maleen as her stand-in to the wedding ceremony. However, Konrad grows suspicious when Walpurga doesn't remember what "she" said on her way to the church and doesn't have the gift he gave "her". Mind: when Walpurga reveals her face, he is only briefly startled before talking to her normally.\\
'''You'd Expect''': Walpurga to confess at once that she switched places with a maid for fear of her own face repulsing him and the guests. She can see that Konrad doesn't mind her ugliness and will be sympathetic towards her. Of course, their marriage will still be dissolved once Konrad finds out the maid is his fiancee whom he thought dead, but they'll surely help Walpurga with her own inheritance troubles or at least treat her with respect.\\
'''Instead''': Walpurga blurts out increasingly unconvincing lies and tries to have Maleen executed for stealing and to get Konrad poisoned. She is found out and banished and loses all her possessions.
** In ''Das Märchen von den zwölf Monaten'', The Frost Prince allies himself with February to bring down the rest of the twelve months and Queen Klara who keeps the calendar going. They are gradually poisoning the queen, and only a few hours remain until the calendar goes haywire for good. The last ingredient in a medicine that can cure Klara has to be provided by February (the last winter snow).\\
'''You'd Expect''': The Prince to treat February with respect and kindness ''at least'' until the calendar has safely collapsed.\\
'''Instead''': When there is still time to prepare Queen Klara's medicine, the Prince gloats that he doesn't plan to share his power and that February will be just his servant. That becomes the last push towards February's HeelFaceTurn, and he helps prepare the medicine; Klara is cured and defeats the Prince.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/The10thKingdom'':\\

to:

* ''Series/The10thKingdom'':\\''Series/The10thKingdom'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved What An Idiot example to this page per Wick Cleaning Project

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/TopChef'': One chef is serving a crowd. She is aware that she will have to prepare her dish in advance because she won't be able to do so on site.\\
'''You'd Expect''': She would choose a recipe that would work in advance: crème caramel, cakes, cookies..\\
'''Instead''': She makes [[https://bakerbynature.com/new-orleans-style-beignets/ beignets]] in advance.\\
'''Result:''' The judges give her a mediocre review.
'''Even worse:''' She says outright she wishes she could have made them to order, but couldn't because of the challenge. The judges call her out in that if she was already aware of the glaring flaw in being unable to make beignets fresh, then she should have just done something else.

Added: 1013

Removed: 1013

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



* ''Series/SesameStreet'': From Seasons 3-16, Big Bird's friend Mr. Snuffleupagus was [[NotSoImaginaryFriend thought to be his imaginary friend]] by the adults of the street, despite not even bothering to see him (or made aware of his presence for that matter). Big Bird tries constantly to prove he's not imagining by bringing the adults to show Snuffy to them, but Snuffy has a habit of leaving early due to forgetting something or remembering he has to be somewhere.\\
'''You'd Expect:''' For Big Bird to get someone else who knows Snuffy to stay and watch over him so he does not leave.\\
'''Instead:''' He never bothers to do this and right when the adults come, Snuffy's gone. It's only by the time of the Season 17 premiere does Gordon suggest this advice, which in turn helps Big Bird succeed at last with Elmo's help.\\
'''Alternatively You'd Expect:''' Snuffy to shout or holler at the adults to get them to turn around when he passes by.\\
'''Instead:''' He just keeps silent, likely due to his shy nature.



* ''Series/SesameStreet'': From Seasons 3-16, Big Bird's friend Mr. Snuffleupagus was [[NotSoImaginaryFriend thought to be his imaginary friend]] by the adults of the street, despite not even bothering to see him (or made aware of his presence for that matter). Big Bird tries constantly to prove he's not imagining by bringing the adults to show Snuffy to them, but Snuffy has a habit of leaving early due to forgetting something or remembering he has to be somewhere.\\
'''You'd Expect:''' For Big Bird to get someone else who knows Snuffy to stay and watch over him so he does not leave.\\
'''Instead:''' He never bothers to do this and right when the adults come, Snuffy's gone. It's only by the time of the Season 17 premiere does Gordon suggest this advice, which in turn helps Big Bird succeed at last with Elmo's help.\\
'''Alternatively You'd Expect:''' Snuffy to shout or holler at the adults to get them to turn around when he passes by.\\
'''Instead:''' He just keeps silent, likely due to his shy nature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the third season of ''Series/SearchParty'', Dory and Drew are on trial for murdering Dory's StalkerWithACrush Keith, something which they're very much guilty of. District Attorney Danziger presents a confession that was CaughtOnTape and which Dory tried to destroy in the season premiere, but due to the damage that Dory caused, half of the courtroom thinks she's saying she "murdered" Keith, and the other half thinks she's claiming to have "pancaked" (supposedly a sex act involving pancakes) Keith.\\
'''You'd Expect:''' Danziger to point out that Dory tried to destroy the tape after she was arrested for murder, and that there's no logical reason why she'd have gone to such lengths to destroy a taped confession of her performing a weird sex act on someone.\\
'''Instead:''' She makes a largely baseless ([[AccidentalTruth but correct]]) accusation that Dory murdered her former downstairs neighbor, who recorded the tape in question. Dory's lawyer immediately objects, and the judge gets annoyed enough that he rules the tape inadmissible, all but destroying Danziger's case.

Top