Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / ThePenguinsofMadagascar

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** What, Kowalski can't be transgendered? A male penguin stuck in a female penguin body. It's probably the reason he couldn't be with Doris, because she found out and couldn't accept him for who he really was. So, when the gender issue came about he rigged the test in his favor so that his teammates wouldn't discover his biological gender and shun him, too. He never admitted the truth, and after seeing how Skipper was treated when they though he was a female, I doubt he ever will.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Personally I'd bet on Rico. His gruff voice may be less due to testosterone than throat damage from coughing up running chainsaws...
** Well, in "Tagged" Rico ''did'' grin at the idea of Skipper preening him. Miss Perky could be a bluff. She's not been seen for a while. Trouble is, ALL of the penguins act AmbiguouslyGay at times, and if one of them is female then somebody else is, to put it basically... not.
*** Skipper, as the leader, is right out (plus his 1950s style sexism towards Marlene also puts him out). We've seen Private's thoughts, and he's just incredibly babyish - rainbows and unicorns, anybody? Kowalski has Doris, and when he fantasised about that jeep he called it 'she'. I'd call it on Rico, and Miss Perky was a bluff that he seems to have forgotten about. That, or she was a cover for him being gay. Trouble is that all those AmbiguouslyGay moments mean somebody's not good at hiding it.

to:

* Personally I'd bet on Rico. His gruff voice may be less due to testosterone than throat damage from coughing up running chainsaws...
** Well, in "Tagged" Rico ''did'' grin at the idea of Skipper preening him. Miss Perky could be a bluff. She's not been seen for a while. Trouble is, ALL of the penguins act AmbiguouslyGay at times, and if one of them is female then somebody else is, to put it basically... not.
***
Skipper, as the leader, is right out (plus his 1950s style sexism towards Marlene also puts him out). We've seen Private's thoughts, and he's just incredibly babyish - rainbows and unicorns, anybody? Kowalski has Doris, and when he fantasised about that jeep he called it 'she'. I'd call it on Rico, and Miss Perky was a bluff that he seems to have forgotten about. That, or she was a cover for him being gay. Trouble is that all those AmbiguouslyGay moments mean somebody's not good at hiding it.\n
** Kowalski made the machine. He could make it lie - most likely for him.

Changed: 545

Removed: 401

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Did you just forget to mention Skipper?
** One female penguin bossing around all the males? If you thought Kowalski being female would cause protests...
** ''Miss Understanding'' already covered some of that ground, without even getting into the point above, as StatusQuoIsGod asserted itself before they could get into that aspect too much.
*** Obviously the penguins' frequent AmbiguouslyGay behaviour is what convinced Alice one was female.

to:

* Did you just forget to mention Skipper?
** One female penguin bossing around all the males? If you thought Kowalski being female would cause protests...
** ''Miss Understanding'' already covered some of that ground, without even getting into the point above, as StatusQuoIsGod asserted itself before they could get into that aspect too much.
***
Obviously the penguins' frequent AmbiguouslyGay behaviour is what convinced Alice one was female.



* Rico just seems too obvious, since he seems to have the most AG moments (for the purpose of messing with our heads, it seems). Skipper, as the leader, is right out (plus his massive 1950s style sexism also puts him down). We've seen Private's thoughts, and he's just incredibly babyish - rainbows and unicorns, anybody? I'd put my money on Kowalski and tell the fangirls they can suck on it. But chances are the writers have too much fun with the DoubleEntendres and AmbiguouslyGay scenes to ever tell us.

to:

* Rico just seems too obvious, since he seems to have the most AG moments (for the purpose of messing with our heads, it seems). *** Skipper, as the leader, is right out (plus his massive 1950s style sexism towards Marlene also puts him down). out). We've seen Private's thoughts, and he's just incredibly babyish - rainbows and unicorns, anybody? Kowalski has Doris, and when he fantasised about that jeep he called it 'she'. I'd put my money call it on Kowalski Rico, and tell the fangirls they can suck on it. But chances are the writers Miss Perky was a bluff that he seems to have too much fun with the DoubleEntendres and forgotten about. That, or she was a cover for him being gay. Trouble is that all those AmbiguouslyGay scenes to ever tell us.
moments mean somebody's not good at hiding it.



[[WMG: ''All'' penguins are biologically female.]]

to:

[[WMG: ''All'' of the penguins are biologically female.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Personally I'd bet on Rico. His gruff voice may be less due to testosterone than throat damage from coughing up chainsaws...
** Well, in "Tagged" Rico ''did'' grin at the idea of Skipper preening him. Miss Perky could be a bluff. Trouble is, ALL of the penguins act AmbiguouslyGay at times, and if one of them is female they're doing a stellar job of hiding it.

to:

* Personally I'd bet on Rico. His gruff voice may be less due to testosterone than throat damage from coughing up running chainsaws...
** Well, in "Tagged" Rico ''did'' grin at the idea of Skipper preening him. Miss Perky could be a bluff. She's not been seen for a while. Trouble is, ALL of the penguins act AmbiguouslyGay at times, and if one of them is female they're doing a stellar job then somebody else is, to put it basically... not.
* Rico just seems too obvious, since he seems to have the most AG moments (for the purpose
of hiding it.
messing with our heads, it seems). Skipper, as the leader, is right out (plus his massive 1950s style sexism also puts him down). We've seen Private's thoughts, and he's just incredibly babyish - rainbows and unicorns, anybody? I'd put my money on Kowalski and tell the fangirls they can suck on it. But chances are the writers have too much fun with the DoubleEntendres and AmbiguouslyGay scenes to ever tell us.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Obviously the penguins' AmbiguouslyGay behaviour is what convinced Alice one was female.
* Personally I'd bet on Rico. His gruff voice may be less due to testosterone than throat damage from coughing up chainsaws ...

to:

*** Obviously the penguins' frequent AmbiguouslyGay behaviour is what convinced Alice one was female.
* Personally I'd bet on Rico. His gruff voice may be less due to testosterone than throat damage from coughing up chainsaws ...
chainsaws...
** Well, in "Tagged" Rico ''did'' grin at the idea of Skipper preening him. Miss Perky could be a bluff. Trouble is, ALL of the penguins act AmbiguouslyGay at times, and if one of them is female they're doing a stellar job of hiding it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Joey is actually a girl.]]
It's suggested above that he could be FTM, but it's also possible he's actually a ciswoman with an unusually masculine voice. The only other marsupials in the zoo are the koalas, who are never awake when Joey is so she doesn't get to talk to them much, and the others aren't familiar enough with marsupial anatomy to know that only females have pouches. The reason "he's" constantly angry is because she's constantly being mistaken for male to the point that she's given up correcting everyone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Maybe, but it's still better than Hoboken.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** According to [[http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17972270 this article]], female ring-tailed lemurs have an enlarged clitoris, so at first glance anyone not familiar with lemurs may not notice, even if you assume they can see through his fur when the viewers of the cartoon can't thanks to artistic convention.

to:

** According to [[http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17972270 this article]], female ring-tailed lemurs have an enlarged clitoris, so at first glance anyone not familiar with lemurs may not notice, even if you assume they can see through his fur when the viewers of the cartoon can't thanks to artistic convention.
convention. Also, male lemurs have spurlike claws on their wrists which the females don't, and Julien doesn't appear to have those - ''probably'' just due to simplified cartoon anatomy, but it leaves the possibility open.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Fred is Zack. Fred dated Marlene and Zack dated Penny, and both suffer from the ''exact'' same kind of total stupidity.

to:

* Fred is Zack. Fred dated Marlene and Zack dated Penny, and both suffer from the ''exact'' same kind of total stupidity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Fred is Zack. Fred dated Marlene and Zack dated Penny, and both suffer from the ''exact'' same kind of total stupidity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Personally I'd bet on Rico. His gruff voice may be less due to testosterone than throat damage from coughing up chainsaws ...



Would reduce the UnfortunateImplications mentioned above, and the whole {{Discworld}}/MonstrousRegiment potential is fun.

to:

Would reduce the UnfortunateImplications mentioned above, and the whole {{Discworld}}/MonstrousRegiment potential is fun.
fun. The way with the fewest Unfortunate Implications and/or the most potential for humour would probably be if all of them except Private, who fills TheChick role, were female.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Maybe the penguins' AmbiguouslyGay behaviour is what convinced Alice one was female.

to:

** Maybe *** Obviously the penguins' AmbiguouslyGay behaviour is what convinced Alice one was female.



In ''his'' case, due to a slight mix-up, he was sent to an Earth realm rather than a Netherworld or Celestia. To cover for this, his soul was sown into a "sturdier" penguin-esque shell -- he would have stood out too much as a regular Prinny. He has most of a Prinny's regular abilities; but he likely ''won't'' explode if thrown, since penguins don't have easy access to quick resurrection. His atonement is to serve under Skipper and the others as a completely loyal soldier -- note the following:

to:

In ''his'' case, due to a slight mix-up, he was sent to an Earth realm rather than a Netherworld or Celestia. To cover for this, his soul was sown into a "sturdier" penguin-esque shell -- - he would have stood out too much as a regular Prinny. He has most of a Prinny's regular abilities; but he likely ''won't'' explode if thrown, since penguins don't have easy access to quick resurrection. His atonement is to serve under Skipper and the others as a completely loyal soldier -- note the following:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Central Park Zoo is classed by the penguins (and other animals) as a prison.]]
Most really good parks nowadays have wide open spaces. Take San Diego zoo, or Disney's Animal Kingdom in Florida. Huge, simulated natrual habitats - designed to fool even the animals there that they are really in the wild. Look at Central Park zoo - small enclosures, constant supervision, and many of the animals are violent or have massive mental problems. And a large number of them are always trying to get out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Maybe the penguins' AmbiguouslyGay behaviour is what convinced Alice one was female.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: ''All'' penguins are biologically female.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* If he was related or married to a high-ranking lemur but wasn't expected to actually wield power himself, that might explain why he's as spoilt and irresponsible as he is. It's possible that once he got the power, he wasn't sure what to do with it and went a bit off the rails.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** His instruction to Rico to deal with a girlfriend by obeying her unquestioningly might be a sign this way as well. Probably depends on how severe the usual lemur matriarchy is as to how much should be read into that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More reliable source than Wikipedia. I can\'t believe I bothered to look this up ...


** According to Wikipedia, female ring-tailed lemurs have an enlarged clitoris, so at first glance anyone not familiar with lemurs may not notice, even if you assume they can see through his fur when the viewers of the cartoon can't thanks to artistic convention.

to:

** According to Wikipedia, [[http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17972270 this article]], female ring-tailed lemurs have an enlarged clitoris, so at first glance anyone not familiar with lemurs may not notice, even if you assume they can see through his fur when the viewers of the cartoon can't thanks to artistic convention.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** According to Wikipedia, female ring-tailed lemurs have an enlarged clitoris, so at first glance anyone not familiar with lemurs may not notice, even if you assume they can see through his fur when the viewers of the cartoon can't thanks to artistic convention.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Kowalski also had a brief thing for Officer X's van before they were forced to destroy it in the line of duty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That way is not particularly up on widely-accepted transgender etiquette, but maybe they just didn't want to argue with the logic loop. Officially a female's supposed to rule, so he can only rule if he's female, but if he's the ruler he can do whatever he wants including declaring himself male ... Meh, either way they all seem to have ended up happy enough, and in a world where it's apparently fairly common to not notice one's own biological sex and Julien seemingly didn't know how to tell he was a mammal, you can't blame them.

to:

** That way is not particularly up on widely-accepted transgender etiquette, but maybe they just didn't want to argue with the logic loop. Officially a female's supposed to rule, so he can only rule if he's female, but if he's the ruler he can do whatever he wants including declaring himself male ... Meh, either way they all seem to have ended up happy enough, and in a world where it's apparently fairly common to not notice one's own biological sex and Julien seemingly didn't know how to tell he was a mammal, you can't blame them. Also, he's comfortable enough in his gender identity to dress as a girl on occasion (in the second movie and in the episode where he and the other lemurs were being cheerleaders), so if this is true it seems to be working pretty well for him - then again, dressing in drag may not have the same significance when he normally doesn't wear ''anything.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Or, keeping with the transgender theory, maybe he [[AmbiguouslyGay didn't mind the idea of marrying a male as such]] but wouldn't do it because he was expected to get pregnant to provide an heir. That might explain why Maurice must have helped him leave; the idea of Julien reproducing is pretty horrifying, regardless of which biological parent he'd be.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Not particularly up on transgender etiquette, but maybe they just didn't want to argue with the logic loop. Officially a female's supposed to rule, so he can only rule if he's female, but if he's the ruler he can do whatever he wants including declaring himself male ... Meh, either way they all seem to have ended up happy enough, and in a world where it's apparently fairly common to not notice one's own biological sex and Julien seemingly didn't know how to tell he was a mammal, you can't blame them.

to:

** Not That way is not particularly up on widely-accepted transgender etiquette, but maybe they just didn't want to argue with the logic loop. Officially a female's supposed to rule, so he can only rule if he's female, but if he's the ruler he can do whatever he wants including declaring himself male ... Meh, either way they all seem to have ended up happy enough, and in a world where it's apparently fairly common to not notice one's own biological sex and Julien seemingly didn't know how to tell he was a mammal, you can't blame them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not particularly up on transgender etiquette, but maybe they just didn't want to argue with the logic loop. Officially a female's supposed to rule, so he can only rule if he's female, but if he's the ruler he can do whatever he wants including declaring himself male ... Meh, either way they all seem to have ended up happy enough, and in a world where it's apparently fairly common to not notice one's own biological sex and Julien seemingly didn't know how to tell he was a mammal, you can't blame them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: More than one of the penguins is biologically female.]]
Would reduce the UnfortunateImplications mentioned above, and the whole {{Discworld}}/MonstrousRegiment potential is fun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Seconded. More specifically, the episode can be compared to [=McCarthy's=] Communist "witch-hunt" trials, with Rockgut representing Joseph [=McCarthy=]. (And the Red Squirrel's also got an accent in English.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Buck Rockgut is a TakeThat not only on paranoia in general, but also specifically on Cold War anti-communist paranoia.]]
Come on, the ''Red'' Squirrel? Also, I don't know about the English original, but in the German dub, the Red Squirrel has a slightly Russian accent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The Penguins will eventually get their very own cinema movie.]]
Because that would be awesome.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Fred the Squirrel ''really is'' the Red Squirrel.]]
It went JustAsPlanned. First, he was ObfuscatingStupidity in order to win the trust of the penguins (especially Private). Then, he manipulated them into finding Buck Rockgut's hideout. Then, he dressed up as the Red Squirrel in order to carry out the final phase of his plan, finally sending Rockgut away to nowhere. You don't believe it? Then you have to learn to think more like Rockgut. Do you know who also doesn't believe it? THE RED SQUIRREL!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* It's strange though, but Private seemed to be able to read in the episode "Tagged", when he was reading from that field guide. So if he can read, why shouldn't Kowalski be able to?

Top