Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / PennyDreadful

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Would Victor willingly use a tuberculosis sufferer as a source of body parts, though? His own mother died of the disease, so he's surely studied it in depth and would know how poor of a condition Brona's tissues (not just her lungs) would be in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Inherit the estate, perhaps? Victor doesn't presently have much money, yet he seems to have grown up quite wealthy. His mother says it's "just you and me" after the dog dies, suggesting his father was already deceased. Eliminating Caroline before Victor could come of age may have allowed a distant relative to lay claim to the family fortune.

to:

** Inherit the estate, perhaps? Victor doesn't presently have much money, yet he seems to have grown up quite wealthy. His mother says it's "just you and me" after the dog dies, suggesting his father was already deceased. Eliminating Caroline before Victor could come of age may have allowed a distant relative to lay usurp claim to the Frankenstein family fortune.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Inherit the estate, perhaps? Victor doesn't presently have much money, yet he seems to have grown up quite wealthy. Possibly eliminating Caroline before Victor could come of age allowed a distant relative to lay claim to the family fortune.

to:

** Inherit the estate, perhaps? Victor doesn't presently have much money, yet he seems to have grown up quite wealthy. Possibly eliminating His mother says it's "just you and me" after the dog dies, suggesting his father was already deceased. Eliminating Caroline before Victor could come of age may have allowed a distant relative to lay claim to the family fortune.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Inherit the estate, perhaps? Victor doesn't seem to have much money, yet he seems to have grown up quite wealthy. Possibly eliminating Caroline before Victor could come of age allowed a distant relative to lay claim to the family fortune.

to:

** Inherit the estate, perhaps? Victor doesn't seem to presently have much money, yet he seems to have grown up quite wealthy. Possibly eliminating Caroline before Victor could come of age allowed a distant relative to lay claim to the family fortune.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What motive would anyone have to kill her, though?

to:

* What motive would anyone have to kill her, though?though?
** Inherit the estate, perhaps? Victor doesn't seem to have much money, yet he seems to have grown up quite wealthy. Possibly eliminating Caroline before Victor could come of age allowed a distant relative to lay claim to the family fortune.

Added: 304

Changed: 209

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Awfully foggy night for the lamplighter to be noticing peoples' faces, however, and his lighter's pole was visible enough that it should've been easy for the killer to just keep some distance between them.
* From the sound of things, Caliban doesn't know ''how'' to construct a creature like himself without Frankenstein's help. In which case, it's doubtful he'd be gathering raw materials in advance: Victor's bound to drag his feet about getting started, and the parts would spoil before they could be used.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Tuberculosis (aka consumption) doesn't come on all at once like in "Resurrection"; it starts out as a normal fever with cough and gets progressively worse. Caroline exhibits no symptoms whatsoever up until she coughs blood all over herself. That's the sort of thing that'd be seen in poisoning with hemotoxins that destroy pulmonary capillaries, not in an infection.

to:

Tuberculosis (aka consumption) doesn't come on all at once like in "Resurrection"; it starts out as a normal fever with cough and gets progressively worse. Caroline exhibits no symptoms whatsoever up until she coughs blood all over herself. That's the sort of thing that'd be seen in poisoning with hemotoxins that destroy pulmonary capillaries, not in an infection.infection.
* What motive would anyone have to kill her, though?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Tuberculosis (aka consumption) doesn't come on all at once like in "Resurrection"; it starts out as a normal fever with cough and gets progressively worse. Caroline exhibits no symptoms whatsoever up until she coughs blood all over herself. That's the sort of thing that'd be seen in poisoning with hemotoxins that destroy pulmonary capillaries, not in infection.s

to:

Tuberculosis (aka consumption) doesn't come on all at once like in "Resurrection"; it starts out as a normal fever with cough and gets progressively worse. Caroline exhibits no symptoms whatsoever up until she coughs blood all over herself. That's the sort of thing that'd be seen in poisoning with hemotoxins that destroy pulmonary capillaries, not in an infection.s
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Tuberculosis (aka consumption) doesn't come on all at once like in "Resurrection"; it starts out as a normal fever with cough and gets progressively worse. Caroline exhibits no symptoms whatsoever up until she coughs blood all over herself. That's the sort of thing that seen in poisoning with hemotoxins that destroy pulmonary capillaries, not in infection.s

to:

Tuberculosis (aka consumption) doesn't come on all at once like in "Resurrection"; it starts out as a normal fever with cough and gets progressively worse. Caroline exhibits no symptoms whatsoever up until she coughs blood all over herself. That's the sort of thing that that'd be seen in poisoning with hemotoxins that destroy pulmonary capillaries, not in infection.s
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


He's the only major character who hasn't been recruited to Sir Malcolm's vampire-hunting crew, and his encounter with Brona suggests he's sufficiently jaded and turned on by the morbid to want to get it on with either a demon-possessed Vanessa (once he gets over his fear) or one of those white-haired vampire women. Either desire would provide motive for him to sell out Sir Malcolm's team. Plus, the series is an obvious SpiritualSuccessor to ''ComicBook/TheLeagueOfExtraordinaryGentlemen'', and any such homage wouldn't be complete without a Griffin plotting treachery.

to:

He's the only major character who hasn't been recruited to Sir Malcolm's vampire-hunting crew, and his encounter with Brona suggests he's sufficiently jaded and turned on by the morbid to want to get it on with either a demon-possessed Vanessa (once he gets over his fear) or one of those white-haired vampire women. Either desire would provide motive for him to sell out Sir Malcolm's team. Plus, the series is an obvious SpiritualSuccessor to ''ComicBook/TheLeagueOfExtraordinaryGentlemen'', and any such homage wouldn't be complete without a Griffin plotting treachery.treachery.

[[WMG: Caroline Frankenstein was murdered.]]
Tuberculosis (aka consumption) doesn't come on all at once like in "Resurrection"; it starts out as a normal fever with cough and gets progressively worse. Caroline exhibits no symptoms whatsoever up until she coughs blood all over herself. That's the sort of thing that seen in poisoning with hemotoxins that destroy pulmonary capillaries, not in infection.s
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Frankenstein's met her once already and probably will again since she's a buddy of Ethan, giving him ample opportunity to learn where she lives and kidnap her; he'll probably reason to himself that she's going to die soon anyway and want to spare her the horrible end of his mother, and just think of the lovely, ''lovely'' angst this will cause for everyone!

to:

Frankenstein's met her once already and probably will again since she's a buddy of Ethan, giving him ample opportunity to learn where she lives and kidnap her; he'll probably reason to himself that she's going to die soon anyway and want to spare her the horrible end of his mother, and just think of the lovely, ''lovely'' angst this will cause for everyone!everyone!

[[WMG: Dorian Gray will be an antagonist, not one of the (anti-)heroes of the story.]]
He's the only major character who hasn't been recruited to Sir Malcolm's vampire-hunting crew, and his encounter with Brona suggests he's sufficiently jaded and turned on by the morbid to want to get it on with either a demon-possessed Vanessa (once he gets over his fear) or one of those white-haired vampire women. Either desire would provide motive for him to sell out Sir Malcolm's team. Plus, the series is an obvious SpiritualSuccessor to ''ComicBook/TheLeagueOfExtraordinaryGentlemen'', and any such homage wouldn't be complete without a Griffin plotting treachery.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** No new dismemberments in episode 3 either, which would make sense if his transformations are on a lunar cycle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* If he's a werewolf based on actual 19th century penny dreadfuls rather than Universal horror films, we can expect OurWerewolvesAreDifferent to apply, e.g. he may have made a DealWithTheDevil to become one, and wouldn't be able to transmit his condition by biting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* There's clearly something supernatural about him; he could control the wolves in the zoo, and when Victor wants some of his blood for a transfusion he flat out refuses, saying that it's "not a good idea."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Frankenstein's met her once already and probably will again since she's a buddy of Ethan, giving him ample opportunity to learn where she lives and kidnap her; he'll probably reason to himself that she's going to die soon anyway and want to spare her the horrible end of his mother, and just think of the lovely, ''lovely'' angst this will cause for everyone

to:

Frankenstein's met her once already and probably will again since she's a buddy of Ethan, giving him ample opportunity to learn where she lives and kidnap her; he'll probably reason to himself that she's going to die soon anyway and want to spare her the horrible end of his mother, and just think of the lovely, ''lovely'' angst this will cause for everyoneeveryone!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Plus, episode 3 suggests that Dracula, unlike the Orlok-like Leader Vampire from the first episode, is able to pass as a man.

to:

* Plus, episode 3 suggests that Dracula, unlike the Orlok-like Leader Vampire from the first episode, is able to pass as a man.man.

[[WMG: Brona will become Caliban's 'bride.']]
Frankenstein's met her once already and probably will again since she's a buddy of Ethan, giving him ample opportunity to learn where she lives and kidnap her; he'll probably reason to himself that she's going to die soon anyway and want to spare her the horrible end of his mother, and just think of the lovely, ''lovely'' angst this will cause for everyone
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Killing the lamplighter was probably just an act of necessity. The lamplighter might have [[HeKnowsTooMuch seen the killer's face]] or something. (And for the record, we don't know for sure if the lamplighter was killed. He might have just run off in a panic.) As for the girl, children can donate organs to adults, so it's not totally implausible.

to:

** Killing the lamplighter was probably just an act of necessity. The lamplighter might have [[HeKnowsTooMuch seen the killer's face]] or something. (And for the record, we don't know for sure if the lamplighter was killed. He might have just run off in a panic.) As for the girl, children can donate organs to adults, so it's not totally implausible.implausible.

[[WMG: When Dracula does appear, he'll be played by a major actor from the Bond films.]]
Either Ralph Fiennes or Daniel Craig. The amount of Bond actors in the show, plus the creative team from [[Skyfall]] being involved means that the Count would likely be played by someone big.
* Plus, episode 3 suggests that Dracula, unlike the Orlok-like Leader Vampire from the first episode, is able to pass as a man.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* I dunno. The idea of were!Ethan seems plausible, but I don't think he's responsible for the murders (though he might think that he is if he's been blacking out). As incompetent as the London police could be in those days, I'd like to think that even they could easily tell the difference between bodies that were sliced apart with a knife and bodies that were ripped apart with claws and teeth. The show might use that as a red herring, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The lamplighter was male, though, and the little girl was too small to contribute body parts to a female Creature.

to:

** The lamplighter was male, though, and the little girl was too small to contribute body parts to a female Creature.Creature.
** Killing the lamplighter was probably just an act of necessity. The lamplighter might have [[HeKnowsTooMuch seen the killer's face]] or something. (And for the record, we don't know for sure if the lamplighter was killed. He might have just run off in a panic.) As for the girl, children can donate organs to adults, so it's not totally implausible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It would explain why the killer seems to be exclusively targeting women...

to:

* It would explain why the killer seems to be exclusively targeting women...women...
** The lamplighter was male, though, and the little girl was too small to contribute body parts to a female Creature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Specific body parts are stolen, mostly organs. One of the monster's issues in Mary Shelley's was that he wanted a mate, could he be building one?

to:

Specific body parts are stolen, mostly organs. One of the monster's issues in Mary Shelley's was that he wanted a mate, could he be building one?one?
* It would explain why the killer seems to be exclusively targeting women...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. Ethan also makes up his mind to stick around in London and work with Sir Malcolm - someone interested in studying and possibly curing supernatural creatures - after walking by one of the murder scenes, where he overheard some women cursing the perpetrator. Finally, the opening credits show moving fur and a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan's face.

to:

He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. Ethan also makes up his mind to stick around in London and work with Sir Malcolm - someone interested in studying and possibly curing supernatural creatures - after walking by one of the murder scenes, where he overheard some women cursing the perpetrator. Finally, the opening credits show moving fur and a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan's face.face.

[[WMG: Frankenstein's original monster is responsible for the deaths.]]
Specific body parts are stolen, mostly organs. One of the monster's issues in Mary Shelley's was that he wanted a mate, could he be building one?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. Ethan also makes up his mind to stick around in London and work with Sir Malcolm - someone interested in studying and possibly curing supernatural creatures - after walking by of the murder scenes, where he overheard some women cursing the perpetrator. Finally, the opening credits show moving fur and a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan's face.

to:

He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. Ethan also makes up his mind to stick around in London and work with Sir Malcolm - someone interested in studying and possibly curing supernatural creatures - after walking by one of the murder scenes, where he overheard some women cursing the perpetrator. Finally, the opening credits show moving fur and a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan's face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. Ethan also makes up his mind to stick around in London and work with Sir Malcolm - someone interested in studying and possibly curing supernatural creatures - after walking by of the murder scenes, where he overheard some women cursing the perpetrator. Finally, the opening credits show a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan and name his actor.

to:

He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. Ethan also makes up his mind to stick around in London and work with Sir Malcolm - someone interested in studying and possibly curing supernatural creatures - after walking by of the murder scenes, where he overheard some women cursing the perpetrator. Finally, the opening credits show moving fur and a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan and name his actor.Ethan's face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. Ethan also makes up his mind to stick around in London and work with Sir Malcolm - someone interested in probing and possibly curing supernatural creatures - right after walking by of the murder scenes, where he overheard some women cursing the perpetrator. Finally, the opening credits show a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan and name his actor.

to:

He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. Ethan also makes up his mind to stick around in London and work with Sir Malcolm - someone interested in probing studying and possibly curing supernatural creatures - right after walking by of the murder scenes, where he overheard some women cursing the perpetrator. Finally, the opening credits show a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan and name his actor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. He makes up his mind to stick around in London and work with Sir Malcolm = someone interested in probing and possibly curing supernatural creatures - right after walking by of the murder scenes, where he overheard some women cursing the perpetrator. Finally, the opening credits show a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan and name his actor.

to:

He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. He Ethan also makes up his mind to stick around in London and work with Sir Malcolm = - someone interested in probing and possibly curing supernatural creatures - right after walking by of the murder scenes, where he overheard some women cursing the perpetrator. Finally, the opening credits show a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan and name his actor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. Finally, the opening credits show a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan and name his actor.

to:

He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. He makes up his mind to stick around in London and work with Sir Malcolm = someone interested in probing and possibly curing supernatural creatures - right after walking by of the murder scenes, where he overheard some women cursing the perpetrator. Finally, the opening credits show a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan and name his actor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Ethan is a werewolf and is responsible for the murders.]]

to:

[[WMG: Ethan is a werewolf and is responsible for the dismemberment murders.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[WMG: Ethan is a werewolf and is responsible for the murders.]]

to:

[WMG: [[WMG: Ethan is a werewolf and is responsible for the murders.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[WMG: Ethan is a werewolf and is responsible for the murders.]]
He wakes up disoriented on the morning after one of the attacks with his nails digging into his palm, as if he'd just endured the pain of reversion from a sharp-clawed WolfMan to his human form. The policeman whom Sir Malcolm spoke to said that there'd been a previous attack outside of London a month earlier, which fits with the Wild West Show's need to travel and a change-every-full-moon timeline. Finally, the opening credits show a wolf's open jaws ''immediately'' before they show Ethan and name his actor.

Top