Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / DoctorWho2022CENThePowerOfTheDoctor

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* '''Jossed''' – Mel said in ''The Giggle'' that she returned to Earth by getting "a lift off a Zingo"; whatever a Zingo is, the Doctor was certainly not involved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mel is confirmed to be returning in Series 14. Perhaps her return to Earth will be explained then.

to:

** Mel is confirmed to be returning in Series 14. Perhaps her return to Earth will be explained then.then.

[[WMG: The Master!Doctor is the Valeyard.]]
The Valeyard claims to be an evil future version of the Doctor, and the Master!Doctor did spend a little while alone on that asteroid, so the Timelords could have picked him up, let him prosecute the Doctor, and then put him back in time for Yaz to pick him up.

Added: 223

Changed: 120

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This actually kind of happened in "The Giggle," in which the Fifteenth doctor "bi-generated" from the Fourteenth, allowing the Fourteen to live a quiet life with Donna and her family while Fifteen continued to adventure.



** '''Jossed'''. No such scene happens.

to:

** '''Jossed'''. No such scene happens. Instead, Davies himself brought in back in "The Giggle," with Fourteen and Fifteen each getting their own time machine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's also possible, given that she talks about checking up on other former companions in ''Series/TheSarahJaneAdventures'', that Sarah Jane Smith had a hand in getting everyone together. Though the lockdown special "Farewell, Sarah Jane" is about her funeral, there's no indication that she's dead in the continuity of the TV series, so the events of "Farewell, Sarah Jane" are either non-canon or have yet to take place. And, given that Tegan and Nyssa being an OfficialCouple, as stated in "Farewell, Sarah Jane", appears not to be canon to the TV series, it's likely that the rest of that story isn't canon either.

to:

* It's also possible, given that she talks about checking up on other former companions in ''Series/TheSarahJaneAdventures'', that Sarah Jane Smith had a hand in getting everyone together. Though the lockdown special "Farewell, Sarah Jane" is about her funeral, there's there was at the time the special was made no indication that she's she was dead in the continuity of the TV series, so the events of "Farewell, Sarah Jane" are either non-canon or have yet to take place. And, given that Tegan and Nyssa being an OfficialCouple, as stated in "Farewell, Sarah Jane", appears not to be canon to the TV series, it's likely that the rest of that story isn't canon either.series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Possibly '''Jossed'''. Towards the end of "The Giggle" it's mentioned that Sarah Jane died off-screen, but we aren't told when this happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the Classic Series Season 26 collection announcement minisode '24 Karot', Langford reprises her role as Mel, revealing the character now heads up an interstellar recruitment drive for potential investments. At the end of the minisode, she is reunited with the Seventh Doctor and once again becomes his companion, heading out into the galaxy aboard the TARDIS. It's entirely possible she is dropped back on Earth at the close of these unseen new adventures. However, like all expanded Who media, the canonicity of this minisode is debatable.

to:

** In the Classic Series Season 26 collection announcement minisode '24 Karot', Langford reprises her role as Mel, revealing the character now heads up an interstellar recruitment drive for potential investments. At the end of the minisode, she is reunited with the Seventh Doctor and once again becomes his companion, heading out into the galaxy aboard the TARDIS. It's entirely possible she is dropped back on Earth at the close of these unseen new adventures. However, like all expanded Who media, the canonicity of this minisode is debatable.debatable.
** Mel is confirmed to be returning in Series 14. Perhaps her return to Earth will be explained then.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Getting rid of this as it looks weird in the formattin, it's a leading comment, and more importantly; it just flatly isn't true.


Given how much the Chibnall era has tried to ride off the major hits of the RTD era...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Until now, Mel's last onscreen appearance was in the Seventh Doctor story "Dragonfire", which ends with her deciding to stay with rogue trader Sabalom Glitz. The Sixth Doctor story "The Trial of a Time Lord: The Mysterious Planet" establishes that Glitz comes from around 2 million years in Earth's future, suggesting that "Dragonfire" also takes place in that time frame. However, Mel is among the former companions attending the meeting towards the end of "The Power of the Doctor", which takes place in 2022. So how did she travel back in time by 2 million years? One possibility is that she crossed paths with the Doctor again and, presumably after a few more adventures, the Doctor set the TARDIS for Pease Pottage [[note]]Mel's home town[[/note]] and dropped her off there.

to:

* Until now, Mel's last onscreen appearance was in the Seventh Doctor story "Dragonfire", which ends with her deciding to stay with rogue trader Sabalom Glitz. The Sixth Doctor story "The Trial of a Time Lord: The Mysterious Planet" establishes that Glitz comes from around 2 million years in Earth's future, suggesting that "Dragonfire" also takes place in that time frame. However, Mel is among the former companions attending the meeting towards the end of "The Power of the Doctor", which takes place in 2022. So how did she travel back in time by 2 million years? One possibility is that she crossed paths with the Doctor again and, presumably after a few more adventures, the Doctor set the TARDIS for Pease Pottage [[note]]Mel's home town[[/note]] and dropped her off there.there.
** In the Classic Series Season 26 collection announcement minisode '24 Karot', Langford reprises her role as Mel, revealing the character now heads up an interstellar recruitment drive for potential investments. At the end of the minisode, she is reunited with the Seventh Doctor and once again becomes his companion, heading out into the galaxy aboard the TARDIS. It's entirely possible she is dropped back on Earth at the close of these unseen new adventures. However, like all expanded Who media, the canonicity of this minisode is debatable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Also '''Confirmed''', but only in the most literal sense: there are ''three'' regenerations - The Master forces The Doctor to regenerate into his form, which is later reversed, before Thirteen herself finally regenerates at the episode's end... into Creator/DavidTennant.

to:

* Also '''Confirmed''', but only in the most literal sense: there are ''three'' regenerations - The Master forces The Doctor to regenerate into his form, form while he possesses her, which is later reversed, before Thirteen herself finally regenerates at the episode's end... into Creator/DavidTennant.



** '''Jossed'''. While this does become an awkward theme in the episode (note 13's look when meeting Tegan and Ace and compare it to 10's look in ''School Reunion''), it sets up the opposite theme of never leaving or forgetting about past companions. The Master acts as the bad influence for Yaz, actively wanting to corrupt them and future companions, and the guilt slinging is brought out by Tegan for feeling disposable. It is also briefly discussed by Hologram-Seven and Ace, with Seven fearing that he taught Ace some bad habits, and Ace responding that, on the contrary, he had been an important moderating influence upon her.

to:

** '''Jossed'''. While this does become an awkward theme in the episode (note 13's look when meeting Tegan and Ace and compare it to 10's look upon meeting Sarah Jane in ''School Reunion''), it sets up the opposite theme of never leaving or forgetting about past companions. The Master acts as the bad influence for Yaz, actively wanting to corrupt them and future companions, and the guilt slinging is brought out by Tegan for feeling disposable. It is also briefly discussed by Hologram-Seven and Ace, with Seven fearing that he taught Ace some bad habits, and Ace responding that, on the contrary, he had been an important moderating influence upon her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Towards the end, some of the Doctor's former companions are shown meeting up to talk about their experiences. The ones we see are Ian, Jo, Tegan, Mel, Ace and Graham, but there are other companions who were last seen on present-day [[note]]at the time they and the Doctor parted company[[/note]] who are not present. Admittedly, several ex-companions are absent because the actors who played them have since died, but, in most cases, there's no confirmation that their characters have also died. So it's possible that at least some of these companions are still alive and are members of this group; we just don't see them. Not to mention that Polly, Mickey, Martha and Ryan could, in theory, also be members.

to:

* Towards the end, some of the Doctor's former companions are shown meeting up to talk about their experiences. The ones we see are Ian, Jo, Tegan, Mel, Ace and Graham, but there are other companions who were last seen on present-day [[note]]at the time they and the Doctor parted company[[/note]] Earth who are not present. Admittedly, several ex-companions are absent because the actors who played them have since died, but, in most cases, there's no confirmation that their characters have also died. So it's possible that at least some of these companions are still alive and are members of this group; we just don't see them. Not to mention that Polly, Mickey, Martha and Ryan could, in theory, also be members.

Changed: 1413

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Towards the end, some of the Doctor's former companions are shown meeting up to talk about their experiences. The ones we see are Ian, Jo, Tegan, Mel, Ace and Graham, but there are other companions who were last seen on present-day [[note]]at the time they and the Doctor parted company[[/note]] who are not present. Admittedly, several ex-companions are absent because the actors who played them have since died, but, with the exception of Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart, none of them are confirmed as having died in the TV series. So it's possible that at least some of the companions whose actors have died are still alive and are members of this group; we just don't see them. Not to mention that Polly, Mickey, Martha and Ryan could, in theory, also be members. It's also possible, given that she talks about checking up on other former companions in ''Series/TheSarahJaneAdventure'' episode "Death of the Doctor", that Sarah Jane Smith had a hand in getting everyone together. Though the lockdown special "Farewell, Sarah Jane" is about her funeral, there's no indication that she's dead in the continuity of the TV series, so the events of "Farewell, Sarah Jane" are either non-canon or have yet to take place. And, given that Tegan and Nyssa being an OfficialCouple, as stated in "Farewell, Sarah Jane", appears not to be canon to the TV series, it's likely that the rest of that story isn't canon either.

to:

* Towards the end, some of the Doctor's former companions are shown meeting up to talk about their experiences. The ones we see are Ian, Jo, Tegan, Mel, Ace and Graham, but there are other companions who were last seen on present-day [[note]]at the time they and the Doctor parted company[[/note]] who are not present. Admittedly, several ex-companions are absent because the actors who played them have since died, but, with the exception of Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart, none of them are confirmed as having died in the TV series. most cases, there's no confirmation that their characters have also died. So it's possible that at least some of the these companions whose actors have died are still alive and are members of this group; we just don't see them. Not to mention that Polly, Mickey, Martha and Ryan could, in theory, also be members.
*
It's also possible, given that she talks about checking up on other former companions in ''Series/TheSarahJaneAdventure'' episode "Death of the Doctor", ''Series/TheSarahJaneAdventures'', that Sarah Jane Smith had a hand in getting everyone together. Though the lockdown special "Farewell, Sarah Jane" is about her funeral, there's no indication that she's dead in the continuity of the TV series, so the events of "Farewell, Sarah Jane" are either non-canon or have yet to take place. And, given that Tegan and Nyssa being an OfficialCouple, as stated in "Farewell, Sarah Jane", appears not to be canon to the TV series, it's likely that the rest of that story isn't canon either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One of the complaints in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS38E10TheTimelessChildren The Timeless Children]] was that TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter by killing off Ashad so early in the story. His defeat in this story is much less clear cut of a death, and electrocution is probably much more survivable to a Cyberman than anyone else.

to:

* One of the complaints in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS38E10TheTimelessChildren The Timeless Children]] was that TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter by killing off Ashad so early in the story. His defeat in this story is much less clear cut of a death, and electrocution is probably much more survivable to a Cyberman than anyone else.else.

[[WMG: The ex-companions group has more members than the six we see]]
* Towards the end, some of the Doctor's former companions are shown meeting up to talk about their experiences. The ones we see are Ian, Jo, Tegan, Mel, Ace and Graham, but there are other companions who were last seen on present-day [[note]]at the time they and the Doctor parted company[[/note]] who are not present. Admittedly, several ex-companions are absent because the actors who played them have since died, but, with the exception of Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart, none of them are confirmed as having died in the TV series. So it's possible that at least some of the companions whose actors have died are still alive and are members of this group; we just don't see them. Not to mention that Polly, Mickey, Martha and Ryan could, in theory, also be members. It's also possible, given that she talks about checking up on other former companions in ''Series/TheSarahJaneAdventure'' episode "Death of the Doctor", that Sarah Jane Smith had a hand in getting everyone together. Though the lockdown special "Farewell, Sarah Jane" is about her funeral, there's no indication that she's dead in the continuity of the TV series, so the events of "Farewell, Sarah Jane" are either non-canon or have yet to take place. And, given that Tegan and Nyssa being an OfficialCouple, as stated in "Farewell, Sarah Jane", appears not to be canon to the TV series, it's likely that the rest of that story isn't canon either.

[[WMG: Mel met up with the Doctor again and was brought back to Earth in the TARDIS]]
* Until now, Mel's last onscreen appearance was in the Seventh Doctor story "Dragonfire", which ends with her deciding to stay with rogue trader Sabalom Glitz. The Sixth Doctor story "The Trial of a Time Lord: The Mysterious Planet" establishes that Glitz comes from around 2 million years in Earth's future, suggesting that "Dragonfire" also takes place in that time frame. However, Mel is among the former companions attending the meeting towards the end of "The Power of the Doctor", which takes place in 2022. So how did she travel back in time by 2 million years? One possibility is that she crossed paths with the Doctor again and, presumably after a few more adventures, the Doctor set the TARDIS for Pease Pottage [[note]]Mel's home town[[/note]] and dropped her off there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** '''Potentially confirmed''' by the original script outright stating that Rasputin was always the Master.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While this theory actually has basis in the show's history (There was a plan to regenerate Colin Baker's Doctor back into Patrick Troughton for a season before regenerating into a woman for the next) and it's happened multiple times in the ExpandedUniverse it would severely take the wind out of Ncuti's casting if David Tennant usurped his regeneration, even if for one story.

to:

* While this theory actually has basis in the show's history (There (there was a plan to regenerate Colin Baker's Doctor back into Patrick Troughton for a season before regenerating into a woman for the next) next), and it's happened multiple times in the ExpandedUniverse ExpandedUniverse, it would severely take the wind out of Ncuti's casting if David Tennant usurped his regeneration, even if just for one story.



** '''Jossed''' in that Thirteen doesn't regenerate into Ncuti. But the Doctor does say the what line upon realizing they turned back into Tennant.

to:

** '''Jossed''' in that Thirteen doesn't regenerate into Ncuti. But the Doctor does say the what "What?" line upon realizing that they turned back into Tennant.



* '''Jossed''', at least for this special - Bel doesn't even appear.

to:

* '''Jossed''', at least for this special - special-- Bel doesn't even appear.



Jodie Whittaker into Olly Alexander and Carole Ann Ford into Lidya West

to:

Jodie Whittaker into Olly Alexander and Carole Ann Ford into Lidya WestWest.



** '''Jossed'''. While this does become an awkward theme in the episode (Note 13's look when meeting Tegan and Ace and compare it to 10's look in ''School Reunion''), it sets up the opposite theme of never leaving or forgetting about past companions. The Master acts as the bad influence for Yaz, actively wanting to corrupt them and future companions, and the guilt slinging is brought out by Tegan for feeling disposable. It is also briefly discussed by Hologram-Seven and Ace, with Seven fearing that he taught Ace some bad habits, and Ace responding that, on the contrary, he had been an important moderating influence upon her.

to:

** '''Jossed'''. While this does become an awkward theme in the episode (Note (note 13's look when meeting Tegan and Ace and compare it to 10's look in ''School Reunion''), it sets up the opposite theme of never leaving or forgetting about past companions. The Master acts as the bad influence for Yaz, actively wanting to corrupt them and future companions, and the guilt slinging is brought out by Tegan for feeling disposable. It is also briefly discussed by Hologram-Seven and Ace, with Seven fearing that he taught Ace some bad habits, and Ace responding that, on the contrary, he had been an important moderating influence upon her.



** '''Potentially Jossed''', however, as it appears the Master's Rasputin disguise is discarded with his seeming death on the disintegrating Conversion Planet, meaning ''someone else'' had to be there in Saint Petersburg for the nobles to poison, shoot and dump in a river...

to:

** '''Potentially Jossed''', however, as it appears the Master's Rasputin disguise is discarded with his seeming death on the disintegrating Conversion Planet, meaning ''someone else'' had to be there in Saint Petersburg for the nobles to poison, shoot shoot, and dump in a river...



In the promo pics, we see Cybermen with Gallifreyan writing on them but without Time Lord headpieces and cloaks, accompanied (led?) by one Cybermaster with a Time Lord headpiece and cloak. The Cybermasters we see in ''The Timeless Children'', all with headpieces and cloaks, are not all the Cybermasters there are. Perhaps those were made from the Time Lord High Council, while the ones with no Time Lord regalia are made from lower-ranking Time Lords (or ordinary Gallifreyans).

to:

In the promo pics, we see Cybermen with Gallifreyan writing on them but without Time Lord headpieces and cloaks, accompanied (led?) by one Cybermaster with a Time Lord headpiece and cloak. The Cybermasters that we see in ''The Timeless Children'', all with headpieces and cloaks, are not all the Cybermasters that there are. Perhaps those were made from the Time Lord High Council, while the ones with no Time Lord regalia are made from lower-ranking Time Lords (or ordinary Gallifreyans).



* That would ''really'' cement its destruction and make impossible (or at least significantly harder) for future writers to bring the Gallifreyan civilization back.

to:

* That would ''really'' cement its destruction and make it impossible (or at least significantly harder) for future writers to bring the Gallifreyan civilization back.

Top