Follow TV Tropes

Following

History UnintentionalUncannyValley / LiveActionFilms

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The producers of the biopic ''Vysotsky: Thank You for Being Alive'' went to great lengths to make the actor portraying Music/VladimirVysotsky, Sergey Bezrukov, look as much like Vysotsky as possible through a combination of heavy makeup, the assistance of CG, and dubbing his voice with that of Vysotsky's son, Nikita, all so that audiences could get to pretend like Vysotsky had come back to life for this movie. Going by the mixed critical response, it didn't really work. The effect is decent enough in some still shots and certain angles/lighting, but otherwise it becomes clear that Bezrukov couldn't emote a whole lot underneath all that makeup, his face looks weirdly smooth, and the emotion of the dubbed voice doesn't always match the facial expressions, or lack thereof. It doesn't help a great deal of the movie is very brightly lit and saturated, meaning the effect can't really be hidden.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Machamp falls into this for a different reason - it's still stylized, yet [[https://d1lss44hh2trtw.cloudfront.net/assets/editorial/2019/02/det-pikachu-snorlax-and-machamp.jpg its lack of shadow and its strange skin tone]] make it look more like [[SpecialEffectFailure it was just clumsily slapped in]] and taken from a [=PlayStation=] era FMV.
** The same image also demonstrates another recurring design choice that results in the Pokémon looking "off", with Snorlax. The bright colourscheme of most Pokémon was faded out. Combined with their internal structure (or lack thereof), they resemble stuffed animals that have been bleached by the sun.
** Ludicolo's texture looks more like Paper Mache, with surprisingly realistic looking eyes that just look ''dead''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Film/RogueOne'' has a digital recreation of Creator/PeterCushing as [[Characters/StarWarsWilhuffTarkin Grand Moff Tarkin]], done by superimposing his computer-generated likeness on a live actor's face, similar to a Deepfake though using direct MotionCapture. This was a major talking point among critics who not only had a mixed reaction to the effect itself, but questioned whether it was even ethical to "resurrect" an actor like this in the first place (although the filmmakers did obtain permission from the Cushing estate). For some viewers the combination of natural body movements and not-quite-right facial movements were deep in UncannyValley. But considering the character is [[TheSociopath Wilhuff Tarkin]], [[FauxAffablyEvil who can commit genocide with the most polite tone of voice]], [[TropesAreTools this isn't necessarily a bad thing]]. On the other hand, [[spoiler:the last-scene cameo of de-aged Carrie Fisher as Princess Leia]] is done the same way, and she isn't anywhere near as evil.

to:

** ''Film/RogueOne'' has a digital recreation of Creator/PeterCushing as [[Characters/StarWarsWilhuffTarkin Grand Moff Tarkin]], done by superimposing his computer-generated likeness on a live actor's face, similar to a Deepfake though using direct MotionCapture. This was a major talking point among critics who not only had a mixed reaction to the effect itself, but questioned whether it was even ethical to "resurrect" an actor like this in the first place (although the filmmakers did obtain permission from the Cushing estate). For some viewers the combination of natural body movements and not-quite-right facial movements were deep in UncannyValley. But considering the character is [[TheSociopath Wilhuff Tarkin]], [[FauxAffablyEvil who can commit genocide with the most polite tone of voice]], [[TropesAreTools this isn't necessarily a bad thing]]. On the other hand, [[spoiler:the last-scene cameo of de-aged Carrie Fisher as Princess Leia]] is done the same way, and she isn't anywhere near as evil.evil... [[spoiler: until she smiles and her top lip moves in a ''very'' unnatural way.]]

Added: 2034

Changed: -9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/Aladdin2019'' has Creator/WillSmith’s Genie who from the original trailer [[https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcR7kjfLMmc8kfNSvrRn63JWxX_r_z383ZqX5Q&usqp=CAU falls]] [[https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcT79IiaD9zrnK8hcoeUhN1iu2sjNlDET_jLOQ&usqp=CAU squarely]] [[https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSMSku4jF-i967g29PQzvD7Ngs8-q0mn0vVOw&usqp=CAU into this trope]]. In an effort to replicate the large torso of the [[WesternAnimation/{{Aladdin}} cartoon Genie]], the remake Genie has a weirdly muscular torso which is at extreme odds with Will Smith’s face, which also doesn’t look right due the shape of the Genie’s head. Fortunately since Genie takes a normal human form for most of the movie the Uncanny Valley-ness isn’t as severe as it could’ve been.

to:

* ''Film/Aladdin2019'' has Creator/WillSmith’s Genie who from the original trailer [[https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcR7kjfLMmc8kfNSvrRn63JWxX_r_z383ZqX5Q&usqp=CAU falls]] [[https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcT79IiaD9zrnK8hcoeUhN1iu2sjNlDET_jLOQ&usqp=CAU squarely]] [[https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSMSku4jF-i967g29PQzvD7Ngs8-q0mn0vVOw&usqp=CAU into this trope]]. In an effort to replicate the large torso of the [[WesternAnimation/{{Aladdin}} cartoon Genie]], the remake Genie has a weirdly muscular torso which is at extreme odds with Will Smith’s face, which also doesn’t look right due to the shape of the Genie’s head. Fortunately Fortunately, since Genie takes a normal human form for most of the movie the Uncanny Valley-ness isn’t as severe as it could’ve been.



* ''Film/TheFlash2023'' has gotten absolutely slammed for this, as whenever Flash goes so fast TimeStandsStill the CG effects on the characters look so, so wrong. The highlights include [[https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YFGQJxpkPg4 the freaky babies Barry rescues from the hospital]] and the [[https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xuYSMUWyG0o scenes]] [[https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=OS0KIVX9A9c&pp=ygUWZmxhc2ggc2F2ZXMgaGlzIG1vdGhlcg%3D%3D where Barry turns back time]] and sees people and events from the previous films and previous scenes. [[spoiler:But above all, the most [[https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ICIZnwZjSRw ghoulish part]] comes in the climax where the universes collide and we see CG reconstructions of Creator/ChristopherReeves’s Superman and Creator/GeorgeReeves’s Superman as well as Creator/HelenSlater’s Supergirl and Creator/NicholasCage’s Superman. Putting aside just how amateurishly freaky they look for the movie of this budget, the highly questionable ethics of resurrecting deceased actors in such a fashion has been criticised like with Peter Cushin in ''Film/RogueOne'' if not more so (particularly given George Reeves killed himself over what Superman did to his career and left him impoverished -- making the decision to bring him back in CGI pretty tasteless). Not to mention the fact Nicholas Cage and Helen Slater are still alive making the need to recreate them in CG unnecessary as simply de-aging them would’ve been comparatively much easier and less creepy.]] Not helping matters is the director Andy Muschietti claiming that the CG [[StylisticSuck was supposed to be uncanny]], something that was {{jossed}} by VFX artists who were overworked on the film and very apologetic at the results.
** A more subtle example but one that is deeply unnerving once you notice it, is whenever there’s two Barry Allens on screen at the same time you can see that one is a stand-in with Ezra Miller’s face superimposed onto him. It works for the most part but some scenes and shots are just plain creepy because of it.



** Grawp, Hagrid's giant brother from ''Film/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix'', is quite literally a big part of the book and later ones, but his depiction in the film is [[https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn%3AANd9GcRkOJP5VacYQWb89ujqKZ6R3KpdTtvydsbFKCAKrgr6qUfABGmX more than a little unsettling]]. It's probably due to him looking much closer to a human than say the troll from the first movie, not helped by the fact he's ''completely silent'' not even grunting or roaring like in the book meaning he can easily invoke this in viewers. WordOfGod confirmed this is partly the reason Gwarp made no return appearance for later films as well as budget reasons.

to:

** Grawp, Hagrid's giant brother from ''Film/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix'', is quite literally a big part of the book and later ones, but his depiction in the film is [[https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn%3AANd9GcRkOJP5VacYQWb89ujqKZ6R3KpdTtvydsbFKCAKrgr6qUfABGmX more than a little unsettling]]. It's probably due to him looking much closer to a human than say the troll from the first movie, not helped by the fact he's ''completely silent'' not even grunting or roaring like in the book meaning he can easily invoke this in viewers. WordOfGod confirmed this is was partly the reason Gwarp made no return appearance for later films as well as budget reasons.



** [[MemeticMutation Infamous example]] is Superman's [[https://www.thewrap.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/supermans-cgi-mouth-henry-cavill-justice-league-9.jpg weird]] [[https://www.thewrap.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/supermans-cgi-mouth-justice-league-henry-cavill-1.jpg ass]] [[https://www.thewrap.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/supermans-cgi-mouth-henry-cavill-justice-league-4.jpg lips]], poor Henry Cavil was contractually obligated to keep his mustache for ''Film/MissionImpossibleFallout'' to the woe of Creator/WarnerBrothers who wanted a clean shaven Superman. So instead of just keeping the facial hair like most superheroes nowadays (although it would require an explanation as to how Supes' facial hair grew while he was dead) they just used CG to take away the stache, ''the result is very upsetting to the eyes''.
** Steppenwolf is a pretty bad case of this too thanks to AdaptationalUgliness making him look like a bad CG combination of [[https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/marvel_dc/images/e/ec/Steppenwolf_DC_Extended_Universe_0002.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20190624220149 man, goat, and tinfoil]]. [[Film/ZackSnydersJusticeLeague The director's cut]] does not fix this enough, as the effects are better executed, but get unnerving when [[https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTV5yFFHekHzz-cry_trdPTEhU-uqUmcgzXpA&usqp=CAU Steppenwolf removes its helmet]]. There’s also an earlier scene in the Director’s cut where Steppenwolf while genuine pleading to Darkseid has [[PuppyDogEyes soft]] [[https://c.tenor.com/sAabTJio2GAAAAAM/hassantaker-zack-snyder.gif sad, pretty adorable eyes]] which uncannily jars with the rest of his inhuman features, although it can be a moment of NarmCharm for certain viewers.

to:

** [[MemeticMutation Infamous example]] is Superman's [[https://www.thewrap.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/supermans-cgi-mouth-henry-cavill-justice-league-9.jpg weird]] [[https://www.thewrap.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/supermans-cgi-mouth-justice-league-henry-cavill-1.jpg ass]] [[https://www.thewrap.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/supermans-cgi-mouth-henry-cavill-justice-league-4.jpg lips]], poor lips]]. Poor Henry Cavil was contractually obligated to keep his mustache for ''Film/MissionImpossibleFallout'' to the woe of Creator/WarnerBrothers who wanted a clean shaven Superman. So instead of just keeping the facial hair like most superheroes nowadays (although it would require an explanation as to how Supes' facial hair grew while he was dead) they just used CG to take away the stache, ''the result is very upsetting to the eyes''.
** Steppenwolf is a pretty bad case of this too thanks to AdaptationalUgliness making him look like a bad CG combination of [[https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/marvel_dc/images/e/ec/Steppenwolf_DC_Extended_Universe_0002.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20190624220149 man, goat, and tinfoil]]. [[Film/ZackSnydersJusticeLeague The director's cut]] does not fix this enough, as the effects are better executed, but get unnerving when [[https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTV5yFFHekHzz-cry_trdPTEhU-uqUmcgzXpA&usqp=CAU Steppenwolf removes its his helmet]]. There’s also an earlier scene in the Director’s cut where Steppenwolf while genuine pleading to Darkseid has [[PuppyDogEyes soft]] [[https://c.tenor.com/sAabTJio2GAAAAAM/hassantaker-zack-snyder.gif sad, pretty adorable eyes]] which uncannily jars with the rest of his inhuman features, although it can be a moment of NarmCharm for certain viewers.



** Granny Goodness briefly seen in ''Film/ZackSnydersJusticeLeague'' has this effect, while she is a New God alien in the comics, she’s a distinctly [[HumanAliens human looking one]]. The filmmakers however decided to render Granny in CG alongside Darkseid and [=DeSaad=] (likely due to the superimposing of a real actress into the shot being too difficult and costly) with the end result of Granny [[https://preview.redd.it/9j79536mpvq61.png?auto=webp&s=87fc0ee5ea09c7a71aea257dbcfad29adeafbf8f looking far creepier]] than her master Darkseid the GodOfEvil himself.

to:

** Granny Goodness who is briefly seen in ''Film/ZackSnydersJusticeLeague'' has this effect, while effect. While she is a New God alien in the comics, she’s a distinctly [[HumanAliens human looking one]]. The filmmakers however decided to render Granny in CG alongside Darkseid and [=DeSaad=] (likely due to the superimposing of a real actress into the shot being too difficult and costly) with the end result of Granny [[https://preview.redd.it/9j79536mpvq61.png?auto=webp&s=87fc0ee5ea09c7a71aea257dbcfad29adeafbf8f looking far creepier]] than her master Darkseid the GodOfEvil himself.



*** [[spoiler:The Hulk seen in ''Film/AvengersEndgame'' takes this to the logical extreme as being the perfect hybrid of both Bruce Banner and Hulk (aka Professor Hulk), it’s like there’s a big green Mark Ruffalo walking around being careful and scientific instead of child-like rage-outs the result is [[https://i.ytimg.com/vi/8K9babkSoOs/maxresdefault.jpg strange]] to say the least. It's also probably thanks the preceding 10 years where you as an audience have gotten used to the savage ManChild Hulk, that the sight of a near-human intelligent Hulk talking with no HulkSpeak is freaky.]]

to:

*** [[spoiler:The Hulk seen in ''Film/AvengersEndgame'' takes this to the logical extreme as being the perfect hybrid of both Bruce Banner and Hulk (aka Professor Hulk), it’s like there’s a big green Mark Ruffalo walking around being careful and scientific instead of child-like rage-outs the result is [[https://i.ytimg.com/vi/8K9babkSoOs/maxresdefault.jpg strange]] to say the least. It's also probably thanks to the preceding 10 years where you as an audience viewer have gotten used to the savage ManChild Hulk, that the sight of a near-human intelligent Hulk talking with no HulkSpeak is freaky.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Film/RogueOne'' has a digital recreation of Creator/PeterCushing as [[Characters/StarWarsWilhuffTarkin Grand Moff Tarkin]], done by superimposing his computer-generated likeness on a live actor's face, similar to a Deepfake though using direct MotionCapture. This was a major talking point among critics who not only had a mixed reaction to the end result, but questioned whether it was even ethical to "resurrect" an actor like this in the first place (although the filmmakers did obtain permission from the Cushing estate). For some viewers the combination of natural body movements and not-quite-right facial movements were deep in UncannyValley. But considering the character is [[TheSociopath Wilhuff Tarkin]], [[FauxAffablyEvil who can commit genocide with the most polite tone of voice]], [[TropesAreTools this isn't necessarily a bad thing]]. On the other hand, [[spoiler:the last-scene cameo of de-aged Carrie Fisher as Princess Leia]] is done the same way, and she isn't anywhere near as evil.

to:

** ''Film/RogueOne'' has a digital recreation of Creator/PeterCushing as [[Characters/StarWarsWilhuffTarkin Grand Moff Tarkin]], done by superimposing his computer-generated likeness on a live actor's face, similar to a Deepfake though using direct MotionCapture. This was a major talking point among critics who not only had a mixed reaction to the end result, effect itself, but questioned whether it was even ethical to "resurrect" an actor like this in the first place (although the filmmakers did obtain permission from the Cushing estate). For some viewers the combination of natural body movements and not-quite-right facial movements were deep in UncannyValley. But considering the character is [[TheSociopath Wilhuff Tarkin]], [[FauxAffablyEvil who can commit genocide with the most polite tone of voice]], [[TropesAreTools this isn't necessarily a bad thing]]. On the other hand, [[spoiler:the last-scene cameo of de-aged Carrie Fisher as Princess Leia]] is done the same way, and she isn't anywhere near as evil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Film/RogueOne'' has the CGI performance of the late Creator/PeterCushing "reprising" his role from 1977 despite having died in 1994. Done by putting a CGI render of his face over a live actor's body, for some viewers the combination of natural body movements and not-quite-right facial movements are deep in UncannyValley... But considering the character is [[TheSociopath Wilhuff Tarkin]], [[FauxAffablyEvil who can commit genocide with the most polite tone of voice]], [[TropesAreTools this isn't necessarily a bad thing]]. On the other hand, [[spoiler:the last-scene cameo of de-aged Carrie Fisher as Princess Leia]] is done the same way, and she isn't anywhere near as evil.

to:

** ''Film/RogueOne'' has the CGI performance a digital recreation of the late Creator/PeterCushing "reprising" as [[Characters/StarWarsWilhuffTarkin Grand Moff Tarkin]], done by superimposing his role from 1977 despite having died in 1994. Done by putting a CGI render of his face over computer-generated likeness on a live actor's body, for face, similar to a Deepfake though using direct MotionCapture. This was a major talking point among critics who not only had a mixed reaction to the end result, but questioned whether it was even ethical to "resurrect" an actor like this in the first place (although the filmmakers did obtain permission from the Cushing estate). For some viewers the combination of natural body movements and not-quite-right facial movements are were deep in UncannyValley...UncannyValley. But considering the character is [[TheSociopath Wilhuff Tarkin]], [[FauxAffablyEvil who can commit genocide with the most polite tone of voice]], [[TropesAreTools this isn't necessarily a bad thing]]. On the other hand, [[spoiler:the last-scene cameo of de-aged Carrie Fisher as Princess Leia]] is done the same way, and she isn't anywhere near as evil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Film/AntManAndTheWaspQuantumania'': [[spoiler:[[https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FpxQx5oXwAAp1OK.jpg M.O.D.O.K aka Darren Cross]] naturally had this effect on people with Creator/CoreyStoll’s head getting widened the comic book version’s massive proportions and having the signature tiny limbs. All of which freaked many viewers out though in fairness this was an unavoidable circumstance of bringing M.O.D.O.K to screen with his [[{{Gonk}} sheer freakishness]] being a core part of his character. InUniverse the heroes have this exact reaction to him. There’s also the fact he’s bald unlike the comic version, which likely contributed to his uncanniness, though you could also argue giving him realistic hair would have just creeped people out even further.]]

to:

** ''Film/AntManAndTheWaspQuantumania'': [[spoiler:[[https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FpxQx5oXwAAp1OK.jpg M.O.D.O.K aka Darren Cross]] naturally had this effect on people with Creator/CoreyStoll’s head getting widened to the comic book version’s massive proportions and having the signature tiny limbs. All of which freaked many viewers out though in fairness this was an unavoidable circumstance of bringing M.O.D.O.K to screen with his [[{{Gonk}} sheer freakishness]] being a core part of his character. InUniverse the heroes have this exact reaction to him. There’s also the fact he’s bald unlike the comic version, which likely contributed to his uncanniness, though you could also argue giving him realistic hair would have just creeped people out even further.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** [[spoiler:The Hulk seen in ''Film/AvengersEndgame'' takes this to the logical extreme as being the perfect hybrid of both Bruce Banner and Hulk (aka Professor Hulk), it’s like there’s a big green Mark Ruffalo walking around being careful and scientific instead child-like rage outs the result is [[https://i.ytimg.com/vi/8K9babkSoOs/maxresdefault.jpg strange]] to say the least. It's also probably thanks the preceding 10 years where you as an audience have gotten used to the savage ManChild Hulk, that the sight of a near-human intelligent Hulk talking with no HulkSpeak is freaky.]]

to:

*** [[spoiler:The Hulk seen in ''Film/AvengersEndgame'' takes this to the logical extreme as being the perfect hybrid of both Bruce Banner and Hulk (aka Professor Hulk), it’s like there’s a big green Mark Ruffalo walking around being careful and scientific instead of child-like rage outs rage-outs the result is [[https://i.ytimg.com/vi/8K9babkSoOs/maxresdefault.jpg strange]] to say the least. It's also probably thanks the preceding 10 years where you as an audience have gotten used to the savage ManChild Hulk, that the sight of a near-human intelligent Hulk talking with no HulkSpeak is freaky.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:This animatronic baby was almost used in the ''Literature/{{Twilight}}'' movie series. Fortunately for our dreams, wiser heads prevailed...]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:This animatronic baby was almost used in the ''Literature/{{Twilight}}'' ''[[Literature/TheTwilightSaga Twilight]]'' movie series. Fortunately for our dreams, wiser heads prevailed...]]



* In old movies where white people wear blackface, this trope will definitely be in play. The people who do it look more like monsters than actual Black people (unfortunately, that may have been the point...)

to:

* In old movies where white people wear blackface, this trope will definitely be in play. The people who do it look more like monsters than actual Black people (unfortunately, that may have been the point...)
).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The turtles' faces in ''Film/TeenageMutantNinjaTurtles2014'', have invoked a surprisingly more human appearance than one might expect, leading for some to have had this reaction to them. Justified given that this is meant to be a realistic take on a story about giant mutated humanoid turtles. Also more than likely meant to be an IntendedAudienceReaction. Not unexpectedly, images of the tie-in toys don't seem to get this reaction.

to:

* The turtles' faces in ''Film/TeenageMutantNinjaTurtles2014'', have invoked a surprisingly more human appearance than one might expect, leading for some to have had this reaction to them. Justified given that this is meant to be a realistic take on a story about giant mutated humanoid turtles. Also more than likely meant to be an IntendedAudienceReaction. Not unexpectedly, images of the tie-in toys don't seem to get this reaction.

Top