Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Trivia / WalkingWithDinosaurs

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ColbertBump: Outside of the already [[UsefulNotes/StockDinosaursTrueDinosaurs well-known]] ''Diplodocus'', ''Brachiosaurus'', ''Allosaurus'', ''Stegosaurus'', ''Rhamphorhynchus'', ''Iguanodon'', ''Utahraptor'', ''Tyrannosaurus rex'', and ''Ankylosaurus'', all the other featured animals gained much attention thanks to their inclusion in this series.

to:

* ColbertBump: Outside of the already [[UsefulNotes/StockDinosaursTrueDinosaurs well-known]] ''Diplodocus'', ''Brachiosaurus'', ''Allosaurus'', ''Stegosaurus'', ''Rhamphorhynchus'', ''Iguanodon'', ''Utahraptor'', ''Tyrannosaurus rex'', and ''Ankylosaurus'', all the other featured animals gained much public attention thanks to their inclusion in this series.



* ''Liopleurodon'' gained some minor notoriety among researchers at the time as one of the largest (then) known pliosaurs together with the Australian ''Kronosaurus'', but during the 2000s, the largest known ''Liopleurodon'' species were placed into the genus ''Pliosaurus'', which itself gained a further boost in fame around that time due to the discovery of a third giant species, ''Pliosaurus funkei'' (Predator X). [[AnimalsNotToScale Though its portrayal here]] [[HistoricalBadassUpgrade isn't the most accurate]], WWD is the main reason ''Liopleurodon'' hasn't faded into obscurity as just another "small" pliosaur.

to:

* ** ''Liopleurodon'' gained some minor notoriety among researchers at the time as one of the largest (then) known pliosaurs together with the Australian ''Kronosaurus'', but during the 2000s, the largest known ''Liopleurodon'' species were placed into the genus ''Pliosaurus'', which itself gained a further boost in fame around that time due to the discovery of a third giant species, ''Pliosaurus funkei'' (Predator X). [[AnimalsNotToScale Though its portrayal here]] [[HistoricalBadassUpgrade isn't the most accurate]], WWD is the main reason ''Liopleurodon'' hasn't faded into obscurity as just another "small" pliosaur.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Liopleurodon'' gained some minor notoriety among researchers at the time as one of the largest (then) known pliosaurs together with the Australian ''Kronosaurus'', but during the 2000s, the largest known ''Liopleurodon'' species were placed into the genus ''Pliosaurus'', which itself gained a further boost in fame around that time due to the discovery of a third giant species, ''Pliosaurus funkei'' (Predator X). [[AnimalsNotToScale Though its portrayal here]] [[HistoricalBadassUpgrade isn't the most accurate]], WWD is the main reason ''Liopleurodon'' hasn't faded into obscurity as just another "small" pliosaur.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ColbertBump: Outside of the already [[UsefulNotes/StockDinosaursTrueDinosaurs well-known]] ''Diplodocus'', ''Brachiosaurus'', ''Allosaurus'', ''Stegosaurus'', ''Iguanodon'', ''Utahraptor'', ''Tyrannosaurus rex'', and ''Ankylosaurus'', all the other featured animals gained much attention thanks to their inclusion in this series.

to:

* ColbertBump: Outside of the already [[UsefulNotes/StockDinosaursTrueDinosaurs well-known]] ''Diplodocus'', ''Brachiosaurus'', ''Allosaurus'', ''Stegosaurus'', ''Rhamphorhynchus'', ''Iguanodon'', ''Utahraptor'', ''Tyrannosaurus rex'', and ''Ankylosaurus'', all the other featured animals gained much attention thanks to their inclusion in this series.



** ''Polacanthus'' was just a typical Early Cretaceous nodosaur and known from fairly incomplete material. Following a boom of new early nodosaur taxa being described from the late '90s onward and from more complete material (most famously its cousin ''Gastonia''), it likely would have faded into obscurity if not for its inclusion in "Giant of the Skies".

to:

** ''Polacanthus'' was just a typical Early Cretaceous nodosaur and known from fairly incomplete material. Following a boom of new early nodosaur taxa being described from the late '90s onward and from more complete material (most famously its cousin ''Gastonia''), it likely would have faded into obscurity if not for its inclusion in "Giant of the Skies". By extension, the episode is the main reason anyone has heard about ''Hoplitosaurus'' and ''Dakotadon'', as they were the basis for the American ''Polacanthus'' and ''Iguanodon'' shown in the episode respectively.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ColbertBump: Outside of the already [[UsefulNotes/StockDinosaursTrueDinosaurs well-known]] ''Diplodocus'', ''Brachiosaurus'', ''Allosaurus'', ''Stegosaurus'', ''Iguanodon'', ''Utahraptor'', ''Tyrannosaurus rex'', and ''Ankylosaurus'', all the other featured animals gained much attention thanks to their inclusion in this series.
** ''Peteinosaurus'' was just one of several Triassic pterosaurs known at the time, and it wasn't even the most complete, yet its inclusion in "New Blood" gave it a major boost in notoriety.
** ''Ornitholestes'' was seen as just a generic small coelurosaur, and likely would have been eclipsed in popularity by other Jurassic coelurosaurs named down the line, like its larger and sympatric relative ''Tanycolagreus'' (named in 2005), [[Literature/PredatoryDinosaursOfTheWorld and Gregory Paul's interpretation of the animal sporting a nasal crest]] would likewise have been buried by the sands of time, if not for its appearance in "Time of Titans".
** ''Eustreptospondylus'' was just one of several Jurassic theropods known from Europe at the time, fairly run-of-the-mill, and more obscure than its larger and more iconic relative ''Megalosaurus'' (even if the former is more complete). Its appearance in "Cruel Sea" changed that.
** ''Polacanthus'' was just a typical Early Cretaceous nodosaur and known from fairly incomplete material. Following a boom of new early nodosaur taxa being described from the late '90s onward and from more complete material (most famously its cousin ''Gastonia''), it likely would have faded into obscurity if not for its inclusion in "Giant of the Skies".
** As its cousin ''Triceratops'' outnumbers it in the fossil record by around ten to one, ''Torosaurus'' wasn't particularly well known to the general public, but that changed after it was featured as the token horned dinosaur in ''Death of a Dynasty".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Evidence of cynodonts in the Chinle Formation was slim at the time, being mostly isolated teeth and other fragments (all of which couldn't be confidently assigned to cynodonts by later researchers), [[AllThereInTheManual and the main inspiration for the cynodonts in the episode were two large teeth]], later named as ''Kraterokheirodon'' (which was later deemed an indeterminate tetrapod). In 2020, however, we named ''Kataigidodon venetus'' based on a partial dentary, the first properly named cynodont from Chinle (though it was only rat-sized).

to:

** *** Evidence of cynodonts in the Chinle Formation was slim at the time, being mostly isolated teeth and other fragments (all of which couldn't be confidently assigned to cynodonts by later researchers), [[AllThereInTheManual and the main inspiration for the cynodonts in the episode were two large teeth]], later named as ''Kraterokheirodon'' (which was later deemed an indeterminate tetrapod). In 2020, however, we named ''Kataigidodon venetus'' based on a partial dentary, the first properly named cynodont from Chinle (though it was only rat-sized).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Evidence of cynodonts in the Chinle Formation was slim at the time, being mostly isolated teeth and other fragments (all of which couldn't be confidently assigned to cynodonts by later researchers), [[AllThereInTheManual and the main inspiration for the cynodonts in the episode were two large teeth]], later named as ''Kraterokheirodon'' (which was later deemed an indeterminate tetrapod). In 2020, however, we named ''Kataigidodon venetus'' based on a partial dentary, the first properly named cynodont from Chinle (though it was only rat-sized).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** While the exact cause of the non-avian dinosaurs' extinction was still debated in the '90s, WWD opted to go with a minority opinion saying that dinosaurs were already on their way out by the end of the Maastricthian, as they lived on a "sick planet" poisoned by constant volcanic activity and the meteor impact was just the straw that broke the camel's back, even though we already had ample evidence, based on the various wildlife such as fish, insects, amphibians, and small crocodiles, as well as the local flora, that Hell Creek was a lush floodplain more similar to the Everglades than anything. At the same time, here, it's depicted as a barren, ashy wasteland dotted with volcanos and with only patches of forests scattered across it, and the dinosaurs are being choked out by excessive volcanism. This was very much an artistic license, as the novelization downplays this aspect and shows a more accurate version of the Hell Creek environment (while still keeping volcanism as a threat to the local dinosaurs), and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' acknowledges that evidence of excessive volcanism at the time of the K-Pg extinction is slim.

to:

*** While the exact cause of the non-avian dinosaurs' extinction was still debated in the '90s, '90s and a gradual extinction was still considered possible, WWD opted to go with a minority opinion saying that dinosaurs were already on their way dying out by the end of the Maastricthian, as they lived specifically due to living on a "sick planet" poisoned by constant volcanic activity and the meteor impact was just the straw that broke the camel's back, activity, even though we already had ample evidence, based on the various wildlife such as fish, insects, amphibians, and small crocodiles, as well as the local flora, that Hell Creek was a lush floodplain more similar to the Everglades than anything. At the same time, Yet here, it's depicted as a barren, ashy wasteland dotted with volcanos and with only patches of forests scattered dotted across it, and the dinosaurs are being choked out by excessive volcanism. it. This was very much an artistic license, as even the novelization downplays this aspect and shows a more accurate version of the Hell Creek environment (while still keeping volcanism as a threat to the local dinosaurs), and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' acknowledges that evidence of for excessive volcanism at the time of the K-Pg extinction is slim.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Brachiosaurus'' is said to be the largest land animal ever to have lived, a popular notion for most of the 20th century, but it was already surpassed in size by ''Argentinosaurus'' by 1993 (when the latter was described). This gets corrected in ''Series/ChasedByDinosaurs''.
** Even though ''Allosaurus'' was known from numerous well-preserved skulls, even back in the late '90s, the series erroneously showed its "brow horns" as being placed above its eyes instead of just if front of them, making it look as if it has permanent AngryEyebrows. Fortunately, this was fixed with the updated model in ''Series/TheBalladOfBigAl''.

to:

** *** ''Brachiosaurus'' is said to be the largest land animal ever to have lived, a popular notion for most of the 20th century, but it was already surpassed in size by ''Argentinosaurus'' by 1993 (when the latter was described). This gets corrected in ''Series/ChasedByDinosaurs''.
** *** Even though ''Allosaurus'' was known from numerous well-preserved skulls, even back in the late '90s, the series erroneously showed its "brow horns" as being placed above its eyes instead of just if in front of them, making it look as if it has permanent AngryEyebrows. Fortunately, this was fixed with the updated model in ''Series/TheBalladOfBigAl''.

Added: 631

Changed: 282

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "Time of Titans", ''Brachiosaurus'' is said to be the largest land animal ever to have lived, a popular notion for most of the 20th century, but it was already surpassed in size by ''Argentinosaurus'' by 1993 (when the latter was described). This gets corrected in ''Series/ChasedByDinosaurs''.

to:

** In "Time of Titans", Titans":
**
''Brachiosaurus'' is said to be the largest land animal ever to have lived, a popular notion for most of the 20th century, but it was already surpassed in size by ''Argentinosaurus'' by 1993 (when the latter was described). This gets corrected in ''Series/ChasedByDinosaurs''.''Series/ChasedByDinosaurs''.
** Even though ''Allosaurus'' was known from numerous well-preserved skulls, even back in the late '90s, the series erroneously showed its "brow horns" as being placed above its eyes instead of just if front of them, making it look as if it has permanent AngryEyebrows. Fortunately, this was fixed with the updated model in ''Series/TheBalladOfBigAl''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "New Blood":
** At the time, no pterosaur fossils were confidently identified from Triassic North America (beyond some fragments tentatively attributed to ''Eudimorphodon''). In 2018, however, we described the dimorphodontid ''Caelestiventus'' from the Late Triassic of Utah.

to:

* ** "New Blood":
** *** At the time, no pterosaur fossils were confidently identified from Triassic North America (beyond some fragments tentatively attributed to ''Eudimorphodon''). In 2018, however, we described the dimorphodontid ''Caelestiventus'' from the Late Triassic of Utah.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Death of a Dynasty'':
** While the exact cause of the non-avian dinosaurs' extinction was still debated in the '90s, WWD opted to go with a minority opinion saying that dinosaurs were already on their way out by the end of the Maastricthian, as they lived on a "sick planet" poisoned by constant volcanic activity and the meteor impact was just the straw that broke the camel's back, even though we already had ample evidence, based on the various wildlife such as fish, insects, amphibians, and small crocodiles, as well as the local flora, that Hell Creek was a lush floodplain more similar to the Everglades than anything. At the same time, here, it's depicted as a barren, ashy wasteland dotted with volcanos and with only patches of forests scattered across it, and the dinosaurs are being choked out by excessive volcanism. This was very much an artistic license, as the novelization downplays this aspect and shows a more accurate version of the Hell Creek environment (while still keeping volcanism as a threat to the local dinosaurs), and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' acknowledges that evidence of excessive volcanism at the time of the K-Pg extinction is slim.

to:

* ** ''Death of a Dynasty'':
** *** While the exact cause of the non-avian dinosaurs' extinction was still debated in the '90s, WWD opted to go with a minority opinion saying that dinosaurs were already on their way out by the end of the Maastricthian, as they lived on a "sick planet" poisoned by constant volcanic activity and the meteor impact was just the straw that broke the camel's back, even though we already had ample evidence, based on the various wildlife such as fish, insects, amphibians, and small crocodiles, as well as the local flora, that Hell Creek was a lush floodplain more similar to the Everglades than anything. At the same time, here, it's depicted as a barren, ashy wasteland dotted with volcanos and with only patches of forests scattered across it, and the dinosaurs are being choked out by excessive volcanism. This was very much an artistic license, as the novelization downplays this aspect and shows a more accurate version of the Hell Creek environment (while still keeping volcanism as a threat to the local dinosaurs), and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' acknowledges that evidence of excessive volcanism at the time of the K-Pg extinction is slim.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Death of a Dynasty'':
** While the exact cause of the non-avian dinosaurs' extinction was still debated in the '90s, WWD opted to go with a minority opinion saying that dinosaurs were already on their way out by the end of the Maastricthian, as they lived on a "sick planet" poisoned by constant volcanic activity and the meteor impact was just the straw that broke the camel's back, even though we already had ample evidence, based on the various wildlife such as fish, insects, amphibians, and small crocodiles, as well as the local flora, that Hell Creek was a lush floodplain more similar to the Everglades than anything. At the same time, here, it's depicted as a barren, ashy wasteland dotted with volcanos and with only patches of forests scattered across it, and the dinosaurs are being choked out by excessive volcanism. This was very much an artistic license, as the novelization downplays this aspect and shows a more accurate version of the Hell Creek environment (while still keeping volcanism as a threat to the local dinosaurs), and ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' acknowledges that evidence of excessive volcanism at the time of the K-Pg extinction is slim.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* "New Blood":
** At the time, no pterosaur fossils were confidently identified from Triassic North America (beyond some fragments tentatively attributed to ''Eudimorphodon''). In 2018, however, we described the dimorphodontid ''Caelestiventus'' from the Late Triassic of Utah.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** This size of the show's ''Liopleurodon''. Back in the '90s, workers would have cited ''Liopleurodon'', based on fragmentary remains from Oxford Clay and younger fossils from Kimmeridge Clay subsequently assigned to ''Pliosaurus'', [[https://www.geokniga.org/bookfiles/geokniga-fossils-oxford-clay-1991.pdf as reaching a max length of maybe 15 meters]] (improved understanding of pliosaurid anatomy would place such specimens at around 10-12 meters). The larger size in the series was based on very fragmentary remains (namely a large vertebra) which yielded length estimates of anywhere between 16 to 20 meters. Even the tie-in book ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' admits that no expert truly thought that 25-meter pliosaurids existed.

to:

*** This size of the show's ''Liopleurodon''. Back in the '90s, workers would have cited ''Liopleurodon'', based on fragmentary remains from Oxford Clay and younger fossils from Kimmeridge Clay subsequently assigned to ''Pliosaurus'', [[https://www.geokniga.org/bookfiles/geokniga-fossils-oxford-clay-1991.pdf as reaching a max length of maybe 15 meters]] (improved understanding of pliosaurid anatomy would place such specimens at around 10-12 meters). The larger size in the series was based on very fragmentary remains (namely a large vertebra) which yielded length estimates of anywhere between 16 to 20 meters. Even the tie-in book ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' admits that no expert truly thought that 25-meter pliosaurids existed. Tellingly, the American cut of WWD shrunk down the ''Liopleurodon'' to 60 feet, which was more in line with the initial estimates for the large Oxford Clay fossils.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "Giant of the Skies":
*** The ''Polacanthus'' was an unfortunate example of new information being published while the series was in production. In the '90s, the fragmentary ''Hoplitosaurus'' was considered so similar to ''Polacanthus'' that some workers synonymized them, and more complete fossils similar to ''Polacanthus'' had been found alongside ''Utahraptor'' in the Cedar Mountain Formation. However, in 1998 (a year before WWD aired), the Utah fossils were described as a distinct genus, ''Gastonia'', and its describers criticized the proposed synonymization of ''Hoplitosaurus'' with ''Polacanthus'', showing that the anatomical similarities between them were plesiomorphic traits that were widespread across early nodosaurs in general. The more complete ''Gastonia'' also revealed several anatomical errors in WWD's ''Polacanthus'', most notably its head shape (which is addressed in ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' as an example of ScienceMarchesOn). The 2000 American cut of WWD, unsurprisingly, renamed the American ''Polacanthus'' as ''Gastonia''.

Added: 1765

Changed: 602

Removed: 1069

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FalselyAdvertisedAccuracy: For all the ScienceMarchesOn, a few things claimed in the series were unambiguously wrong even for 1999.
** This size of the show's ''Liopleurodon''. Back in the '90s, workers would have cited ''Liopleurodon'', based on fragmentary remains from Oxford Clay and younger fossils from Kimmeridge Clay subsequently assigned to ''Pliosaurus'', as reaching a max length of maybe 15 meters (improved understanding of pliosaurid anatomy would place such specimens at around 10-12 meters). The larger size in the series was based on very fragmentary remains (namely a large vertebra) which yielded length estimates of anywhere between 16 to 20 meters. Even the tie-in book ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' admits that no expert truly thought that 25-meter pliosaurids existed.
** Bizarrely, when comparing the locomotion of ''Ophthalmosaurus'' and ''Cryptoclidus'' in "Cruel Sea", the narrator states that the latter represents the "norm" for marine reptiles by using its four flippers for propulsion, even though most other marine reptiles such as mosasaurs and sea crocs used their tails for propulsion just like ichthyosaurs, and plesiosaurs were actually the odd ones out.

to:

* FalselyAdvertisedAccuracy: For all the ScienceMarchesOn, a few certain things claimed in the series were unambiguously wrong even for 1999.
** This size of the show's ''Liopleurodon''. Back in the '90s, workers would have cited ''Liopleurodon'', based on fragmentary remains from Oxford Clay and younger fossils from Kimmeridge Clay subsequently assigned to ''Pliosaurus'', as reaching a max length of maybe 15 meters (improved understanding of pliosaurid anatomy would place such specimens at around 10-12 meters). The larger size in the series was based on very fragmentary remains (namely a large vertebra) which yielded length estimates of anywhere between 16 to 20 meters. Even the tie-in book ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' admits that no expert truly thought that 25-meter pliosaurids existed.
** Bizarrely, when comparing the locomotion of ''Ophthalmosaurus'' and ''Cryptoclidus'' in "Cruel Sea", the narrator states that the latter represents the "norm" for marine reptiles by using its four flippers for propulsion, even though most other marine reptiles such as mosasaurs and sea crocs used their tails for propulsion just like ichthyosaurs, and plesiosaurs were actually the odd ones out.
1999.



** In "Cruel Sea", the narrator claims that large dinosaurs are rare in Late Jurassic Europe and that the 5-meter ''Eustreptospondylus'' is one of the biggest (at least in England). This is simply not true, as some of the first large dinosaurs ever named, like ''Dacentrurus'', ''Cetiosaurus'', and ''Megalosaurus'' (the first non-avian dinosaur ever named) all come from Late Jurassic England, and others, like the Portuguese ''Lustotitan'' (then lumped into ''Brachiosaurus'') were also known at the time. This is especially odd since the unaired pilot shows ''Cetiosaurus'' coexisting with ''Eustreptospondylus''.

to:

** "Cruel Sea" has several examples:
*** This size of the show's ''Liopleurodon''. Back in the '90s, workers would have cited ''Liopleurodon'', based on fragmentary remains from Oxford Clay and younger fossils from Kimmeridge Clay subsequently assigned to ''Pliosaurus'', [[https://www.geokniga.org/bookfiles/geokniga-fossils-oxford-clay-1991.pdf as reaching a max length of maybe 15 meters]] (improved understanding of pliosaurid anatomy would place such specimens at around 10-12 meters). The larger size in the series was based on very fragmentary remains (namely a large vertebra) which yielded length estimates of anywhere between 16 to 20 meters. Even the tie-in book ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' admits that no expert truly thought that 25-meter pliosaurids existed.
*** Bizarrely, when comparing the locomotion of ''Ophthalmosaurus'' and ''Cryptoclidus'' in "Cruel Sea", the narrator states that the latter represents the "norm" for marine reptiles by using its four flippers for propulsion, even though most other marine reptiles such as mosasaurs and sea crocs used their tails for propulsion just like ichthyosaurs, and plesiosaurs were actually the odd ones out.
***
In "Cruel Sea", the narrator claims that large dinosaurs are rare in Late Jurassic Europe and that the 5-meter ''Eustreptospondylus'' is one of the biggest (at least in England). This is simply not true, as some of the first large dinosaurs ever named, like ''Dacentrurus'', ''Cetiosaurus'', and ''Megalosaurus'' (the first non-avian dinosaur ever named) all come from Late Jurassic England, and others, like the Portuguese ''Lustotitan'' (then lumped into ''Brachiosaurus'') were also known at the time. This is especially odd since the unaired pilot shows ''Cetiosaurus'' coexisting with ''Eustreptospondylus''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** An unnamed large pliosaur briefly appears in the episode. A [[WordOfSaintPaul tie-in video game]] claims that it's ''Plesiopleurodon'' (a case of both InformedSpecies and major AnachronismStew). In 2018, however, we described ''Sachicasaurus'', a very large pliosaurid from Barremian Columbia, which fits the former's profile quite perfectly.

to:

*** An unnamed large pliosaur briefly appears in the episode. A [[WordOfSaintPaul tie-in video game]] claims that it's ''Plesiopleurodon'' (a case of both InformedSpecies and major AnachronismStew). In 2018, however, we described ''Sachicasaurus'', a very large pliosaurid from Barremian Columbia, Colombia, which fits the former's profile quite perfectly.

Added: 1657

Changed: 6984

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More organized


* AccidentallyCorrectZoology:
** Several scenes in "Giant of the Skies" show a generic midsized pterosaur with a ''Pteranodon''-like crest, most notably the one who gets its fish stolen by the ''Ornithocheirus'' (''Tropeognathus'') in Europe. At the time, no such animals were known from the Lower Cretaceous, but then in 2003, we named ''Ludodactylus'', a midsized anhanguerid with a ''Pteranodon''-like crest that lived in Brazil at roughly the same time as its larger cousin ''Tropeognathus'', and two years later, we also described the similar-looking ''Caulkicephalus'', who lived in Britain during the Barremian (when “Giant of the Skies” takes place).
** In "Giant of the Skies", the tapejarids are depicted as having black bodies and red crests. In 2017, a tapejarid was discovered with preserved melanosomes (pigment cells). Guess what colors its body and crest were.
** An unnamed large pliosaur briefly appears in "Giant of the Skies". A [[WordOfSaintPaul tie-in video game]] claims that it's ''Plesiopleurodon'' (a case of both InformedSpecies and major AnachronismStew). In 2018, however, we described ''Sachicasaurus'', a very large pliosaurid from Barremian Columbia, which fits the former's profile quite perfectly.
** The ''Deinosuchus'' shown in "Death of a Dynasty", which has a gharial-esque head and is described as weighing about one ton, is actually very similar to the largest crocodylomorph actually known from the Hell Creek area: ''Thoracosaurus''.
** The ''Anurognathus'' in "Time of the Titans" was a case of MisplacedWildlife. In 2007, the Morrison pterosaur ''Mesadactylus'' became classified as an anurognathid (although the classification is rather tentative, as it's based only on a single set of fused vertebrae).
** The ''Dinilysia'' is live-acted by a boid snake and unnamed. There is an actual, unnamed boid in the Hell Creek Formation (the earliest boid in the fossil record, in fact).
** Though fossil discoveries disproved the show's depiction of a stocky, badger-like ''Didelphodon'', it also turned to be a largely true portrait of ''Repenomamus'' by sheer coincidence (although ''Repenomamus'' didn't live anywhere close, geographically or temporally, to the Hell Creek Formation).
** ''Iberomesornis'' an enantiornithine is depicted with a tail fan, which until the the discovery of enantiornithines with [[https://www.cell.com/current-biology/fulltext/S0960-9822%2815%2901430-X?_returnURL=https%3A%2F%2Flinkinghub.elsevier.com%2Fretrieve%2Fpii%2FS096098221501430X%3Fshowall%3Dtrue fan-shaped]] tail feathers and [[https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/02724634.2015.1054035?journalCode=ujvp20 elaborate]] tail displays, it was thought that all enantiornithines instead possessed ribbon like tail feathers.[[note]]Though it is not known if ''Iberomesornis'' itself possessed such a structure.[[/note]]
** The European theropod ''Eustreptospondylus'' is [[AnachronismStew inaccurately shown living at the end of the Jurassic]] and is a PaletteSwap of ''Allosaurus'' (despite being a megalosaur). Coincidently, in 1999 (when WWD debuted), paleontologists in Portugal described fossil material of ''Allosaurus'' itself from the Late Jurassic Lourinhã Formation, which would later be named ''Allosaurus europaeus'' (2006).
** The German ''Rhamphorhynchus'' is shown coexisting with Oxford Clay Formation in England, likely based off fragmentary fossils from the site previously classified within the genus (and ''Rhamphorhynchus'' being thought to have a much bigger geographical range at the time due to scrappy Jurassic pterosaur fossils from around the world ascribed to it), but have since been determined to be dubious and likely represent unrelated rhamphorhynchoids (on top of the fact the episode is set more than ten million years after all the Oxford Clay fauna died out). However, an actual English ''Rhamphorhynchus'' was discovered in 2002 (named ''Rhamphorhynchus etchesi'' in 2015), and lived at the exact time the episode is set to boot (in the younger Kimmeridge Clay Formation).
** At the time the series premiered, the inclusion of ''Torosaurus'' in "Death of a Dynasty" (set in Hell Creek at the time of the Cretaceous-Paleogene extinction) was considered a minor example of an AnachronisticAnimal. While ''Torosaurus'' was indeed part of the Hell Creek biota, it was at the time only known from the middle Maastrichtian about 1-2 million years earlier than the setting of the episode. However, late Maastrichtian ''Torosaurus'' material has been uncovered since then and confirms that the genus really was still around to witness the K-Pg event[[note]]That said, the late Maastrichtian ''Torosaurus'' material comes mainly from the Scollard Formation in Canada. We don't actually know whether it was still present in Hell Creek at this point (given the overall extreme rarity of ''Torosaurus'' fossils from Hell Creek, the idea they were there at the time and we just haven't found their fossils is highly plausible).[[/note]].

to:

* AccidentallyCorrectZoology:
AccidentallyCorrectZoology: While WWD was hit by ScienceMarchesOn hard, some of the speculative ideas presented in it were justified by future discoveries.
** Several scenes "Time of the Titans":
*** The North American ''Anurognathus'' was a case of MisplacedWildlife. In 2007, the Morrison pterosaur ''Mesadactylus'' became classified as an anurognathid (although the classification is rather tentative, as it's based only on a single set of fused vertebrae).
** "Cruel Sea":
*** The European theropod ''Eustreptospondylus'' is [[AnachronismStew inaccurately shown living at the end of the Jurassic]] and is a PaletteSwap of ''Allosaurus'' (despite being a megalosaur). Coincidently,
in 1999 (when WWD debuted), paleontologists in Portugal described fossil material of ''Allosaurus'' itself from the Late Jurassic Lourinhã Formation, which would later be named ''Allosaurus europaeus'' (2006).
*** The German ''Rhamphorhynchus'' is shown coexisting with Oxford Clay Formation in England, likely based off fragmentary fossils from the site previously classified within the genus (and ''Rhamphorhynchus'' being thought to have a much bigger geographical range at the time due to scrappy Jurassic pterosaur fossils from around the world ascribed to it), but have since been determined to be dubious and likely represent unrelated rhamphorhynchoids (on top of the fact the episode is set more than ten million years after all the Oxford Clay fauna died out). However, an actual English ''Rhamphorhynchus'' was discovered in 2002 (named ''Rhamphorhynchus etchesi'' in 2015), and lived at the exact time the episode is set to boot (in the younger Kimmeridge Clay Formation).
**
"Giant of the Skies" Skies":
*** Several scenes
show a generic midsized pterosaur with a ''Pteranodon''-like crest, most notably the one who gets its fish stolen by the ''Ornithocheirus'' (''Tropeognathus'') in Europe. At the time, no such animals were known from the Lower Cretaceous, but then in 2003, we named ''Ludodactylus'', a midsized anhanguerid with a ''Pteranodon''-like crest that lived in Brazil at roughly the same time as its larger cousin ''Tropeognathus'', and two years later, we also described the similar-looking ''Caulkicephalus'', who lived in Britain during the Barremian (when “Giant of the Skies” takes place).
** In "Giant of the Skies", the *** The tapejarids are depicted as having black bodies and red crests. In 2017, a tapejarid was discovered with preserved melanosomes (pigment cells). Guess what colors its body and crest were.
** *** An unnamed large pliosaur briefly appears in "Giant of the Skies".episode. A [[WordOfSaintPaul tie-in video game]] claims that it's ''Plesiopleurodon'' (a case of both InformedSpecies and major AnachronismStew). In 2018, however, we described ''Sachicasaurus'', a very large pliosaurid from Barremian Columbia, which fits the former's profile quite perfectly.
** The ''Deinosuchus'' shown in "Death of a Dynasty", which has a gharial-esque head and is described as weighing about one ton, is actually very similar to the largest crocodylomorph actually known from the Hell Creek area: ''Thoracosaurus''.
** The ''Anurognathus'' in "Time of the Titans" was a case of MisplacedWildlife. In 2007, the Morrison pterosaur ''Mesadactylus'' became classified as an anurognathid (although the classification is rather tentative, as it's based only on a single set of fused vertebrae).
** The ''Dinilysia'' is live-acted by a boid snake and unnamed. There is an actual, unnamed boid in the Hell Creek Formation (the earliest boid in the fossil record, in fact).
** Though fossil discoveries disproved the show's depiction of a stocky, badger-like ''Didelphodon'', it also turned to be a largely true portrait of ''Repenomamus'' by sheer coincidence (although ''Repenomamus'' didn't live anywhere close, geographically or temporally, to the Hell Creek Formation).
**
*** ''Iberomesornis'' an enantiornithine is depicted with a tail fan, which until the the discovery of enantiornithines with [[https://www.cell.com/current-biology/fulltext/S0960-9822%2815%2901430-X?_returnURL=https%3A%2F%2Flinkinghub.elsevier.com%2Fretrieve%2Fpii%2FS096098221501430X%3Fshowall%3Dtrue fan-shaped]] tail feathers and [[https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/02724634.2015.1054035?journalCode=ujvp20 elaborate]] tail displays, it was thought that all enantiornithines instead possessed ribbon like tail feathers.[[note]]Though it is not known if ''Iberomesornis'' itself possessed such a structure.[[/note]]
** "Death of a Dynasty":
***
The European theropod ''Eustreptospondylus'' is [[AnachronismStew inaccurately shown living at the end of the Jurassic]] temporally displaced ''Deinosuchus'' has a gharial-esque head and is a PaletteSwap of ''Allosaurus'' (despite being a megalosaur). Coincidently, in 1999 (when WWD debuted), paleontologists in Portugal described fossil material of ''Allosaurus'' itself as weighing about one ton, is actually very similar to the largest crocodylomorph actually known from the Late Jurassic Lourinhã Formation, which would later be named ''Allosaurus europaeus'' (2006).
**
Hell Creek area: ''Thoracosaurus''.
***
The German ''Rhamphorhynchus'' ''Dinilysia'' is shown coexisting with Oxford Clay live-acted by a boid snake and unnamed. There is an actual, unnamed boid in the Hell Creek Formation (the earliest boid in England, likely based off fragmentary fossils from the site previously classified within fossil record, in fact).
*** Though fossil discoveries disproved
the genus (and ''Rhamphorhynchus'' being thought to have show's depiction of a much bigger geographical range at the time due to scrappy Jurassic pterosaur fossils from around the world ascribed to it), but have since been determined stocky, badger-like ''Didelphodon'', it also turned to be dubious and likely represent unrelated rhamphorhynchoids (on top a largely true portrait of ''Repenomamus'' by sheer coincidence (although ''Repenomamus'' didn't live anywhere close, geographically or temporally, to the fact the episode is set more than ten million years after all the Oxford Clay fauna died out). However, an actual English ''Rhamphorhynchus'' was discovered in 2002 (named ''Rhamphorhynchus etchesi'' in 2015), and lived at the exact time the episode is set to boot (in the younger Kimmeridge Clay Hell Creek Formation).
** *** At the time the series premiered, the inclusion of ''Torosaurus'' in "Death of a Dynasty" (set in Hell Creek at the time of the Cretaceous-Paleogene extinction) was considered a minor example of an AnachronisticAnimal. While ''Torosaurus'' was indeed part of the Hell Creek biota, it was at the time only known from the middle Maastrichtian about 1-2 million years earlier than the setting of the episode. However, late Maastrichtian ''Torosaurus'' material has been uncovered since then and confirms that the genus really was still around to witness the K-Pg event[[note]]That said, the late Maastrichtian ''Torosaurus'' material comes mainly from the Scollard Formation in Canada. We don't actually know whether it was still present in Hell Creek at this point (given the overall extreme rarity of ''Torosaurus'' fossils from Hell Creek, the idea they were there at the time and we just haven't found their fossils is highly plausible).[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
We already had (fragmentary) evidence of dromaeosaurs coexisting with T. rex at the time. They've simply been given their own names after WWD.


** The dromaeosaurid from "Death of a Dynasty" was seen as an example of AnachronismStew, as ''Dromaeosaurus'' (what the animal was called during production despite its flaws) was extinct by the K/Pg extinction (it was likely based on numerous dromaeosaur teeth from Hell Creek tentatively assigned to ''Dromaeosaurus''). Skip ahead to 2013, and a dromaeosaur just the right size to match with this creature was discovered in the exact formation the episode takes place in, ''Acheroraptor'' (indeed, the study that described ''Acheroraptor'' stated that it was likely the various "''Dromaeosaurus''" teeth from Hell Creek actually belonged to ''Acheroraptor''). ''Dakotaraptor'' lived in the same time and place, but was much bigger than the one in the show[[note]]That said, ''Dakotaraptor'' may be a chimera rather than a real animal[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WordOfSaintPaul: ''Dinosaur Worlds'', a tie-in video game to the series, claims that the unnamed pliosaur that briefly shows up in "Giant of the Skies" is ''Plesiopleurodon''. However, this would be a major case of both InformedSpecies and AnachronismStew, as ''Plesiopleurodon'' was a very small taxon that lived ''30 million years'' after the setting of the episode, and this isn't supported in the novelization or any of the tie-in books (which don't mention it at all).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** An unnamed large pliosaur briefly appears in "Giant of the Skies". A [[WordOfSaintPaul tie-in video game]] claims that it's ''Plesiopleurodon'' (a case of both InformedSpecies and major AnachronismStew). In 2018, however, we described ''Sachicasaurus'', a very large pliosaurid from Barremian Columbia, which fits the former's profile quite perfectly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Bizarrely, when comparing the locomotion of ''Ophthalmosaurus'' and ''Cryptoclidus'' in "Cruel Sea", the narrator states that the latter represents the "norm" for marine reptiles by using its four flippers for propulsion, even though most other marine reptiles such as mosasaurs and sea crocs used their tails for propulsion just like ichthyosaurs, and plesiosaurs were actually the odd ones out.

Added: 370

Changed: 1

Removed: 370

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Diplodocus'' (and later ''Apatosaurus'' in ''Series/TheBalladOfBigAl'') having horizontal, relatively inflexible necks was a theory sauropod expert Kent Stevens (the main advisor for "Time of Titans") was developing while the series was in production, so its inclusion in "Time of Titans" was very cutting-edge for its time ([[ScienceMarchesOn but later research on diplodocid biomechanics would heavily criticize it]]). ''Diplodocus'' having iguana-like spines was also a very new idea, thanks to the 1990 discovery of the "Howe Quarry diplodocid", which preserved impressions of long, keratenous spines.
** "Spirits of the Ice Forest" was certainly this for 1999, due to the then-recent boom of fossil finds from the Dinosaur Cove site in Victoria during the late 1980s and '90s, which helped boost our understanding of South Pole dinosaurs, not to mention the 1997 description of ''Koolasuchus'', a giant temnospondyl amphibian that survived long past its kin’s glory days.

to:

* ** ''Diplodocus'' (and later ''Apatosaurus'' in ''Series/TheBalladOfBigAl'') having horizontal, relatively inflexible necks was a theory sauropod expert Kent Stevens (the main advisor for "Time of Titans") was developing while the series was in production, so its inclusion in "Time of Titans" was very cutting-edge for its time ([[ScienceMarchesOn but later research on diplodocid biomechanics would heavily criticize it]]). ''Diplodocus'' having iguana-like spines was also a very new idea, thanks to the 1990 discovery of the "Howe Quarry diplodocid", which preserved impressions of long, keratenous spines.
** "Spirits of the Ice Forest" was certainly this for 1999, due to the then-recent boom of fossil finds from the Dinosaur Cove site in Victoria during the late 1980s and '90s, which helped boost our understanding of South Pole dinosaurs, not to mention the 1997 description of ''Koolasuchus'', a giant temnospondyl amphibian that survived long past its kin’s glory days.
spines.


Added DiffLines:

** "Spirits of the Ice Forest" was certainly this for 1999, due to the then-recent boom of fossil finds from the Dinosaur Cove site in Victoria during the late 1980s and '90s, which helped boost our understanding of South Pole dinosaurs, not to mention the 1997 description of ''Koolasuchus'', a giant temnospondyl amphibian that survived long past its kin’s glory days.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Diplodocus'' (and later ''Apatosaurus'' in ''Series/TheBalladOfBigAl'') having horizontal, relatively inflexible necks was a theory sauropod expert Kent Stevens (the main advisor for "Time of Titans") was developing while the series was in production, so its inclusion in "Time of Titans" was very cutting-edge for its time ([[ScienceMarchesOn but later research on diplodocid biomechanics would heavily criticize it]]). ''Diplodocus'' having iguana-like spines was also a very new idea, thanks to the 1990 discovery of the "Howe Quarry diplodocid", which preserved impressions of long, keratenous spines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CreatorProvincialism: It's a British documentary and "Cruel Sea" and "Giant of the Skies" focus heavily on British fossil animals. Though their depiction of ''Ornithocheirus'' was mainly based on the Brazilian ''Tropeognathus'' (as the British fossils are very fragmentary) and ''Liopleurodon'' originated in France (where it was first named from teeth but proper skeletal remains come from Oxford Clay).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Female T. rex being larger and MoreDeadlyThanTheMale is another clear-cut example, as this theory only came about during the early to mid '90s, with workers arguing that the more robust specimens represented the female of the species based on features such as a wider pelvis and an alleged reduced chevron in order to more effectively lay their eggs. However, for numerous reasons, this interpretation was heavily criticized by subsequent studies, [[https://doc.rero.ch/record/14378/files/PAL_E1827.pdf ironically starting back in 2005]] (when the WW series wrapped up).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trivia aren't called tropes, sentence removed since the entry gets the same point across anyway


** This size of the show's ''Liopleurodon''. Back in the '90s, workers would have cited ''Liopleurodon'', based on fragmentary remains from Oxford Clay and younger fossils from Kimmeridge Clay subsequently assigned to ''Pliosaurus'', as reaching a max length of maybe 15 meters (improved understanding of pliosaurid anatomy would place such specimens at around 10-12 meters). The larger size in the series was based on very fragmentary remains (namely a large vertebra) which yielded length estimates of anywhere between 16 to 20 meters, so treating the highest estimates as fact and speculating that even larger animals could have existed is essentially this trope. Even the tie-in book ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' admits that no expert truly thought that 25-meter pliosaurids existed.

to:

** This size of the show's ''Liopleurodon''. Back in the '90s, workers would have cited ''Liopleurodon'', based on fragmentary remains from Oxford Clay and younger fossils from Kimmeridge Clay subsequently assigned to ''Pliosaurus'', as reaching a max length of maybe 15 meters (improved understanding of pliosaurid anatomy would place such specimens at around 10-12 meters). The larger size in the series was based on very fragmentary remains (namely a large vertebra) which yielded length estimates of anywhere between 16 to 20 meters, so treating the highest estimates as fact and speculating that even larger animals could have existed is essentially this trope.meters. Even the tie-in book ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' admits that no expert truly thought that 25-meter pliosaurids existed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This size of the show's ''Liopleurodon''. Back in the '90s, workers would have cited ''Liopleurodon'', based on fragmentary remains from Oxford Clay and younger fossils from Kimmeridge Clay subsequently assigned to ''Pliosaurus'', as reaching a max length of maybe 15 meters (improved understanding of pliosaurid anatomy would place such specimens at around 10 meters). The larger size in the series was based on very fragmentary remains (namely a large vertebra) which yielded length estimates of anywhere between 16 to 20 meters, so treating the highest estimates as fact and speculating that even larger animals could have existed is essentially this trope. Even the tie-in book ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' admits that no expert truly thought that 25-meter pliosaurids existed.

to:

* ** This size of the show's ''Liopleurodon''. Back in the '90s, workers would have cited ''Liopleurodon'', based on fragmentary remains from Oxford Clay and younger fossils from Kimmeridge Clay subsequently assigned to ''Pliosaurus'', as reaching a max length of maybe 15 meters (improved understanding of pliosaurid anatomy would place such specimens at around 10 10-12 meters). The larger size in the series was based on very fragmentary remains (namely a large vertebra) which yielded length estimates of anywhere between 16 to 20 meters, so treating the highest estimates as fact and speculating that even larger animals could have existed is essentially this trope. Even the tie-in book ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' admits that no expert truly thought that 25-meter pliosaurids existed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* This size of the show's ''Liopleurodon''. Back in the '90s, workers would have cited ''Liopleurodon'', based on fragmentary remains from Oxford Clay and younger fossils from Kimmeridge Clay subsequently assigned to ''Pliosaurus'', as reaching a max length of maybe 15 meters (improved understanding of pliosaurid anatomy would place such specimens at around 10 meters). The larger size in the series was based on very fragmentary remains (namely a large vertebra) which yielded length estimates of anywhere between 16 to 20 meters, so treating the highest estimates as fact and speculating that even larger animals could have existed is essentially this trope. Even the tie-in book ''Walking with Dinosaurs: The Evidence'' admits that no expert truly thought that 25-meter pliosaurids existed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActorAllusion: From the 3D movie, this wouldn't be [[WesternAnimation/IceAge the first time]] Creator/JohnLeguizamo played a prehistoric animal, although this time he's playing a bird. And not [[Film/SuperMarioBros1993 the first time]] [[WesternAnimation/IceAgeDawnOfTheDinosaurs he's been surrounded by dinosaurs]]. Humorously enough, his Ice Age costar, Creator/RayRomano was picked to host the Creator/DiscoveryChannel premier of "Walking With Beasts" in order to promote Ice Age. This was an America only thing however, Canada was Romano free. Also amusing, Skylar Stone, the voice of Scowler, would later be [[TheOtherDarrin the new voice actor]] for Diego in ''WesternAnimation/TheIceAgeAdventuresOfBuckWild''.

to:

* ActorAllusion: From the 3D movie, this wouldn't be [[WesternAnimation/IceAge the first time]] Creator/JohnLeguizamo played a prehistoric animal, although this time he's playing a bird. And not [[Film/SuperMarioBros1993 the first time]] [[WesternAnimation/IceAgeDawnOfTheDinosaurs he's been surrounded by dinosaurs]]. Humorously enough, his Ice Age costar, Creator/RayRomano was picked to host the Creator/DiscoveryChannel premier of "Walking With Beasts" in order to promote Ice Age. This was an America only thing however, Canada was Romano free. Also amusing, Skylar Skyler Stone, the voice of Scowler, would later be [[TheOtherDarrin the new voice actor]] for Diego in ''WesternAnimation/TheIceAgeAdventuresOfBuckWild''.

Top