Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Trivia / Lensman

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShrugOfGod: Creator/RobertAHeinlein claimed in his ''Expanded Universe'' anthology that Smith told him how the series was supposed to continue, though he refused to explain it because it wasn't his story. All he would divulge was that "the ending develops by inescapable logic from clues in ''Children of the Lens''".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatCouldHaveBeen: There was going to be a Lensman movie written by J. Michael Straczinsky and directed by Ron Howard, but it immediately fell in DevelopmentHell before Universal decided to drop the project due to budget issues.

to:

* WhatCouldHaveBeen: There was going to be a Lensman movie written by J. Michael Straczinsky Straczynski and directed by Ron Howard, but it immediately fell in DevelopmentHell before Universal decided to drop the project due to budget issues.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** With the UrExample possibly being the gigantic Brain (1 cubic kilometer) of the ''Skylark of Valeron." Which had the advantage of "thinking" in not only electrical elements, but also gravitational, possibly the nuclear forces, and in faster-than-light forces supposed connected with thought in living creatures.

Added: 400

Changed: 397

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fix indentation


* ScienceMarchesOn: Spaceships developed on slide rule, with fantastic beam weapons that use vacuum tubes and punch cards! Given that every spaceship which flew in Smith's lifetime (d.1965) was probably drafted on slide rule, he wasn't doing too badly. It's also helpful to keep in mind that when he started writing, the concept of an entirely electronic programmable computer was itself the stuff of science fiction.

to:

* ScienceMarchesOn: ScienceMarchesOn:
**
Spaceships developed on slide rule, with fantastic beam weapons that use vacuum tubes and punch cards! Given that every spaceship which flew in Smith's lifetime (d.1965) was probably drafted on slide rule, he wasn't doing too badly. It's also helpful to keep in mind that when he started writing, the concept of an entirely electronic programmable computer was itself the stuff of science fiction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Add example

Added DiffLines:

** All of the stories except ''First Lensman'', ''Children of the Lens'', and the first five chapters of ''Triplanetary'' were written before World War II, and give insanely-high-powered explosives names that imply they're types of chemical explosives. The post-WWII stories just use nuclear weapons instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The ''TabletopGame/{{GURPS}}'' RPG supplement [[Administrivia/JustifyingEdit threw in the explanation]] that the Arisians deliberately [[FakeDifficulty prevented anyone]] in Civilization from inventing the transistor or modern computing theory, because the entire point of the Arisian breeding program was to improve the powers of the mind. Allowing the existence of surrogate minds (i.e., computers) would have interfered with that development, by removing most of the need for heightened intellectual capacity beyond the current human average. Some canonical support for this theory exists – when the Arisian breeding program finally reached its end (i.e., when the Children of the Lens were finally born), Civilization ''did'' immediately start to develop advanced computing technology, as seen in both ''Children of the Lens'' and ''Masters of the Vortex''. Although ''that'' begs the question of why even ''slide rules'' had been allowed in the interim...

to:

** The ''TabletopGame/{{GURPS}}'' RPG supplement [[Administrivia/JustifyingEdit threw in the explanation]] explanation that the Arisians deliberately [[FakeDifficulty prevented anyone]] in Civilization from inventing the transistor or modern computing theory, because the entire point of the Arisian breeding program was to improve the powers of the mind. Allowing the existence of surrogate minds (i.e., computers) would have interfered with that development, by removing most of the need for heightened intellectual capacity beyond the current human average. Some canonical support for this theory exists – when the Arisian breeding program finally reached its end (i.e., when the Children of the Lens were finally born), Civilization ''did'' immediately start to develop advanced computing technology, as seen in both ''Children of the Lens'' and ''Masters of the Vortex''. Although ''that'' begs the question of why even ''slide rules'' had been allowed in the interim...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fix typos


*** The vacuum tubes might not qualify, give that transistors can only handle very small power loads and tube circuits are very much more resistant to [=EMP=]s and hard radiation.
*** The vacuum tubes are best described as qualifying in some cases and not in others. In low-power benchtop gadgets such as the apparatus used by the Delgonians to extract life-force they certainly do. At the other end of the scale, however, the "sunbeam" works by converting an entire solar system into a giant "vacuum tube", and the description of its operation only makes sense in terms of vacuum-tube physics; a solid-state version would just be silly... In any case, vacuum tubes are far from obsolete in Real Life - specialised vacuum tubes are still the device of choice for a lot of high-frequency, high-power applications.

to:

*** ** The vacuum tubes might not qualify, give that transistors can only handle very small power loads and tube circuits are very much more resistant to [=EMP=]s and hard radiation.
*** The vacuum tubes are best described as qualifying in some cases and not in others. In low-power benchtop gadgets such as the apparatus used by the Delgonians to extract life-force they certainly do. At the other end of the scale, however, the "sunbeam" works by converting an entire solar system into a giant "vacuum tube", and the description of its operation only makes sense in terms of vacuum-tube physics; a solid-state version would just be silly... In any case, vacuum tubes are far from obsolete in Real Life RealLife - specialised vacuum tubes are still the device of choice for a lot of high-frequency, high-power applications.



* WhatCouldHaveBeen: There was going to be a Lensman movie written by J. Michael Straczinsky and directed by Ron Howard, but it immediatley fell in DevelopmentHell before Universal decided to drop the project due to budget issues.

to:

* WhatCouldHaveBeen: There was going to be a Lensman movie written by J. Michael Straczinsky and directed by Ron Howard, but it immediatley immediately fell in DevelopmentHell before Universal decided to drop the project due to budget issues.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The ''TabletopGame/{{GURPS}}'' RPG supplement [[Administrivia/JustifyingEdit threw in the explanation]] that the Arisians deliberately [[FakeDifficulty prevented anyone]] in Civilization from inventing the transistor or modern computing theory, because the entire point of the Arisian breeding program was to improve the powers of the mind. Allowing the existence of surrogate minds (i.e., computers) would have interfered with that development, by removing most of the need for heightened intellectual capacity beyond the current human average. Some canonical support for this theory exists – when the Arisian breeding program finally reached its end (i.e., when the Children of the Lens were finally born), Civilization ''did'' immediately start to develop advanced computing technology, as seen in both ''Children of the Lens'' and ''Masters of the Vortex''.

to:

** The ''TabletopGame/{{GURPS}}'' RPG supplement [[Administrivia/JustifyingEdit threw in the explanation]] that the Arisians deliberately [[FakeDifficulty prevented anyone]] in Civilization from inventing the transistor or modern computing theory, because the entire point of the Arisian breeding program was to improve the powers of the mind. Allowing the existence of surrogate minds (i.e., computers) would have interfered with that development, by removing most of the need for heightened intellectual capacity beyond the current human average. Some canonical support for this theory exists – when the Arisian breeding program finally reached its end (i.e., when the Children of the Lens were finally born), Civilization ''did'' immediately start to develop advanced computing technology, as seen in both ''Children of the Lens'' and ''Masters of the Vortex''. Although ''that'' begs the question of why even ''slide rules'' had been allowed in the interim...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling...


*** Note that the description of the SunBeam in terms of a vaccuum tube is explicitly called out as an analogy, and when Kinnison tries to correct the description he is told that the audience (Hayes and Lacey) do not need the exact detail, just the general idea.

to:

*** Note that the description of the SunBeam Sunbeam in terms of a vaccuum vacuum tube is explicitly called out as an analogy, and when Kinnison tries to correct the description he is told that the audience (Hayes and Lacey) do not need the exact detail, just the general idea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Note that the description of the SunBeam in terms of a vaccuum tube is explicitly called out as an analogy, and when Kinnison tries to correct the description he is told that the audience (Hayes and Lacey) do not need the exact detail, just the general idea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** At one point in the main series, Kimball Kinnison needs to find Civilization's absolutely smartest minds to work on a weapons project of utmost importance. To figure out who he needs, he performs an index search on the personality profiles listed in Civilization's main records database... using a mechanical [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tabulating_machine tabulating machine]] to process stacks upon stacks of hardcopy files.

to:

** At one point in the main series, Kimball Kinnison needs to find Civilization's absolutely smartest minds to work on a weapons project of utmost importance. To figure out who he needs, he performs an index search on the personality profiles listed in Civilization's main records database... using a mechanical an electromechanical [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tabulating_machine tabulating machine]] to process stacks upon stacks of hardcopy files.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** At one point in the main series, Kimball Kinnison needs to find Civilization's absolutely smartest minds to work on a weapons project of utmost importance. To figure out who he needs, he performs an index search on the personality profiles listed in Civilization's main records database... using a mechanical sorting device to process stacks upon stacks of hardcopy files.

to:

** At one point in the main series, Kimball Kinnison needs to find Civilization's absolutely smartest minds to work on a weapons project of utmost importance. To figure out who he needs, he performs an index search on the personality profiles listed in Civilization's main records database... using a mechanical sorting device [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tabulating_machine tabulating machine]] to process stacks upon stacks of hardcopy files.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The ''TabletopGame/{{GURPS}}'' RPG supplement [[JustifyingEdit threw in the explanation]] that the Arisians deliberately [[FakeDifficulty prevented anyone]] in Civilization from inventing the transistor or modern computing theory, because the entire point of the Arisian breeding program was to improve the powers of the mind. Allowing the existence of surrogate minds (i.e., computers) would have interfered with that development, by removing most of the need for heightened intellectual capacity beyond the current human average. Some canonical support for this theory exists – when the Arisian breeding program finally reached its end (i.e., when the Children of the Lens were finally born), Civilization ''did'' immediately start to develop advanced computing technology, as seen in both ''Children of the Lens'' and ''Masters of the Vortex''.

to:

** The ''TabletopGame/{{GURPS}}'' RPG supplement [[JustifyingEdit [[Administrivia/JustifyingEdit threw in the explanation]] that the Arisians deliberately [[FakeDifficulty prevented anyone]] in Civilization from inventing the transistor or modern computing theory, because the entire point of the Arisian breeding program was to improve the powers of the mind. Allowing the existence of surrogate minds (i.e., computers) would have interfered with that development, by removing most of the need for heightened intellectual capacity beyond the current human average. Some canonical support for this theory exists – when the Arisian breeding program finally reached its end (i.e., when the Children of the Lens were finally born), Civilization ''did'' immediately start to develop advanced computing technology, as seen in both ''Children of the Lens'' and ''Masters of the Vortex''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DuelingDubs: Both Harmony Gold and Creator/StreamlinePictures released dubbed versions of the anime movie. Harmony Gold also produced a CompilationMovie of the first episodes of the [[RecycledTheSeries series]].

Changed: 16

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScienceMarchesOn: Spaceships developed on slide rule, with fantastic beam weapons that use vacuum tubes! Given that every spaceship which flew in Smith's lifetime (d.1965) was probably drafted on slide rule, he wasn't doing too badly. It's also helpful to keep in mind that when he started writing, the concept of an entirely electronic programmable computer was itself the stuff of science fiction.

to:

* ScienceMarchesOn: Spaceships developed on slide rule, with fantastic beam weapons that use vacuum tubes! tubes and punch cards! Given that every spaceship which flew in Smith's lifetime (d.1965) was probably drafted on slide rule, he wasn't doing too badly. It's also helpful to keep in mind that when he started writing, the concept of an entirely electronic programmable computer was itself the stuff of science fiction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LifeImitatesArt: Development of the Essex-class Combat Information Center was inspired by the Directrix after operational analysis indicated that fleet losses early on in WorldWarII were due to a lack of coordination.

to:

* LifeImitatesArt: Development of the Essex-class Combat Information Center was inspired by the Directrix after operational analysis indicated that fleet losses early on in WorldWarII UsefulNotes/WorldWarII were due to a lack of coordination.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The {{GURPS}} RPG supplement [[JustifyingEdit threw in the explanation]] that the Arisians deliberately [[FakeDifficulty prevented anyone]] in Civilization from inventing the transistor or modern computing theory, because the entire point of the Arisian breeding program was to improve the powers of the mind. Allowing the existence of surrogate minds (i.e., computers) would have interfered with that development, by removing most of the need for heightened intellectual capacity beyond the current human average. Some canonical support for this theory exists – when the Arisian breeding program finally reached its end (i.e., when the Children of the Lens were finally born), Civilization ''did'' immediately start to develop advanced computing technology, as seen in both ''Children of the Lens'' and ''Masters of the Vortex''.

to:

** The {{GURPS}} ''TabletopGame/{{GURPS}}'' RPG supplement [[JustifyingEdit threw in the explanation]] that the Arisians deliberately [[FakeDifficulty prevented anyone]] in Civilization from inventing the transistor or modern computing theory, because the entire point of the Arisian breeding program was to improve the powers of the mind. Allowing the existence of surrogate minds (i.e., computers) would have interfered with that development, by removing most of the need for heightened intellectual capacity beyond the current human average. Some canonical support for this theory exists – when the Arisian breeding program finally reached its end (i.e., when the Children of the Lens were finally born), Civilization ''did'' immediately start to develop advanced computing technology, as seen in both ''Children of the Lens'' and ''Masters of the Vortex''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Formatting consistency pass, part three! Hooray! :D


* LifeImitatesArt - Development of the Essex-class Combat Information Center was inspired by the Directrix after operational analysis indicated that fleet losses early on in WorldWarII were due to a lack of coordination.
* ScienceMarchesOn - Spaceships developed on slide rule, with fantastic beam weapons that use vacuum tubes! Given that every spaceship which flew in Smith's lifetime (d.1965) was probably drafted on slide rule, he wasn't doing too badly. It's also helpful to keep in mind that when he started writing, the concept of an entirely electronic programmable computer was itself the stuff of science fiction.

to:

* LifeImitatesArt - LifeImitatesArt: Development of the Essex-class Combat Information Center was inspired by the Directrix after operational analysis indicated that fleet losses early on in WorldWarII were due to a lack of coordination.
* ScienceMarchesOn - ScienceMarchesOn: Spaceships developed on slide rule, with fantastic beam weapons that use vacuum tubes! Given that every spaceship which flew in Smith's lifetime (d.1965) was probably drafted on slide rule, he wasn't doing too badly. It's also helpful to keep in mind that when he started writing, the concept of an entirely electronic programmable computer was itself the stuff of science fiction.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Smith invents a collision of galaxies to explain the improbable number of planets in the galaxy. Now that planetary formation is regarded as a typical result of stellar formation, rather than the consequence of a near collision of stars, the explanation is superfluous as well as inaccurate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moved entry from main page

Added DiffLines:

* LifeImitatesArt - Development of the Essex-class Combat Information Center was inspired by the Directrix after operational analysis indicated that fleet losses early on in WorldWarII were due to a lack of coordination.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Whoops.


** At one point in the main series, Kimball Kinnison needs to find Civilization's absolutely smartest minds to work on a weapons project of utmost importance. To figure out who he needs, he performs an index search on the personality profiles listed in Civilization's main records database... using a mechanical sorting device to process stacks upon stacks of hardcopy files.

to:

** At one point in the main series, Kimball Kinnison needs to find Civilization's absolutely smartest minds to work on a weapons project of utmost importance. To figure out who he needs, he performs an index search on the personality profiles listed in Civilization's main records database... using a mechanical sorting device to process stacks upon stacks of hardcopy files.files.
* WhatCouldHaveBeen: There was going to be a Lensman movie written by J. Michael Straczinsky and directed by Ron Howard, but it immediatley fell in DevelopmentHell before Universal decided to drop the project due to budget issues.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ScienceMarchesOn - Spaceships developed on slide rule, with fantastic beam weapons that use vacuum tubes! Given that every spaceship which flew in Smith's lifetime (d.1965) was probably drafted on slide rule, he wasn't doing too badly. It's also helpful to keep in mind that when he started writing, the concept of an entirely electronic programmable computer was itself the stuff of science fiction.
** The {{GURPS}} RPG supplement [[JustifyingEdit threw in the explanation]] that the Arisians deliberately [[FakeDifficulty prevented anyone]] in Civilization from inventing the transistor or modern computing theory, because the entire point of the Arisian breeding program was to improve the powers of the mind. Allowing the existence of surrogate minds (i.e., computers) would have interfered with that development, by removing most of the need for heightened intellectual capacity beyond the current human average. Some canonical support for this theory exists – when the Arisian breeding program finally reached its end (i.e., when the Children of the Lens were finally born), Civilization ''did'' immediately start to develop advanced computing technology, as seen in both ''Children of the Lens'' and ''Masters of the Vortex''.
** Well before that, they already had MechaMooks to crew at least some of their war fleets, and robots (albeit more primitive ones) were around before humanity had expanded beyond the solar system. Lensman information technology is ... [[SchizoTech weird]] by modern standards.
** The early version of the Nebular Hypothesis that dominated the books' ideas of stellar and planetary formation, and the pre-DNA eugenics and EvolutionaryLevels concepts used in the Lensman breeding programs.
** The inertialess drive was theoretically possible when the books were written, but advancements in relativity and quantum mechanics have both made hash of it.
** Negamatter. It's essentially antimatter, but as originally imagined by Paul Dirac in the 1930s. As such, it has negative mass and some other weird properties most scientists today don't believe it should have.
*** The vacuum tubes might not qualify, give that transistors can only handle very small power loads and tube circuits are very much more resistant to [=EMP=]s and hard radiation.
*** The vacuum tubes are best described as qualifying in some cases and not in others. In low-power benchtop gadgets such as the apparatus used by the Delgonians to extract life-force they certainly do. At the other end of the scale, however, the "sunbeam" works by converting an entire solar system into a giant "vacuum tube", and the description of its operation only makes sense in terms of vacuum-tube physics; a solid-state version would just be silly... In any case, vacuum tubes are far from obsolete in Real Life - specialised vacuum tubes are still the device of choice for a lot of high-frequency, high-power applications.
** Atomic power generation. As hinted in the "main sequence" and explicitly described in ''Masters of the Vortex'', atomic power plants generate power from a "vortex of atomic destruction" which eats ''everything'', not just fissile materials... and is self-sustaining. So the Lensman-universe equivalent of China Syndrome is an atomic vortex which escapes from the power plant's control, fuelling itself on ordinary rock and spewing a continuous effluvium of highly radioactive reaction products, like a version of Chernobyl that doesn't stop.
*** The climax of ''Masters of the Vortex'' is Neal Cloud and Joan Janowick's discovery of just ''why'' those powerplants are exploding, who is responsible, and what can be done about it.
** At one point in the main series, Kimball Kinnison needs to find Civilization's absolutely smartest minds to work on a weapons project of utmost importance. To figure out who he needs, he performs an index search on the personality profiles listed in Civilization's main records database... using a mechanical sorting device to process stacks upon stacks of hardcopy files.

Top