Follow TV Tropes

Following

History TheScrappy / LiveActionTv

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Worst, in Forever Red, Cole SINGLE-HANDEDLY took out Darkanda. You remember Darkonda, right? The enormous zord-like ship that was said to be impossible to defeat? Cole defeated it, by himself, without even using his zord.

to:

** Worst, in Forever Red, Cole SINGLE-HANDEDLY took out Darkanda. Serpentera. You remember Darkonda, Serpentera, right? The enormous zord-like ship that was said to be impossible to defeat? Cole defeated it, by himself, without even using his zord.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** You could say Turbo was the Scarppy ''season.''


Added DiffLines:

* PowerRangersWildForce has Cole, the rookie Red Ranger who stole the team from Taylor, and became instantly the leader for no reason. He would constantly talk about how he could read a beings "heart," which didn't help the fact that many fans think Wild Force was too preachy.
** Worst, in Forever Red, Cole SINGLE-HANDEDLY took out Darkanda. You remember Darkonda, right? The enormous zord-like ship that was said to be impossible to defeat? Cole defeated it, by himself, without even using his zord.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Purple Parrots from TheLegendsOfTheHiddenTemple. While no one really "hates" them, they are the most put down team. They won the least temple runs, and made it to the temple less then any of the teams. Plus, the network often skrewed them, with putting the shortest, least-talented kids on that team.

to:

* The Purple Parrots from TheLegendsOfTheHiddenTemple.LegendsOfTheHiddenTemple. While no one really "hates" them, they are the most put down team. They won the least temple runs, and made it to the temple less then any of the teams. Plus, the network often skrewed them, with putting the shortest, least-talented kids on that team.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*The Purple Parrots from TheLegendsOfTheHiddenTemple. While no one really "hates" them, they are the most put down team. They won the least temple runs, and made it to the temple less then any of the teams. Plus, the network often skrewed them, with putting the shortest, least-talented kids on that team.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pretty much any female companion or almost companion in the new series has a faction of the fanbase that dislikes her and accuses her of being a MarySue: perhaps with some justification, but more frequently for being repetitive and somewhat anodyne. This would include Rose, Martha, Donna, Astrid, Jenny, River Song, and most recently Lady Christina. Jenny was apparently declared a Sue before the episode featuring her even aired because, of course, the episode was entitled "The Doctor's Daughter" and any suggestion the Doctor has or could have children is anathema to a certain segment of the base that thinks the Doctor is and always has been celibate.

to:

** Pretty much any female companion or almost companion in the new series has a faction of the fanbase that dislikes her and accuses her of being a MarySue: perhaps with some justification, but more frequently for being repetitive and somewhat anodyne. This would include Rose, Martha, Donna, Astrid, Jenny, River Song, and most recently Lady Christina. Jenny was apparently declared a Sue before the episode featuring her even aired because, of course, the episode was entitled "The Doctor's Daughter" and any suggestion the Doctor has or could have children is anathema to a certain segment of the base that thinks the Doctor is and always has been celibate. This position, of course, requires that segment of the fanbase to [[FanDumb completely ignore the fact that the very first episode of the first series introduced the First Doctor ]]''[[FanDumb and his granddaughter]]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** It's generally accepted among fans that the quality of any 7th season episode can be determined by how many lines Kennedy has in it. The more she has to say, the worse the episode is.
*** And then in the Season 8 comics, Whedon decides to troll fans by [[spoiler:having Willow mention that Kennedy died...but then say that it was a magical death so she was able to resurrect her. Even though [[WallBanger resurrection spells had already been established to be a bad idea, given that when Willow used one on Buffy it literally ripped her out of Heaven against her will, traumatizing her for most of the next year]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A lot of Mandy's Scrappiness was her inability to fit in with the compassionate, quirky, slightly bumbling, bleeding-heart, idealistic senior staff. Unlike most TV shows, every single main character on The West Wing was a member of one single [[{{Nakama}} unified, close-knit team]], and Mandy, being the only exception and not a very important one at that, was left floating.

to:

** A lot of Mandy's Scrappiness was her inability to fit in with the compassionate, quirky, slightly bumbling, bleeding-heart, idealistic senior staff. Unlike most TV shows, every single main character on The West Wing was a member of one single [[{{Nakama}} [[Nakama unified, close-knit team]], and Mandy, being the only exception and not a very important one at that, was left floating.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A lot of Mandy's Scrappiness was her inability to fit in with the compassionate, quirky, slightly bumbling, bleeding-heart, idealistic senior staff. Unlike most TV shows, every single main character on The West Wing was a member of one single [[Nakama unified, close-knit team]], and Mandy, being the only exception and not a very important one at that, was left floating.

to:

** A lot of Mandy's Scrappiness was her inability to fit in with the compassionate, quirky, slightly bumbling, bleeding-heart, idealistic senior staff. Unlike most TV shows, every single main character on The West Wing was a member of one single [[Nakama [[{{Nakama}} unified, close-knit team]], and Mandy, being the only exception and not a very important one at that, was left floating.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mandy was also blamed by fans for blighting several season 1 scenes by doing things and being involved in plots that, in the hands of other characters, would have been interesting. How by dint of [[FlatCharacter flatness]], making said plots and actions boring and annoying. Suffice to say that CJ would probably have been even cooler than she already was had Mandy not been created.

to:

** Mandy was also blamed by fans for blighting several season 1 scenes by doing things and being involved in plots that, in the hands of other characters, would have been interesting. How intriguing, empathetic and complex. However, by dint of [[FlatCharacter flatness]], making Mandy made said plots and actions boring boring, unemotional, and annoying. Suffice to say that CJ would probably have been even cooler than she already was had Mandy not been created.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A lot of Mandy's Scrappiness was her inability to fit in with the compassionate, quirky, slightly bumbling, bleeding-heart, idealistic senior staff. Unlike most TV shows, every single main character on The West Wing was a member of one single [[Nakama unified, close-knit team]], and Mandy, being the only exception and not a very important one at that, was left floating.
** Mandy was also blamed by fans for blighting several season 1 scenes by doing things and being involved in plots that, in the hands of other characters, would have been interesting. How by dint of [[FlatCharacter flatness]], making said plots and actions boring and annoying. Suffice to say that CJ would probably have been even cooler than she already was had Mandy not been created.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





to:

\n\n*Babe Cary Chandler from AllMyChildren. Oh my God, Babe. She started as the slutty gold digger playing two brothers, then the writers decided to make her a heroine, without actually changing her in any way. The worst was when she knowingly kept Miranda, Bianca's daughter, away from her, letting everybody believe Miranda was dead. Oh, but she wasn't totally heartless, she let Bianca be Miranda's godmother! And said to her at least once that Bianca was lucky to not be a mother because she had all this time for herself, while Bianca was grieving the "dead" of her daughter. And then, after Bianca got her daughter back, not thanks to Babe, and gave her a very deserving slap, the writers actual had Bianca said that everything Babe did was out of love, for others, with total sincerity... Yeah.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





to:

\n\n* Tori from SavedByTheBell is widely despised for jumping into the series, [[ReplacementScrappy replacing Kelly and Jessie out of nowhere]], and being a general MarySue by besting everything anybody does, and ends up with the rather popular Lisa begging to be her friend.


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This troper doesn't want to sound pretentious, but I really do wonder how much of the vitrol towards Vanessa stems from the young people watching the show not being able to identify with her geek passions. Teenagers watching the show wouldn't get her having a Jean-Luc Godard poster on her wall, or Dan's aside [[spoiler:to the baby]] in the 4th season that he'll be watching "Battleship Potemkin" a lot.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''PowerRangersSPD'' has Sam, the Omega Ranger, because he was just a ball of light and we really don't know anything about him just added to the hatred. And when he finally appeared out of costume for all of three seconds, it was seen as a huge insult to the fanbase.

to:

* ''PowerRangersSPD'' has Sam, the Omega Ranger, because he was just a ball of light and we really don't know anything about him just added to the hatred. him. And when he finally appeared out of costume for all of three seconds, it seconds--in the ''finale'', no less--it was seen as a huge insult to the fanbase.

Added: 846

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Tommy Oliver has a bit of a hatedom. This appears to be in hindsight, though, since if you ask anybody who grew up in TheNineties their favorite Power Ranger, only those who still watch the show will most likley not say Tommy. Those who insist he is TheScrappy say so for all the usal reasons: SpotlightStealingSquad, MarySue, ShillingTheWesley (which depends on him being TheWesley in the first place, rather than fan demand)...

to:

** Tommy Oliver has a bit of a hatedom. This appears to be in hindsight, though, since if you ask anybody who grew up in TheNineties their favorite Power Ranger, only those who still watch the show will most likley not say Tommy. Those who insist he is TheScrappy say so for all the usal usual reasons: SpotlightStealingSquad, MarySue, ShillingTheWesley (which depends on him being TheWesley in the first place, rather than fan demand)...demand)...
* From ''PowerRangersLightspeedRescue'', there was Carter Grayson. His preference for using blasters and [[DullSurprise having the personality of a wooden board]] were the major reasons why he was so hated. However, over the years and thanks to [[AtopTheFourthWall Linkara]]'s review of the season, he was RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap in hindsight.
** Vypra, also from the same season, was not so lucky. The large reason why she was so hated was due to her portrayer's [[{{Narm}} notoriously bad acting]], even ''[[BeyondTheImpossible worse]]'' than the typical Power Rangers fare.
* ''PowerRangersSPD'' has Sam, the Omega Ranger, because he was just a ball of light and we really don't know anything about him just added to the hatred. And when he finally appeared out of costume for all of three seconds, it was seen as a huge insult to the fanbase.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Tommy Oliver has a bit of a hatedom. This appears to be in hindsight, though, since if you ask anybody who grew up in TheNineties their favorite Power Ranger, only those who still watch the show will most likley not say Tommy. Those who insist he is TheScrappy say so for all the usal reasons: SpotlightStealingSquad, MarySue, ShillingTheWesley (which depends on him being TheWesley in the first place, rather than fan demand)...

Added: 172

Changed: 693

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Vanessa Abrams on ''GossipGirl'' is thuroughly despised by a vast, and vocal, majority of the show's viewers. Aside from being played by an actress who really cannot act, the character Vanessa is just as shallow, manipulative and self-serving as Blair Waldorf, yet she keeps putting herself up on high horses, lecturing and mastering others, in addition to being the DistaffCounterpart to Dan and thus serving no real purpose on her own. In fact, the showrunners seem to be quite aware of how unpopular she is - despite being credited as a main character Vanessa is missing from several episodes each season (including the season three finale), and hardly ever gets any storlines of her own.
** Jenny Humphrey is either [[LoveItOrHateIt this or well liked]]. [[YourMileageMayVary Depends on who you ask]].
** Dan Humphrey is slipping into Scrappy territory as well.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Between the bad acting, personality void, and being the only character to have nearly so much make-up and hair care AfterTheEnd, Emily Sullivan was fairly quick to become ''{{Jericho}}'' fandom's least favorite. Matters weren't helped later in the season, with her lack of caring about her fiance and being seen as a rival - in general as well as [[DieForOurShip romantically]] - to recurring character Heather.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Type in "Tuvok" into a Youtube search and let the auto-fill menu come up - the number one recommendation is [[spoiler: "Tuvok kills Neelix"]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Elmo on ''SesameStreet''. Some parents (including ThisTroper) only show their children old pre-Elmo episodes and movies and DVD.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Kate Austen is possibly the most hated main character. This is mostly due to her constantly bouncing back and forth between Jack and Sawyer, resulting in a recurring love triangle subplot which many fans found annoying. Also, her flashback episodes are often considered to be some of the worst in the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Wolowitz is a BrokenBase case - half of the fans find his TheLeisureSuitLarry antiques hilarious, while the other half never found it funny in the first place and wish he gets less screentime.

to:

** Wolowitz is a BrokenBase case - half of the fans find his TheLeisureSuitLarry antiques antics hilarious, while the other half never found it funny in the first place and wish he gets less screentime.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** While trying to replace Kelso at the same time.

Added: 149

Changed: 147

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removing an example that has already been mentioned


** Leia was also despised by many for [[SatelliteCharacter being useless]]. Thankfully the writers finally [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome took the hint.]]



* Just write that you think Jenna from ''DegrassiTheNextGeneration'' is not so bad, or even goodness forbid that you like her and see what happens.

to:

* Just write that you think Jenna from ''DegrassiTheNextGeneration'' is not so bad, or even goodness forbid that you like her and see what happens.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Further, it's okay for [=McCoy=] to insult Spock because Vulcans have a high amount of political power and nobody would cite Spock's being a Vulcan as a reason to remove him from command. Data on the other hand goes through ''genuine'' prejudice over his status as an android, with officers questioning if Data can do things like make command decisions or care for small children. At the time in which Pulaski was on the ship, Data wasn't even being recognized as a sentient being, and thus had none of the rights that would entail. Keeping all this in mind, Pulaski's slamming of Data's cold logic making him inferior to humans just makes her look like a bigot. Pulaski was also regularly cited by other characters as having a very kind and compassionate personality. Her treatment of Data says otherwise.

to:

** Further, it's okay for [=McCoy=] to insult Spock because Vulcans have a high amount of political power and nobody would cite Spock's being a Vulcan as a reason to remove him from command. Data on the other hand goes through ''genuine'' prejudice over his status as an android, with officers questioning if Data can do things like make command decisions or care for small children. At the time in which Pulaski was on the ship, Data wasn't even being recognized as a sentient being, and thus had none of the rights that would entail. Keeping all this in mind, Pulaski's slamming of Data's cold logic making him inferior to humans just makes her look like a bigot. [[ShillingTheWesley Pulaski was also regularly cited by other characters as having a very kind and compassionate personality.personality]]. Her treatment of Data says otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Mandy in TheWestWing. [[BrotherChuck She disappeared without a trace from Season 2 onward]].

Changed: 8

Removed: 16

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Another Scrappy on the show would not so much be a character but multiple characters played by the same actress. These would be the multitude of Ali Larter clone characters. Once the first character ran her course fans were happy to see her character's storyline come to a close and Ali Larter to be done on ''{{Heroes}}'', but WAIT ''{{Heroes}}'' fans were introduced to a concept that no matter how many characters played by Ali Larter die, there could always be another one in hiding. In the promos for season 4 it is shown that Ali Larter's many characters have become a Wesley as the next season centers around her. Unless she is in a whipped cream bikini there really isn't a reason to keep her around, her acting is horrible. The only good thing about this Scrappy is you actually get to watch her die multiple times on the show and though each one is exciting for the fans, it is bittersweet because the fans know she'll always return as Gina, or Brenda, or Cookie, or Lanora, or any other name and random power you can put on her.

to:

** Another Scrappy on the show would not so much be a character but multiple characters played by the same actress. These would be the multitude of Ali Larter clone characters. Once the first character ran her course fans were happy to see her character's storyline come to a close and Ali Larter to be done on ''{{Heroes}}'', ''Heroes'', but WAIT ''{{Heroes}}'' ''Heroes'' fans were introduced to a concept that no matter how many characters played by Ali Larter die, there could always be another one in hiding. In the promos for season 4 it is shown that Ali Larter's many characters have become a Wesley as the next season centers around her. Unless she is in a whipped cream bikini there really isn't a reason to keep her around, her acting is horrible. The only good thing about this Scrappy is you actually get to watch her die multiple times on the show and though each one is exciting for the fans, it is bittersweet because the fans know she'll always return as Gina, or Brenda, or Cookie, or Lanora, or any other name and random power you can put on her.



<<|TheScrappy|>>
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Further, it's okay for [=McCoy=] to insult Spock because Vulcans have a high amount of political power and nobody would cite Spock's being a Vulcan as a reason to remove him from command. Data on the other hand goes through ''genuine'' prejudice over his status as an android, with officers questioning if Data can do things like make command decisions or care for small children. At the time in which Pulaski was on the ship, Data wasn't even being recognized as a sentient being, and thus had none of the rights that would entail. Keeping all this in mind, Pulaski's slamming of Data's cold logic making him inferior to humans just makes her look like a bigot.

to:

** Further, it's okay for [=McCoy=] to insult Spock because Vulcans have a high amount of political power and nobody would cite Spock's being a Vulcan as a reason to remove him from command. Data on the other hand goes through ''genuine'' prejudice over his status as an android, with officers questioning if Data can do things like make command decisions or care for small children. At the time in which Pulaski was on the ship, Data wasn't even being recognized as a sentient being, and thus had none of the rights that would entail. Keeping all this in mind, Pulaski's slamming of Data's cold logic making him inferior to humans just makes her look like a bigot. Pulaski was also regularly cited by other characters as having a very kind and compassionate personality. Her treatment of Data says otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* For some reasons, the writers of ''CSINewYork'' decided that what season 3 really needed was Reed; an annoying, TooDumbToLive internet journalist who was the son of Mac's dead wife. A wife who was dead before the series begun. That's right. They thought viewers would embrace this character because he was related to a character we'd never actually met. A collective cheer went up when he was kidnapped by the Cabbie Killer at the end of season 4. A collective groan went out when he was rescued at the start of season 5. Still the writers seemed to have learned their lesson and he did nor reappear afterwards.

Added: 325

Changed: 253

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added


*** The character came close to being RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap in "Earthshock" when [[spoiler:he got killed off heroically]], and the impact of this event shaped further developments in the Fifth Doctor's character and in fact continued to reverberate even during recent (2010) comic book stories featuring the Tenth Doctor.



*** Pretty much any female companion or almost companion in the new series has a faction of the fanbase that dislikes her and accuses her of being a MarySue: perhaps with some justification, but more frequently for being repetitive and somewhat anodyne. This would include Rose, Martha, Donna, Astrid, Jenny, River Song, and most recently Lady Christina. Jenny was apparently declared a Sue before the episode featuring her even aired because, of course, the episode was entitled "The Doctor's Daughter" and any suggestion the Doctor has or could have children is anathema to a certain segment of the base that thinks the Doctor is and always has been celibate.
** The Doctor himself hasn't escaped Scrappy-dom, either; both the Sixth Doctor (as played by Colin Baker) and the Seventh Doctor (as played by [=Sylvester McCoy=]) are considered Scrappies by certain parts of fandom. This mainly applies to their television portrayals, however, both of which are agreed to have been debuted in a particularly difficult era of the show's history which affected the way both were introduced and presented; it's widely agreed that the various ExpandedUniverse media featuring these characters has largely contributed to them being RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap.

to:

*** ** Pretty much any female companion or almost companion in the new series has a faction of the fanbase that dislikes her and accuses her of being a MarySue: perhaps with some justification, but more frequently for being repetitive and somewhat anodyne. This would include Rose, Martha, Donna, Astrid, Jenny, River Song, and most recently Lady Christina. Jenny was apparently declared a Sue before the episode featuring her even aired because, of course, the episode was entitled "The Doctor's Daughter" and any suggestion the Doctor has or could have children is anathema to a certain segment of the base that thinks the Doctor is and always has been celibate.
** The Doctor himself hasn't escaped Scrappy-dom, either; both the Sixth Doctor (as played by Colin Baker) and the Seventh Doctor (as played by [=Sylvester McCoy=]) are considered Scrappies by certain parts of fandom. This mainly applies to their television portrayals, however, both of which are agreed to have been debuted in a particularly difficult era of the show's history which affected the way both were introduced and presented; it's widely agreed that the various ExpandedUniverse media featuring these characters has largely contributed to them being RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap. Both David Tennant and Matt Smith were initially declared "Scrappys" by elements of fandom once they were cast; in both cases, however, they rescued themselves from the Scrappy Heap within about 5 seconds of actually appearing on screen as the Doctor.

Top