Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / SiskelAndEbert

Go To

OR

Added: 511

Changed: 151

Removed: 210

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fits here better


* AuthorAppeal: In Siskel's case, he pointed out that he loved doing the show because it combined three things he passionately love: movies, television and journalism.

to:

* AuthorAppeal: AuthorAppeal:
**
In Siskel's case, he pointed out that he loved doing the show because it combined three things he passionately love: loved: movies, television and journalism.journalism.
** One Viewer's Thumb entry claimed that the only reason the duo gave ''Film/SpaceJam'' two thumbs up is because Michael Jordan is from Chicago, where the show was filmed, which might seem like InsaneTrollLogic until you recall that Siskel was a huge Chicago Bulls fan (Ebert didn't much care for sports, despite having began his career as a sportswriter).



* InsaneTrollLogic: One particularly baffling Viewer's Thumb entry claimed that the only reason the duo gave ''Film/SpaceJam'' two thumbs up is because Michael Jordan is from Chicago, where the show was filmed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AuthorAppeal: In Siskel's case, he pointed out that he loved doing the show because it combined three things he passionately love: movies, television and journalism.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Siskel & Ebert'' (''Siskel & Ebert & the Movies'' in its first season) was a FirstRunSyndication American television series that ran from 1986 to 1999. It was a continuation of three previous shows they'd done together: ''Opening Soon...at a Theater Near You'' on Chicago Creator/{{PBS}} affiliate WTTW (1975-77); ''Sneak Previews'' (1977-82), a renamed version of the first show that went national on PBS in 1978 and became massively popular; and ''At the Movies'' (1982-86), the first show they did after leaving public television for syndication (''Sneak Previews'' and ''At the Movies'' both continued for several years with different hosts after Siskel and Ebert left, but eventually folded). All of the shows had the same basic format: two critics, Creator/GeneSiskel of the ''UsefulNotes/{{Chicago}} Tribune'' and Creator/RogerEbert of the ''Chicago Sun-Times'', discuss and debate the week's new films. Roughly four or five films were critiqued per episode. It usually ended with a special segment like "Video/Laserdisc Pick of the Week/Month", an interview with a celebrity or director, or a short-lived segment where viewers wrote in to provide a second opinion or correct S&E about something. The show taped at [[Creator/AmericanBroadcastingCompany ABC's]] Chicago affiliate, WLS-TV, which is also where ''Series/TheOprahWinfreyShow'' initially taped as well.

to:

''Siskel & Ebert'' (''Siskel & Ebert & the Movies'' in its first season) was a FirstRunSyndication American television series that ran from 1986 to 1999. It was a continuation of three previous shows they'd done that Creator/GeneSiskel and Creator/RogerEbert did together: ''Opening Soon...at a Theater Near You'' on Chicago Creator/{{PBS}} affiliate WTTW (1975-77); ''Sneak Previews'' (1977-82), a renamed version of the first show that went national on PBS in 1978 and became massively popular; and ''At the Movies'' (1982-86), the first show they did after leaving public television for syndication (''Sneak Previews'' and ''At the Movies'' both continued for several years with different hosts after Siskel and Ebert left, but eventually folded). All of the shows had the same basic format: two critics, Creator/GeneSiskel of the ''UsefulNotes/{{Chicago}} Tribune'' Siskel and Creator/RogerEbert of Ebert, film critics for rival UsefulNotes/{{Chicago}} newspapers (Siskel at the ''Chicago Sun-Times'', Tribune'', Ebert at the ''Chicago Sun-Times''), discuss and debate the week's new films. Roughly four or five films were critiqued per episode. It usually ended with a special segment like "Video/Laserdisc Pick of the Week/Month", an interview with a celebrity or director, or a short-lived segment where viewers wrote in to provide a second opinion or correct S&E about something. The show taped at [[Creator/AmericanBroadcastingCompany ABC's]] Chicago affiliate, WLS-TV, which is also where ''Series/TheOprahWinfreyShow'' initially taped as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvolvingCredits: ''Opening Soon...at a Theater Near You'' opened with a montage of stills of various Hollywood icons. ''Sneak Previews'' had a comical scene set at a movie theater, where a [[TheFaceless Faceless]] patron buys a ticket labeled "Sneak Previews", a tub of popcorn with Roger Ebert's name on it, a box of candy with Gene Siskel's name on it, and has a "Sneak Previews" paper cup get stuck in a faulty drink dispenser. ''At the Movies'' had the pair in the opening for the first time, separately arriving at a theater and delivering sight gags as they make their way through the lobby (Siskel sneaking in popcorn and other snacks inside his briefcase, Ebert buying a notebook in a snack vending machine) before they head up to the balcony. ''Siskel & Ebert'' showed a DayInTheLife of its hosts, working at their respective newspapers, ending with them arguing about each other's reviews as they head to the theater.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SerialEscalation: The "If We Picked the Winners" Oscar special began as a simple FormulaBreakingEpisode with Gene and Roger in the balcony wearing tuxedos, but eventually turned into a huge spectacle done on a stage at the Disney complex in Florida with a studio audience and an orchestra.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigGuyLittleGuy: They both fit either role, depending on how looked at it. Hefty Ebert contrasted with skinny Siskel, but Siskel was the taller of the two (by about 6 inches[=/=]15cm).

to:

* BigGuyLittleGuy: They both fit either role, depending on how you looked at it. Hefty Ebert contrasted with skinny Siskel, but Siskel was the taller of the two (by about 6 inches[=/=]15cm).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ebert wasn't really short (5'8")


* BigGuyLittleGuy: Siskel was tall and skinny; Ebert was short and fat.

to:

* BigGuyLittleGuy: They both fit either role, depending on how looked at it. Hefty Ebert contrasted with skinny Siskel, but Siskel was tall and skinny; Ebert was short and fat.the taller of the two (by about 6 inches[=/=]15cm).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrieferThanTheyThink: Even thought it was the show that made them big names, the Siskel & Ebert-hosted era of ''Sneak Previews'' as a nationally-aired Creator/{{PBS}} show only lasted four years (1978-82) before they moved to syndication. By contrast, the Jeffrey Lyons-Michael Medved era (1985-1996) was almost three times as long (with Lyons starting in 1982).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Another good one was when they reviewed Creator/NicolasCage's ''It Could Happen To You'', which they were '''very''' enthusiastic about, calling it one of the best films of the year... After the commercial that followed this review came the ''Film/{{North}}'' review, which doesn't need an explanation.

to:

** Another good one was when they reviewed Creator/NicolasCage's ''It Could Happen To You'', ''Film/ItCouldHappenToYou'', which they were '''very''' enthusiastic about, calling it one of the best films of the year... After the commercial that followed this review came the ''Film/{{North}}'' review, which doesn't need an explanation.

Added: 454

Changed: 148

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Siskel & Ebert'' (''Siskel & Ebert & the Movies'' in its first season) was a FirstRunSyndication American television series that ran from 1986 to 1999. It was a continuation of three previous shows they'd done together: ''Opening Soon...at a Theater Near You'' on Chicago Creator/{{PBS}} affiliate WTTW (1975-77); ''Sneak Previews'' (1977-82), a renamed version of the first show that went national on PBS in 1978 and became massively popular; and ''At the Movies'' (1982-86), the first show they did after leaving public television for syndication. All of the shows had the same basic format: two critics, Creator/GeneSiskel of the ''UsefulNotes/{{Chicago}} Tribune'' and Creator/RogerEbert of the ''Chicago Sun-Times'', discuss and debate the week's new films. Roughly four or five films were critiqued per episode. It usually ended with a special segment like "Video/Laserdisc Pick of the Week/Month", an interview with a celebrity or director, or a short-lived segment where viewers wrote in to provide a second opinion or correct S&E about something. The show taped at [[Creator/AmericanBroadcastingCompany ABC's]] Chicago affiliate, WLS-TV, which is also where ''Series/TheOprahWinfreyShow'' initially taped as well.

to:

''Siskel & Ebert'' (''Siskel & Ebert & the Movies'' in its first season) was a FirstRunSyndication American television series that ran from 1986 to 1999. It was a continuation of three previous shows they'd done together: ''Opening Soon...at a Theater Near You'' on Chicago Creator/{{PBS}} affiliate WTTW (1975-77); ''Sneak Previews'' (1977-82), a renamed version of the first show that went national on PBS in 1978 and became massively popular; and ''At the Movies'' (1982-86), the first show they did after leaving public television for syndication.syndication (''Sneak Previews'' and ''At the Movies'' both continued for several years with different hosts after Siskel and Ebert left, but eventually folded). All of the shows had the same basic format: two critics, Creator/GeneSiskel of the ''UsefulNotes/{{Chicago}} Tribune'' and Creator/RogerEbert of the ''Chicago Sun-Times'', discuss and debate the week's new films. Roughly four or five films were critiqued per episode. It usually ended with a special segment like "Video/Laserdisc Pick of the Week/Month", an interview with a celebrity or director, or a short-lived segment where viewers wrote in to provide a second opinion or correct S&E about something. The show taped at [[Creator/AmericanBroadcastingCompany ABC's]] Chicago affiliate, WLS-TV, which is also where ''Series/TheOprahWinfreyShow'' initially taped as well.


Added DiffLines:

* RedOniBlueOni: Siskel (Red) was the more vocal one, prone to wisecracks, and often went to bat for things like lowbrow comedies or genre films that Ebert didn't care for. Ebert (Blue) was more restrained, more prone to dry sarcasm, and would defend more unconventional or arty movies that Siskel may not have liked. This was actually at odds with their backgrounds: Siskel was an Ivy Leaguer (Yale specifically), Ebert came from a working-class family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Siskel & Ebert'' (''Siskel & Ebert & the Movies'' in its first season) was a syndicated American television series that ran from 1986 to 1999, spun off from an earlier show on Creator/{{PBS}}: ''Opening Soon at a Theater Near You''[=/=]''Sneak Previews'' (1975 to 1982), as well as the syndicated ''At the Movies'' (1982 to 1986), both of which utilized a similar format of two critics, Creator/GeneSiskel of the ''UsefulNotes/{{Chicago}} Tribune'' and Creator/RogerEbert of the ''Chicago Sun-Times'', discussing and debating the week's new films. Roughly four or five films were critiqued per episode. It usually ended with a special segment like "Video/Laserdisc Pick of the Week/Month", an interview with a celebrity or director, or a short-lived segment where viewers wrote in to provide a second opinion or correct S&E about something. The show taped at Creator/{{ABC}}'s Chicago station, WLS-TV, which is also where ''Series/TheOprahWinfreyShow'' initially taped as well.

to:

''Siskel & Ebert'' (''Siskel & Ebert & the Movies'' in its first season) was a syndicated FirstRunSyndication American television series that ran from 1986 to 1999, spun off from an earlier show on Creator/{{PBS}}: 1999. It was a continuation of three previous shows they'd done together: ''Opening Soon Soon...at a Theater Near You''[=/=]''Sneak You'' on Chicago Creator/{{PBS}} affiliate WTTW (1975-77); ''Sneak Previews'' (1975 to 1982), as well as (1977-82), a renamed version of the syndicated first show that went national on PBS in 1978 and became massively popular; and ''At the Movies'' (1982 to 1986), both (1982-86), the first show they did after leaving public television for syndication. All of which utilized a similar format of the shows had the same basic format: two critics, Creator/GeneSiskel of the ''UsefulNotes/{{Chicago}} Tribune'' and Creator/RogerEbert of the ''Chicago Sun-Times'', discussing discuss and debating debate the week's new films. Roughly four or five films were critiqued per episode. It usually ended with a special segment like "Video/Laserdisc Pick of the Week/Month", an interview with a celebrity or director, or a short-lived segment where viewers wrote in to provide a second opinion or correct S&E about something. The show taped at Creator/{{ABC}}'s [[Creator/AmericanBroadcastingCompany ABC's]] Chicago station, affiliate, WLS-TV, which is also where ''Series/TheOprahWinfreyShow'' initially taped as well.




to:

* WritingAroundTrademarks: The annual Oscar show was originally called "If We Picked the Oscars", but since "Oscars" is trademarked, they had to change it to "If We Picked the Winners".

Added: 152

Changed: 157

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ConspiracyTheorist: PlayedForLaughs in the infamous outtakes. Siskel, in a very tongue-in-cheek manner, rallies against [=WASPs=], claiming they run the country, and Ebert name-drops the "international bankers" and the Vatican.

to:

* ConspiracyTheorist: PlayedForLaughs in the infamous outtakes. Siskel, in a very tongue-in-cheek manner, rallies rails against [=WASPs=], claiming they run the country, and Ebert name-drops the "international bankers" and the Vatican.Vatican, before they realize that, with Siskel being Jewish and Ebert being Catholic, they shouldn't be BoomerangBigots and should team up against the [=WASPs=].


Added DiffLines:

* IrishmanAndAJew: Ebert was part Irish on his mother's side, and grew up staunchly Catholic, while Siskel was the son of Jewish immigrants from Russia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->'''Siskel:''' As I once said to you on another film, many years ago: "Date her, don't give the film a positive review."\\

to:

--->'''Siskel:''' As I once said to you on another film, many years ago: "Date her, don't give the film a positive review."\\"[[note]]Referring to their segment on ''The Sender'' in 1982, in which Siskel made that particular snarky comment in response to Ebert gushing over the film's lead Kathryn Harrold, even comparing her to a younger Creator/IngridBergman.[[/note]]\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Since they both gave films star ratings in their newspaper reviews, according to Ebert, the agreed-upon threshold was that "thumbs up"=three stars or higher, but, also according to Ebert, there were a handful of cases where Siskel gave a thumbs-up to a two-a-half-star movie because he just couldn't stand to give it a bad notice on the show, despite its flaws.

Added: 64

Removed: 64

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"That's next week, and until then, the balcony is closed."''



----

to:

--------
->''"That's next week, and until then, the balcony is closed."''

Added: 356

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAnnouncer: The series had a ColdOpen announcer for many years, but around 1996, Siskel and Ebert began introducing the shows themselves.

to:

* TheAnnouncer: The series had a ColdOpen announcer for many years, but around in 1996, Siskel and Ebert began introducing the shows themselves.themselves.
* TheArtifact: The 2007-2008 season was titled ''At the Movies with Ebert & Roeper''. Despite this, the on-air graphics still used the ''Ebert & Roeper'' title. Ebert's name continuing to be in the title for that season could also qualify, as he didn't appear in that season due to his surgeries, though he was still under contract with Disney at the time.

Added: 639

Changed: 665

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LaterInstallmentWeirdness: Towards the end of the ''Roeper & guest'' era, the thumbs up/down rating was replaced by See It, Rent It, or Skip It, as Disney/ABC refused to pay Ebert and the Siskel estate for continued use of the "Two Thumbs Up" trademark.
** The second half of the 1998-1999 season is this, due to every episode containing a different guest host, due to Gene Siskel's sudden death. The 1999-2000 season also had this, but by then they had narrowed the stable a bit until they decided on Richard Roeper as his permanent co-host.

to:

* LaterInstallmentWeirdness: LaterInstallmentWeirdness:
**
Towards the end of the ''Roeper & guest'' era, the thumbs up/down rating was replaced by See It, Rent It, or Skip It, as Disney/ABC refused to pay Ebert and the Siskel estate for continued use of the "Two Thumbs Up" trademark.
** The "two Bens" and Phillips/Scott eras went under the name "At the Movies" (a title introduced in the 2007-2008 season) and dropped the traditional balcony seating, leaving the chairs the hosts sat on along with a table. The sign-off "Until then, the balcony is closed" was replaced with "Until then, we'll see you [[TitleDrop at the movies]]".
** The second half of the 1998-1999 season is this, due to every episode containing a different guest host, due to Gene Siskel's sudden death. The 1999-2000 season also had this, but by then they had narrowed the stable a bit until they decided on Richard Roeper as his Ebert's permanent co-host.



* OddballInTheSeries: The 1996 season introduced a couple new segments that were quickly dropped: The Viewer's Thumb (video criticisms from viewers), which was quickly dropped, and The Revolving Thumb (the duo giving thumbs up or down to a trend in the movies), which lasted a little longer but was mostly gone from the series by 1997.

to:

* OddballInTheSeries: The 1996 season introduced a couple new segments that were quickly dropped: segments: The Viewer's Thumb (video criticisms from viewers), which was quickly dropped, and The Revolving Thumb (the duo giving thumbs up or down to a trend in the movies), which lasted a little longer but was mostly gone from the series by 1997.



* VocalEvolution: Due to throat surgery, Ebert's voice changed in late 2003/early 2004.

to:

* VocalEvolution: Due to throat surgery, Ebert's voice changed in late 2003/early 2004.2004, sounding more nasal and slightly slurred.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 548

Removed: 177

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The very first episodes had the "Coming Up" teasers consisted simply of movie clips. They were changed to animations of filmstrips incorporating footage from the films as the announcer (later Siskel and Ebert) introduces the movies.



** Until 1977, ''Sneak Previews'' was originally called ''Opening Soon at a Theater Near You'' and was broadcast locally in Chicago.
** ''Sneak Previews'' didn't use the trademark thumbs up and down yet; the votes were merely "yes" or "no".
** In the show's 1970s incarnation, the pair occasionally reviewed pornos.



** ''Sneak Previews'' didn't use the trademark thumbs up and down yet; the votes were merely YES or NO.
** In the show's 1970s incarnation, the pair occasionally reviewed pornos.

Added: 241

Changed: 242

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The ''Ebert & Roeper'' era initially used the ''Siskel & Ebert'' set, but with alterations. The set was remodeled in 2001.

to:

** The ''Ebert & Roeper'' era initially used the ''Siskel & Ebert'' set, but with alterations. alterations, as well as the ''Roger Ebert & the Movies'' theme. The theme song was rearranged in early 2001, while the set was remodeled in 2001.redesigned the following season.



* TruncatedThemeTune: The remaining episodes in the 1998-1999 season after Gene's passing cut the intro short after the title graphic.

to:

* TruncatedThemeTune: TruncatedThemeTune:
**
The remaining episodes in the 1998-1999 season after Gene's passing cut the intro short after the title graphic.graphic.
** Later episodes in the 1999-2000 season and most of Richard's first season shortened the ''Roger Ebert & the Movies'' theme.

Added: 229

Changed: 108

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Siskel & Ebert and the Movies'' (usually just called ''Siskel & Ebert'') was a syndicated American television series that ran from 1986 to 1999, spun off from an earlier show on Creator/{{PBS}}: ''Opening Soon at a Theater Near You''[=/=]''Sneak Previews'' (1975 to 1982), as well as the syndicated ''At the Movies'' (1982 to 1986), both of which utilized a similar format of two critics, Creator/GeneSiskel of the ''UsefulNotes/{{Chicago}} Tribune'' and Creator/RogerEbert of the ''Chicago Sun-Times'', discussing and debating the week's new films. Roughly four or five films were critiqued per episode. It usually ended with a special segment like "Video/Laserdisc Pick of the Week/Month", an interview with a celebrity or director, or a short-lived segment where viewers wrote in to provide a second opinion or correct S&E about something. The show taped at Creator/{{ABC}}'s Chicago station, WLS-TV, which is also where ''Series/TheOprahWinfreyShow'' initially taped as well.

to:

''Siskel & Ebert'' (''Siskel & Ebert and & the Movies'' (usually just called ''Siskel & Ebert'') in its first season) was a syndicated American television series that ran from 1986 to 1999, spun off from an earlier show on Creator/{{PBS}}: ''Opening Soon at a Theater Near You''[=/=]''Sneak Previews'' (1975 to 1982), as well as the syndicated ''At the Movies'' (1982 to 1986), both of which utilized a similar format of two critics, Creator/GeneSiskel of the ''UsefulNotes/{{Chicago}} Tribune'' and Creator/RogerEbert of the ''Chicago Sun-Times'', discussing and debating the week's new films. Roughly four or five films were critiqued per episode. It usually ended with a special segment like "Video/Laserdisc Pick of the Week/Month", an interview with a celebrity or director, or a short-lived segment where viewers wrote in to provide a second opinion or correct S&E about something. The show taped at Creator/{{ABC}}'s Chicago station, WLS-TV, which is also where ''Series/TheOprahWinfreyShow'' initially taped as well.


Added DiffLines:

** The first season was titled ''Siskel & Ebert & The Movies''. The title was shortened to ''Siskel & Ebert'' in 1987. Likewise, the ''Ebert & Roeper'' incarnation was titled ''Ebert & Roeper and The Movies'' in its first season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, in the early shows, Ebert had thicker glasses and bushier hair.
** During the show's earliest incarnation in the 1970s, Siskel had a [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bD2RhWCJkWk thick mustache]].

to:

** Also, in the early pre-1990s shows, Ebert had thicker glasses and bushier hair.
** During the show's earliest incarnation in the 1970s, Siskel had a [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bD2RhWCJkWk thick mustache]]. Also, their earliest episodes together had them speaking in a much more mellow manner, compared to their more energetic personalities later on.



** ''Sneak Previews'' didn't use the trademark thumbs up & down yet; the votes were merely YES or NO.

to:

** ''Sneak Previews'' didn't use the trademark thumbs up & and down yet; the votes were merely YES or NO.

Added: 202

Changed: 81

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: Nothing major, as the show stayed roughly the same since it began in 1986, but in 1992, the show's backdrop switched from a yellow-ish hue to a blue one.

to:

* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: Nothing major, as the show stayed roughly the same since it began in 1986, but in there were still some differences:
** In
1992, the show's backdrop switched from a yellow-ish hue to a blue one.


Added DiffLines:

** The ''Ebert & Roeper'' era initially used the ''Siskel & Ebert'' set, but with alterations. The set was remodeled in 2001.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhatDoYouMeanItsForKids: Occurred a few times when they reviewed movies that fell into this category, like ''Film/KindergartenCop'' and ''Film/CoolWorld''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ColdOpen: Every episode began with an announcer telling a few of the movies Siskel and Ebert would be reviewing.

to:

* ColdOpen: Every episode began with an announcer telling a few of the movies Siskel and Ebert would be reviewing. Starting in the Fall of 1996, Siskel and Ebert would announce the films themselves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the show's 1970s incarnation, the pair occasionally reviewed pornos.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeliberatelyMonochrome: When they did an episode on black and white movies, the footage was also given a black and white filter, with Ebert telling the viewers not to adjust their sets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MilestoneCelebration: The 500th episode of their show was a live full-hour performance as Disneyland.

to:

* MilestoneCelebration: The 500th episode of their show was a live full-hour performance as Disneyland.Disney's Hollywood Studios, where they discussed their careers and imitators.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambiguation


** Siskel made one in the episode where Ebert gave ''Film/FullMetalJacket'' a marginal thumbs down. Siskel said it was absurd that Ebert was giving a Kubrick film that rating, while in the same show he gave a recommendation to ''Benji the Hunted'' (which he disliked). As Ebert rightfully pointed out, ''Jacket'' and ''Benji'' are two totally different genres and as such, deserve to have different criteria for judging them[[note]]Long-time readers of Ebert's reviews and website would be aware that this was a major aspect of the way he reviewed films - when scoring a movie like ''Film/SpiderMan2'' or ''Film/TheDarkKnight'', he would compare it to ''Film/{{Superman}}'' (which he considered the greatest comic book/Superhero movie ever), not to something like ''Film/TheGodfather'' or ''Film/CitizenKane''[[/note]].

to:

** Siskel made one in the episode where Ebert gave ''Film/FullMetalJacket'' a marginal thumbs down. Siskel said it was absurd that Ebert was giving a Kubrick film that rating, while in the same show he gave a recommendation to ''Benji the Hunted'' (which he disliked). As Ebert rightfully pointed out, ''Jacket'' and ''Benji'' are two totally different genres and as such, deserve to have different criteria for judging them[[note]]Long-time readers of Ebert's reviews and website would be aware that this was a major aspect of the way he reviewed films - when scoring a movie like ''Film/SpiderMan2'' or ''Film/TheDarkKnight'', he would compare it to ''Film/{{Superman}}'' ''Film/SupermanTheMovie'' (which he considered the greatest comic book/Superhero movie ever), not to something like ''Film/TheGodfather'' or ''Film/CitizenKane''[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MilestoneCelebration: The 500th episode of their show was a live full-hour performance as Disneyland.

Top