Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / GreysAnatomy

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Hahn makes a valid point that the 'Gentlemen's Evening' Richard arranges, from an outside perspective, looks like him excluding his female staff from a social gathering with the Chief.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When the nurses go on strike in Season 2, the hospital quickly starts to come apart at seams. TruthInTelevision, as the nursing staff handle a large amount of the day to day care of patients, and without them a hospital would all but cease to function.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* ArtisticLicenceExplosives: Specifically, the episode where a patient has a shell from a homemade bazooka embedded in his chest, and when it detonates it ''completely vaporizes'' three bomb squad technicians. Completely as even their ''body armor'' is turned to ash. No homemade explosive in an amount small enough to fit inside a homemade shell from a homemade bazooka is going to have that much power. Even the ''original'' shell from a WWII bazooka didn't have that kind of power and wasn't intended to. It was designed to penetrate a tank's armor, then once inside the explosive charge would kill the tank crew with shrapnel, not turn them to mist. And if the explosion was powerful enough to completely vaporize three men (and their body armor), it would have also destroyed a large section of the hospital floor and killed Meredith outright, as she was standing less than 20 feet away.

to:

* ArtisticLicenceExplosives: ArtisticLicenseExplosives: Specifically, the episode where a patient has a shell from a homemade bazooka embedded in his chest, and when it detonates it ''completely vaporizes'' three bomb squad technicians. Completely as even their ''body armor'' is turned to ash. No homemade explosive in an amount small enough to fit inside a homemade shell from a homemade bazooka is going to have that much power. Even the ''original'' shell from a WWII bazooka didn't have that kind of power and wasn't intended to. It was designed to penetrate a tank's armor, then once inside the explosive charge would kill the tank crew with shrapnel, not turn them to mist. And if the explosion was powerful enough to completely vaporize three men (and their body armor), it would have also destroyed a large section of the hospital floor and killed Meredith outright, as she was standing less than 20 feet away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FiveSecondRule: A somewhat serious example. In season 5, during a domino surgery in which eight people donate kidneys to eight other patients, Meredith Grey is walking with the donor kidney for her patient, but it slips from her hands and falls on the OR floor. She and Bailey stare back and forth between each other and the kidney on the floor, before Bailey yells out, "Five second rule! Five second rule!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
green link fix.


''Grey's Anatomy'' is a [[LongRunners long-running]] Creator/{{ABC}} MedicalDrama. Its creator and showrunner was Creator/ShondaRhimes, for whom it serves as a StarMakingRole.

to:

''Grey's Anatomy'' is a [[LongRunners long-running]] Creator/{{ABC}} [[Creator/AmericanBroadcastingCompany ABC]] MedicalDrama. Its creator and showrunner was Creator/ShondaRhimes, for whom it serves as a StarMakingRole.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Dr. Castello, who declared how there was no time for a CT scan [[spoiler:and by doing so killed Derek]], should have been reviewed by the medical board [[spoiler:after Derek died]]. CT scans of the head are the protocol of most hospitals for anyone who may have suffered a concussion. [[spoiler:In real life, with this outcome, Meredith would have been in the right to sue the hospital. It's quite strange she didn't do anything and waited five years to accuse him of incompetence.]]

to:

** Dr. Castello, who declared how there was no time for a CT scan [[spoiler:and by doing so killed Derek]], should have been reviewed by the medical board [[spoiler:after Derek died]]. CT scans scan of the head are IS the protocol of most hospitals internationally recognized for anyone who may have suffered a concussion.concussion and who arrives in the ER with an alterated state of consciousness, because in these cases one of the first things that must be ruled out before going further with any treatment is head trauma. [[spoiler:In real life, with this outcome, Meredith would have been in the right to sue the hospital. It's quite strange she didn't do anything and waited five years to accuse him of incompetence.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


** Meredith's Morality is most definitely [[JustForPun Grey]]. She tampers with the Alzheimer's Trial to help Webber's wife, which puts her in a very bad spot with her husband who accuses her of not knowing [[BlackAndWhiteMorality the difference between Right and Wrong]].

to:

** Meredith's Morality is most definitely [[JustForPun [[{{Pun}} Grey]]. She tampers with the Alzheimer's Trial to help Webber's wife, which puts her in a very bad spot with her husband who accuses her of not knowing [[BlackAndWhiteMorality the difference between Right and Wrong]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Character reactions don't count for "Surprisingly Realistic" under new rules


** So the characters who won the lawsuit in season 9 are all set buy the hospital, only they don't have enough money. The investor they hoped to get last minute rejected their proposal on the grounds that none of them have any kind of experience running a hospital. When they get Richard, who has many years of experience as the chief, to help them out, the investor still rejects them because he just isn't that interested.



** Alex walks into the apartment he shares with Jo and finds her nearly naked with [=DeLuca=] lying on top of her and reaches the wrong but understandable conclusion. He proceeds to beat the crap out of [=DeLuca=] so badly that he has to be hospitalized. Rather than let it go, [=DeLuca=] files a police report and Alex is arrested and charged with felony assault; he also is suspended from his job and has to work in the clinic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PromotedToOpeningTitles: Something like twenty actors have managed to score this trope for themselves. [[note]] Creator/KateWalsh in early Season 2, Creator/SaraRamirez in Season 3, Eric Dane in early Season 3, Creator/ChylerLeigh in Season 4, Creator/BrookeSmith in early Season 4, Kevin [=McKidd=] in late Season 5, Creator/JessicaCapshaw in Season 6, Kim Raver in late Season 6, Sarah Drew and Jesse Williams in Season 7, Creator/CamillaLuddington, Gaius Charles, Jerrika Hinton and Tessa Ferrer in Season 10, Creator/CaterinaScorsone and Kelly [=McCreary=] in Season 11, and Jason George, Martin Henderson, and Giacomo Gianniotti in season 12.[[/note]]

to:

* PromotedToOpeningTitles: Something like twenty actors have managed to score this trope for themselves. [[note]] Creator/KateWalsh in early Season 2, Creator/SaraRamirez in Season 3, Eric Dane in early Season 3, Creator/ChylerLeigh in Season 4, Creator/BrookeSmith in early Season 4, Kevin [=McKidd=] in late Season 5, Creator/JessicaCapshaw in Season 6, Kim Raver in late Season 6, Sarah Drew and Jesse Williams in Season 7, Creator/CamillaLuddington, Gaius Charles, Jerrika Hinton and Tessa Ferrer in Season 10, Creator/CaterinaScorsone and Kelly [=McCreary=] in Season 11, and Jason George, Creator/JasonGeorge, Martin Henderson, and Giacomo Gianniotti in season 12.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected spoiler tag formatting and an ellipses


* MoreExperiencedChasesTheInnocent: Mark Sloan, also known as "[=McSteamy=]", is an infamous playboy, whose [[ReallyGetsAround sexual appetite]] becomes such an issue that the nurses at Seattle Grace ''unionize'' in protest. Lexie Grey on the other hand is TheIngenue: upbeat, highly intelligent, and [[WideEyedIdealist idealistic to the point of naivete at times]]. While she has dated in the past, she's mostly depicted as a SmittenTeenageGirl for George up until now. When Mark shows interest in Lexi, everyone tells him to back off, and he begrudgingly does...until [[InvertedTrope Lexi goes to his apartment]], strips in front of him, and asks him to [[SexualEuphemism teach her]]. Mark relents and the two start seeing each other soon after, [[spoiler:eventually [[LadykillerInLove falling in love]]]].

to:

* MoreExperiencedChasesTheInnocent: Mark Sloan, also known as "[=McSteamy=]", is an infamous playboy, whose [[ReallyGetsAround sexual appetite]] becomes such an issue that the nurses at Seattle Grace ''unionize'' in protest. Lexie Grey on the other hand is TheIngenue: upbeat, highly intelligent, and [[WideEyedIdealist idealistic to the point of naivete at times]]. While she has dated in the past, she's mostly depicted as a SmittenTeenageGirl for George up until now. When Mark shows interest in Lexi, everyone tells him to back off, and he begrudgingly does...until [[InvertedTrope Lexi goes to his apartment]], strips in front of him, and asks him to [[SexualEuphemism teach her]]. Mark relents and the two start seeing each other soon after, [[spoiler:eventually [[spoiler: eventually [[LadykillerInLove falling in love]]]].



** He also catches Alex pulling pranks in "Idle Hands" and chew him out....for lacking imagination.

to:

** He also catches Alex pulling pranks in "Idle Hands" and chew him out....out...for lacking imagination.



* OurGhostsAreDifferent: Season 17 has Meredith talking to ghosts, including [[Spoiler:Derek and George. George knows about Meredith's children. When Meredith says they were all born after he died, George explains "I check in sometimes." Meredith also notes George looks a little older than when she knew him.]]

to:

* OurGhostsAreDifferent: Season 17 has Meredith talking to ghosts, including [[Spoiler:Derek [[spoiler: Derek and George. George knows about Meredith's children. When Meredith says they were all born after he died, George explains "I check in sometimes." Meredith also notes George looks a little older than when she knew him.]]

Added: 1664

Removed: 457

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This may be typical of many tv dramas, but let's clarify anyway that if any real life doctor would practice his job as the main characters with their too frequente ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight attitude, they would be fired for sure and very probably lose their license and facing criminal charges.
*** Izzie's lie about Danny's deteriorating condition to get him the heart would have landed her in jail for years, and she would never have been allowed to work in a hospital or medical facility again. The chief and her friends justify her actions by saying that she was a young resident who, in the end, only wanted to save a man's life. If the authorities had found out that the case was not reported to the police, the entire hospital would have been investigated, everyone involved in the case would have faced criminal charges, and many would have had to resign at least.
*** Meredith treating an uninsured patient was certainly morally the right thing to do, but unfortunately it would not have been enough to save her medical license. Considering her involvement in the aforementioned heart theft case and many other legally gray decisions, Meredith would never have been able to practice medicine.
*** One episode featured the surgeons lying about the time of the surgery, as the patient's insurance benefits had just lapsed and it wouldn't be covered if it was recorded as being done on the actual date, so they backdated it to the previous day. That's ''insurance fraud'', it's a ''criminal offense'', and the insurance company ''will'' find out about it. Not only will the surgeons face charges, but the hospital could very well lose its accreditation.



** One episode featured the surgeons lying about the time of the surgery, as the patient's insurance benefits had just lapsed and it wouldn't be covered if it was recorded as being done on the actual date, so they backdated it to the previous day. That's ''insurance fraud'', it's a ''criminal offense'', and the insurance company ''will'' find out about it. Not only will the surgeons face charges, but the hospital could very well lose its accreditation.

Changed: 91

Removed: 979

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Example arguing with itself.


** Somehow George is shipping out to Iraq within days of enlisting. He still needs to graduate both Basic Training and Officer Candidate School, which would require him to spend months in training.
*** Actually, no. While he would not be shipping out within days of commissioning (not enlisting. Officers are ''commissioned'', not enlisted), but neither would he be attending either Basic Training or Officer Candidate School. Basic Training is for enlisted, Officer Candidate School is boot camp for commissioned officers. George would not attend either one, as he would be ''directly commissioned'' into the Medical Corps as a Captain (O-3). Doctors and nurses are simply too badly needed by the Department of Defense to be put through boot camp with a risk of washing out. George would instead attend Commissioned Officer Training, which is a two or three week course where he would be issued his uniforms, attend classes on military customs and courtesies, learn military history, get briefings from other doctors on what being a military doctor is like, etc. He'd have a private room, there's no getting kicked out of bed at 5am, there's no "drop and give me twenty', etc.

to:

** Somehow George is shipping out to Iraq within days of enlisting. He still needs to graduate both Basic Training and Officer Candidate School, which would require him to spend months in training.
*** Actually, no. While he would not be shipping out within days of commissioning (not enlisting. Officers are ''commissioned'', not enlisted), but neither would he be attending either Basic Training or Officer Candidate School. Basic Training is for enlisted, Officer Candidate School is boot camp for commissioned officers. George would not attend either one, as he would be ''directly commissioned'' into the Medical Corps as a Captain (O-3). Doctors and nurses are simply too badly needed by the Department of Defense to be put through boot camp with a risk of washing out. George would instead attend
Commissioned Officer Training, which is a two or three week course where he would be issued his uniforms, attend classes on military customs and courtesies, learn military history, get briefings from other doctors on what being a military doctor is like, etc. He'd have a private room, there's no getting kicked out of bed several weeks at 5am, there's no "drop and give me twenty', etc.least.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Grey's Anatomy'' is a LongRunning Creator/{{ABC}} MedicalDrama. Its creator and showrunner was Creator/ShondaRhimes, for whom it serves as a StarMakingRole.

to:

''Grey's Anatomy'' is a LongRunning [[LongRunners long-running]] Creator/{{ABC}} MedicalDrama. Its creator and showrunner was Creator/ShondaRhimes, for whom it serves as a StarMakingRole.



* LongRunner:

to:

* LongRunner:LongRunners:

Added: 96

Changed: 10

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswick.


-->'''Jackson:''' How could this ever be kept secret at all?
-->'''Catherine:''' Money, honey. Good God don't be naive. A fortune was paid to silence those woman.

to:

-->'''Jackson:''' How could this ever be kept secret at all?
-->'''Catherine:'''
all?\\
'''Catherine:'''
Money, honey. Good God don't be naive. A fortune was paid to silence those woman.



-->'''Sloan''': Does it ever stop raining in his hellhole?
-->'''Alex''': Not really

to:

-->'''Sloan''': Does it ever stop raining in his hellhole?
-->'''Alex''':
hellhole?\\
'''Alex''':
Not really


Added DiffLines:

* {{Symploce}}: "Could We Start Again, Please?":
--> '''Arizona:''' I can't do it. I won't do it.

Added: 1904

Changed: 2294

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Syphilis results are picked up from the Hematology lab.....which studies cells and has NOTHING to do with bacteria. In real life, results for syphilis would be picked up from the microbiology lab.

to:

** Syphilis Lots of times results for many disease are asked from the wrong labs. When Alex, George and Olivia develope syphilis, results are picked up from the Hematology lab.....which studies cells and has NOTHING to do with bacteria. In real life, results for syphilis would be picked up from the microbiology lab.



** Alex has a patient with c-diff in one episode, a young woman. They give her a fecal transplant to restore the bacterial culture in her stomach, which is a wholly unnecessary procedure. C-diff is very common in hospitals, it happens a lot with patients on iv antibiotics, and the treatment is to simply wait it out. Other measures might be taken if a patient is very sick or elderly, but not when you're a young, healthy person.

to:

** The main characters often perform surgeries that are part of different specialties from theirs, and at the same time many specialties don't appear at all. For example, abdominal aneurysms are treated by vascular surgeons, while thyroid/parathyroid/pituitary tumors are treated by endocrinology surgeons. However, even though there are many patients treated for these conditions, the ones to treat them are the main characters, while vascular and endocrine surgeons never appear. In one episode, Cristina and Teddy are assigned to perform an appendectomy, but once they begin, they realize that they have both forgotten how to perform a step in the procedure. The question is, why were two ''cardiothoracic'' surgeons supposed to remember how a ''general surgery'' procedure is performed in the first place?
** Even worse, sometimes they deal with patients who are not surgical at all. In one episode,
Alex has a patient with c-diff in one episode, c-diff, a young woman. They give her woman, who is treated with a fecal transplant transplant, to restore the bacterial culture in her stomach, which stomach. Her case would not have been not only treated, but would not have even ''managed'' this way. Let's start with the fact that a fecal transplant in such a young and otherwise healthy patient is a wholly totally unnecessary procedure. C-diff is very common in hospitals, it happens a lot with (the patients on iv antibiotics, and the treatment is to simply wait who need it out. Other measures might be taken if are pluripathological and/or elderly), but apart from that, a patient who comes to the hospital with abdominal pain would have been become a surgical patient only after the problem had been determined. It seems that the moment patients arrive at the hospital, they're immediately visited by surgeons who then determine whether they're surgical patients or not. In real life, this process is very sick or elderly, but not when you're usually reversed, especially in front of a young, healthy person.patient with a common symptom such as abdominal pain.



** CPR and defibrillation is depicted as reviving patients back to the shape they were in before coding. In reality CPR is a violent procedure that is likely to break ribs. People who are elderly and/or have multiple underlying illnesses are unlikely to survive it. Among those who do, cerebral function can be severely compromised. One episode of the show has an old lady who goes into cardiac arrest over and over and over, each time easily revived with CPR and defibrillation, never with any negative effects. The likelihood of that happening in real life is... slim.
*** It's also common on the show for the doctors to defibrillate the patients several times in succession, without performing CPR in-between. You ''need'' to perform CPR between each defibrillation, or it doesn't work.

to:

** CPR and defibrillation defibrillation.
*** CPR
is depicted portrayed as reviving a procedure that returns patients back to the shape condition they were in before coding. In reality reality, CPR is a violent procedure that is likely to break with significant risk of breaking the patient's ribs. People who are elderly and/or have multiple several underlying illnesses diseases are already unlikely to survive it. Among and, those who do, cerebral do survive, have a high chance that their brain function can may be severely compromised. One impaired. In one episode of the show has there is an old elderly lady who goes into cardiac arrest over and over and over, again, each time being easily revived resuscitated with CPR and defibrillation, never with any negative adverse effects. The likelihood of that this happening in real life is... slim.
*** It's It is also common on the show for the doctors to defibrillate the patients several times in succession, without performing CPR in-between. You ''need'' between each time. It is ''necessary'' to perform CPR between each defibrillation, or defibrillations, otherwise it doesn't work.does not work.
*** Many times, defibrillation is used on asystolic patients, with flat EKG. Defibrillation is used only in cases of fibrillation (doesn't the name suggest it?), i.e., when the heart, due to defective electrical activity, beats but in a disorganized and therefore nonfunctional way. The EKG of a fibrillating heart is not flat. Defibrillation interrupts this ''wrong'' electrical activity so the heart, that is functional, could restart with a correct and organized one. An asystolic heart, i.e., one that has no electrical activity, and therefore does not beat at all and does have a flat line on the EKG, is not shockable; as long as there's no electrical activity, defibrillation is useless and what is needed is CPR!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the last episode of season 4, a patient has a PE and because Hann is not available right then, Webber allows Cristina to intervene. When Hann arrives, she immediately questions Cristina's work, pointing out the alleged tecnical mistakes she made. Cristina is quick to explain why she did them and why they were necessary, but when Hann still disagrees and bluntly orders her to move to replace her, Cristina yells at her to shut up and let her work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The lawyer for the plaintiff makes irrelevant, rambling statements like asking for advice on buying a snowboard and speculative statements which are not allowed, and the defense only objects to some, asks questions without knowing the answer, and calls a member of the hospital staff as the first witness, who is clearly hostile, rather than the patient's girlfriend.

Added: 584

Changed: 348

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In Season 10, Episode 9, Dr. Torres is sued by a patient alleging medical malpractice that resulted in the amputation of both of his legs. Twice during the episode, characters speak as though they are in a criminal trial, rather than a civil suit. First the patient's lawyer, concluding his case, announces to the judge "The Prosecution rests", rather than "the Plaintiff rests". Then at the end, the jury foreman announces "Not Guilty", rather than "We find in favor of the Defendant."

to:

** In Season 10, Episode 9, Dr. Torres is sued by a patient alleging medical malpractice that resulted in the amputation of both of his legs. legs.
***
Twice during the episode, characters speak as though they are in a criminal trial, rather than a civil suit. First the patient's lawyer, concluding his case, announces to the judge "The Prosecution rests", rather than "the Plaintiff rests". Then at the end, the jury foreman announces "Not Guilty", rather than "We find in favor of the Defendant.""
*** The suit has a downright light speed pace, with it going to court the next day after a settlement offer is rejected. The settlement process would take weeks or months and a malpractice suit could take years before going to court.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoreExperiencedChasesTheInnocent: Mark Sloan, also known as "[=McSteamy=]", is an infamous [[ReallyGetsAround playboy]], whose [[AnythingThatMoves sexual appetite]] becomes such an issue that the nurses at Seattle Grace ''unionize'' in protest. Lexie Grey on the other hand is TheIngenue: upbeat, highly intelligent, and [[WideEyedIdealist idealistic to the point of naivete at times]]. While she has dated in the past, she's mostly depicted as a SmittenTeenageGirl for George up until now. When Mark shows interest in Lexi, everyone tells him to back off, and he begrudgingly does...until [[InvertedTrope Lexi goes to his apartment]], strips in front of him, and asks him to [[SexualEuphemism teach her]]. Mark relents and the two start seeing each other soon after, [[spoiler:eventually [[LadykillerInLove falling in love]]]].

to:

* MoreExperiencedChasesTheInnocent: Mark Sloan, also known as "[=McSteamy=]", is an infamous playboy, whose [[ReallyGetsAround playboy]], whose [[AnythingThatMoves sexual appetite]] becomes such an issue that the nurses at Seattle Grace ''unionize'' in protest. Lexie Grey on the other hand is TheIngenue: upbeat, highly intelligent, and [[WideEyedIdealist idealistic to the point of naivete at times]]. While she has dated in the past, she's mostly depicted as a SmittenTeenageGirl for George up until now. When Mark shows interest in Lexi, everyone tells him to back off, and he begrudgingly does...until [[InvertedTrope Lexi goes to his apartment]], strips in front of him, and asks him to [[SexualEuphemism teach her]]. Mark relents and the two start seeing each other soon after, [[spoiler:eventually [[LadykillerInLove falling in love]]]].

Top