Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / AndThenThereWereNone2015

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In Wargrave's flashback to [[spoiler:Seton's execution]], the man smirks at him before being hanged, even refusing the customary hood so Wargrave could see his face.

to:

** In Wargrave's flashback to [[spoiler:Seton's execution]], the man smirks at him before being hanged, even refusing the customary hood so Wargrave could see his face. He was actually smirking because [[spoiler: he'd recognised Wargrave as a kindred spirit.]]

Added: 599

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This happes to [[spoiler: Vera]] before Soldier Island. [[spoiler: The love of her life knows she's a murderer and wants nothing to do with her, and she's working at a substandard school because most schools wouldn't want to be associated with an inquest - or, perhaps, wouldn't want to employ someone whose young charge died in her care.]]



* LudicrousGibs: The copious amounts of blood and gore spraying the walls after [[spoiler: Wargrave's]] [[spoiler:faked]] murder were actually liver and kidneys stolen from the pantry.

to:

* LudicrousGibs: The copious amounts of blood and gore spraying the walls after [[spoiler: Wargrave's]] [[spoiler:faked]] Wargrave's faked]] murder were actually liver and kidneys stolen from the pantry.


Added DiffLines:

* SpottingTheThread: [[spoiler: During the inquest for Cyril, Vera says that she turned her back for a minute, Cyril ran off and she wasn't able to catch up with him in time. Hugo realises she's lying because he's seen what a good runner she actually is.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler:In the series, Emily Brent casually remarks that Beatrice Taylor killed herself by jumping in front a moving train. In the novel, Beatrice drowns herself instead.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:In the series, Emily Brent casually remarks that Beatrice Taylor killed herself by jumping in front of a moving train. In the novel, Beatrice drowns herself instead.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BloodierAndGorier: In ''spades'' - not only are the deaths more bloody --([[spoiler:Brent]] goes from being jabbed with a syringe to outright stabbed in the neck with her own knitting needle)-- but several characters have hallucinations and dreams that expose their crimes in gruesome detail, particularly [[spoiler: Armstrong's nightmare]].

to:

* BloodierAndGorier: In ''spades'' - ''spades''-- not only are the deaths more bloody --([[spoiler:Brent]] ([[spoiler:Brent goes from being jabbed poisoned with a syringe to outright stabbed in the neck with her own knitting needle)-- needle]]) but several characters have hallucinations and dreams that expose their crimes in gruesome detail, particularly [[spoiler: Armstrong's nightmare]].



* CountingBullets: At the end, [[spoiler:the last survivor is hanging from a rope when the killer (who had [[FakingTheDead faked his own death]] earlier on to be BeneathSuspicion) reveals himself. She tries to convince him to rescue her because there are no more bullets for him to make [[ThanatosGambit his planned suicide]] appear as a murder, spoiling his plan to create an unsolveable mystery. He plays along for a bit before pulling out the chair from under her and pointing out that she forgot the one bullet that was earlier "used" on him, which he holds up]].

to:

* CountingBullets: At the end, [[spoiler:the last survivor is hanging from a rope when the killer (who had [[FakingTheDead faked his own death]] earlier on to be BeneathSuspicion) reveals himself. She tries to convince him to rescue her because there are no more bullets for him to make [[ThanatosGambit his planned suicide]] appear as a murder, spoiling his plan to create an unsolveable unsolvable mystery. He plays along for a bit before pulling out the chair from under her and pointing out that she forgot the one bullet that was earlier "used" on him, which he holds up]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Vera is much more frigid and cruel than she appeared to be in the original novel. In the book, she is wracked with guilt and slowly begins losing her mind as she comes to terms with what she has done, but in the miniseries it is strongly implied to all be an act of a vicious [[TheSociopath sociopath]]. Also, little Cyril's death at sea is now shown to be a cold and calculated murder, while in the book it was implied to be a spur-of-the-moment crime of passion.

to:

** Vera is much more frigid cold and cruel than she appeared to be in the original novel. In the book, she is wracked with guilt and slowly begins losing her mind as she comes to terms with what she has done, but in the miniseries it is strongly implied to all be an act of a vicious [[TheSociopath sociopath]]. Also, little Cyril's death at sea is now shown to be a cold and calculated murder, while in the book it was implied to be a spur-of-the-moment crime of passion.



* AllForNothing: Macathur's killing of Henry Richmond comes to this in the end, as his wife Leslie ends up dying of [[UsefulNotes/TheSpanishFlu the 1918-1920 Spanish flu pandemic]], leaving him alone with his guilt.

to:

* AllForNothing: Macathur's killing of Henry Richmond comes to this in the end, as his wife Leslie ends up dying of in [[UsefulNotes/TheSpanishFlu the 1918-1920 Spanish flu pandemic]], leaving him alone with his guilt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalJerkass: Dr. Armstrong is much less professional and meaner towards Vera when she accuses him of being U.N. Owen.

to:

* AdaptationalJerkass: Dr. Armstrong is much less professional and meaner more angry towards Vera when she accuses him of being U.N. Owen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArmouredClosetGay: Heavily implied with Emily Brent. She keeps the fasçade of a pious and devout Christian spinster. However, underneath that, she appeared to have strong romantic feelings towards her young maid, Beatrice Taylor.

to:

* ArmouredClosetGay: Heavily implied with Emily Brent. She keeps the fasçade façade of a pious and devout Christian spinster. However, underneath that, she appeared to have strong romantic feelings towards her young maid, Beatrice Taylor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArmouredClosetGay: Heavily implied with Emily Brent. She keeps the fasçade of a pious and devout Christian spinster. However, underneath that, she appeared to have strong romantic feelings towards her young maid, Beatrice Taylor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* StealthInsult: [[spoiler: Judge Wargrave, knowing the truth about Vera's crime,gives her an EXTREMELY stealthy one]] during the first dinner together when he mentions [[spoiler: Vera's]] students.

to:

* StealthInsult: [[spoiler: Judge Wargrave, knowing the truth about Vera's crime,gives crime, gives her an EXTREMELY stealthy one]] during the first dinner together when he mentions [[spoiler: Vera's]] students.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RightForTheWrongReasons: Player with. After Armstrong disappears, Vera surmises that he has faked his own death and is actually the murderer. [[spoiler: She's onto something here — someone has indeed faked his own death, but it's Warfield, not Armstrong]].

to:

* RightForTheWrongReasons: Player with. After Armstrong disappears, Vera surmises that he has faked his own death and is actually the murderer. [[spoiler: She's onto something here — someone has indeed faked his own death, but it's Warfield, Wargrave, not Armstrong]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ProperlyParanoid: When it gets down to three, the remaining character agree that they are being watched. [[spoiler: Given that the murderer is in fact someone they think is already dead, they are correct in this assumption.]]


Added DiffLines:

* RunningGag: Lombard addressing Blore as "Tubbs".

Changed: 738

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RightForTheWrongReason: After Armstrong disappears, Vera surmises that he has faked his own death and is actually the murderer. She's onto something here — [[spoiler: someone has indeed faked his own death, but it's Wakefield, not Armstrong]].

to:

* RightForTheWrongReason: RightForTheWrongReasons: Player with. After Armstrong disappears, Vera surmises that he has faked his own death and is actually the murderer. [[spoiler: She's onto something here — [[spoiler: someone has indeed faked his own death, but it's Wakefield, Warfield, not Armstrong]].



* ScrewTheWarWerePartying: Vera being given a tot of brandy to settle her nerves leads to the bottle being passed around the four remaining guests. Then when they find Wargrave's body, following which those who are still alive don't just hit what's left of the booze, they also dig out Marston's cocaine and put on some records so that they can at least have some laughs in what they're sure are their last hours alive. The recordsIt's suggested that they're trying to keep awake so they're not killed in their sleep.

to:

* ScrewTheWarWerePartying: Vera being given a tot of brandy to settle her nerves leads to the bottle being passed around the four remaining guests. Then when they find Wargrave's body, following which those who are still alive don't just hit what's left of the booze, they also dig out Marston's cocaine and put on some records so that they can at least have some laughs in what they're sure are their last hours alive. The recordsIt's suggested records they play include the U.N. Owen recording, to which at least two of them joyfully shout out their guilt at the appropriate point. The use of cocaine could suggest that they're trying to keep awake so they're not killed in their sleep.sleep, although the consumption of brandy would negate that.



* ShipperOnDeck: Cyril all but tells Vera that he supports her marrying his uncle because then she'd be his aunt. [[spoiler:It only adds to the horror when Vera allows him to drown.]]
* SleepingSingle: The group bursts into Marston's room to find Rogers all but under the bed. When questioned (at gunpoint, mind) Rogers brings out a folded-up camp-bed. They'd stored it under Marston's bed originally, because 'young gentlemen never look under the beds'; he intended to use it in a spare room. Given how he treated his wife during the brief time we see her alive, it's possible that Ethel insisted on separate beds. Or even that it was simply the only below-stairs bedroom with enough bed/s for two people. (U.N. Owen didn't want two of his killers/victims to have easy access for hanky-panky??)

to:

* ShipperOnDeck: In a flashback, Cyril all but tells Vera that he supports her marrying his uncle because then she'd be his aunt. [[spoiler:It only adds to the horror when Vera allows him to drown.]]
* SleepingSingle: The group bursts into Marston's room to find Rogers all but under the bed. When questioned (at gunpoint, mind) gunpoint), Rogers brings out a folded-up camp-bed. They'd stored it under Marston's bed originally, because 'young gentlemen never look under the beds'; camp-bed, which he intended intends to use it as he does not wish to sleep in a spare room. Given how he treated the same room as his wife during the brief time we see her alive, it's possible that Ethel insisted on separate beds. Or even that it was simply the only below-stairs bedroom with enough bed/s for two people. (U.N. Owen didn't want two of his killers/victims to have easy access for hanky-panky??)(by this point, murdered) wife.

Added: 302

Changed: 786

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OffTheWagon: Armstrong is a recovering alcoholic and refuses wine at dinner. When they realize that the first couple of deaths are murders, though, he finds a flask and downs it in an unsuccessful effort to stop his panic attack. (To say nothing of the cocaine-and-booze binge in the third episode.)

to:

* OffTheWagon: Armstrong is a recovering alcoholic and refuses wine at dinner. When they realize that the first couple of deaths are murders, though, he finds a flask and downs it in an unsuccessful effort to stop his panic attack. (To say nothing of Later, he partakes in the [[ScrewTheWarWerePartying cocaine-and-booze binge binge]] in the third episode.)



* PragmaticAdaptation: The ending of the novel has [[spoiler:Vera hang herself in her guilt fueled daze and the killer's motivations and some of the details of his plans are explained through an epilogue in the form of a letter in a bottle Wargrave threw into the sea as a form of confession. To give the audience a more engaging ending, Wargrave instead confronts Vera as she's in the process of hanging herself so that he can both give his MotiveRant in person and actually kill her directly by pulling away the chair she was balancing on. In addition, his method for faking his 'murder' in the book involves a somewhat contrived apparatus to fling the gun out of his hands after he shoots himself. As this would look bizarre to witness first hand, the drama of the moment is preserved by having him simply position the gun such that his dying reflex flings it to the other end of the table he's sitting at]].

to:

* PragmaticAdaptation: The ending of the novel has [[spoiler:Vera hang herself in her guilt fueled guilt-fuelled daze and the killer's motivations and some of the details of his plans are explained through an epilogue in the form of a letter in a bottle Wargrave threw into the sea as a form of confession. To give the audience a more engaging ending, Wargrave instead confronts Vera as she's in the process of hanging herself so that he can both give his MotiveRant in person and actually kill her directly by pulling away the chair she was balancing on. In addition, his method for faking his 'murder' in the book involves a somewhat contrived apparatus to fling the gun out of his hands after he shoots himself. As this would look bizarre to witness first hand, the drama of the moment is preserved by having him simply position the gun such that his dying reflex flings it to the other end of the table he's sitting at]].



* RuleOfSymbolism: [[GenreSavvy Vera]] is the first to realise that the ten figurines on the dining table - which also feature in the opening credits - represent the ten little soldiers from the poem on the wall. She's also the first to notice they're disappearing at the same rate as guests are dying.

to:

* RightForTheWrongReason: After Armstrong disappears, Vera surmises that he has faked his own death and is actually the murderer. She's onto something here — [[spoiler: someone has indeed faked his own death, but it's Wakefield, not Armstrong]].
* RuleOfSymbolism: [[GenreSavvy Vera]] is the first to realise that the ten figurines on the dining table - which also feature in the opening credits - represent the ten little soldiers from the poem on the wall. She's also the first to notice they're disappearing at the same rate as guests are dying.



* ScrewTheWarWerePartying: Vera being given a tot of brandy to settle her nerves leads to the bottle being passed around the four remaining guests. Then when they find Wargrave's body, they dig out Marston's cocaine and put on the phonograph so that they can at least have some laughs in what they're sure are their last hours alive. It's suggested that they're trying to keep awake so they're not killed in their sleep.

to:

* ScrewTheWarWerePartying: Vera being given a tot of brandy to settle her nerves leads to the bottle being passed around the four remaining guests. Then when they find Wargrave's body, following which those who are still alive don't just hit what's left of the booze, they also dig out Marston's cocaine and put on the phonograph some records so that they can at least have some laughs in what they're sure are their last hours alive. It's The recordsIt's suggested that they're trying to keep awake so they're not killed in their sleep.



* TooDumbToLive: The booze-and-cocaine party when we're down to four surviving characters. Sure, folks, you're stuck on an island and for all you know, one of your three companions is homicidally around the bend and responsible for the six murdered bodies around the house. What better time to screw up your perception, judgment, and ability to react to a threat?

to:

* TooDumbToLive: The booze-and-cocaine party when we're down to four surviving characters. Sure, folks, you're stuck on an island and for all you know, one of your three companions is homicidally around the bend and responsible for the six murdered bodies around the house. What better time to screw up your perception, judgment, and ability to react to a threat?threat? That said, by that point the remaining suspects have probably realised that they're not going to get off the island alive and so are resorting to ScrewTheWarWerePartying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ToiletHumour: Downplayed, but Blore reluctantly admitting to be suffering from constipation is what brings on the TensionCuttingLaughter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DiesDifferentlyinAdaptation:

to:

* DiesDifferentlyinAdaptation:DiesDifferentlyInAdaptation:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DiesDifferentlyinAdaptation:
** Of the 10 guests on the island, [[spoiler:only Blore's death is substantially different from his novel counterpart. In the original book, Owen drops a large, bear-shaped clock on Blore's head from Vera's window. In the series, Owen stabs Blore with a kitchen knife while wearing a bear-skin rug.]]
** [[spoiler:In the series, Emily Brent casually remarks that Beatrice Taylor killed herself by jumping in front a moving train. In the novel, Beatrice drowns herself instead.]]

Added: 203

Changed: 89

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The casual bigotry that was more socially accepted in 1939 is now reframed to foreshadow how unpleasant certain characters really are, such as the antisemitism leveled at Isaac Morris.

to:

** The casual Casual bigotry that was more socially accepted in 1939 is now reframed abounds, with some instances used to foreshadow depict how unpleasant certain characters really are, such as the antisemitism leveled at Isaac Morris.Morris.
** Downplayed in the case of Lombard, who faces some anti-Irish xenophobia (with Blore groundlessly referring to him as a "Fenian") but is more mistrusted for his shady nature than his country of origin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PsychoLesbian: It's implied that Emily had feelings for Beatrice (who in this version is shown to have been underage), and dismissed her out of jealousy when Beatrice became pregnant.

to:

* PsychoLesbian: It's implied that Emily had feelings for Beatrice (who in this version is shown to have been underage), and dismissed her out of jealousy when Beatrice became pregnant. Specifically, in a flashback when Beatrice accidentally pokes her finger with a knitting needle and draws blood, Emily pulls her hand to her mouth and performs FingerSuckHealing while staring at her.

Added: 971

Changed: 1094

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* EvenEvilHasStandards: This trope is {{averted|Trope}} when several of the other, more sanctimonious guests try to chew out Lombard for ''his'' crime, (because he flat out admits it's all true almost immediately) as he points out (quite accurately) that they're all hypocrites. It is played straight, however, when just about everybody in the room is horrified that Anthony Marston thinks running down two children was bad luck for ''[[ItsAllAboutMe him]]'' because he got his license taken away for six months.

to:

* EvenEvilHasStandards: EvenEvilHasStandards:
**
This trope is {{averted|Trope}} when several of the other, more sanctimonious guests try to chew out Lombard for ''his'' crime, (because he flat out admits it's all true almost immediately) as he points out (quite accurately) that they're all hypocrites. It is played straight, however, when just about everybody in the room is horrified that Anthony Marston thinks running down two children was bad luck for ''[[ItsAllAboutMe him]]'' because he got his license taken away for six months.



* SuspectExistenceFailure: [[spoiler: Happens to a number of the eventual victims, particularly Armstrong, who Lombard and Vera are completely convinced is the killer until they find his corpse.]]

to:

* SuspectExistenceFailure: SuspectExistenceFailure:
**
[[spoiler: Happens to a number of the eventual victims, particularly Armstrong, who Lombard and Vera are completely convinced is the killer until they find his corpse.]]



---> '''U.N. Owen''': Maybe there's something in that. There are differences between [[spoiler: Seton]] and myself. All his victims were innocent. You are all guilty.
* VillainRespect: In the climax, U.N. Owen expresses admiration for his final victim's resourcefulness [[spoiler:before yanking the chair she's balancing herself on out from under her, leaving her to suffocate in a noose]].
-->'''U.N. Owen:''' [[spoiler:What a beguiling woman you are, Ms. Claythorne. ''Vera''. Quite my favorite, really.]]

to:

---> --> '''U.N. Owen''': Maybe there's something in that. There are differences between [[spoiler: Seton]] and myself. All his victims were innocent. You are all guilty.
* VillainRespect: VillainRespect:
**
In the climax, U.N. Owen expresses admiration for his final victim's resourcefulness [[spoiler:before yanking the chair she's balancing herself on out from under her, leaving her to suffocate in a noose]].
-->'''U.--->'''U.N. Owen:''' [[spoiler:What a beguiling woman you are, Ms. Claythorne. ''Vera''. Quite my favorite, really.]]]]
** At the moment of his execution, Edward Seton realizes that [[spoiler:Wargrave]] was just as bloodthirsty as he was and flashed him a smile in admiration for his ability to hide his nature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalDumbass: Inverted in that [[spoiler:Armstrong's relationship with the judge is truer to the original story than in previous film versions. Previously, Wargrave arranged an incident in which he and the doctor were left alone in the dark, convincing Armstrong that he could not be the murderer by pointing out that both of them could have killed each other but chose not to. Only then does Armstrong put his faith in him. In this version, Armstrong blindly trusts Wargrave solely because of his occupation and the belief that no one in a profession as respectable as his own could possibly be capable of murder.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AllForNothing: Macathur's killing of Henry Richmond comes to this in the end, as his wife Leslie ends up dying of [[UsefulNotes/TheSpanishFlu the 1918-1920 Spanish flu pandemic]], leaving him alone with his guilt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also on the train, [[spoiler: Vera, uncomfortable with Lombard's clear interest in her legs, moves away to the compartment with a sleeping Wargrave and settles there for the remainder of the journey. This sequence of events basically sums up what happens towards the end of the final episode as Vera becomes sure that Lombard is the killer and kills him before returning to the house and finding herself alone in a room with a noose and Wargrave.]]


Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: In fact, in a blink-and-you'll-miss-it moment just after Wargrave fires the shot that kills him, it's possible to see quite a bit of blood and what's presumably flesh and brain matter splatter the wall and curtains behind him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TruerToTheText: Along with the 1987 Soviet film, the BBC miniseries is the only adaptation that restores the EverybodyDiesEnding and deep cynicism of the original novel.

to:

* TruerToTheText: Along with the 1987 Soviet film, the BBC miniseries is the only adaptation that restores the EverybodyDiesEnding (albeit with its own share of deviations) and deep cynicism of the original novel.

Added: 461

Changed: 543

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CriticalStaffingShortage: Mr. and Mrs. Rogers are the only staff in the house and expected to serve three hot meals a day, along with every other household task, to eight other people.

to:

* CriticalStaffingShortage: Mr. and Mrs. Rogers are the only staff in the house and expected to serve three hot meals a day, along with every other household task, to eight other people. [[spoiler: This comes into play even more as the series progresses, as Mrs. Rogers is the second victim, and Rogers is the fourth, leaving the remaining six survivors to fend for themselves. In fact, after Rogers dies, and due to the stress of the situation, the survivors dispatch with any meal formalities and start simply eating food directly out of tins.]]



** Surprisingly enough, U.N. Owen lampshades this when referring to his own actions. Whilst he ''is'' a serial killer, he points out that all of his victims are ''killers'' themselves. In other words, Owen never harmed an innocent person. He is simply giving the guilty their [[PayEvilUntoEvil punishment]].

to:

** Surprisingly enough, U.N. Owen lampshades this when referring to his own actions. Whilst he ''is'' a serial killer, he points out that all of his victims are ''killers'' themselves. In other words, Owen never harmed an innocent person. He is simply giving the guilty their [[PayEvilUntoEvil punishment]].punishment, for crimes that the law couldn't touch them for]].



* NeverOneMurder: [[spoiler: In fact, there are more than 10, as well as one on-screen suicide]]



** It's blink-and-you'll-miss-it, but Blore is shown going over the list of guests he's been given in his letter. He writes 'Fenian' next to Phillip Lombard's name, and at one point claims that Lombard's the obvious suspect because he's Irish, and out to kill all English. Probably, a PragmaticAdaptation / RealLifeWritesThePlot due to Aiden Turner being Irish.

to:

** It's blink-and-you'll-miss-it, but Blore is shown going over the list of guests he's been given in his letter. He writes 'Fenian' next to Phillip Lombard's name, and at one point claims that Lombard's the obvious suspect because he's Irish, and out to kill all English. Probably, This is a PragmaticAdaptation / RealLifeWritesThePlot due to Aiden Turner being Irish.Irish, as the novel never states specifically where Lombard is from, but treats him as English.



** [[spoiler:Wargrave tells Vera that his terminal cancer is "extraordinarily painful" but gives no indication of it other than telling her so.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:Wargrave tells Vera that his terminal cancer is "extraordinarily painful" but gives no indication of it other than telling her so.so and giving a bit of a wince.]]
* SuspectExistenceFailure: [[spoiler: Happens to a number of the eventual victims, particularly Armstrong, who Lombard and Vera are completely convinced is the killer until they find his corpse.]]
** [[spoiler: Subverted by Lombard in the final confrontation with Vera. He KNOWS the killer is not her. Unfortunately, Vera doesn't subvert it, and she guns him down.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalSexuality: The book emphasises Emily Brent's cruel sense of propriety as her motive for abandoning Beatrice. Here, her anguished flashbacks suggest that her feelings for Beatrice were romantic and she abandoned her out of jealousy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added info up top

Added DiffLines:

This is the first in a series of five Christie adaptations adapted by Sarah Phelps for the BBC. The others are: ''Series/WitnessForTheProsecution'' (2016), ''Series/OrdealByInnocence'' (2018), ''Series/TheABCMurders'' (2018) and ''Literature/ThePaleHorse'' (2020).

Added: 189

Changed: 498

Removed: 644

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Punctuation only goes inside spoiler tags if the contents are one or more complete sentences. Almost every spoiler on this page gets this wrong. Also, leading articles do not count toward alphabetisation.





* ActuallyPrettyFunny: When being questioned by Lombard about where he was at the time of [[spoiler: Rogers]] death, Blore admits he was in the lavatory, constipated. This makes the rest of the survivors break down laughing, breaking some of the tension.

to:

* ActuallyPrettyFunny: When being questioned by Lombard about where he was at the time of [[spoiler: Rogers]] [[spoiler:Rogers']] death, Blore admits he was in the lavatory, constipated. This makes the rest of the survivors break down laughing, breaking some of the tension.



* AdaptationalIntelligence: Lombard establishes himself as a hunter who completely understands the situation they're in, compared to how it's implied he's just a pragmatic ThrillSeeker in the book. He also points out that [[NotSoDifferentRemark he and Vera are not so different]] in how they [[spoiler:killed for profit, even if Vera denies it]]. [[spoiler:He knows Vera isn't the killer when Blore is killed while they're both outside and he told her to stay on the rocks, giving her an alibi. Ergo, the killer isn't either of them. It's not enough to save him when he tries to reason with Vera, and aptly says the killer is still on the island and hunting them]].

to:

* AdaptationalIntelligence: Lombard establishes himself as a hunter who completely understands the situation they're in, compared to how it's implied he's just a pragmatic ThrillSeeker in the book. He also points out that [[NotSoDifferentRemark he and Vera are not so different]] in how they [[spoiler:killed for profit, even if Vera denies it]]. [[spoiler:He it. He knows Vera isn't the killer when Blore is killed while they're both outside and he told her to stay on the rocks, giving her an alibi. Ergo, the killer isn't either of them. It's not enough to save him when he tries to reason with Vera, and aptly says the killer is still on the island and hunting them]].



** Lombard changes from a man who abandoned his followers to starve in the name of self-preservation to one who [[spoiler:burned a village to steal diamonds]]. Interestingly, Lombard's line that he was either "embellishing a story for shocking effect, or I'm the only one telling the truth in a room full of liars," indirectly references Christie's 1943 theatre adaptation inversion of this trope, where it is revealed at the end [[spoiler:Lombard didn't actually kill the Africans (he went ahead to find help and didn't come back in time) despite admitting it after the gramophone indictment. It turned out that he embellished the story just for the sheer joy of watching everyone's faces react to his admission.]]

to:

** Lombard changes from a man who abandoned his followers to starve in the name of self-preservation to one who [[spoiler:burned a village to steal diamonds]]. Interestingly, Lombard's line that he was either "embellishing a story for shocking effect, or I'm the only one telling the truth in a room full of liars," indirectly references Christie's 1943 theatre adaptation inversion of this trope, where it is revealed at the end [[spoiler:Lombard didn't actually kill the Africans (he went ahead to find help and didn't come back in time) despite admitting it after the gramophone indictment. It turned out that he embellished the story just for the sheer joy of watching everyone's faces react to his admission.]]admission]].



* AdaptationExplanationExtrication: The killer's long and detailed confession is distilled into a five-minute long conversation. While it leaves in the explanation for their motives, as well as [[spoiler:how they faked their own death and killed Armstrong,]] any details on how the crime was planned and how they killed everyone undetected is left to the viewer's imagination.

to:

* AdaptationExplanationExtrication: The killer's long and detailed confession is distilled into a five-minute long conversation. While it leaves in the explanation for their motives, as well as [[spoiler:how they faked their own death and killed Armstrong,]] Armstrong]], any details on how the crime was planned and how they killed everyone undetected is left to the viewer's imagination.



* TheBadGuyWins: And how. Not only does U.N. Owen successfully manage to execute their carefully thought out scheme, they manage to get away with it in the end, due to being ... well, dead.



* ChekhovsGun: [[spoiler: Rogers]] notices the platter of liver and kidneys is gone from the storeroom. The same platter is [[spoiler: used to create the "gore"when Wargrave fakes his death.]]

to:

* ChekhovsGun: [[spoiler: Rogers]] notices the platter of liver and kidneys is gone from the storeroom. The same platter is [[spoiler: used to create the "gore"when "gore" when Wargrave fakes his death.]]death]].



* CountingBullets: At the end, [[spoiler:the last survivor is hanging from a rope when the killer (who had [[FakingTheDead faked his own death]] earlier on to be BeneathSuspicion) reveals himself. She tries to convince him to rescue her because there are no more bullets for him to make [[ThanatosGambit his planned suicide]] appear as a murder, spoiling his plan to create an unsolveable mystery. He plays along for a bit before pulling out the chair from under her and pointing out that she forgot the one bullet that was earlier "used" on him, which he holds up.]]

to:

* CountingBullets: At the end, [[spoiler:the last survivor is hanging from a rope when the killer (who had [[FakingTheDead faked his own death]] earlier on to be BeneathSuspicion) reveals himself. She tries to convince him to rescue her because there are no more bullets for him to make [[ThanatosGambit his planned suicide]] appear as a murder, spoiling his plan to create an unsolveable mystery. He plays along for a bit before pulling out the chair from under her and pointing out that she forgot the one bullet that was earlier "used" on him, which he holds up.]]up]].



* DidntWantAnAdventure: Wargrave notes dryly that his stay on the island was supposed to be recuperation after his cancer surgery. Of course [[spoiler:the {{Irony}} is that he's the reason why everyone is there.]]

to:

* DidntWantAnAdventure: Wargrave notes dryly that his stay on the island was supposed to be recuperation after his cancer surgery. Of course [[spoiler:the {{Irony}} is that he's the reason why everyone is there.]]there]].



** Subverted with [[spoiler:Vera. It looks like she's going to face her death with dignity by calmly hanging herself with a hallucination of Cyril looking on, until Wargrave's unexpected appearance causes her to slip from the chair she's standing on and spend the last few minutes of her life as a panicked mess [[AintTooProudToBeg desperately trying to get Wargrave to save her]] before the noose completely tightens around her neck.]]

to:

** Subverted with [[spoiler:Vera. It looks like she's going to face her death with dignity by calmly hanging herself with a hallucination of Cyril looking on, until Wargrave's unexpected appearance causes her to slip from the chair she's standing on and spend the last few minutes of her life as a panicked mess [[AintTooProudToBeg desperately trying to get Wargrave to save her]] before the noose completely tightens around her neck.]]neck]].



** U. N. Owen gives one to the last victim: [[spoiler:She's trapped in the noose, struggling for balance on an overturned chair, when he arrives. She tries to convince him to spare her. He compliments her, tells her she's his favourite... and then pulls the chair away.]]
* HoistbyHisOwnPetard: [[spoiler:Lombard is adamant about keeping hold of his revolver, seeming to believe that if he's armed, he's untouchable. When the gun is mysteriously returned to him after Armstrong disappears, he thinks nothing of it, and is just pleased to have it in his possession. Blore attempts to convince him to get rid of it, but Lombard refuses. Because he keeps it on his person for the remainder of the film, Vera is easily able to steal it from him when he's distracted by moving Armstrong's body, and Lombard ends up getting shot and killed by Vera with his own gun. ]]

to:

** U. N. Owen gives one to the last victim: [[spoiler:She's trapped in the noose, struggling for balance on an overturned chair, when he arrives. She tries to convince him to spare her. He compliments her, tells her she's his favourite... and then pulls the chair away.]]
away]] .
* HoistbyHisOwnPetard: HoistByHisOwnPetard: [[spoiler:Lombard is adamant about keeping hold of his revolver, seeming to believe that if he's armed, he's untouchable. When the gun is mysteriously returned to him after Armstrong disappears, he thinks nothing of it, and is just pleased to have it in his possession. Blore attempts to convince him to get rid of it, but Lombard refuses. Because he keeps it on his person for the remainder of the film, Vera is easily able to steal it from him when he's distracted by moving Armstrong's body, and Lombard ends up getting shot and killed by Vera with his own gun. ]]



-->'''Lombard:''' So either I'm embellishing a story for shocking effect, or I'm the only one telling the truth in a room full of ''liars''.

to:

-->'''Lombard:''' --->'''Lombard:''' So either I'm embellishing a story for shocking effect, or I'm the only one telling the truth in a room full of ''liars''.



* {{Irony}}:
** When Vera gets worked up in the first episode and a half over the unsettling atmosphere and seemingly innocent deaths, Dr. Armstrong coolly accuses her of being hysterical. In the last episode and a half, when it's really set in that someone intends to kill them all, Vera enters a [[DissonantSerenity very creepy state of Zen]], while Armstrong grows hysterical.

to:

* {{Irony}}:
**
{{Irony}}: When Vera gets worked up in the first episode and a half over the unsettling atmosphere and seemingly innocent deaths, Dr. Armstrong coolly accuses her of being hysterical. In the last episode and a half, when it's really set in that someone intends to kill them all, Vera enters a [[DissonantSerenity very creepy state of Zen]], while Armstrong grows hysterical.



* OnceMoreWithClarity: Most of Vera's flashbacks to the day Cyril died show her running in haste and screaming after him to stop. [[spoiler:What actually happened was she suggested he swim to the rock like he always wanted, and in fact took her time running and swimming after him. Something that Hugo calls her out on because he knows she could outrun Cyril at any point]].

to:

* OnceMoreWithClarity: Most of Vera's flashbacks to the day Cyril died show her running in haste and screaming after him to stop. [[spoiler:What actually happened was she suggested he swim to the rock like he always wanted, and in fact took her time running and swimming after him. Something that Hugo calls her out on because he knows she could outrun Cyril at any point]].point.]]



* PragmaticAdaptation: The ending of the novel has [[spoiler:Vera hang herself in her guilt fueled daze and the killer's motivations and some of the details of his plans are explained through an epilogue in the form of a letter in a bottle Wargrave threw into the sea as a form of confession. To give the audience a more engaging ending, Wargrave instead confronts Vera as she's in the process of hanging herself so that he can both give his MotiveRant in person and actually kill her directly by pulling away the chair she was balancing on. In addition, his method for faking his 'murder' in the book involves a somewhat contrived apparatus to fling the gun out of his hands after he shoots himself. As this would look bizarre to witness first hand, the drama of the moment is preserved by having him simply position the gun such that his dying reflex flings it to the other end of the table he's sitting at.]]

to:

* PragmaticAdaptation: The ending of the novel has [[spoiler:Vera hang herself in her guilt fueled daze and the killer's motivations and some of the details of his plans are explained through an epilogue in the form of a letter in a bottle Wargrave threw into the sea as a form of confession. To give the audience a more engaging ending, Wargrave instead confronts Vera as she's in the process of hanging herself so that he can both give his MotiveRant in person and actually kill her directly by pulling away the chair she was balancing on. In addition, his method for faking his 'murder' in the book involves a somewhat contrived apparatus to fling the gun out of his hands after he shoots himself. As this would look bizarre to witness first hand, the drama of the moment is preserved by having him simply position the gun such that his dying reflex flings it to the other end of the table he's sitting at.]]at]].



* ScrewTheWarWerePartying: Vera being given a tot of brandy to settle her nerves leads to the bottle being passed around the four remaining guests. Then when they find Wargrave's body, they dig out Marston's cocaine and put on the phonograph so that they can at least have some laughs in what they're sure are their last hours alive.
** It's suggested that they're trying to keep awake so they're not killed in their sleep.

to:

* ScrewTheWarWerePartying: Vera being given a tot of brandy to settle her nerves leads to the bottle being passed around the four remaining guests. Then when they find Wargrave's body, they dig out Marston's cocaine and put on the phonograph so that they can at least have some laughs in what they're sure are their last hours alive.
**
alive. It's suggested that they're trying to keep awake so they're not killed in their sleep.



* ShipperOnDeck: Cyril all but tells Vera that he supports her marrying his uncle because then she'd be his aunt. [[spoiler:It only adds to the horror when Vera allows him to drown]].

to:

* ShipperOnDeck: Cyril all but tells Vera that he supports her marrying his uncle because then she'd be his aunt. [[spoiler:It only adds to the horror when Vera allows him to drown]].drown.]]



* TheBadGuyWins: And how. Not only does U.N. Owen successfully manage to execute their carefully thought out scheme, they manage to get away with it in the end, due to being ... well, dead.



* UndeadChild: Vera hallucinates Cyril haunting her, even [[spoiler:accompanying her to the noose that's been prepared in her room.]]

to:

* UndeadChild: Vera hallucinates Cyril haunting her, even [[spoiler:accompanying her to the noose that's been prepared in her room.]]room]].



* VillainRespect: In the climax, U.N. Owen expresses admiration for his final victim's resourcefulness [[spoiler:before yanking the chair she's balancing herself on out from under her, leaving her to suffocate in a noose.]]

to:

* VillainRespect: In the climax, U.N. Owen expresses admiration for his final victim's resourcefulness [[spoiler:before yanking the chair she's balancing herself on out from under her, leaving her to suffocate in a noose.]]noose]].



* WhamShot: When the last survivor goes to hang herself, someone else opens the door. The person is shown with a waist-level shot that pans up to reveal that [[spoiler:Justice Wargrave was the killer.]]
* YourDaysAreNumbered: [[spoiler:Though he claimed that his surgery was successful earlier, Wargrave's cancer is terminal. Knowing this, he decided to spend his remaining days indulging in his desire for karmic execution of some very guilty people, and then takes his own life while he is still relatively well and able to do so with dignity]].

to:

* WhamShot: When the last survivor goes to hang herself, someone else opens the door. The person is shown with a waist-level shot that pans up to reveal that [[spoiler:Justice Wargrave was the killer.]]
killer]].
* YourDaysAreNumbered: [[spoiler:Though he claimed that his surgery was successful earlier, Wargrave's cancer is terminal. Knowing this, he decided to spend his remaining days indulging in his desire for karmic execution of some very guilty people, and then takes his own life while he is still relatively well and able to do so with dignity]].
dignity.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Wargrave could not have joined the party, since he was allegedly dead by that point.


** It's suggested that they're trying to keep awake so they're not killed in their sleep, which is [[spoiler: (apparently) exactly what happens to Wargrave, who does not join in.]]

to:

** It's suggested that they're trying to keep awake so they're not killed in their sleep, which is [[spoiler: (apparently) exactly what happens to Wargrave, who does not join in.]]sleep.

Top