Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Retcon / LiveActionTV

Go To

OR

Changed: 28

Removed: 140

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


-->Sam: He also said you were a scientist.
--> (Martin shoots a look at Frasier)
-->Frasier: Oh, what did it matter? You were dead!
** Penny was originally said to have been married six times. Later seasons retconned that into only ''engaged'' six times, and married four.

to:

-->Sam: --->'''Sam:''' He also said you were a scientist.
--> (Martin
scientist.\\
(''Martin
shoots a look at Frasier)
-->Frasier:
Frasier'')\\
'''Frasier:'''
Oh, what did it matter? You were dead!
** Penny was originally said to have been married six times. Later seasons retconned that into only ''engaged'' six times, and married four.
dead!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->Sam: He also said you were a scientist.
--> (Martin shoots a look at Frasier)
-->Frasier: Oh, what did it matter? You were dead!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** One episode says that Monk did not have his psychological quirks until after the death of his wife, however another shows he still had extreme OCD as a teenager.

Added: 435

Changed: 33

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/BetterCallSaul'', which is a prequel and spinoff to ''Series/BreakingBad'', has some minor cases of this.

to:

* ''Series/BetterCallSaul'', which is a prequel and spinoff to ''Series/BreakingBad'', avoids it for the most part, but has some minor cases of this.


Added DiffLines:

** In his first episode of ''Series/BreakingBad'' it's inferred that Saul Goodman only uses that name professionally as a lawyer just because it sounds Jewish, with the phonetic joke of the name ('s all good, man) being an out-of-universe gag. However in ''Better Call Saul'' it's revealed that Saul has been using the alias in his con artist days, long before ever becoming a lawyer, and fully acknowledges the "'s'all good, man" pun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Later seasons made jokes about J.D. knowing nothing about sports, despite him having sports memorabilia in his bedroom in earlier episodes. Zach Braff stated that this character trait was added after he mentioned to the producer that he wasn't interested in sports, and he thought it would be funny to add that to J.D.'s character.

Added: 1989

Changed: 726

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A minor example concerning Anya's demon friend Halfrek. She was played by Kali Rocha who had appeared in another episode as Cecily, one of Spike's human love interests. In her next episode when she and Spike appeared on screen together they had Halfrek say "William?" and then the two avoided each other's gaze, implying Halfrek and Cecily to be the same person. Also Halfrek's flashback scene in "[[{{Recap/BuffyTheVampireSlayerS7E5Selfless}} Selfless]]" was changed from the Renaissance to the Russian Revolution to support this.

to:

** A minor example concerning Anya's demon friend Halfrek. She was played by Kali Rocha who had appeared in another episode as Cecily, one of Spike's human love interests. In her next episode when she and Spike appeared on screen together they had Halfrek say "William?" and then the two avoided each other's gaze, implying Halfrek and Cecily to be the same person. Also Halfrek's flashback scene in "[[{{Recap/BuffyTheVampireSlayerS7E5Selfless}} Selfless]]" was changed from the Renaissance to the Russian Revolution to support this. [[WordOfSaintPaul The actress herself]] stated that she was already a vengeance demon as 'Cecily' and was on assignment when she met Spike.



* In ''Series/{{Charmed|1998}}'' the sisters constantly had to fight the risk of exposing their magic to the public. The season 3 finale revolves around them trying to get a demon to turn back time for them to reverse this. But season 6 adds in entities called The Cleaners whose job is to fix things whenever magic is exposed. They claim they've been watching the sisters from the beginning. They would have been really useful three years ago. One also wonders why they didn't step in to stop the bad future in "Morality Bites".

to:

* ''Series/{{Charmed|1998}}'':
**
In ''Series/{{Charmed|1998}}'' Victor's first appearance, his actor is credited as 'Victor Halliwell'. Halliwell would later be retconned to be Patty's last name, and Victor's would be 'Bennett'.
** The series flip-flopped on precisely when Victor and Patty split up and when he left
the family. In "That 70s Episode", they are already separated before Patty even knows she's pregnant with Phoebe, which seemed to contradict "Thank You For Not Morphing", where he still appeared in a Christmas home movie when Phoebe was two. Piper also says the last meal she had with him was when she was four, when Season 5 would retcon it into him leaving the night of her fifth birthday after a demon attacked.
** The
sisters constantly had to fight the risk of exposing their magic to the public. The season 3 finale revolves around them trying to get a demon to turn back time for them to reverse this. But season 6 adds in entities called The Cleaners whose job is to fix things whenever magic is exposed. They claim they've been watching the sisters from the beginning. They would have been really useful three years ago. One also wonders why beginning, although it is given a hand wave with the Cleaners saying the sisters otherwise had a good track record for covering their exposure risks, suggesting they didn't step never had to intervene.[[note]]While magic was exposed in to stop "All Hell Breaks Loose", the bad future in "Morality Bites".ones who exposed it were Prue and Piper, and the "Forget Me...Not" highlights that the Cleaners can't erase the Charmed Ones without shifting the balance of power to evil and therefore maintain their neutrality, suggesting that the solution of resetting time while they still could was more practical.[[/note]]



*** The first mention of Leo's bosses identifies them as "a group of elder Whitelighters, called The Founders." The Founders title is immediately dropped, labeling them the Elders, and when a teenage witch is admitted into their ranks, it proves that even Elder is a NonindicativeName and that they aren't even Whitelighters (who are regular humans who died committing an act of Good), meaning everything Leo said was wrong.

to:

*** The first mention of Leo's bosses identifies them as "a group of elder Whitelighters, called The Founders." The Founders title is immediately dropped, labeling them the Elders, and when a teenage witch is admitted into their ranks, it proves that even Elder is a NonindicativeName and that they aren't even Whitelighters (who are regular humans who died committing an act of Good), meaning everything Leo said was wrong. The Season 9 comics would state that the Elders are "sometimes" called The Founders.


Added DiffLines:

** The dates on the family tree in "Pardon My Past" had to be retconned because of the leaps they took with logic - listing Penny's birth date as 1937, and Patty's as 1950, meaning Penny was a mother at twelve! Penny was later retconned to have been born in 1930.
** Penny's amount of husbands is first said to have been four, and then six, and then clarified as four marriages but six ''engagements''.

Changed: 1727

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trimming down Text Wall.


** [=NuWho=] Series 7 and 50th Anniversary Special "[[Recap/DoctorWho50thASTheDayOfTheDoctor The Day of the Doctor]]" managed to retcon in an entire new Doctor. When it was revealed that a secret hidden Doctor, played by Creator/JohnHurt, existed, fan theories melted down the Internet (including on this very wiki) as to who he really was. One fan theory that was roundly rejected was that he was the Doctor who fought in the Time War and destroyed both his planet and people and the Daleks as well, thus the epic guilt that caused him to try and forget that persona. The problem there was that the Doctor had spoken frequently about his involvement in the war, and the action he took to destroy both sides, leaving himself as the sole survivor, and the massive guilt he feels. None of that was a secret, so why would the body he used to do it in be one? Of course, once the fiftieth anniversary special aired, it turned out that that was indeed who John Hurt's Doctor was, meaning that every line of dialogue establishing that Creator/ChristopherEccleston's Doctor was the ninth, Creator/DavidTennant's the tenth, Creator/MattSmith's the eleventh, etc., were all lies that the Doctor was telling so that he could try and forget the version of himself that committed the heinous act that he had no trouble talking about in all three of his subsequent forms. On the other hand, the Tenth Doctor's line about regenerating "half a dozen times" since the last time he saw Sarah Jane has a new meaning now: he didn't forget about the events of "[[Recap/DoctorWho20thASTheFiveDoctors The Five Doctors]]" after all. The series itself at least tries to avert the numbering controversy arising from this retcon by having the Eleventh Doctor point out that his John Hurt incarnation renounced the name of the Doctor, feeling that he didn't deserve that title after what he did in the Time War. Thus, while he was the ninth ''incarnation'' of our favourite Time Lord, he ''wasn't'' the ninth ''Doctor''. Although, confusingly, the end credits name him "The War Doctor".

to:

** [=NuWho=] Series 7 and 50th Anniversary Special "[[Recap/DoctorWho50thASTheDayOfTheDoctor The "The Day of the Doctor]]" Doctor" managed to retcon in an entire new Doctor. When it was revealed in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS33E13TheNameOfTheDoctor the preceding story]] that a secret hidden Doctor, played by Creator/JohnHurt, existed, fan theories melted down the Internet (including on this very wiki) as to who he really was. One fan theory that was roundly rejected was that he was Once the Doctor who fought in "The Day of the Time War and destroyed both his planet and people and the Daleks as well, thus the epic guilt that caused him to try and forget that persona. The problem there was that the Doctor had spoken frequently about his involvement in the war, and the action he took to destroy both sides, leaving himself as the sole survivor, and the massive guilt he feels. None of that was a secret, so why would the body he used to do it in be one? Of course, once the fiftieth anniversary special Doctor" aired, it turned out that that the Hurt incarnation was indeed who John Hurt's the Doctor was, meaning that had fought in the Time War, and committed genocide against both the Time Lords and the Daleks. This meant that every line of dialogue establishing that Creator/ChristopherEccleston's Doctor was the ninth, Creator/DavidTennant's the tenth, Creator/MattSmith's the eleventh, etc., were all lies that the Doctor was telling so that he could try and forget the version of himself that committed the heinous act that he had no trouble talking about in all three of his subsequent forms. On the other hand, the Tenth Doctor's line about regenerating "half a dozen times" since the last time he saw Sarah Jane has a new meaning now: he didn't forget about the events of "[[Recap/DoctorWho20thASTheFiveDoctors The Five Doctors]]" after all. The series itself at least tries to avert the numbering controversy arising from this retcon by having the Eleventh Doctor point out that his John Hurt incarnation renounced the name of the Doctor, feeling that he didn't deserve that title after what he did in the Time War. Thus, while he was the ninth ''incarnation'' of our favourite Time Lord, he ''wasn't'' the ninth ''Doctor''. Although, confusingly, the end credits name him "The War Doctor".act.

Added: 2527

Changed: 695

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS13E5TheBrainOfMorbius The Brain of Morbius]]" displays the faces of previous incarnations of the Doctor at one point, including several others in addition to those of the first three Doctors. These were retconned to have been Morbius' previous incarnations just a handful of stories later in "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS14E3TheDeadlyAssassin The Deadly Assassin]]", in which the Fourth Doctor informs Borusa that he's only had three "[[UnusualEuphemism face lifts]]", and in which the twelve-regeneration limit was established. [[spoiler:Re-retconned in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS38E10TheTimelessChildren "The Timeless Children"]], which makes those previous reincarnations of the Doctor after all. ]]

to:

** The question of whether or not the Doctor had incarnations preceding Creator/WilliamHartnell has been answered, retconned, re-retconned and re-re-retconned:
*** In "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS10E1TheThreeDoctors The Three Doctors]]", one of the Time Lords refers to Hartnell as "the earliest Doctor", implying that the Doctor had had no pre-Hartnell incarnations.
***
"[[Recap/DoctorWhoS13E5TheBrainOfMorbius The Brain of Morbius]]" displays attempts to retcon what had been established in "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS10E1TheThreeDoctors The Three Doctors]]"; during the mind-bending contest between the Doctor and Morbius, eight faces of previous apparently prior incarnations of the Doctor at one point, including several others in addition to those of are shown (this was confirmed as the first three Doctors. production team's intent by [[invoked]]WordOfGod).
***
These were retconned to have been Morbius' previous apparent prior incarnations just a handful of stories later in the Doctor were, however, not referenced again afterwards. One year later, "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS14E3TheDeadlyAssassin The Deadly Assassin]]", Assassin]]" created threw a major spanner in which the Fourth Doctor informs Borusa works by establishing that he's Time Lords could only had three "[[UnusualEuphemism face lifts]]", and in which regenerate twelve times. This did not directly contradict the twelve-regeneration limit "Morbius Doctors" interpretation, as the incumbent Creator/TomBaker would have been the twelfth incarnation, within the limit. However, as this would have left him as the penultimate incarnation, it made a future re-retcon necessary in order to extend the life of the show beyond Baker's successor Creator/PeterDavison.
*** It
was established. [[spoiler:Re-retconned eventually re-retconned in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS38E10TheTimelessChildren "The Timeless Children"]], which makes those previous reincarnations of "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS20E3MawdrynUndead Mawdryn Undead]]", when the Doctor after all. ]]says "I can only regenerate twelve times. I have already done so four times." This re-retcon was backed up several more times over the following decades by lines that explicitly referred to the Hartnell incarnation as the first or to the Doctor having only as many incarnations as would be consistent with this, and of course, by the Davison Doctor successfully regenerating in "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS21E6TheCavesOfAndrozani The Caves of Androzani]]"[[note]]If the eight faces from "Brain of Morbius" were the Doctor's previous incarnations, this would have been the Doctor's 13th regeneration[[/note]].
*** For the next 37 years, fandom squared the circle of the "Morbius Doctors" by concluding that the faces shown in "The Brain of Morbius" were in fact prior incarnations of ''Morbius'', which did not contradict what was shown onscreen even though it hadn't been the production team's intent.
*** "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS38E10TheTimelessChildren The Timeless Children]]" re-re-retconned this by showing the Doctor as not being a Time Lord at all, having had countless pre-Hartnell incarnations (including the "Morbius Doctors") and having had their memory erased every thirteen regenerations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding more information


** The revelation made late in ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'' that Dr. Bashir is a genetically engineered superhuman causes numerous conflicts with earlier episodes, and basically makes him an awful person through FridgeLogic. For instance, the episode reveals that he could win every game of darts against O'Brien. Not only does this make their entire friendship seem like a farce, since playing darts is the chief activity they're seen enjoying together, but it contradicts the episode "[[{{Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS03E17Visionary}} Visionary]]" where O'Brien's foreknowledge of where Bashir's darts are going to hit was used to show that he had really been to the future. Then the episode "[[{{Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS03E18DistantVoices}} Distant Voices]]" is centered around an alien probing his mind and drawing out his deepest secrets, but him knowing himself to be the product of illegal genetic engineering never comes up.

to:

** The revelation made late in ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'' that Dr. Bashir is a genetically engineered superhuman explains how he was able to beat O’Brien in racquetball so many times and shows that he most likely mistook a preganglionic fiber for a postganglionic nerve on purpose to not draw suspicion to himself. But this also causes numerous conflicts with earlier episodes, episodes and basically makes him an awful person through FridgeLogic. For instance, the episode reveals that he could win every game of darts against O'Brien. Not only does this make their entire friendship seem like a farce, since playing darts is the chief activity they're seen enjoying together, but it contradicts the episode "[[{{Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS03E17Visionary}} Visionary]]" where O'Brien's foreknowledge of where Bashir's darts are going to hit was used to show that he had really been to the future. Then the episode "[[{{Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS03E18DistantVoices}} Distant Voices]]" is centered around an alien probing his mind and drawing out his deepest secrets, but him knowing himself to be the product of illegal genetic engineering never comes up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No longer a trope. Can't tell if replacement or others apply.


** It's revealed right from the start that Regina got the Dark Curse from Rumplestiltskin, thereby implying that he's the one who created it. But then Season 4 reveals that he just stole it from the cave where it had been hidden, suggesting that he didn't have anything to do with its creation. This is confirmed in Season 6, with the revelation that it was actually the Black Fairy, the show's UltimateEvil [[spoiler: and Rumple's mother]], who actually created the curse.

to:

** It's revealed right from the start that Regina got the Dark Curse from Rumplestiltskin, thereby implying that he's the one who created it. But then Season 4 reveals that he just stole it from the cave where it had been hidden, suggesting that he didn't have anything to do with its creation. This is confirmed in Season 6, with the revelation that it was actually the Black Fairy, the show's UltimateEvil [[spoiler: and Rumple's [[spoiler:Rumple's mother]], who actually created the curse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's worse than that, though. The original series finale also [[spoiler: implies an entire alternate universe in which many of the events of the show, long before the final season, must have been totally different in order to explain the different sexualities and relationships (Mark/Darlene? How did THAT happen?)]] but there's no time to explain that. Then the revival [[spoiler: makes entirely different retcons, throwing out most of the final season, removing certain characters, changing Harris's age, etc]]. Then when the show transitions to ''Series/TheConners'', ''even more'' changes are made, [[spoiler: officially declaring that Jerry and Andy and Fred never existed, that Darlene apparently never went to college, etc]]. The showrunners have described it as a "multiverse" from which they can assemble whatever version of the characters they want, but the end result is that [[ContinuitySnarl no one knows]] what elements of the original show are canon anymore.

to:

** It's worse than that, though. The original series finale also [[spoiler: implies an entire alternate universe in which many of the events of the show, long before the final season, must have been totally different in order to explain the different sexualities and relationships [[spoiler: (Mark/Darlene? How did THAT happen?)]] but there's no time to explain that. Then the revival [[spoiler: makes entirely different retcons, throwing out most of the final season, removing certain characters, changing Harris's age, etc]]. etc. Then when the show transitions to ''Series/TheConners'', ''even more'' changes are made, [[spoiler: officially declaring that Jerry and Andy and Fred never existed, that Darlene apparently never went to college, etc]].etc. The showrunners have described it as a "multiverse" from which they can assemble whatever version of the characters they want, but the end result is that [[ContinuitySnarl no one knows]] what elements of the original show are canon anymore.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/{{Alias}}'': "Hey you know the man you loved that died and you grieved over? Yeah, know he's alive remember, and we totally knew about it all the time, even though you cried lots in private over his loss." Explainable in-universe, however, since the enemy is dangerous enough to be able to successfully bug even the private homes of the characters for long periods of time before being uncovered. Having experienced that in the past, it would be sensible for that kind of charade to continue in private just to be on the safe side.

to:

* ''Series/{{Alias}}'': "Hey you know the man you loved that died and you grieved over? Yeah, know now he's alive remember, and we totally knew about it all the time, even though you cried lots in private over his loss." Explainable in-universe, however, since the enemy is dangerous enough to be able to successfully bug even the private homes of the characters for long periods of time before being uncovered. Having experienced that in the past, it would be sensible for that kind of charade to continue in private just to be on the safe side.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's worse than that, though. The original series finale also [[spoiler: implies an entire alternate universe in which many of the events of the show, long before the final season, must have been totally different in order to explain the different sexualities and relationships (Mark/Darlene? How did THAT happen?)]] but there's no time to explain that. Then the revival [[spoiler: makes entirely different retcons, throwing out most of the final season, removing certain characters, changing Harris's age, etc]]. Then when the show transitions to ''Series/TheConners'', ''even more'' changes are made, [[spoiler: officially declaring that Jerry and Andy and Fred never existed, that Darlene apparently never went to college, etc]]. The showrunners have described it as a "multiverse" from which they can assemble whatever version of the characters they want, but the end result is that [[ContinuitySnarl no one knows]] what elements of the original show are canon anymore.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Time Lords' binary vascular system was introduced in the Third Doctor's [[Recap/DoctorWhoS7E1SpearheadFromSpace first story]] and has remained a consistent feature of Gallifreyan biology ever since, despite the fact it was indicated that the Doctor only had one heart in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS1E3TheEdgeOfDestruction the third story of the show]]. An accepted explanation by fanon and [[Main/ExpandedUniverse books and audio]] is that Time Lords only gain the second heart after their first regeneration.
** In [[Recap/DoctorWhoS9E3TheSeaDevils "The Sea Devils"]], the Doctor points out that the cave creatures from [[Recap/DoctorWhoS7E2DoctorWhoAndTheSilurians "Doctor Who and the Silurians"]] should have, in fact, been named the "Eocenes" instead of the "Silurians", because of the epoch they originated from, which is the real-life author (same for both stories) correcting his earlier mistake when he was called on it after the broadcast of the first story. Unfortunately, it's highly unlikely that that they could have come from the Eocene period, either.

to:

** The Time Lords' binary vascular system was introduced in first three seasons were mostly ambiguous about the nature of the Doctor and his people, but ran on the implicit idea that they were simply a highly-advanced human society from the distant future. This would change with the Third Doctor's [[Recap/DoctorWhoS7E1SpearheadFromSpace first story]] and story]], which introduced the Time Lords' binary cardiovascular system. It has remained a consistent feature of Gallifreyan biology ever since, despite the fact it was indicated that the Doctor only had one heart in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS1E3TheEdgeOfDestruction the third story of the show]]. An accepted explanation by fanon and [[Main/ExpandedUniverse books and audio]] is that Time Lords only gain the second heart after their first regeneration.
regeneration.
** In [[Recap/DoctorWhoS9E3TheSeaDevils "The Sea Devils"]], the Doctor points out that the cave creatures from [[Recap/DoctorWhoS7E2DoctorWhoAndTheSilurians "Doctor Who and the Silurians"]] should have, in fact, been named the "Eocenes" instead of the "Silurians", because of the epoch they originated from, which is the real-life author (same for both stories) correcting his earlier mistake when he was called on it after the broadcast of the first story. Unfortunately, it's highly unlikely that that they could have come from the Eocene period, either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/{{Riverdale}}'': The later seasons try to portray Alice as a ParentsAsPeople type as opposed to being an AbusiveParent. However, she never atones or acknowledges her behavior, instead doubling down.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The first couple shapeshifters they meet have to strip off their current skin to reveal their new form. The first they meet takes a long time to transform in what appears to be a painful process, the second takes almost no time to stripe their skin off, and the others don't even strip their skins off, they just transform.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added an example.

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/{{MASH}}'': Radar was flanderized over the course of the series, evolving from a gruff unmotivated draftee to a sweet, innocent kid. Perhaps the most egregious example comes from his smoking cigars: early on, he's often seen with his feet up on Lt.Col. Blake's desk, helping himself to the CO's cigars. A few seasons later, Col. Potter has to teach Radar how to smoke a cigar, as he apparently has never done it before.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Several times in ''Series/TheBrittasEmpire'':
** The 1994 Christmas Special shows Julie working at the centre in 1991 mere days after it first opened. This contradicts Series 1, which had the long-lost Angie working there instead.
** Initially, Carol's twins were a boy and a girl (Tom and Emily). However, by series 5, Tom had turned into a girl, Jessica.
** Also, initially, Helen and Gordon had three children, Jonathan, Tom, and an unnamed third child. This increases to to five with the birth of Matthew and Mark in Series 3. However, Gordon claims to have only 4 children in 'Curse of the Tiger Woman'.

to:

* Several This happens several times in ''Series/TheBrittasEmpire'':
** The 1994 Christmas Special shows Julie working at the centre in 1991 mere only days after it first opened. opened in 1989. This contradicts Series 1, which had the long-lost Angie working there at the time instead.
** Initially, Carol's twins (born in Series 2) were a boy and a girl (Tom and Emily). However, by By series 5, 5 however, Tom had turned been retconned into a girl, girl named Jessica.
** Also, initially, Helen and Gordon had three children, that being Jonathan, Tom, and an unnamed third child. This increases to to five with the birth of Matthew and Mark in at the end of Series 3. However, by "The Disappearing Act", Helen mentions only having four children, a fact which is backed up by Gordon claims to have only 4 children in 'Curse "Curse of the Tiger Woman'.Women".

Top