Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / SouthParkS22E3TheProblemWithAPoo

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rename/IUEO


* EasilyForgiven: Kyle seems to have forgiven Heidi for her mistreatment of him in the last season, since he doesn't mind her sitting near him in band rehearsals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KarmicShunning: The entire town shuns Mr. Hankey for his racist and inappropriate tweets and [[NeverMyFault refusal to acknowledge his faults]]. It gets to the point where Mr. Hankey is forced to leave South Park and move to another town that would accept him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CliffhangerCopout: The season 21 finale has Heidi’s story end right after she breaks up with Cartman, implying that her story will continue into the next season and will focus on her efforts to return to her NiceGirl self and make amends with everyone she’s wronged, especially in regards to Kyle. However, when she makes her first season 22 appearance, she is immediately back to her normal self, is sitting near Kyle without any issues, and has been DemotedToExtra. She doesn’t make another appearance until the season 22 finale.


Added DiffLines:

* EasilyForgiven: Kyle seems to have forgiven Heidi for her mistreatment of him in the last season, since he doesn’t mind her sitting near him in band rehearsals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ban evader reversion


* AesopAmnesia: The ''entire town'' shuns Kyle for defending Mr. Hankey, seemingly forgetting the last time people had picked on him, he led a protest that led to '''''Canada being nuked'''''.



* DudeWheresMyRespect: Well, perhaps not quite respect, but one would figure the town would realize the person they're shunning was recently, albeit not quite directly, responsible for a ''country being nuked'' after repeatedly being picked on before. By all means, if they truly consider that, ''especially'' the kids who did pick on him, they'd at least try and ''listen'' to what he had to say, at the very least to avoid pissing him off again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrapsackWorld: [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons Springfield]] is considered to be a place where “racist, awful beings” like Mr. Hankey can live in. That’s right, ''South Park'' is saying Springfield is an ''even worse'' place to live in.

to:

* CrapsackWorld: [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons Springfield]] is considered to be a place where “racist, "racist, awful beings” beings" like Mr. Hankey can live in. That’s That's right, ''South Park'' is saying Springfield is an ''even worse'' place to live in.



* EtTuBrute: Kyle's reaction to his three closest friends walking away after seeing his disheveled state (due to Hankey's abuse) screams this.

to:

* EtTuBrute: Kyle's reaction to his three closest friends walking away after seeing his disheveled state (due to Mr. Hankey's abuse) screams this.



* HeadDesk: All Kyle can do is slam his head on the table when he learns Mr. Hankey called the Mayor "a titless whore" on Twitter.

to:

* HeadDesk: All Kyle can do is slam his head on the table during the trial when he learns Mr. Hankey called the Mayor "a titless whore" on Twitter.



* NoHoldsBarredBeatdown: {{Parodied|Trope}} to a ridiculous degree. When Kyle tries to restrain Mr. Hankey after he lashes out at the [=PC=] Babies on stage, the latter brutally attacks him, punching and headbutting all throughout. Considering Mr. Hankey is, well, a literal piece of shit, it looks more like Kyle is playing tug of war with a bunch of ghosts and getting dragged across the stage at complete random, while he just ''happens'' to be holding poop. Predictably, most of his bruises are completely covered by skid marks.

to:

* NoHoldsBarredBeatdown: {{Parodied|Trope}} to a ridiculous degree. When Kyle tries to restrain Mr. Hankey after he lashes out at the [=PC=] PC Babies on stage, the latter brutally attacks him, punching and headbutting all throughout. Considering Mr. Hankey is, well, a literal piece of shit, it looks more like Kyle is playing tug of war with a bunch of ghosts and getting dragged across the stage at complete random, while he just ''happens'' to be holding poop. Predictably, most of his bruises are completely covered by skid marks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DudeWheresMyRespect: Well, perhaps not quite respect, but one would figure the town would realize the person they're shunning was recently, albeit not quite directly, responsible for a ''country being nuked'' after repeatedly being picked on before. By all means, if they truly consider that, ''especially'' the kids who did pick on him, they'd at least try and ''listen'' to what he had to say, at the very least to avoid pissing him off again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AesopAmnesia: The ''entire town'' shuns Kyle for defending Mr. Hankey, seemingly forgetting the last time people had picked on him, he led a protest that led to '''''Canada being nuked'''''.

Added: 786

Changed: 152

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EtTuBrute: Kyle's reaction to his three closest friends walking away after seeing his disheveled state (due to Hankey's abuse) screams this.



** Stan and Kenny are no better when they turn against Kyle for defending Mr. Hankey.

to:

** Stan and Kenny are no better when they turn against Kyle for defending Mr. Hankey.Hankey, not even being sympathetic when the latter crosses the line into genuine physical abuse towards Kyle.



* MirrorCharacter: Mr. Hankey here could be one to Heidi Turner. Both were once [[FallenHero heroic characters]] whose bad choices have caused them to be shunned by their peers (though Hankey's was more justified while Heidi was in a psychological abusive relationship with Cartman), with only Kyle trying to help them out, only for them [[TookALevelInJerkass to take a level in Jerkass]] and mistreat Kyle, resulting in him giving up on them. Though Heidi would eventually hold herself accountable for her behavior after [[HeelRealization realizing]] what it cost her, while Mr. Hankey would [[NeverMyFault refuse to admit any fault of his own]] blaming his behavior on Ambien, worsening his predicament. As a result, Heidi was able to find [[HeelFaceTurn redemption]] and return to her circle of friends, while Mr. Hankey was forced out of town [[HeelFaceDoorSlam before he had a chance to atone for his behavior]].

to:

* MirrorCharacter: Mr. Hankey here could be one to Heidi Turner. Both were once [[FallenHero heroic characters]] whose bad choices have caused them to be shunned by their peers (though Hankey's was more justified (Hankey's decisions were extremely black-and-white, while Heidi was in a psychological abusive relationship with Cartman), with only Kyle trying to help them out, only for them [[TookALevelInJerkass to take a level in Jerkass]] and mistreat Kyle, resulting in him giving up on them. Though Heidi would eventually hold herself accountable for her behavior after [[HeelRealization realizing]] what it cost her, while Mr. Hankey would [[NeverMyFault refuse to admit any fault of his own]] blaming his behavior on Ambien, worsening his predicament. As a result, Heidi was able to find [[HeelFaceTurn redemption]] and return to her circle of friends, while Mr. Hankey was forced out of town [[HeelFaceDoorSlam before he had a chance to atone for his behavior]].


Added DiffLines:

* NoHoldsBarredBeatdown: {{Parodied|Trope}} to a ridiculous degree. When Kyle tries to restrain Mr. Hankey after he lashes out at the [=PC=] Babies on stage, the latter brutally attacks him, punching and headbutting all throughout. Considering Mr. Hankey is, well, a literal piece of shit, it looks more like Kyle is playing tug of war with a bunch of ghosts and getting dragged across the stage at complete random, while he just ''happens'' to be holding poop. Predictably, most of his bruises are completely covered by skid marks.
* NoSympathy: {{Exaggerated|Trope}}. The ''entire town'' is unsympathetic to Kyle being walloped by Mr. Hankey.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuityCameo: Heidi Turner makes one revealing to have lost weight and sitting far away for Cartman, confirming that she really is no longer in a relationship with him.

to:

* ContinuityCameo: Heidi Turner makes one revealing to have lost weight and sitting far away for from Cartman, confirming that she really is no longer in a relationship with him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuityCameo: Heidi Turner makes one revealing to have lost weight and sitting far away for Cartman, confirming that she has indeed broke up with him.

to:

* ContinuityCameo: Heidi Turner makes one revealing to have lost weight and sitting far away for Cartman, confirming that she has indeed broke up really is no longer in a relationship with him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ContinuityCameo: Heidi Turner makes one revealing to have lost weight and sitting far away for Cartman, confirming that she has indeed broke up with him.

Changed: 164

Removed: 538

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Falls under Strawman Has A Point because nobody in-universe supports him.


* JerkassHasAPoint:
** Cartman warns Kyle that in today's politically correct climate, allying himself with Mr. Hankey will just bring him trouble. Kyle realizes he was right by the end.
** As much as an actual piece of crap he was being, Mr. Hankey himself was right about something. The PC Babies were causing clear disruption to his concert with their continued crying, and everyone attending just let it happen. Furthermore, he states that you shouldn't bring a baby [[note]]let alone five hypersensitive newborns[[/note]] to a public event to begin with.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint:
**
JerkassHasAPoint: Cartman warns Kyle that in today's politically correct climate, allying himself with Mr. Hankey will just bring him trouble. Kyle realizes he was right by the end.
** As much as an actual piece of crap he was being, Mr. Hankey himself was right about something. The PC Babies were causing clear disruption to his concert with their continued crying, and everyone attending just let it happen. Furthermore, he states that you shouldn't bring a baby [[note]]let alone five hypersensitive newborns[[/note]] to a public event to begin with.
end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmicableExes: {{Downplayed}} with Heidi and Kyle. They aren't seen interacting with each other, but they don't seem to mind sitting near each other in the music room.
** This is [[{{Averted}} not]] the case with Cartman, Heidi's other ex, as she's sitting far away from him during the music room and the school assembly, seemingly trying to avoid him.
* BittersweetEnding: Mr. Hankey is forced to leave South Park after being made a pariah, and Kyle loses one of his best friends. However, Mr. Hankey finds a new home in Springfield, whose residents welcome him with open arms. PC Principal and Strong Woman come to terms with keeping their relationship a secret from their children, with PC Principal vowing to be the best principal he can be to them.
** Oh, and Heidi's back to her old self, having managed to fully recover from her abusive relationship last season. However she's reduced to her [[DemotedToExtra background character role]] and doesn't make another appearance until "Bike Parade".

to:

* AmicableExes: {{Downplayed}} with Heidi and Kyle. They aren't seen interacting with each other, but they don't seem to mind sitting near each other in the music room.
** This
room. However, this is [[{{Averted}} not]] the case with Cartman, Heidi's other ex, as she's sitting far away from him during the music room and the school assembly, seemingly trying to avoid him.
* BittersweetEnding: BittersweetEnding:
**
Mr. Hankey is forced to leave South Park after being made a pariah, and Kyle loses one of his best friends. However, Mr. Hankey finds a new home in Springfield, whose residents welcome him with open arms. PC Principal and Strong Woman come to terms with keeping their relationship a secret from their children, with PC Principal vowing to be the best principal he can be to them.
** Oh, and Heidi's back to her old self, having managed to fully recover from her abusive relationship last season. However she's reduced to her [[DemotedToExtra background character role]] and doesn't make another appearance until "Bike Parade".



* EveryoneHasStandards: Cartman and Gerald refuse to associate themselves with Mr. Hankey.

to:

* EveryoneHasStandards: Cartman EvenEvilHasStandards: Cartman[[note]]a bigoted sociopath who's easily up there as one of the biggest Jerkasses in all of Western Animation[[/note]] and Gerald Gerald[[note]]a notorious {{troll}} who ''bullied a breast cancer survivor'' to the point that she '''''[[DrivenToSuicide killed herself]]'''''[[/note]] refuse to associate themselves with Mr. Hankey.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just adding a trope where it seemed appropriate.

Added DiffLines:

* MassOhCrap: All the students in the gym have this when Strong Woman's water breaks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/the_problem_with_a_poo.png]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Oh and Heidi's back to her old self having managed to fully recover from her abusive relationship last season. However she's reduced to her [[DemotedToExtra background character role]] and doesn't make another appearance until "Bike Parade".

to:

** Oh Oh, and Heidi's back to her old self self, having managed to fully recover from her abusive relationship last season. However she's reduced to her [[DemotedToExtra background character role]] and doesn't make another appearance until "Bike Parade".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

'''Original air date:''' 10/10/2018
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"Far-left" appears to be used as a snarl word and a bit of an exaggeration here. By all standards, Hari Kondabolu appears to be left-leaning at most.


** Springfield is referred to as a place where racist assholes thrive and are welcomed with open arms, plus the episode ends with the hashtag "#cancelthesimpsons". Though this was most likely heavily tongue-in-cheek, given that Trey and Matt are fans of ''WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons'', and due to their libertarianism and beliefs on political correctness, probably are not the type of people to want it cancelled over Apu's continued existence. However, some people, mostly people unfamiliar with the show's sense of humor and general worldview, including the director of the documentary ''The Problem With Apu'', far-left South Asian stand-up comedian Hari Kondabolu, took it at face value and praised Trey and Matt on Twitter after the episode aired for their perceived calling-out of ''The Simpsons''.

to:

** Springfield is referred to as a place where racist assholes thrive and are welcomed with open arms, plus the episode ends with the hashtag "#cancelthesimpsons". Though this was most likely heavily tongue-in-cheek, given that Trey and Matt are fans of ''WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons'', and due to their libertarianism and beliefs on political correctness, probably are not the type of people to want it cancelled over Apu's continued existence. However, some people, mostly people unfamiliar with the show's sense of humor and general worldview, including the director of the documentary ''The Problem With Apu'', far-left South Asian stand-up comedian Hari Kondabolu, took it at face value and praised Trey and Matt on Twitter after the episode aired for their perceived calling-out of ''The Simpsons''.

Added: 331

Changed: 4

Removed: 331

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShipSinking: If there was any doubt that the Cartman/Heidi ship wouldn't stay sunk after "[[Recap/SouthParkS21E10SplattyTomato Splatty Tomato]]", they are diminished when Heidi reverts to her [[FormerlyFat normal weight]] and [[DemotedToExtra background character status]], while sitting far from Cartman in both her appearances.



* ShipSinking: If there was any doubt that the Cartman/Heidi ship wouldn't stay sunk after "[[Recap/SouthParkS21E10SplattyTomato Splatty Tomato]]", they are diminished when Heidi reverts to her [[FormerlyFat normal weight]] and [[DemotedToExtra background character status]], while sitting far from Cartman in both her appearances.



** Springfield is referred to as a place where racist assholes thrive and are welcomed with open arms, plus the episode ends with the hashtag "#cancelthesimpsons". Though this was most likely heavily tongue-in-cheek, given that Trey and Matt are fans of WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons, and due to their libertarianism and beliefs on political correctness, probably are not the type of people to want it cancelled over Apu's continued existence. However, some people, mostly people unfamiliar with the show's sense of humor and general worldview, including the director of the documentary ''The Problem With Apu'', far-left South Asian stand-up comedian Hari Kondabolu, took it at face value and praised Trey and Matt on Twitter after the episode aired for their perceived calling-out of ''The Simpsons''.

to:

** Springfield is referred to as a place where racist assholes thrive and are welcomed with open arms, plus the episode ends with the hashtag "#cancelthesimpsons". Though this was most likely heavily tongue-in-cheek, given that Trey and Matt are fans of WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons, ''WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons'', and due to their libertarianism and beliefs on political correctness, probably are not the type of people to want it cancelled over Apu's continued existence. However, some people, mostly people unfamiliar with the show's sense of humor and general worldview, including the director of the documentary ''The Problem With Apu'', far-left South Asian stand-up comedian Hari Kondabolu, took it at face value and praised Trey and Matt on Twitter after the episode aired for their perceived calling-out of ''The Simpsons''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MirrorCharacter: Mr. Hankey here could be one to Heidi Turner. Both were once [[FallenHero heroic characters]] whose bad choices have caused them to be shunned by their peers (though Hankey's was more justified while Heidi was in a psychological abusive relationship with Cartman), with only Kyle trying to help them out, only for them [[TookALevelInJerkass to take a level in Jerkass]] and mistreat Kyle, resulting in him giving up on them. Though Heidi would eventually hold herself accountable for her behavior after [[HeelRealization realizing]] what it cost her, while Mr. Hankey would [[NeverMyFault refuse to admit any fault of his own]] blaming his behavior on Ambien, worsening his predicament. As a result, Heidi was able to find [[HeelFaceTurn redemption]] and return to her circle of friends, while Mr. Hankey was forced out of town [[HeelFaceDoorSlam before he had a chance to atone for his behavior]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Foils need to interact with one another


* {{Foil}}: Mr. Hankey here could serve as one to Heidi Turner. Both were once [[FallenHero heroic characters]] whose bad choices have caused them to be shunned by their peers (though Hankey's was more justified while Heidi was in a psychological abusive relationship with Cartman), with only Kyle trying to help them out, only for them [[TookALevelInJerkass to take a level in Jerkass]] and mistreat Kyle, resulting in him giving up on them. They differ however in that Heidi would eventually hold herself accountable for her behavior after [[HeelRealization realizing]] what it cost her, while Mr. Hankey would [[NeverMyFault refuse to admit any fault of his own]] blaming his behavior on Ambien, worsening his predicament. While Heidi was able to find [[HeelFaceTurn redemption]] and return to her circle of friends, Mr. Hankey was forced out of town [[HeelFaceDoorSlam before he had a chance to atone for his behavior]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrapsackWorld: [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons Springfield]] is considered to be a place where “racist, awful beings” like Mr. Hankey can live in. That’s right,, ''South Park'' is saying Springfield is an ''even worse'' place to live in.

to:

* CrapsackWorld: [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons Springfield]] is considered to be a place where “racist, awful beings” like Mr. Hankey can live in. That’s right,, right, ''South Park'' is saying Springfield is an ''even worse'' place to live in.

Added: 180

Changed: 138

Removed: 211

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkassBall: Mr. Hankey has [[OlderThanTheyThink been somewhat of a jerk in the past]]. However, it's nowhere as bad as he's depicted in this episode.

to:

* JerkassBall: JerkassBall:
**
Mr. Hankey has [[OlderThanTheyThink been somewhat is notably much more of a jerk an asshole than in his earlier appearances in the past]]. However, it's nowhere as bad as he's depicted in this episode.series.
** Stan and Kenny are no better when they turn against Kyle for defending Mr. Hankey.



* TookALevelInJerkass:
** Mr. Hankey is notably much more of an asshole than in his earlier appearances in the series.
** Stan, Cartman and Kenny are no better when they turn against Kyle for defending Mr. Hankey.

Added: 220

Removed: 217

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LaserGuidedKarma: Mr. Hankey loses his job, his friends, his family, and the respect of South Park thanks to his offensive ramblings. It's only made worse by the fact he accepts no blame for anything he's said or done.



* RealityEnsues: Mr. Hankey loses his job, his friends, his family, and the respect of South Park thanks to his offensive ramblings. It's only made worse by the fact he accepts no blame for anything he's said or done.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
the episode imitated the Kavanaugh hearings, but didn't mock the man himself.


** Mr. Hankey is one towards Roseanne Barr and Brett Kavanaugh, being a literal piece of shit.

to:

** Mr. Hankey is one towards Roseanne Barr and Brett Kavanaugh, Barr, being a literal piece of shit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VocalDissonance: When Bart speaks at the end, no effort was made to make him sound like Creator/NancyCartwright.

to:

* VocalDissonance: When Bart speaks at the end, no effort was made to make him sound like Creator/NancyCartwright.Creator/NancyCartwright, and he sounds like a teenager.

Top