Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / MonkS7E16MrMonkFightsCityHall

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AttemptedHomewrecker: Eileen Hill had [[UnusualHiringPractices hired]] a pregnant woman while claiming to give her a drug test during the process, in order to [[BabyGambit show a positive pregnancy test]] to Paul Crawford so that he would leave his wife.

to:

* AttemptedHomewrecker: Eileen Hill had [[UnusualHiringPractices hired]] a pregnant woman while claiming to give her a drug test during the process, in order to [[BabyGambit [[BabyTrap show a positive pregnancy test]] to Paul Crawford so that he would leave his wife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AttemptedHomewrecker: Eileen Hill had [[UnusualHiringPractices hired]] a pregnant woman while claiming to give her a drug test during the process, in order to [[BabyGambit show a positive pregnancy test]] to Paul Crawford so that he would leave his wife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnusualHiringPractices: Monk finds out that Eileen Hill hired her secretary Maria Schechter by leaving flyers for the job at a Lamaze class (where they would be seen by pregnant women), and having the candidate who showed up give a urine sample, claiming it was for a drug test. It turns out the real purpose was to get a positive pregnancy test to show the man she was having an affair with, in order to convince him to leave his wife; instead, [[ADeadlyAffair the man murdered her]].

to:

* UnusualHiringPractices: Monk finds out that Eileen Hill hired her secretary Maria Schechter by leaving flyers for the job at a Lamaze class (where they would be seen by pregnant women), and having the candidate who showed up give a urine sample, claiming it was for a drug test. It turns out the real purpose was to get a positive pregnancy test to show the man she was having an affair with, Crawford, in order to convince him to leave his wife; instead, [[ADeadlyAffair the man he murdered her]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No spoilers on a recap page


* UnusualHiringPractices: Monk finds out that Eileen Hill hired her secretary Maria Schechter by leaving flyers for the job at a Lamaze class (where they would be seen by pregnant women), and having the candidate who showed up give a urine sample, claiming it was for a drug test. [[spoiler:It turns out the real purpose was to get a positive pregnancy test to show the man she was having an affair with, in order to convince him to leave his wife; instead, [[ADeadlyAffair the man murdered her]].]]

to:

* UnusualHiringPractices: Monk finds out that Eileen Hill hired her secretary Maria Schechter by leaving flyers for the job at a Lamaze class (where they would be seen by pregnant women), and having the candidate who showed up give a urine sample, claiming it was for a drug test. [[spoiler:It It turns out the real purpose was to get a positive pregnancy test to show the man she was having an affair with, in order to convince him to leave his wife; instead, [[ADeadlyAffair the man murdered her]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnusualHiringPractices: Monk finds out that Eileen Hill hired her secretary Maria Schechter by leaving flyers for the job at a Lamaze class (where they would be seen by pregnant women), and having the candidate who showed up give a urine sample, claiming it was for a drug test. [[spoiler:It turns out the real purpose was to get a positive pregnancy test to show the man she was having an affair with, in order to convince him to leave his wife; in stead, [[ADeadlyAffair the man murdered her]].]]

to:

* UnusualHiringPractices: Monk finds out that Eileen Hill hired her secretary Maria Schechter by leaving flyers for the job at a Lamaze class (where they would be seen by pregnant women), and having the candidate who showed up give a urine sample, claiming it was for a drug test. [[spoiler:It turns out the real purpose was to get a positive pregnancy test to show the man she was having an affair with, in order to convince him to leave his wife; in stead, instead, [[ADeadlyAffair the man murdered her]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* UnusualHiringPractices: Monk finds out that Eileen Hill hired her secretary Maria Schechter by leaving flyers for the job at a Lamaze class (where they would be seen by pregnant women), and having the candidate who showed up give a urine sample, claiming it was for a drug test. [[spoiler:It turns out the real purpose was to get a positive pregnancy test to show the man she was having an affair with, in order to convince him to leave his wife; in stead, [[ADeadlyAffair the man murdered her]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnragedByIdiocy: Maria Schecter is so unyieldingly stupid that Monk compares talking to her torture.

to:

* EnragedByIdiocy: Maria Schecter is so unyieldingly stupid that Monk compares calls talking to her torture.

Added: 390

Changed: 157

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DidntThinkThisThrough: It never occurred to Hill that Paul might take drastic action to avoid her "pregnancy" coming to his wife.

to:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: DidntThinkThisThrough:
** Monk chains himself to a pillar in the parking garage in protest of it being torn down. When the foreman asks for the key, Monk tosses it into the sewer. He only realizes his error when the demolition of the garage is postponed and Natalie asks for the key to unchain him
**
It never occurred to Hill that Paul might take drastic action to avoid news of her "pregnancy" coming to reaching his wife.



* EnragedByIdiocy: Maria Schecter is so unyieldingly stupid, Monk says it is actually torture to talk to her.

to:

* EnragedByIdiocy: Maria Schecter is so unyieldingly stupid, stupid that Monk says it is actually torture compares talking to talk to her.her torture.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ItsAllAboutMe: Monk is at his worst in this episode. He's willing to go above and beyond to save the parking garage his wife was murdered in by claiming that there is some evidence in the parking garage he missed, even though tearing it down would provide for the environment and a park for citizens. His therapy session with Dr. Bell, however, confirms he's lying and admits he knows there is no new evidence. The truth is Monk just doesn't want to lose the parking garage because it was the last place she was alive. Worse is that he cares more about the vote to demolish the parking garage than Councilwoman Hill being killed and devotes most of his time trying to bribe her assistant Maria into helping him.

to:

* ItsAllAboutMe: Monk is at his worst in this episode. He's willing to go above and beyond to save the parking garage his wife was murdered in by claiming that there is some evidence in the parking garage he missed, even though tearing it down would provide for the environment and a park for citizens. His therapy session with Dr. Bell, however, confirms he's lying and admits he knows there is no new evidence. The truth is Monk just doesn't want to lose the parking garage because it was the last place she was alive. Worse is that he cares more about the vote to demolish the parking garage than Councilwoman Hill being killed and devotes most of his time trying to bribe her assistant Maria into helping him. The cherry on top is how he tries to twist the issue about for Maria, trying to frame the parking garage as a suitable substitute for the playground it will be torn down for.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ItsAllAboutMe: Monk is at his worst in this episode. He's willing to go above and beyond to save the parking garage his wife was murdered in by claiming that there is some evidence in the parking garage he missed, even though tearing it down would provide for the environment and a park for citizens. His therapy session with Dr. Bell, however, confirms he's lying and admits he knows there is no new evidence. The truth is Monk just doesn't want to lose the parking garage because it was the last place she was alive. Worse is that he cares more about the vote to demolish the parking garage than Councilwoman Hill being killed and devotes most of his time trying to bribe her assistant Maria into helping him.
* LaserGuidedKarma: Monk loses the parking garage once he rudely and selfishly insults Maria several times as he solves the case, resulting in her changing her vote to spite him. As sad as it is to see Monk at the end of the episode, given how Monk only cared for himself and the parking garage over innocent people's lives throughout the episode, it's hard to say he didn't deserve it.


Added DiffLines:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: As pointed out by Dr. Bell, there is no new evidence in the parking garage Monk is determined to save. As Monk has examined it for hours on end many times in the last eleven years, if there was any evidence he overlooked, it's doubtful he'd find it now. In the end he is forced to admit the truth: he's been lying the whole time and is fully aware there is no evidence in the parking garage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Maria is torn, but figures she can vote the way Hill wanted if she had access to the councilor's journal, which Monk states the police did not find anywhere like her office or apartment. When Maria asks if the police checked Hill's ''other'' apartment, it is revealed that the councilwoman had a love nest. There. Natalie finds a positive pregnancy test, which seems to mean that Hill was pregnant. Unfortunately, she's dead: her body turns up floating at the pier. However, when the autopsy on the councilwoman is performed, it is revealed that she was ''not'' pregnant. So what was a positive pregnancy test doing at the love nest?

to:

Maria is torn, but figures she can vote the way Hill wanted if she had access to the councilor's journal, which Monk states the police did not find anywhere like her office or apartment. When Maria asks if the police checked Hill's ''other'' apartment, it is revealed that the councilwoman had a love nest. There. There, Natalie finds a positive pregnancy test, which seems to mean that Hill was pregnant. Unfortunately, she's dead: her body turns up floating at the pier. However, when the autopsy on the councilwoman is performed, it is revealed that she was ''not'' pregnant. So what was a positive pregnancy test doing at the love nest?



So Hill wanted Paul to leave his wife, so she lied about being pregnant. Hill obtained a positive pregnancy test by hiring the incompetent Maria. By using Maria's drug test urine sample, Hill turned a pregnancy test positive, and used it to blackmail Paul into leaving his wife. So Paul strangled Hill with one of his ties, made by Chalmers of London, and then dumped her body at the pier, killing the tourists to avoid the risk that they saw him dump the body.

to:

So Hill wanted Paul to leave his wife, so she lied about being pregnant. Hill obtained a positive pregnancy test by hiring the incompetent Maria. By using Maria's drug test urine sample, Hill turned a pregnancy test positive, and used it to blackmail Paul into leaving his wife. So Paul strangled Hill with one of his ties, made by Chalmers of London, and then dumped her body at the pier, killing the tourists to avoid the risk that they saw him dump the body.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoldDigger: The reason Paul was so willing to kill Hill when he thought she was pregnant, He is married to the daughter of a billionaire, and knew if Hill went through with her BabyTrap, he'd lose access to all that money.

to:

* GoldDigger: The reason Paul was so willing to kill Hill when he thought she was pregnant, pregnant. He is married to the daughter of a billionaire, and knew if Hill went through with her BabyTrap, he'd lose access to all that money.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ActorAllusion: Jon Polito's character laughing as he repeats [[Series/HomicideLifeOnTheStreet "homicide"]] after Stottlemeyer introduces himself as a homicide detective. Polito played homicide detective Steve Crosetti on that series.

Top