Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / LawAndOrderS4E4Profile

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseLaw: Tunney claims that, according to the Constitution, a black only counts as three fifths of a person. The only argument made against this is that a subsequent amendment makes this no longer valid. In other words, this actually was the case at some point. What the Constitution actually says is:
-->Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers, which shall be determined by adding to the whole Number of free Persons, including those bound to Service for a Term of Years, and excluding Indians not taxed, three fifths of all other Persons.
** This clause did not allow the murders of anyone who isn't a "free Person", nor would it have applied to a black living in New York simply for being black.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In court, Arthur's new lawyer is Horace [=McCoy=], whom the judge recognizes. [=McCoy=] is black, and Tunney looks uncomfortable, but pleads not guilty. He's held without bail, despite [=McCoy=]'s protests.

to:

In court, Arthur's new lawyer is Horace [=McCoy=], [=McCoy=] (Creator/JamesEarlJones), whom the judge recognizes. [=McCoy=] is black, and Tunney looks uncomfortable, but pleads not guilty. He's held without bail, despite [=McCoy=]'s protests.

Added: 263

Changed: 44

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed spoilers and added text indicating that this page has no spoiler tags


%%% Administrivia/Per Administrivia/SpoilerPolicy, all spoiler tags have been removed from this recap page and a warning has been added.

!! As per Tv Tropes policy, this page is Administrivia/SpoilersOff on any and all plot points. Administrivia/YouHaveBeenWarned!



Kincaid wonders why the sister didn't call to warn Tunney, but Kincaid points out that the gun was unloaded -- Tunney was probably taking it to be dumped. From the phone records, they learn that Mary did call Tunney -- twenty minutes later. They theorize that Allen Bradley delayed Mary somehow.

to:

Kincaid wonders why the sister didn't call to warn Tunney, but Kincaid points out that the gun was unloaded -- Tunney unloaded—Tunney was probably taking it to be dumped. From the phone records, they learn that Mary did call Tunney -- twenty Tunney—twenty minutes later. They theorize that Allen Bradley delayed Mary somehow.



In the neighborhood, Van Buren says they have 18 cars patroling, and then someone screams. Logan drives after someone running away from the victim and almost runs him down, driving him up against a wall -- he was a mugger. Then Van Buren catches up to them -- someone was shot elsewhere in the neighborhood.

to:

In the neighborhood, Van Buren says they have 18 cars patroling, and then someone screams. Logan drives after someone running away from the victim and almost runs him down, driving him up against a wall -- he wall—he was a mugger. Then Van Buren catches up to them -- someone them—someone was shot elsewhere in the neighborhood.



* FreudianExcuse: Tunney's mother was murdered by black muggers, which fuels his murderous racism. [[spoiler:When the detectives investigate his safehouse, then find a makeshift shrine to his mother, with three shotgun shells mounted on it to represent his three victims, as though they were sacrifices to his mother's memory.]]
* IronicEcho: Arthur Tunney murders minorities, claiming that they wreck nice white neighborhoods. When [[spoiler:he himself is shot by a would-be victim, she laments that her neighborhood used to be so nice.]]

to:

* FreudianExcuse: Tunney's mother was murdered by black muggers, which fuels his murderous racism. [[spoiler:When When the detectives investigate his safehouse, then find a makeshift shrine to his mother, with three shotgun shells mounted on it to represent his three victims, as though they were sacrifices to his mother's memory.]]
memory.
* IronicEcho: Arthur Tunney murders minorities, claiming that they wreck nice white neighborhoods. When [[spoiler:he he himself is shot by a would-be victim, she laments that her neighborhood used to be so nice.]]

Added: 4

Changed: 49

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



!Tropes include:

to:

\n!Tropes include:----
!!This episode contains examples of:



* IronicEcho: Arthur Tunney murders minorities, claiming that they wreck nice white neighborhoods. When [[spoiler: he is himself shot by a would-be victim, she laments that her neighborhood used to be so nice.]]

to:

* IronicEcho: Arthur Tunney murders minorities, claiming that they wreck nice white neighborhoods. When [[spoiler: he is [[spoiler:he himself is shot by a would-be victim, she laments that her neighborhood used to be so nice.]]



-->'''[=McCoy=]''': Do you ask white lawyers if they have qualms when they defend a black man accused of killing white people?

to:

-->'''[=McCoy=]''': -->'''[=McCoy=]:''' Do you ask white lawyers if they have qualms when they defend a black man accused of killing white people?



* ShamelessSelfPromoter: Horace [=McCoy=] only gets involved because it's a high-profile case and he wants the recognition.

to:

* ShamelessSelfPromoter: Horace [=McCoy=] only gets involved because it's a high-profile case and he wants the recognition.recognition.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Directed by Creator/EWSwackhamer

Written by Creator/GordonRayfield & Creator/EdZuckerman

Added: 865

Changed: 326

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The police swarm the scene. A black man's been wounded and Tunney's been shot and killed. Tunney was killed by the victim's daughter. She bemoans the state of the neighborhood as the episode ends.

to:

The police swarm the scene. A black man's been wounded and Tunney's been shot and killed. Tunney was killed by the victim's daughter. She bemoans the state of the neighborhood as the episode ends.



* AxCrazy: Tunney, even moreso than most white supremacists. He can't even keep himself from making racist remarks about his own lawyer, who he ''specifically hired'' to make himself look less racist.

to:

* AxCrazy: Tunney, even moreso than most white supremacists. He can't even keep himself from making racist remarks about his own lawyer, who he ''specifically hired'' to make himself look less racist.racist.
* EveryoneHasStandards: Horace [=McCoy=] is a shifty lawyer who's only representing Tunney to win recognition in a high-profile case, but even he's clearly disgusted by Tunney's racism. Of course, [=McCoy=] is himself black, so his disdain is [[ItsPersonal quite understandable.]]
* FreudianExcuse: Tunney's mother was murdered by black muggers, which fuels his murderous racism. [[spoiler:When the detectives investigate his safehouse, then find a makeshift shrine to his mother, with three shotgun shells mounted on it to represent his three victims, as though they were sacrifices to his mother's memory.]]



* SawedOffShotgun: The killer's chosen weapon.
* SerialKiller: Arthur Tunney, a racist serial killer who murders minorities with a shotgun.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: [=McCoy=] is only in it for the fame, but he has a point that his race shouldn't be a factor in who he chooses to represent.
-->'''[=McCoy=]''': Do you ask white lawyers if they have qualms when they defend a black man accused of killing white people?
* SawedOffShotgun: The killer's Tunney's chosen weapon.
* SerialKiller: Arthur Tunney, a racist serial killer who murders minorities with a shotgun.shotgun.
* ShamelessSelfPromoter: Horace [=McCoy=] only gets involved because it's a high-profile case and he wants the recognition.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In court, Arthur's new lawyer is Horus [=McCoy=], whom the judge recognizes. [=McCoy=] is black, and Tunney looks uncomfortable, but pleads not guilty. He's held without bail, despite [=McCoy=]'s protests.

to:

In court, Arthur's new lawyer is Horus Horace [=McCoy=], whom the judge recognizes. [=McCoy=] is black, and Tunney looks uncomfortable, but pleads not guilty. He's held without bail, despite [=McCoy=]'s protests.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 411

Changed: 92

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AxCrazy: Tunney, even moreso than most white supremacists. He can't even keep himself from making racist remarks about his own lawyer, who he ''specifically hired'' to make himself look less racist.
* IronicEcho: Arthur Tunney murders minorities, claiming that they wreck nice white neighborhoods. When [[spoiler: he is himself shot by a would-be victim, she laments that her neighborhood used to be so nice.]]





to:

\n* SerialKiller: Arthur Tunney, a racist serial killer who murders minorities with a shotgun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n!Tropes include:
* SawedOffShotgun: The killer's chosen weapon.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The FBI unit says that the killer is speeding up; two weeks passed between the shootings of Hector and Ruben, two days between Ruben and the latest victim. The spokesperson for the unit says that the shooter will look normal, have trouble with personal relations, and get an ego boost from killing during the police search. They deduced that the shotgun was an old gun (they say if he had bought a new weapon, it wouldn't be a breech-loading twelve-guage), so either he or his father's a hunter. They estimate his age to be between 35 and 40, contrary to the old woman's (Ms. Whitney) guess of 30. He probably has a grudge against the victims. The FBI is investigating the market, but Van Buren points out that all the victims are minorities, so it could be a white supremicist. On the way out, Van Buren says they're putting together a large force to patrol the neighborhood. Logan says to make sure they look like locals.

to:

The FBI unit says that the killer is speeding up; two weeks passed between the shootings of Hector and Ruben, two days between Ruben and the latest victim. The spokesperson for the unit says that the shooter will look normal, have trouble with personal relations, and get an ego boost from killing during the police search. They deduced that the shotgun was an old gun (they say if he had bought a new weapon, it wouldn't be a breech-loading twelve-guage), twelve-gauge), so either he or his father's a hunter. They estimate his age to be between 35 and 40, contrary to the old woman's (Ms. Whitney) guess of 30. He probably has a grudge against the victims. The FBI is investigating the market, but Van Buren points out that all the victims are minorities, so it could be a white supremicist. On the way out, Van Buren says they're putting together a large force to patrol the neighborhood. Logan says to make sure they look like locals.

Top